LECTURE ON
LAW OF CONSUMER JUSTICE.
Presented By:
B.A. PRABUSHANKAR,B.A.B.L.DLAL., (M.L)
At: AMIRTHA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT STUDIES
ETTIMADAI, COIMBATORE.LAW OF CONSUMER JUSTICE
Consumerism is a social movement
To safe guard the rights and powers of the
consumers
In relation to sellers
Ralphanadar, the pioneer in Consumer
movement define:-
Consumerism as societies right to quality of life
And towards protection, preservation &
enhancement of human life
The increase in volume of international trade &
commerce has brought in the need for Consumer
protection movement.
The Consumer protection in a developing country has
become more a necessity than of academic interest.
At present, several legislative enactments Consumer
courts, Consumer associations and advertisements
about Consumer rights have accelerated the
ey etetni
The movement is mainly for quality of human life and
protection against hazardous and adulterated goods.LAW OF CONSUMER JUSTICE
The U.N.O. was established on 247 Oct 1945.
Main aims of U.N.O. is that each country must
become a welfare state rather than a police
Scie
Further, international cooperation was required
for exchange of information on banned and
health hazardous among the countries to
protect themselves against import of the said
goods.
Economic and social counsel
Promotes higher standard of living
Conditions of economic and| social progress
Solutions for international economy
Social health and related problems
The said counsel encourages consumerism for
CYNE eNom Unt Tn saneLAW OF CONSUMER JUSTICE
LL.O
= Aims to protect the interest of workers
and their families
= To provide basic goods at reasonable
price
= In sufficient quantity
= In satisfactory quantity
= Their main aim of W.H.O happens to be
taking care of basic good health of the
people across the globe.
= In 1977, the expert committee took a list
of drugs, to meet the basic needs of the
people and directed the member
countries to provide these basic
medicines at a reasonable price to the
consumers.It envisages programs for
Food control
Increase of production
Increase of quality and quantity of food
And also prepared a code of conduct for
use of pesticides upon food stuffs.
In 1986 a resolution was passed for Consumer
protection
AOR eMIC CN Teel ccs ances Mmice ate Uy
hazards
Furnish adequate information of the goods
To curb mis-leading advertisements
Unfair trade practices
And to implement effective Consumer redressal.
ae result, INDIA enacted Consumer protection ActLAW OF CONSUMER JUSTICE
Sale Of Goods Act 1930
The Essential Commodities Act 1955
Drugs Control Act 1950
Prevention Of Food Adulteration Act
aiefor.3
Standards Of Weights And
Measurements Act 1976
The MRTP Act 1969
Indian Constitution Aims At
Promotion Of The Welfare Of The People
Raising The Level Of Nutrition.
Improving The Public Health
And In Order To See The Above
Intention Of The Constitution, Is Duly
Given Force The Consumer Protection
Act 1986 Was Enacted.LAW OF CONSUMER JUSTICE
The Act is comprehensive
Gives simple, speedy, an inexpensive
remedy for Consumer grievances.
Consumer courts were established at
district levels, state level, and national
IEW
Not only goods, but also services were
brought within the ambit of the Act
To protect the interest of people, who are
consumers
To encourage healthy trade and services
to consumers.
Consumer has the right to safety
Right to be informed
Right to choose & the right to be heared.LAW OF CONSUMER JUSTICE
attempts to put an end to block
marketing
To prevent adulteration
To prevent excess pricing
To prevent false weights and measures
To prevent poor quality of goods
The forums for redressal of grievances can be
called CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL
FORUMS.
At the district level, we have district forum
PNM MI ClCH N-MALE eMIt Lom eltULA)
And above all, we have national commission at
Pyne
The Consumer who is aggrieved with any
defects with regard to goods or services can
approach the above forums depending upon
the pecuniary jurisdiction,LAW OF CONSUMER JUSTICE
Up To 20 LAKHS Complaints To Be Filed
Before The District Forum
Above 20 Lakhs Up to 1 Crore To Be
Filed Before The State Forum
Above 1 Crore To Be Filed Before The
National Commission And Against
Appeal Will Lie To The Supreme Court
The Act protects the Consumer who is
aggrieved by unfair trade practice
Or restrictive trade practice adopted by
any trader
For any defects in the goods bought by
ital
And any deficiency in the services
availed by himLAW OF CONSUMER JUSTICE
Consumer is a person
Purchases any goods for a consideration
Also includes person who avails any services
for a consideration
A person who obtains goods for resale or for
any commercial use is not covered under the
Act
The person who purchases any goods for
purpose of earning his livelihood by means of
self-employment is also a Consumer
Means any fault
nee
Or short comings in
Quality
Quantity
Potency
eval
icicle}
Pricing
Which is required to be maintained under lawLAW OF CONSUMER JUSTICE
Deficiency means any fault
Imperfection
Short comings
Or inadequacy in
Quality
Nature and manner of performance
In relation to any service
Complaints can be with regard to
unfair trade practices
Restrictive trade practices
Defects in goods purchased
Deficiency in services
Excessive pricing
Goods are dangerous to life of public
Non-display of vital information on goods
Non supply of proper quantity of goods, etc.,LAW OF CONSUMER JUSTICE
Generally, The Person Who Is Aggrieved
Can Give A Complaint
The Consumer
Voluntary Consumer Association
Central Or State Government
lf Many Consumers, Then One Or More
Of Them Can Lodge A Complaint
Punjab National Bank Vs. KB Shetty
Court held generally the complainant
should be Consumer himself
But in certain cases, a person can file a
complaint on behalf of the other
Eg. The husband can file a complaint on
behalf of his illiterate wife.LAW OF CONSUMER JUSTICE
Dr. Pradeep Vs. L&T Ltd.
Ultra sound machine was purchased by
the doctor for purpose installing it in his
hospital for which separate charges were
charged.
In this case court held it is for a
commercial purpose and hence, he is not
a Consumer.
Eagle ultra marine industries Vs.
Paramount pollution control inds:-
Designing and installation of machinery
for air pollution control was held to be a
purchase for commercial purpose and
hence he is not a Consumer since it was
installed in a place where commercial
activity was carried on it was held so.LAW OF CONSUMER JUSTICE
ESSEN computers Ltd., Vs. Tagore :-
In this case, complainants wife
purchases a computer for preparing her
Ph.D thesis, there was a defect in the
computer.
The court held it was only for a personal
use and not a commercial transaction
and hence, the trader is liable
The judgment passed in IMA Vs.
VY P Shantha held that medical profession
is covered under the definition “Service”
And the patient is the Consumer except if
the service is completely free.
Medical profession includes para-medical
services like Blood Bank, Druggists,
Scan Centres, Testing Labs, etc.,LAW OF CONSUMER JUSTICE
After the judgment, in IMA case, in 1995,
consumer protection Act was made
applicable to medical professionals.
Service rendered by a Doctor by way of
consultation, diagnosis & treatment could
fall within the ambit of service.
Only services where it is rendered free of
charge to everybody, then it is not a service.
If non-government hospital or a doctor renders.
free service for some patients as well as
service for patients to some other patients, it is
covered under the Act.
Complete free services alone are not covered
under the Act.LAW OF CONSUMER JUSTICE
Services rendered free of charge to everybody
Services rendered by collecting charges
Services rendered for free of charge for certain
category of persons
Services by collecting charges from some
category of persons
In the above services, free of charge to
everybody alone is not covered under the Act.
Professional negligence or medical
negligence is defined as
Want of reasonable degree of care and
skill or
Willful negligence on the part of medical
practitioner
In treatment of a patient so as to lead to
bodily injury or loss of lifeNegligence must be shown to be the cause of ultimate
tii
Negligence on the part of physician must be proved
If there is no material evidence on record, allegations
of medical negligence will not be entertained.
Undue delay on the part of the doctor has to be proved
Technique of treatment is a well recognised one, the
doctor is not liable
Mis-representation by a doctor that he possess skill
and expertise
Excessive billing or charges for which no service is
performed
Consumers are now a days are cheated,
exploited and mis-lead by false
advertisements, gifts, discounts, prizes,
etc. which compromise for quality and
induces the Consumer to gamble and
buy un-quality products which leads to
un-healthy competition, as people are
attracted towards cheap products.LAW OF CONSUMER JUSTICE
It further includes any practice in trade
which adopts any unfair method or
deceptive practice for purpose of
promoting sales, use or supply of any
goods or for provision of any service.
Oral or written false representation
Making false representation that goods are of
particular standard, quality, quantity, model,
Cin
Making any false representations of certain
second hand , renovated, rebuild or old goods
as new once
Making false representation that goods are
services have sponsorship, _ approval,
performance, benefits which actually they don't
have.LAW OF CONSUMER JUSTICE
Making false representation that seller or
supplier has some _ affiliations or
sponsorship which they really don’t have
Making false representations regarding
the usefulness of any goods ( Advertising
that the bike gives 150 Kmpl — whereas
its efficiency is only 50 Kmpl)
Giving false warranty
Making false representation in form of
Melee lniny
Promise to replace or repair an article ]
Making false representation ole
statements lowering the value of goods
or services of any low end value of goods
are services of any other person.LAW OF CONSUMER JUSTICE
Offering of gifts, prizes, ete with no
intention of offering them in reality
Violation of prescribed standards
Hoarding destruction or refusal
The above all are called as unfair trade
practices
Use of exaggerated terms and descriptions in
advertisement is not unfair trade practice It is
natural that advertisement be able to invoke
interest to buy the product
Exaggerating efficiency of medicines for
promoting sales
Description of manufacture with well known
productsLAW OF CONSUMER JUSTICE
Genuine gift schemes
Genuine sales promotion schemes
Genuine discount sales
Attracting consumers by providing comparative
information about the same products of other
brands
Any repairs in the product after the warranty
fe=Taere|
The above all are the instances which cannot
be construed as unfair trade practice.
The Consumer Protection Act Provides
Lint lautat-a Oxo )at=iUlant