Professional Documents
Culture Documents
3 UROHJyPHQRVFXOWXUDOHV
0UPJPV LZ[H YLL_P}U HUV[HUKV
KVZ HJVU[LJPTPLU[VZ 3H ZLTHUH
KLS HS KL KPJPLTIYL KL
LU (U[PN\H .\H[LTHSH ZL SSL]} H
JHIV \U LUJ\LU[YV LU LS X\L \U
NY\WV KL LZ[\KPVZVZ KL SVZ WYVJL
ZVZTPNYH[VYPVZLU*LU[YVHTtYPJH`
4t_PJV ZL KPLYVU JP[H ,S VIQL[P]V
IHQV SH JVU]VJH[VYPH WVY SH (NLU
JPH ,ZWH|VSH KL *VVWLYHJP}U 0U
[LYUHJPVUHS WHYH LS +LZHYYVSSV LYH
WYLZLU[HY \UH ZLYPL KL [YHIHQVZ `
YLL_PVULZZVIYLSHTHULYHLUX\L LUSHKPZJ\ZP}ULS[LTHX\L
SH TPNYHJP}U LZ[m YLJVUZ[P[\`LUKV T\JOVZ WHYLJxHU [YHLY LU
SVZ WYVJLZVZ J\S[\YHSLZ ` KL PKLU Z\HNLUKH!KPZJ\[PYZVIYLSH
[PKHK KL U\LZ[YVZ WHxZLZ ;YHZ SHZ J\S[\YHLU\UTVTLU[VLU
WYPTLYHZ KPZJ\ZPVULZ X\L WHYLJxHU X\LT\JOHZWLYZVUHZLZ[mU
IVYKLHYSVJ\S[\YHS`LUSHZX\LZL ZPLUKV T\[PSHKHZ WVY LS
PUZPZ[xH X\L LU SH TLKPKH LU X\L [YLULZJLKLYHSH[LU[HJP}U
WRGRHVFXOWXUDZLW\LKLOHJLY\UH KLSVZ[LTHZPYYLSL]HU[LZ
SLJ[\YH KL SH JHU[PKHK KL YLTLZHZ 3HJ\S[\YHLZHSNVKLSVX\L
X\L YLJPILU U\LZ[YVZ WHxZLZ ` LZHZ ZLVJ\WHUSVZVJPVZVZ
LZ[HKxZ[PJHZ ZVU J\S[\YHSLZ <UH KL 1\U[VHLZ[HZP[V
SHZWHY[PJPWHU[LZZLHUPT}HJVSVJHY \UHTmZYLJPLU[L
V[YV KLQH KL SHKV LS mTIP[V KL SV SH J\S[\YH K\YHU[L SVZ ZPNSVZ ?=00 `
ZLUZVYPHS ` SV KPVUPZxHJV JVTV \U ?=000WLUZHUKVX\LLZHJ\S[\YHUVZ
LSLTLU[V PUULNVJPHISL KL SH L_WL SSL]HYxH HS WYVNYLZV \UH *\S[\YH
YPLUJPHLZ[t[PJH LUZPUN\SHY`LUTH`ZJ\SHX\LZL
,Z[L LUZH`V JVUZ[H KL [YLZ WHY KPZJ\[L KLZKL LS SLUN\HQL LZJYP[V
[LZ 3HZ JVUZPKLYHJPVULZ PUPJPHSLZ X\LPU]PZPIPSPaH`UPLNHSHZT\JOHZ
X\L T\LZ[YHU LS W\U[V KL WHY[PKH! `TS[PWSLZVYHSPKHKLZWHYHUHSPaHY
SH J\S[\YH JVTV \U mTIP[V WVJV JVU \UH WYPTLYH WYVW\LZ[H KL X\t
KPZJ\[PKV ` JVUZPKLYHKV KL SH ]PKH HJJPVULZKLILYxHUZLYJVUZPKLYHKHZ
UHJPVUHSS\LNV\UIYL]LHUmSPZPZKL LU SH KPZJ\ZP}U ZVIYL J\S[\YH 7HYH
SVZKVZKVJ\TLU[VZ`Z\ZWYVW\LZ LSSVZLWYVWVUL\UKLJmSVNVPUPJPHS
[HZKLNLZ[P}UJ\S[\YHS\UHYL]PZP}U TmZX\LJVU\UZLU[PKVKLTHUKH
KL J}TV KLZKL SH WVSx[PJH ZL ZPN\L TPLU[VZVKVNTHZJVTV\ULQLYJP
WYP]PSLNPHUKV SH ]PZP}U TVKLYUH JPVKLYLL_P}U`WYV]VJHJP}U
/DVSURSXHVWDVSROtWLFDV
A otro nivel ciertamente, pero en una direccin bien cercana, se halla la condena que
hace Lukcs de la modernidad por disolver la forma y mezclar, confundir los gneros. Los
parecidos con la apocalptica y conservadora teora de la decadencia cultural de la sociedad
de masas conguran una extraa coincidencia.
Jess Martn Barbero
/
H`\UH[YHTWHHSJVTWHYHY TLYH LZ SH WVZPIPSPKHK KL LSL]HY H
\U KVJ\TLU[V WYVNYHTm YHUNVTPUPZ[LYPHSSHPUZ[P[\JPVUHSPKHK
[PJV [HU NLULYHS JVTV LZ X\LZLLUJHYNHKLSmTIP[VJ\S[\YHS
\U WSHU KL NVIPLYUV JVU \U KVJ\ SV X\L JVUSSL]H H YLJVUVJLY SH \Y
TLU[V KL JHYmJ[LY TmZ LZWLJxJV NLUJPH KL \UH YLPUNLUPLYxH ` H SH
X\LHKLTmZ[PLULJVTVZ\Z[LU[V\U YLHKLJ\HJP}UUVZVSVKLSHWHY[PKH
KPHNU}Z[PJV KL SVZ WVZPJPVUHTPLU WYLZ\W\LZ[HYPH N\ILYUHTLU[HS X\L
[VZ ZVIYL SH J\S[\YH ` LS JVUZ\TV LZ \UH KL SHZ NYHUKLZ KLIPSPKHKLZ
J\S[\YHS KLS WHxZ *65*<3;<9( ZPUV KL SH LZ[Y\J[\YH TPZTH WVY
:PULTIHYNVJVTV\ULQLY HOVYH KP]PKPKH LU J\H[YV KPYLJJPV
JPJPVHJHKtTPJVJYLVX\LZHS]HUKV ULZ X\L YLZWVUKLU H \UH ]PZP}U
SHZKPZ[HUJPHZZLW\LKLPUPJPHY\UH JSmZPJH KL SH NLZ[P}U J\S[\YHS 3H
KPZJ\ZP}U TmZ HTWSPH ZVIYL SHZ ZLN\UKH LZ X\L LU Z\Z WVSx[PJHZ ZL
MYVU[LYHZ`SVZSxTP[LZKLSVJ\S[\YHS ZL|HSHU\L]HTLU[LSHULJLZPKHKKL
\UU\L]VKPHNU}Z[PJVWHYHSHJ\S[\
+VZWYVW\LZ[HZX\PZPLYHYLZHS[HY YH`\UU\L]VWYVJLZVKLJVUJLY[H
KLS KVJ\TLU[V KLS -435 3H WYP JP}U UHJPVUHS ZVIYL \U [LTH X\L
'HFiORJRGHUHIOH[LRQHVLQLFLDOHV
X\L JVUKLUZL SHZ HNLUKHZ \YNLU[LZ ZP WLYTP[PTVZ LZ[L KPmSVNV LUJVU
ZVIYLSHYLL_P}UJ\S[\YHS [YHYLTVZ U\L]VZ JHTPUVZ WHYH SVZ
WYVJLZVZLTHUJPWH[VYPVZX\LZPN\LU
*DQDUVHHOGHUHFKRDODHVFXFKD
ZPLUKV\YNLU[LZLU*LU[YVHTtYPJH
:L OHISH T\JOV KLS KLYLJOV H
0iVTXHHQVHxDUVHODFXOWXUD
SH WHSHIYH H KLJPY SH SPILY[HK X\L
GHEH UHIOH[LRQDUVH GHVGH VX FRQV
ZPN\L ZPLUKV JVUZPKLYHKH \UV KL
WUXFFLyQHQORVSURFHVRVHGXFDWLYRV
SVZ IPLULZ TmZ WYLJPHKVZ 7VJV ZL
KPJL ZPU LTIHYNV X\L [HTIPtU LZ <U HWVY[L M\UKHTLU[HS X\L
M\UKHTLU[HS LS KLYLJOV H SH LZJ\ KLZKLSHHJHKLTPH`SVZmTIP[VZKL
JOH \U KLYLJOV X\L ZL JVUX\PZ[H SHLK\JHJP}UMVYTHSW\LKLUSSL]HYZL
X\LZLNHUH,Z[HPTHNLUTLWHYLJL H JHIV 3H KPZJ\ZP}U KL J}TV ZL
PU[LYLZHU[L7\LZJVSVJH\UYL[VM\U ZP[H SH YLL_P}U ZVIYL SV J\S[\YHS
KHTLU[HS WHYH X\PLULZ [YHIHQHTVZ J}TV ZL JVUZ[P[\`L LZWHJPV KPUm
[LTHZ YLSHJPVUHKVZ JVU SH J\S[\YH! TPJV JHTIPHU[L LU WLYTHULU[L
WVZPJPVUHY LS [LTH J\S[\YHS 5HKPL JVUZ[Y\JJP}U ` J}TV KLZKL SH LZ
JVTWYLUKLYmSHPTWVY[HUJPHKLLZ[H J\LSH ZL KLIL HWYLUKLY H JVUZ[Y\PY
KPZJ\ZP}U ZP UV ZL PUPJPH ` KLZWV ZPNUPJHKVZ H JVU[HY Z\Z WYVWPHZ
QmUKVZLKLHYYVNHUJPHZ`THSLU[LU UHYYH[P]HZ PKLU[PKHKLZ OPZ[VYPHZ `
KPKVZ ZL JVUZPN\L LS KLYLJOV H SH TLTVYPHZ ,Z M\UKHTLU[HS YL]PZHY
LZJ\JOH`ZLJVSVJHLUSHHNLUKHKL L_WLYPLUJPHZ WHYH SH ]HSVYHJP}U KL
KPZJ\ZP}ULSmTIP[VKLSVJ\S[\YHS SHZKP]LYZHZJ\S[\YHZ
/DFXOWXUDHVRUGLQDULD 5HFXSHUDU OD GLPHQVLyQ HVWpWLFD
GH OD YLGD ` LZ[V PTWSPJH YLJ\WLYHY
:L [PLUL LU T\JOVZ TVTLU[VZ
SH L_WLYPLUJPH KPUVZxHJH X\L [HU
SH [LU[HJP}U KL THU[LULY SH ]PZP}U
KLZKPI\QHKH ZL LUJ\LU[YH LU ZVJPL
TVKLYUH L PS\Z[YHKH KL SH J\S[\YH
KHKLZ JVTV SHZ U\LZ[YHZ 5PL[ZaJOL
:PULTIHYNVZPZLX\PLYLJVSVJHYLS
SV ZL|HS} KL THULYH JVU[\UKLU[L
[LTHLUSHKPZJ\ZP}UKLSHZVJPLKHK
:PIPLULUSHZZVJPLKHKLZKLSWYPTLY
LZULJLZHYPVYLJVYKHYQ\U[VJVU9H
T\UKV `H ZL OHISH KL SVZ KLYLJOVZ
`TVUK>PSSPHTZ X\LZPIPLU
HS NVJL ` HS KPZMY\[L LU U\LZ[YVZ
LS[tYTPUVJ\S[\YHLZ\UVKLSVZTmZ
WHxZLZ [VKH]xH WHYLJL L_PZ[PY JVTV
KPMxJPSLZ KL KLUPY V JVU )H\THU
SVZL|HS}LSJOPSLUV5VYILY[3LJOULY
X\L OH` ]HYPHZ KLUPJPVULZ
LULSPUMVYTLKLKLZHYYVSSVO\THUV
X\L JVU]LYNLU LU \U TPZTV ZPNUP
$VtVRPRVQRVRWURVORVFKLOHQRV\UH
JHU[L" ]HSL PUZPZ[PY X\L OD FXOWXUD
LZWLJPL KL YLZLY]H V KL LZJYW\SV
HVRUGLQDULDZLJVUZ[P[\`LKLZKLSH
LUHKTP[PY`WVZPIPSP[HYWYVJLZVZX\L
]PKH JV[PKPHUH ` Z\ JLU[YHSPKHK :P
JVUZ[P[\`HUSHZL_WLYPLUJPHZKLSNVJL
\UH OLYLUJPH UVZ W\LKLU KLQHY SHZ
]HUN\HYKPHZ`SHYLL_P}UKLV[YVZ 5HFXSHUDUODGLPHQVLyQSROtWLFD
[L}YPJVZ JVTV SVZ MYHURM\Y[PHUVZ GH OD FXOWXUD PTWSPJH ZP[\HY SH KPZ
V LS TPZTV )YLJO[ LZ X\L LS HY[L J\ZP}U ZVIYL SVZ YLJVUVJPTPLU[VZ
I}SPJH1LZZ4HY[xU)HYILYVZL|HSH KLZLU[PKVZKLS]LYIVFRQWDULZUH
X\LOH`\USHYNVJHTPUVX\L]HKLS YYHYOPZ[VYPHZZLY[LUPKVLUJ\LU[H`
KLZJVUVJPTPLU[V HS YLJVUVJPTPLU OHJLYJ\LU[HZKLZKLLZ[HWVSPZLTPH
[V ` KLS YLJVUVJPTPLU[V KL Zx HS ZLJVSVJHUSVZmTIP[VZM\UKHTLU[H
YLJVUVJPTPLU[VT\[\V"WHYHLSSVSH SLZKLSHPUJS\ZP}U
UHYYHJP}ULZM\UKHTLU[HSW\LZ[VKH 6DQ6DOYDGRUDEULOPD\RGH
PKLU[PKHK LZ HSNV X\L ZL UHYYH ,U
BIBLIOGRAFA
NOTAS
,SKVJ\TLU[VM\LWYLZLU[HKVLSKLVJ[\IYLKLLULS4\ZLV5HJPVUHSKL(U[YVWVSVNxH,SL]LU[V
UVM\LYLZL|HKVWVYSVZNYHUKLZTLKPVZKLSWHxZ
:LOHISHKLYLMVYTHZLJVU}TPJHZZVJPHSLZ`WVSx[PJHZ`KLNLZ[P}UHTIPLU[HS
JVTVSVZJ\H[YVNYHUKLZ[LTHZKLZ[HJHKVZ
,SHY[LWVYLSHY[LKLZ]PUJ\SHKHJHZPKLSH]PKHJV[PKPHUH
*YP[PJHKVLUJPLY[VZLZWHJPVZZVIYL[VKVHJHKtTPJVZWVYZ\TL[VKVSVNxH`Z\
WHYJPHSPaHJP}ULUHSN\UVZmTIP[VZ"WLYVKPHNU}Z[PJVHSUW\U[VKLWHY[PKH`OVQHKLY\[HX\L[\]VKPZ
J\ZPVULZJVUKPZ[PU[VZHJ[VYLZKLSmTIP[VKLSVJ\S[\YHS