2017 , 2 (62)

2016

1

2017

.

.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.

.-

.

.

.

: 279 : 46, ,
ISSN:2226-9185 4 , /15160/,
1,
. 5 .
: +(976)-11-315735
: 315735
: www.legalinstitute.mn
: lawjournal@legalinstitute.mn

3
 EDITORIAL BOARD

J.Amarsanaa Academician

Ts.Sarantuya (Sc.D)

B.Bayarsaikhan (Ph.D)

D.Gangabaatar (LL.D)

D.Zumberellkham (Ph.D)

J.Oyuntungalag (LL.D)

D.Sunjid (Dr.jur)

Z.Sukhbaatar (Ph.D)

Ts.Tsogt Judge of the Administrative Appellate Court

Kh.Erdem-Undrakh (Dr.jur)

Executive Editorin-Chief
S.Enkhtsetseg

Acting Assistant Editor

D.Nyambayar

Designed by
Z.Erdenetugs

State Registration Number:279 Address: 4th Khoroo of Chingeltei District,

ISSN: 2226-9185 Lawyers Street-1, Ulaanbaatar-15160, Mongolia
The National Legal Institute Phone:+(976)-11-315735
publishes this law review five times Fax: 315735
per year. Website: www.legalinstitute.mn
E-mail: lawjournal@legalinstitute.mn

4

/ , /

10
, .

17
.

:
27

.

34
, .
.

, 42
.

: ,

:
50
, ,
.

70
, -
, .

,
77
- ,
, , - - ..

5
 2017 2 (62)

, 87
, .

,
97
- - , .

- 105
, .
, .

111
,
.

,
116
, .

125
, ,
.

, ,

132
- , ,
.

143
.

151
- , .

6
 / , /

CONTENT
BEFORE CREATING A LAW /UNDERLINE ARTICLE AND INTERVIEW/

Constitution of Mongolia and Conception of Civil Society 10

Amarsanaa. J, Academician, Advisor, The National Legal Institute

Strengthening Legislative Power by using Experienced Apparatuses 17

Amarjargal.P, Ph.D.

Amendments to the Constitution of Mongolia: The System

Disruption Threat 27
Mashbat.O, Chairman of the Board, Ulaanbaatar Policy Research Center

The Security of Constitutional Organizations 34

Narmandakh.B, Ph.D., Associate Professor.
Munkhzul. N, Ph.D.

Constitutional Amendments and Review 42

Ochirbal. R, Lecturer, Otgontenger University

LEGAL THINKING: VIEWS AND REFLECTIONS

The Fundamental Perspectives of Mongolia: Conception and Challenges 50

Sunjid.D, J.D, Associate Professor, Lecturer, National Academy
of Governance

The Role of the Constitutional Court in State Structures 70

Udval.V, Ph.D. candidate, The Russian Presidential Academy
of National Economy and Public Administration, Lecturer, National
Academy of Governance

The Legal Consequences and the Grounds for Imposing Constitutional

Legal Responsibilities 77
Azjargal. T, Ph.D. candidate, School of Law, National University of Mongolia,
Lecturer, Law Theory Faculty, Law and Social Science Institute,
Law Enforcement University, Senior Lieutenant.

Morality and Tendencies of Mongolian Constitutionalism and

the National Security Concept 87
Shishmishig. J, Lawyer and Diplomat.

IMPLEMENTATION OF EFFICIENCY AND LAW

Freedom of Religion and the Jurisprudence of the Constitutional

Court of Mongolia 97
Gangabaatar.D, Ph.D., Associate Professor, School of Law,
National University of Mongolia

7
 2017 2 (62)

The Legal Status of Mongolian Citizens Traveling to Russia 105

Gantulga. G, Ph.D., Professor
Narmandakh.B, Ph.D., Associate Professor

Regulation for Legal Responsibility of High-Ranking Officials 111

Muhiit. R, Ph.D. candidate, Law Enforcement University, Lecturer,
National Academy of Governance

Issues Regarding Private Farming and Regulation of State Registration 116

Enkhbayar.S, Ph.D, Judge

LEGAL DESCRIPTIONS

Protecting the Right to Life under the Constitution 125

Sarantuya. Ts, Sc.D.,Professor, Merited Lawyer of Mongolia

LEGAL RESEARCHES, SUMMARY, RESULTS

Disputes over Legal Norms that Violate the Constitution and

the Constitutional Court 132
Byambajargal.A, Ph.D., Professor, Deputy Director, School of Law,
National University of Mongolia

Limiting the Disposition Principle in the Process of Dispute Resolution

at the Constitutional Court 143
Nomiinbayasgalan. S, LL.M

FOREIGN COUNTRY PRACTICES

The Constitution of Mongolia and Economic Independence

of the Court 151
Altansukh. J, LL.M, Researcher, National Legal Institute of Mongolia

INFORMATION

1992
,
, , , ,
,
,

,
.


25
.

- , - ,

.
14
2


.
-

.

: .

 2017 2 (62)

,
,
.1
,

, , ,

.
.
, ,
.
.

. ,
,
, , , ,
, , , .
, . , . 18
,
, ,
,
The new Constitution of Mongolia, ,
1992, stipulates several provisions on .
the civil society. The concept of a civil ., ., ..,
society comprises within itself the notions ., .
regarding the free market economy, .
private property or ownership, human ...
rights and individual freedoms and public
opinion. The other side or counterpart . ...
of the civil society is the rule of law. The
civil society does not exclusively mean III
the non-governmental organizations. The ,
state or government, the civil society and
the private sector are intrinsically linked .2
with each other.
:

,
.:
<<-Conception>>


, 1
., . II .
., 2017 . 53 .
2
. . 2009. . 221-443.

10
 / , /

; 1940
;
.3 1960
, ,
. ; 1992
6
,
. . 1992

, , . () ,
()-
.:
.
, ,


, ,
.


.4
: : ,
.
, ,
.

.5 , ,


.
.
, ,
,

, 2013
,




/ ./
.
,

,
,
, ,
.

,
, , .

1921 , ,

- , , .
,

, ;
2010
1924




.
. . . .. .,
3

2016 . 9 .
. -
4
.. .
, , . . 2016 . 52
.
5
: . 6
The Constitutions of Mongolia (1924, 1940, 1960, 1992)
., .. 139 . ., 2017 . Ulaanbaatar, 2009, P. 6, 86.246, 380.

11
 2017 2 (62)

.
, , ,
, ,
, ,

. .

, -
.
, 7 . , ,
. ,
.
.
2008 ,
,
,
. ,

.
.
,
,
, . 1950 , - 1949 ,
1947 , 1997
. , - 1787 , 1988
, , 1946 , 1982
.
.
, 1995
, : , ,
,

. ...
, .9

,
. ,
,
. .
, , ,
8
.
, , .10
.
,
.
,
9
, . .
7
www.legalinfo.mn. ... , 2014, . 807.
8
., . ., 2006 Durga Das Basu. Introduction to the Constitution of India.
10

, 43 . New Delhi 1997. P. 24.

12
 / , /

, (), (, ,
, )
, , , , , .

. .
. , ,
, , .
, ,
.
, , ,

. .
,
?
, ,
, .
,
. , .
, ,
, ,

. ,
,
( .
,

.)

.11
, ,

. ,

, ,
.
.

, ,

,
,

,
.
,


,

, .

.
, .
,

,
,
,
.

,
. ,

, ,
. .

11
9 .
. ., 2010 , 5 .

13
 2017 2 (62)

, ,

,
, , , .
. ,
, .
, , , ,
,
.
.
,
,
. .
,
, ,
,
, ,
.
, , ,
, ,
. ,
, ,
.
.
. . ,
,
, . ,
,
,
.

. .
,
.
,
.
. , , ,
, ,
. .
, .
. , ,
,

.
. ,
.
, ,
, .
, , , ,
,
. , ,

14
 / , /

,
. . ,
,
.

. ,

.
, ,
. ,
,
.
.
,

.
,
. .
, , ,
.
.
,
,
. , ,
. ,
, ,
. , (
,
, , ,
)
. ,
.
, .
.
,

. , ,
, ,
, ,
. ,
, . .

. .
, ,
. ,
, .
, ,
. , ,
, , ,
,
. , ,

15
 2017 2 (62)

. ,


.
, ,
,
,
, , ,
,
. .

---o0o---

,
,
., , .,
, ,
.
,
, ,
.

16
 / , /

- ,

.

,
.
,
, ,
, ,



,
. Winston Churchill 1 . ,


,
, ,
, ,
, ,
.2



,
,



,
, ,

,



,



. ,


,
,




.
.

2
Sewell, W.H. Rhetoric of Bourgeois Revolution: The Ab-
1
K. Beyme, Parliamentary Democracy: Democratization, bat Sieyes and What is the Third Estate? Duke University
Destabilization, Reconsolidation, 2000, .198. Press Books, 1994, .42.

17
 2017 2 (62)

,
, , ,
, , ,

.
.3
,

, .


, , , ,
,
, ,

. ,
.
,
,




,


, ,
,


,
,
, ,

,

.
.





.
.



, ,

, .
,
. ,
,
,
,
. .



. ,
1960- ,
3
., : ,

, ., 2016 , 138 . ,

18
 / , /

, , ,
, ,

4
.5 . , ,
//
, . ,
, , ,
,
, ,

.8
,
6
,

.
,

,
, ,


,
, .
.
,

, , ,
.
, 40
.7
9,
, ,
4
., - ,
, ., 2005 , 534 . Legal expert
,
,
.
5
., , , ,
,
: , , ,
. , ,
, ., 2013 , 15 .
,
6
., :
,

.
, 2009 , 74 . ,
//
, , , 8
.,
, , , ,
, : ,
. .
7
., : , ., 2013 , 15 .
, 9
,
. , .,
, 2009 , 74 . 2012 , 7 .

19
 2017 2 (62)

,
,
. ,

.
,
, ,

,
.10 , , ,



.

, ,
,
. , , 12


,
,
,


.11 .

,

,





, ,

, , ,

,
, ,
,

,


, ,

,

, , ,

,

10
, 19 .
11
, 12
,
(: ., : ., , 2012
.), ., 2013 , 106 . , 17 .

20
 / , /

, ,
, , ,
,
,
.14

, . 2005
, ,
, ,

,
.13

, .15

,




,

, ,
.16 ,
.



,
,


, ,
.
,
, ,
,

,

,
. .17


,
, , ,
,
, -
,
, ,
, , ,

.
. , -
14
,
, , .,
2012 , 57 .
, 15
T. B.Ginsburg, Strenghthening Legislative Research and
Analysis Capacity of Mongolias State Great Hural, 2005,
, .27.
, 16
., ,

: , ,
13
., ., 2006 , 45 .
, 17
., ., .,
: , ,
, , ., 2005
, ., 2013 , 19 . , 7 .

21
 2017 2 (62)

20
.




,
,

. ,


. ,

.21

.



.18 ,

,
.







. , -




. ,

2008

-


2



,
,
22 .

,
,



,
.
,

, ,

,
19
2015
20
, ., 2015 .
21
. , ,
18
, 10 . , 2004 12.
19
- 22
- .
, - , USAID. (: .,
, .), ., 2005 , -
, (: .), ., , ,
2008 , 217 . 57 .

22
 / , /

,




.23 27
,

, , .
,



, ,

. .
,
, ,

.



.24 , .
,

,
,

,

.25
, . 2001



,
, ,

.26 ,
, ,
.
,



,


Parliament and Democracy in the Twenty-First Century: A
23
Guide to Good Practice, IPU, 2006, .58.
., ., ,
24

: (:
.), ., 2008 , 70 .
25
, 71 .
26
., .,
: (: . , ,
27

.), ., 2008 , 71 . , ., 2004 , 12.

23
 2017 2 (62)

.28 , .31


20


.29 60
2003 5 .
19 .
64 630
, 53 -
. 1.6
,
97470
, , , 4-5
, .

.30

80%

.32
21
,

,
450 -
. , 20
-
, 15
. 2002
1998 71
4774
.

2003 3
03- .33


.
,







.




28
,
, .,
2012 , 67 . 31
/
. , ,
29 , /,
, ., 2004 , 12. , 2003 .
30
. , /
32
.
/, , 2003 . 33
.

24
 / , /

2001
3
.34
.

, ,



, ,

,


,
.35
.


1998
,
,
,

.
.
,

.

, ,
,
.36
, ,

, .

,
.37 ,
,

,
,

.
34
.

35
.

36
.

37
/
, /,
, 2003 .

25
 2017 2 (62)

,
, ,

,
,
.
,

. ,


,



. .
,

, ,

.
,


. .



. ,


2015



, ,
, . 2017
,
. ,
, 41

,
,



.

---o0o---

26
 / , /

:

.

.
,
.

.

,



. .
system integrity

, ,
,
, ,
, , .
,
,
.
:
,
.
,
,
, .
.
,

, ,

, ,
, , ,
,
, , ,
, ,
. 1

, 1
,
,
() http://www.parliament.mn/n/nhoo

27
 2017 2 (62)

. ,
,
.


, . , ,
,
. 4 ,
4.1.2 :
.
4.1.2. ,


,

25
,
.

,
2


.

.

. , -
-
-
,

,


.
.

.
,
- 5

, , ,


, .
3,

,

,



4 .
,

2
,
.
, .
( ) http://www.legalinfo.mn/law/details/368
3
, /1993-1997/

, , ,
., 2017 , 32 . .
4
, 48 .
. 5
Jen Borchert, Individual Ambition and Institutional Opportu-
nity: A Conceptual Approach to Political Careers in Multi-lev-
, el Systems, Regional & Federal Studies:Moving through
the Labyrinth: Political Careers in Multi-level Systems Vol.
. 21, Issue 27, 2014.

28
 / , /

.
- ,

, -
.
. 1998
,
6,

, .7 ,


. - , , .
,


8

.
,
.
,



/2000-2016/
,

,



/

,


.
/ : ,



,
, -

.
.
, 7
, 31-32
.
8

.

.
,
- ,
,


, . Tom Ginsburg, Constitutionalism: East Asian An-
tecedents, 88 Chi-Kent 1.Rev.11 (2012); Tom Ginsburg,
6
1992 Confusian Constitutionalism: Globalization and Judicial
, , - 2013- Review in Korea and Taiwan, Illinois Public Law and Legal
2016 , ., 2016 , Theory Research Papers Series, (Research Paper No.00-
213 . 03; 2001).

29
 2017 2 (62)

- ,

.
.
-







,
.
,

.
,
,
.

, ,
-
, .


, .
.
,

,



.
.
,



,

.



,

.
.

1895


.9
,
,




,

,
. 100.000


:
10
.

,

, ,
40-50 9
Maria Brouwer, Governmental Forms and Economic De-
velopment: From Medieval to Modern Times. (Springer:
Amsterdam, 2016), .52.
10

, 1984
,
,

,
.

30
 / , /

-
.11 .
, . ,
, -
. // . 27
, 1
,
15
,
// .12 25
- ,
25.3-
,
16
, .

.
, - 10
, ,
,
. ,
.
13 17
.18


.
,
.



,
. - (Polizeistaat,
: )
,
,
,
.


14 15
,
. + . http://www.legalinfo.mn/law/details/367
- 16
,
. http://www.legalinfo.mn/law/
details/354
11
Maria Brouwer, Governmental Forms and Economic De-
velopment,.53.
17
Geheimstaatspolizei
.
12
Tom Ginsburg, Constitutionalism: East Asian Anteced- , , ,
ents, 88 Chi-Kent 1. Rev.11 (2012), .31. ,
13
. .
14
, 50 18
., : ,
. 24 .. http://www.breakingnews.mn/c/r/12051.htm

31
 2017 2 (62)

.

,
, ,
-

25 .
. ,
-
-
,
,

.
.

- ,
-

.

,
.
: ,
,
- - : ,

-
.
,
,
,
, ,
, ,

, ,



,
,
,
,
,
. ,
.
,

,
,

,



,
.
,
.
,

. ,

,
:

, :
, 3.3-
, .

32
 / , /

:
, ,

, ,
, , ,
, ,
, 5.2-

, , ,
,
.
,
-
.

---o0o---

-
2017 7 3-
, .-, ,
., , , .
- ,
, ,
, , -
,
.

33
 2017 2 (62)

, .
.

, ,
, , , 1,
.
,
, ,
,

, .


,
. ,
,
,






.
, ,

,
.
,

.

1

, - 2010 10 .

34
 / , /

2, ,
,
. .
,
,

, , ,
, ,


,


, ,
, , , ,
, ,
- , ,
, .3

,
.

, -
, ,
.
,
, ,

. :
- ;

- , ;

. - ;
-
, ;
. - ;
-
;

- ;

- / /;
. - ;
- ;
, , - ;
,
- ;
,
, -
,
.
.
2
2000 3
.. . ., 2017, 34
. .

35
 2017 2 (62)

,

,
.
, , ,

.
, ,
, , ,

.
,

,
.
,

,
. .
,
, ,
,


//-
. .

,
,

:


,
, ,
.

.


,


,
.

,

,
.
, ,
.
, .

.

,

36
 / , /

,
, ,
,
.
,
.
, , .
5
,
,
, .
,



. ,

,
, ,
, ,



. : 6 50
, 7 100
.

. .
,
, , :
.
- ,

,
, ;

- ,
. ,

,

,

,
;

- ,
.4 ,
, ,
,
. , 5
: - ,
, 10
. , 27
. 1947 , 1953
,
.
6
https://www.senato.it/documenti/repository/istituzione/cos-
4
... , tituzione_inglese.pdf
., 1997, . 42 7
http://australianpolitics.com/constitution/text

37
 2017 2 (62)

, .
,

, . :
, 8
-

;
,
-
, , ;
-
,

;
. - ,
9
, ;
, -
;
,
- ,


,

,
.


,

10 ,

, ,
, ,
, . ,

- ,
.

11 ;
,
- ,
,
;

- ,
, ,

. ;
, - ,
, ,
;
- ,
8
http://www.parliament.am/library/sahmanadrutyunner/is-
pania.pdf

9
http://legislationline.org/documents/section/constitutions/ .
country/12
https://www.constituteproject.org/constitution/Portu- ,
10

gal_2005.pdf
,
11
https://india.gov.in/my-government/constitution-india/con-
stitution-india-full-text

38
 / , /

,
:
, 12, -
, 2, 3
13,
14, ;

-
15 .
3


16 ;
,
-

,


.


,

.
17 .
,


,


, , , ,

1-4 ,
2
1 ,

1 ,

2 ,

1, 2 ,

1 ,
.
, , ,

,
.
1 ,
, 1 ,
1 , ,
, , 1,2
, , ,
,
35, .

2017 2
.
9- ,

5.2.2
.
... ,
1
12
, ., 1992, 01
4
13
, ., 2011, 03
, ,
14
, ., 2016, 09
1 ,
15
, ., 2017, 09 1 ,
16
26
,
, . .
17

:
, ,
.
- 5.4

39
 2017 2 (62)

, ,
5.3.3-

,

- 20
.




- 30.1
, ,
,
,
- 40.1 , ,
,
,
, ,
, ,
.
, ,
actus contrarius- ,
, , ,

.
.
,
6.1.1- , ,
, ,

, 74
, ,
74.9
18 .
,

. , .
,

...

,
,
, ,



,
, ,






,


.
, ,

18
., .. ,
. ., 2017. 509 .

40
 / , /

, ...
,
,

.
.




/ / .

---o0o---

.
2006 90
,
.
, ,
,
,
.

, , ,,
. . 14
.
,
, , :
, .
.
, .

41
 2017 2 (62)

,



,
,

,
,

.




. .
,

,

/amendment/, , ,
/replacement/,
/Basic Structure ,
Doctrine/,
/constitutional essentials/
, ,


.
,

. ,
,
2010
,
,
, ,
. . ,
,
,
, ,
, ,
,
.

,
.

42
 / , /

,
,

1
.
, .
2015
2000

. ,
,
/
,


,
/,


,

.

1999 12

,
,


2000

11 29-




2
2, 1,
2015 40
1


.
.
,
,

,


, ,
, ,
. 2000 12
14-
,
.
,
. ,
,
2005 .

,
.

1

, 2005 12 19- ,
5/51,
2005 .
5/51 2

, 2015 03 30- ,
, 40,
.

43
 2017 2 (62)

,
, ,
,

, .
, /1920/, /1958/, /1949/,
, /1949/, /1950/,
, /1991/, /1988/, /1787/,
,
,




.
,
, ,
. ,
368
4, 5
, 1976
,
.
. 1980

Union of India- Minerma

Mills-


,




.4
3

,

. , ,
140
,

.
,

.

,

.
, . 1949 -
93
, ,
4
Virendra Kumar. (2007). Basic Structure of the Indian Con-
3
Kemal Kozler. (2008). Judicial Review of Constitutional stitution: Doctrine of constitutionally controlled governance,
Amendments: A Comparative Study, Ekin Press. .22. Journal of the Indian Law Institute, Vol.49:3. .373.

44
 / , /

.
,
, ,
,
1970, 1991, 1996, 2004
,

.5
,


,
.
, .
2000
, , ,
, /
, ,
, ,
/
, .
,

. , ,


,
, ,

. ,
.
, ,

,
,
2010
,

. .
9 ,
,

//- ,
45 , - ,
79
,
1952 12 12-
, .

5
Kemal Kozler. (2008). Judicial Review of Constitutional
Amendments: A Comparative Study, Ekin Press..22.

45
 2017 2 (62)

,
44 3- 35,
,

.
,

,
,
,

, .
.
,
,


,
,
.
1942
. , ,
, ,



.
,


,




, ,
,

.6
.

,
1 1.3- .
,
,


,
6
Carlos Berna. (2013). Unconstitutional constitutional
amendments in the case study of Colombia: An Analysis of
2 2.4- the justification and meaning of the constitutional replace-
, ment doctrine, International Journal of Constitutional law.
.342.

46
 / , /

8
/constitutional essentials/
-
.
,
, , ,
.
,
.9

,
, ,
.

.
/ 9 2-

/,
, / ,
, ,
, / 112
.7 ,


.


.


1973
.


. , -
,


/Basic Structure Doctrine/ ,
,

.
, ,

, ,

, ,
, . 1958
, ,
, ,
8
Jasdeep Randhawa, Understanding Judicialization of
Mega-Politics: The Basic Structure Doctrine and Minimum
7
Gary J. Jacobsohn, The Wheel of Law: Indias Secularism Core, 2012, http://juspoliticum.com
in Comparative Constitutional Context, Princeton University 9
Gabor Halmai, Internal and external limits of Constitutional
Press, 2003, .171. amendment sovereignty, 2010. www.eui.eu.

47
 2017 2 (62)

89

,

441
.10
,

,
.
, ,
,
, Constitutional Replacement Doctrine
,

. .

,



,



,





,


.
.
-1040/2005
,



, ,

,
7
,
. ,


,
,





,
. ,


,
,



. ,


,




.

,

, 10
Carlos Berna. (2013). Unconstitutional constitutional
amendments in the case study of Colombia: An Analysis of
the justification and meaning of the constitutional replace-
, ment doctrine, International Journal of Constitutional law.
.344.

48
 / , /

, ,
,

, .

---o0o---

, ,
,

,
, ,
, , ,
,
.

,
, ,
12
.

, .

2017
.

49
 2017 2 (62)

:

:
1. ,
, 2.
,
3. , 4.

, 5.
, 6.
, 7.

.


, ,
. 2000
, -

, -


, , 2016
, ,
, , ,
, . ,
,


1992
,

.

,
,

, , ,
,
,

, , ,

,
,

2017 -
, ,



.


,


3.2 , 2010


.
48
1.1.2-

50
 , : ,

, ,
, ,
,

? . 2.1
,

3.1

, 4.1
,

,
,
, , ,
,5.1


, , ,
,
,


.5.4
, ,


,
.


, 8.1
, ,
. , 9.1
,
. 11.1
.

,
.
, 12.1
,
. , , ,
, , 14
,
, ... , 16
... ,
, 23.1
.

,
, . 30.1
,

,
.1 . 38.1

. 38.2

, , ,
.
, 1.2 ,
1
., , .,

2006 , 142 . ...

51
 2017 2 (62)

. 47.1 .
11.1
,
. ,
,
19.1

,
, ,
2 3.2- , ,
,
,
,
, .
, ,
,
, ,
,
. 2010 ,

- 48 .
3 1.1.2- ,

,
,
, , ,
, , ,
,
, ,
,
, ?
.
?
,
,
.
1.
: 2000
1. ,
, 2.
,
3. , 4.
29.1
, 5. ,
, 6.
, 7. .4
. , ,
,

4
.,
, ., 2006 , 153-157 ,
.
2
http://www.legalinfo.mn/law/details/18 , ., 2016 ,
3
http://www.legalinfo.mn/annex/details/3350?lawid=6163 194-196 .

52
 , : ,

, , 2006 17 15 , 2007
16 8 , 2009 16 12
, 2012 19 17 , 2016
, 16 8

,

. 1748 . 1992
2.1
6

.5
, ,
,
. (
20, 25.1, 38.1, ?
38.2, 41.1, 47.1 )


1

1.2-






1992
.


, ,
.6


.
, ,
,


, ,

,

.
,

,
,
,

.

,




.
2000
,


,
.

2000

29.2-
.

-
,

,
1997 -




http://www.wikimon.mn/content/57798.shtml

5

6

, , ., 2004
. 2004 18 12 , 111 .

53
 2017 2 (62)

,
.

, , , ,
,
,
.
-
25.1

, ,
.
2016
25
,
. . 8
2000 59.9 ,
27.6

32.8
-
39 3.4
.
72.5
20
, - 4.5
.
.
- 36.3,
15.1,
9


. -
84.4 . -
53.9 ,
, - 40.9 , 44.6
6.9.1, 6.13-7 , 51 ,
- 40.4,
53.1,
25.1,
, 52.2 .
,
- ,
,
, ,
-
,
, ,
, 8
, .
, Nr.15(49), 2016 3 , http://www.
7
http://www.legalinfo.mn/law/details/354?lawid=354 kas.de/wf/doc/kas_18872-1442-18-30.pdf?160409103353

54
 , : ,

, ,
.
.
2.
2016
, .9


. -
3.1 1992
.10
. ,
,

2012 .
.
16.1.9 1992 , 1996,
2000, 2004

. 2008
, . . 2012
21.2
48:28
.
2016 -
, ,
. 2016
, -
. 2016 4 21-


. , , ,
, , , -
, .

. 2016 5
: 5-
11 ,
.
.




;

. () ()

; .
. ,

. .. , , ,
9

. ., 2008 . 39-40 .
10
. .
, :
, . ., 2015 , 47-48 .
11
http://www.legalinfo.mn/law/details/11847?lawid=11847

55
 2017 2 (62)

21 .13
48 , 28 . -


, .
, , 2008
. , 7

17
20 -
.12

2011 12 15- ,

4 . 2016 2012
,
3 , , 2016
30 000- ,
2
.

, .
,


, ,
2015
,

. 1990 ,

. -,

. .
, 2000
76
.
53.32 1990 92
76 72-,
13.35
1 ; - 2012 65.24
10,95 1 ; 2016
3.45 75.5 , 10
1 ; 2.92
1 . , ,
15.97
. 16
190 14
10 13
. .
:
12
2015 12 25- . ., 2015 . 51 .
30 . 14
http://eagle.mn/r/13502

56
 , : ,

21199 . 2004

18309 .
, 2890 , , ,

. 30
3300
2985 ,
, 2261
, 1341 24 16
. .
,
1200
, ,
. 2008
, ,
,
- . 2003-2014
. 2016

40.6
, 20.2 ,
59.4 78.1
.17 2016
53.1 ,
42.3
. 15 , .
,
76.8 ,
. 15 .18
2016
, - ,
, ,
,
, ,

. ,
3.
,
, ,
, , ,
,
,
. ,
1990-2004 ,
http://www.supremecourt.mn/nam
16

,
17
http://www.asianbarometer.org/survey/survey-results
18
, .
15
http://asiafoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/ , Nr.15(49), 2016 3 , http://www.
------- kas.de/wf/doc/kas_18872-1442-18-30.pdf?160409103353
-2016.pdf http://www.president.mn/content/11958

57
 2017 2 (62)

,
,
,

.21 2005
.19
10

. , ,
,
- , , ,

, .22
-

,
, ,
, ,
,
,
2012 -
.20 , 2013 -
,
, 23, 2015, 2016


,
. -
. 2015
,
-
,
, ,
.


, , ,
, , 24,
,

. - ,

21
http://www.kas.de/mongolei/mn/publications/41857/8
, 22
http://www.president.mn/content/11958
23
- ., ., .,
.
,
-
19
.- .
, 2007 7 24- 24
,
, http://news.gogo.mn/r/3677 , , 2015 ,
20
.-, , 23 . , 2011
- - , 8
, 2017.02.21- . .

58
 , : ,

-

, ,
62.1
, ,
.

,
.

, 1994
.
1995
.



,
. ,
,
, .

.25 2006
,
,
.
,

, ,
, , .
. 2017
- .
,
,
- .
, , ,
,

. ,
,
, , ,

- , ,
,

.
20
. ,
4.
2- ,
25
http://www.iaac.mn/old/pdf/book/Tailan_Layout_2015.pdf

59
 2017 2 (62)

. 26 , . 29
2 , 2012-2013 30 000
,
, , 15 000
, 30 000
.30 2014
480
, 90 . 2016
, - 22
, ,
, , .31
,
,
,
,
,

,
,





.
.27
, ,
,
,
2014
, 32

. ,
, 57.2
,
. 29.4
11.6



40.5

.
2016 155

4841
,
,
,
.28 , 115

361

, ,

7 670

, .
,
, 6

3141
11.6 .

26
.,
- ,http://csc.gov.

mn/s/44/217 ,
27
., ,., 29
.,
2006 , 153 . - , http://csc.gov.
28
2016 12 31- mn/s/44/217
188 974 30
http://www.ikon.mn/n/g4z
. 18960 /10.03%/ ,
130033 /68.82%/ , 36949 /19.55%/
31
http://www.today.mn/p/27100
3032/1.60%/ 32
, ,
. , , ., 2014 .

60
 , : ,

,
,
, , - 2014
,
3.58
2015 3.61 .35

,
, 3.96, 3.91,
, 3.80

. . ,

,
, .
,
,
, , ,
, ,
,
. .
,
5. ,

,
,
,

,


.

1996 2015
, 2006 -
, 2007
. 50.9
-
2005 , ,

,
, 62.7 .36 2015
9
,
2016 26.7
-
.33 . 2015
41.2




2016
2013
176 87
.
2015
15 http://www.iaac.mn/files/b5df9fb0-b545-4181-893f-
35

1c8498b279f8/Uls%20tur%20huuli%20hyanalt%20
.34 2015%20last.pdf
, 36
,
,
33
https://www.iaac.mn/news/2489 , .,
34
http://itoim.mn/index.php/site/news/8015 2015 , 28-29 .

61
 2017 2 (62)

336,000

2013 5
39.7 2015 9
62.1 .37 , ,
, ,
/52.1 /, ,
/26.2 /, /21.5
/ , /30.6 /, ,
,
/18.2 /, /11.8 , ,
/- ,

.
, ,
2016 3 . ,
,
,
2016 ,


,
, ,
58.8

2015
. .


2016 , ,
, ,
.
,

. 2015 .
6. 1990-

,
(2015 59 ,2016 58.8
). .
2015

,
. - ,

2014
. .
,
2015 3 277,000 ,
2016 3

37
, 31 .

62
 , : ,

. .

, , 4 4
, , .
.

,
.
.
2017





145 0 80 ,
.
.


1991-2000

.
11.7
2008-2010
.
2 .



,
, 14.8

.42 3
, ,
1
. 3
,
2014
2-3
.38
2017
2.408.7
4 - 9.1
, 2012 .43 2013
17,3
2017 4.2 2013 166
39 , 2017 2016
2.0 16 .
.40 20 ,
2011 4,62
. 20
13 , 5
2017 2 ,
1
-7.1 .
18.7 .
.41 ,
-
2016 88
79 , 2017 85
38
http://www.ife.edu.mn/files/pdf/__
_20160421_final.pdf 2 . 72,7 .44
39
http://www.ikon.mn/n/sy9, https://ubinfo.mn/read/5024,
http://www.nso.mn
40
http://eagle.mn/r/27085,
3 . http://www.mnb.
42
http://bloombergtv.mn/---
mn/i/100618 ----/?cid=59

https://ecrc.mn/media/ecrc/content/macro-overview/2017/
41
43
http://www.mongolianeconomy.mn/mn/i/9263
Macro_overview_2017_March_mon.pdf 44
http://www.montsame.mn/read/55382

63
 2017 2 (62)

/15 , 2
/ 440
100 . 2017-2019

, .
, - 1.3
.

.
.
, -
2017 5
, 24- ,
, .46


.


, 12 .
, 2005
, ,
140
, . ,
, , - 2016 19

, , -2030


. 5
.
, 7 3,8 ,
140
. 104- . 2016-2017
2017
.
-
-
.45
5.5 . . ,
2 . , ,
- 2017
9.1
- 47, 2014 21.6 48,
900 2015 -
. 600 50 .49
. ,
, 300 .
. 46
http://www.montsame.mn/read/55519
600 . 47
http://www.nso.mn
45
https://www.mof.gov.mn/2017/02/---
48
http://www.nso.mn/content/1155#.WSV0qFi0nZg
---3/ 49
http://www.olloo.mn/n/20768.html

64
 , : ,

. 2016
3 , ,

27.8
.50
, , ,
,
, 54-
, ,
, - ,
.
. ,
,
,

.
3-4

. . 55


51 - .

50
,
. ,
,
,
, .
. ,

30 . 135
56
2013 36.5 .
187 103 , ,
.52 20

40
20 7 //-
.53 6055 .
-
, .

//- 4028
50
http://khamtdaa.mn/----
----2016/ . .57
51
Lipset, Seymour M. 1959. Some Social Requisites of De-
mocracy: Economic Development and Political Legitimacy.
54
http://lantuu.mn/lantuuhuu/project/id-shidijn-oron-tsl
American Political Science Review. 1959. 55
http://www.trends.mn/n/6627
52
http://www.ikon.mn/n/xsm, http://hdr.undp.org/en/content/ 56
Prezeworski, Adam and Fernando Limongi. 1997. Mod-
income-gini-coefficient ernization: Theories and Facts. World Politics.49
53
http://www.mn.undp.org/content/mongolia/en/home/ 57
,
ourperspective/ourperspectivearticles/2015/08/13/inequali- . , ., 2016
ty-in-mongolia.html , 6 .

65
 2017 2 (62)

, 1 395 661 ,
, 950 000 .
20 ,

, 1,2
.

1475.5 . 32564.6 ..
, 18453.9 ..
. , 123.3 .
, 365.3 . ,
338.1 .
, 24.2 .
.
, , .61

,
.58 ,
7. ,
, ,
,

,
. . -
2010
25
77.8 , . 2016 12
, 19-
35.3
, 25.9 , 6.7 2328
, 9.9
.59 .
,
, 4.6
62.
2.5
. 2011 7 ,
3
551, , .63 2015-
483, , 1587 2016
, . 2015 10

, 2014

.60 55 - 32%-,
5 -
,
9%-, 4 -
.
11%- ,
,
61
https://prezi.com/5al6ioqkottk/presentation/
58
http://sarr.emory.edu/MAS/MAS2_Chap3.pdf 62
http://eagle.mn/r/21590
59
http://www.eic.mn/DLDbase/ 63
https://www.unicef.org/mongolia/Agaariin_bohirdol_mgl.
60
http://old.news.mn/r/84161 pdf

66
 , : ,

5 - .64

10 2.4
2013

.65 129
36
.66 6.61
: ,
10- 9 ,
,
7.5
, ,
,
, , , 5.5
. 5 .
30
.
53
.


, , 2006
,
, . 2014


,
,
.
. 2015
24.4
,
2016 34.9
,
, .

. ,
,

,
, ,
, ,

, ,
.
, ,

,
64
http://www.ikon.mn/n/m5o

65
https://www.unicef.org/mongolia/Agaariin_bohirdol_mgl.
pdf 66
http://www.bti-project.org/de/index/status-index/

67
 2017 2 (62)

, . 561

. ,
, ,
,
, , ,
, , ,

, .
,
, ,
,
. -
, ,
,
.
.
,
, , - ,
,
,

.
, .
,


,

,


35 30
. 68
, 2017 5
25- - .
- , .
-
-67
28.3,4
.

, ,

. - ,
,
.
,
.
., ,
,
68

, , ,
, , 2017.05.12, http://www.presi-
67
http://judcouncil.mn/main/5746--.html dent.tj/ru/taxonomy/term/5/112

68
 , : ,

, ,
, ,
,
,

.
, ,

---o0o---

/, /
2017
2017 6 27- .
- - -
,
/,
/ .
, -
., - - .
, - -
. ,
., -

, .,
. .
/,
/ ,
, , ,
,
.

69
 2017 2 (62)

25

100
,
,


.
,
, , , ,
-
, .
.
,


, , , .
, . 1992



.


. ,

, ,
, ,

,
. .

,
.
,


. , ,
,
,

. .
70
 , : ,

.
, ,

, ,

1 .
, ,
. , ,

, ,

.
.
,
, . 1992
, 19
,
, ,
. , ,
, ,
, \
\- 2
. ,
. Rule of law
,


,

. .
,
,

25 .
.
...
, ,

,

,





,
. ,
.


,



,
.


, 1
, , ., , 1992,
. 189.
. 2
, 1992 .

71
 2017 2 (62)

.

.
1. ,
.
1992 ,

,

,
.3

... .

1992

,
,




.

3
. 2015
-
,
,
\
,
\-
\

\

,

,

5





,
,



,
.
,



.
. , 64




,
,

,


4 .
,

.
2 .5
,
.
, 4

, : , ., 2015 , 13
.
3
., , ., 2002 , 5
... . ., 1994,
30 . . 69.

72
 , : ,

, - ,
.
, .
,
. ,
.
,


. , .

- ,
.
.
.

,


. .
,
,
,
, .
,
6 .
.


. ,

, . ,
7
3-
.
.
-
, .

- 7
.
:
.
2.

, ,
,
6
., , ., 2002 ,
. 63 .
7

: , ., 2015 , 58
.

73
 2017 2 (62)

,

. \
common law\ .
,
,
,

. .
,

, ,
.
.
,
. ,

rule
of law
3 .

. , ,
.
,
.
, ,

.8

.
,

,
.
, -
.



, . 1996 7
, 17-

. 22 1
, ,
, 29 1


. , 8
.., , .,
1907, . 212-213.

74
 , : ,

.
,
22 1

. -

.
.
1998
10 23-
29 1

,
, -
29 1
.9
,

06 8 2
. 11 ,
1996 6
- 7 30- , 3

,
.
6
, 1

. ,
-
9 29
7- , 3 1

. ,
1995 1 4-
.10

2 ,


.
20 4


-



4 ,
,
4

11
29 1


10

2, ., 2005 , 73 .
9
11
., , ., 2012 ,
1, ., 2005 , 242 . 170 .

75
 2017 2 (62)

2000
7 - ,

.
.
, ,
, , , ,
,


,


.
,
,

.



,
,
, , ,
, ,
, ,
, .
,

---o0o---

2017 5 19-

, , -
-
, , ,
.

76
 , : ,

,




.



,
.



- ,

, , - - .
.
.

.


,
, .
,
, () .

,

;


,
. . :
,
, , ,
,
, ,
.
.
.

;






.

77
 2017 2 (62)

.


.
.

;

, ,

;

,

,
; ;
,
,

. ,

; .


;



. :
.
,
,
,
,

;


.
.

,

.
;
X
.

;
.

78
 , : ,

. 2
,
, , ,
,
. .




. . ...

.

; ,
,
.
.

. , ,
.
,

. .
,
.

, , ,
. .
.


.


.




, ,


.3
.

,
.1


70 70.1 . ... :

1
, ., 2011 4 (35), 16-17
2
: 1.
, . ... ,
. (70.1)
. 3
.

79
 2017 2 (62)

... ,

. 4 .
(
)

. (


) .6

.

,
. ,
.



.5

.



,
,

-

. .
, ,

,


.
.
.
(
,
\
, , \
)
.

, . - -
4
., , ., 2008 , 461- , ,
462 . , ,
5
, ., 2015 2(32), 42-45 ,
. .
6
C. ., 2008 ,
. 437 .

80
 , : ,

;

;
- ,
,


,
;
. 7



,
.
:

13



,
.
8;

...13.2.
, ,
, .
11.1.2- , , ,
,

, .


.
- 6 .
:9 ... 6.9.1. -



;
- : .
10
2009 34
;
- - , .
- , ,
- ,
, .

;

7
: ,
., 2017 , 154
.
, .
. .
8
. ., :
2006.07.06 35.
9
. - 21
., 2006.01.26 http://www.legalinfo.mn/law/de- ...
tails/354?lawid=354.
10
.
http://www.legalinfo.mn/law/de-
tails/6192?lawid=6192.

81
 2017 2 (62)

.
- .
39
4 ...
.
()

( )13
6 . ,




. ( ,


),



.14
.11

,


.
,
,
, , ;
;

, ;
13
(Impeachment) :
.

.
, -
,
, . -
.
. . 1787 -

. 12
,
.
constitutional
. \
responsibility - 2\3 \
.

\, , ,
: - , ,
\ .



,
11
, - .
: 14
Andrs Szigeti,T. J. Donahue Constitutional Responsibil-
., 2005. . 22-23. ity Working Paper Version of 24 March 2008. 9,031 words
12
. (including notes) ,
.
, , C. , ., 2008 ,
2015 02, 39 , 461-462 .

82
 , : ,

;

;
.


.

.
: (constitutional violation)
( )
, , .


,



.

.

.


.
.

.
,
.15
. - ..
:
.


. -
, 84
. ...


. 5

.
...

1
. .

,



.
.

15
John C. Jeffries, Jr. The Liability Rule for Constitutional
Torts University of Virginia School of Law September 2012
http://ssrn.com/abstract=2143180.

83
 2017 2 (62)

198
.
.
...
. -
..

. .

;
-
2002 7 24- :
,
,


(-
1 5

2/3
). .



. 16

.
1.
; . :
2. (
, );
, ; (
3. );

; (
4. );
(

. 16
.
. ...3., ,
, , ,
,
; 4/ ,
, ,
...
,
. 3 4.
13 2,3
, ,
,
7-9
. .
-
,
.

84
 , : ,

,
). .


.
.


.

,
(

.)17 .


.

18 .


,

. .
.
. ,

,
.



17
.
.
.
, ,

. http://www.legalinfo.mn/law/
.
details/367?lawid=367. .
18
, ,

.
89 ,

. 112
,
. -

.
.
-
(
),



. . . 2.
.
,
. . 1.
,
.http:// ,
www.legalinfo.mn/law/details/367?lawid=367.

85
 2017 2 (62)

;
( )
, ;

;
.
;
,
, ,
,

.
: .
,
,
.



.


:
;
( .

, ), .

; ,

, , ,
.
;

, ; .


( ,
); .
( )
;
---o0o---

,

2017.06.24-
.
,
.
.

86
 , : ,

1924, 1940,
1960
1992
.
1992

,
1


, . ,
. ,

, ,

,
,
,
, ,
, ,
, ,
. ,

, ,
,
1992
,

,
,

.
,
,


.

, ,


,
,

, ,
,
.



1
, 1992 .

87
 2017 2 (62)

, ;
, , ,
. , ,

,


-Conception ,
3 .





:


, ,
.2 ,


, , ,

,

,

, ,
,
,
,

,
.4

.


,
,
,
,


, ,


,
,
.
,
.

.

, .
,
,
.
.

, ,
, ,
, ,
, ,

. 3
.. -25 ,
.
, : ,
, , . ., 2017 .
4
-2030
2
.. : . ., . 2016 , 43
. . ., 2004 . 97 . .

88
 , : ,

,
,
,
,
5 ,
.
,

.
2009-2016
.
1992 397 , 233 ,
166 .
1994

6 . 2010

1.2.3-

,
,
, ,
,
, ,
,
,
. .
,

,

-


// .
.


1992 5
,
29- ,



7
,
, ,
,




, ,

,
.

,
.
,
5
-2030
. /, /. .,
. 2016 .
6 1992
. 2016 .
7
.
.
2001 .

89
 2017 2 (62)

-
, .

,
,
, .
,


. ,
2010 .

, .
-
,
. ,

, .
, , , ,
, .


.
.
, .

,
.
1992 , , 8
.
1992
, 1994
.

. 2010

. : 1.2.3-

. : ,
,
,
,
,
,
.

, ,
. , -
,

- 8
.. 20 .
. 2011 .

90
 , : ,

. ;
1.1.5. , ,

// (1994, 2010),
.
(1994, 2011), 1.1.6. , , ,
(1994), , ,
(2016)
, ,
, . .

,
.
,
2010
,

.
//-
,

, , /1994 , 2011
10/
. : ,

,
:
1.1.1. ,
9 .

,
;
1.1.2. ,
-
, ,
, .
, ,
,
,
, .
,
, ,
;
1.1.3. 1992
, ,
2000
-
.
1.1.4. , , ,
,
, 2000, 2012
-

9
. 2010 . 10
. 2011 .

91
 2017 2 (62)

11 //- 5.1.
,
.
1998 - ,

. 5 ,
: 4 4 , 12 , 14
. , , 1 .

.
/power hard, soft/

,, , .

. , , ,

,
.
,

,
,
2 .




. 2
,




.


.

, ,
.

, .
. :
-
, ,
. ,

,
.

. , ,
, , ,

, ,
.
-
,
,
, . ,

11
. 2001 .

92
 , : ,

,
./

, ,

, , ,
, .
/ 8.3.

2001 12 27-
- , ,
. 5 21 .
.

.
,

, ,

,
,

.
,

. ,
, -

,
, - . :
.

, , ,
, , ;
,

. , .
,
.

. . -
8
/
, ,
. /;
:
8.1. .
, ,
, ;
.
.
8.2.
-
, .

93
 2017 2 (62)

,

, ,
- , .
. ,

- .
53

- . ,
. , - ,
, ,
. , , ,

.
.

- 1)
,
, 2) ,
3) , ,
, , -,
4) .
; 1)
,
2)
, 3) -

, 4) ,
;
.
1)
, 2)
3) .
,
,
.

,
, , ,
, -

,
, ,
.
.

,
:

,
, ,
. , , , ,
,
, ,

94
 , : ,

.
-25
-

. ,
,
, ,
, ,
. , ,
, ,



.
,

,
, ,
. ,

.


,
,

,
.
,
. , ,
, ,
, ,

, ,
. ,
.
,
, , ,
, , ,
/ /
, ,
. ,

, 12 .
,
, ,

.


, ,
,
, , ,
, , , ,
(nation state) , ,
. ,
.
,
, , 12
.. -25.
. 2017 .

95
 2017 2 (62)

,
.
, -


- .
. .
,




,



.



,
-

.



70 ,

. ,

,
. ,

,
,


. ,


.
.

,

.
/
.
/

.

.



, .
-

---o0o---

2017 6 28-
.
: , .

96
 ,

. ,

, ,
,
,
,
.

,
,
- - ,
.
.1


, ,

.
. . ,


.
, ,
, .
, , , ,
, ,
, .
, .
.

,

,

.
,
,
.
,



,
,
.


,


.

1
(1992), 19.2 .

97
 2017 2 (62)

,

,
. , ,
, .
, , ,
,
. , ,

.2 .
, ,
, .


. ,
, .
-
- , ,
,
,
.3 .5



.4 .
,
,
, , ,
.
.
,
, ,

. 1993
,
2

, 400
, , -
, , .
1000 , 30

.
, . ,
, , , ,
, ,
, , ,
,

, ,
. 5
,
3
..
, ,
2014 2(48). 24-25 . .
4
Natan Lerner, Religion, Secular Beliefs and Human Rights: , ,
Second Revised Edition (Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 2006), ,
. 6. .

98
 ,

. , .8

, ,
, .
, 9
.6

.
.
.
.
.
-
. -
, . 9 -
.






.
.
,

.7


.

,

.
, , ,

,
. .

, ,
, , , ,
.
.

, ,
,





.




.

,
,

,
.

8
,
6
- 18 , - (
, 1993. 02 1994).
7
, 14.2 . 9
.

99
 2017 2 (62)

,
. , ,
,


. , .13
, , , ,
- 14

.
.

10 .
,
.
.
11 2000
.


.
.15

.
16
.
,

-
.
.
. ,



. . ,
,

.


. III
13
Anver M. Emon, Religious Pluralism and Islamic Law:
, Dhimmis and Others in the Empire of Law (OUP Oxford,
2012).namely the dhimmi rules that are at the center of this
study. These rules, when read in isolation, are certainly dis-
.12 criminatory in nature. They legitimate discriminatory treat-
ment on grounds of what could be said to be religious faith
and religious difference. The dhimmi rules are often invoked
10
, 9 as proof-positive of the inherent intolerance of the Islamic
. III faith (and thereby of any believing Muslim
14
Dr Myriam Hunter-Henin, Law, Religious Freedoms and
. Education in Europe (Ashgate Publishing, Ltd., 2013).
Republic of Lithuania Law on Religious Communities and
11 15
., . 109.
Associations of the Republic of Lithuania (1995), . 5. 16
Edward P. Lipton, Religious Freedom in the Near East,
12
Radhakumud Mookerji, Asoka (Motilal Banarsidass Pub- Northern Africa and the Former Soviet States (Nova Pub-
lishe, 1962). lishers, 2002), . 39.

100
 ,

.

.
, , , ,
,
.20
.

, 21
, ,
, ,

,
.

, ;

, , ;

;

;
,
; ;

;

;
18, 19 3
, ;

; ,
.


.17

,
,

,
, ,

,
.
, .



,


, ,
,
, , ,



.
18

.
,
,
,
19

,
,

. ,
.


9
,
3
, , ,
,
,
20
,
17
- 18 , 4 , 02
, - , 1993. .
18
, 21
, (1993),
, 02. 4.7 . (
19
, 19.2 . ).

101
 2017 2 (62)

22 . .
,
.
23
, 25
, ,
,
. ,
,
, .
.

,
.

,



.
,
,

,

, ,
.


.


, ,

. -
.

. , , ,

. 26 .


.
27
.


,
. .
:
, , , .
,
,
25

.24 . ,
,.
c 2016 1(33): 1-3 .
26
- 18 , 5
22
, 9.3 . , - , 1993.
23
., 17.2 . 27
1995 Report of the Special Rapporteur on Religious Intol-
24
. erance, E/CN.4/1995/91, . 269

102
 ,

. . ,

, . -
. 18 ,28


. 1642

.29
,

. .

, ,

.
.
. ,
,
. ,

. . ,
, ,
. - ,
. ,
. ,
,
,


,
30
.
- ,
,
. -
9.1
, ,
,

,
.

9.2-
14.2, 16.15 ,
,
, .
. , ,


. .

,
,

. 28
Richard F. Hamm, Shaping the Eighteenth Amendment:
, Temperance Reform, Legal Culture, and the Polity, 1880-
1920 (Univ of North Carolina Press, 2000), . 1548.
, 29
Brian Manning, Politics, Religion and the English Civil
, War (Edward Arnold, 1973).
. , 30
- (1949), 137 .

103
 2017 2 (62)

. ,

, .
.
,
,

,


.
,
,

,
.



,
,

.




. ,


31
,
.


.
. , ,
,

,
, ,
31
- 18 , 9
, - , 1993. .

---o0o---

,

2017 6
9- -

-
,
,
,
, , -
,

,
2
.

104
 ,

, . ,
.

,


, .



.
2014 09 03-
- , ,
,

,
, ,
,
.




.
1
-
, ,
,
,



,
-

800

,

.
.
1

. - , 2003,10

105
 2017 2 (62)

, . ,
, ,

2014 12
300

3000 , 10
,
.

, .

. 4000

2.6 ,
2 800
2 , 240

. 3
2.

2
2014 09 03- 25
- , .

-
, 11 ,
04-
2
. . ,


,

.
1922
- , ,
,
, 9
, 122 ,
, , , 20,5

. 20
.3


,
,
.


.
2
http://www.mfa.gov.mn/?p=17922
3
http://mobile.inet.mn/shortArticle/?y80ni17/12710

106
 ,

5.
.


.


. .
,

, .
3 -
. 5
- 2014 101 844
2015 238 833, 2016
. : 293 563 , 13.4-18,8
1. .
.

.

. .
2015 500

2016
2500- .
. ,


4. . -

.
,
. ,
2.

. 2015 6.

2,77
, 15 14 . :
- -


. -

, ;
4

5
Tuvaonline.ru
, http://www.newsbabr.com 6
, thhp:www.gazeta2n1.ru

107
 2017 2 (62)

- 70,9%;
. : - - 9,8% .

30-49

, ,

,

-

.

; -
:
- -
- 61,0% ;
. -
21,5% ;
30 - 17,4%
, .

-

65,1%
7.
.
-
.

, 30
8 -
.
18 1,7%, 19-
29 36%, 30-49 -
51,7%, 49- -
10,6%- . :
- 49,4% ;
1,2%,
-
1,8%,
14% ;
22,1%,
5,8%, -
50%, 9,9% ;
19,2% . - , ,
,
72,1%, 27,9% 26,7%
11%, .
61,6%, / ,
, , /
28%- . :
- - 4,7% ,
;
- 18,6%; - 36% ;
- , - 4,7% ;
- 4,7% ;
7
http://www.press.mfa.gov.mn
8
- - 12,8%
- .
,
, 2017, 3-6 .

108
 ,

, 22,1% ,
: 28,5% , 36,6%
- 10,5% ; ,
12,8% .
- 19,8% ,
;
- ,
- 48,8% ;
,
- 7,6% ;
- 13,5
,
. .

? :
- 10,5% 2014
;
- 14,5%

; , , ,
- 20,3%

; .
- 32%
; ,
,
- 22,7% .
,
,
2
: .
- 41,9% ;
- 32,6% ; -

- 12,2%

;
,
- 13,4%
. ,
- .
-
,
:
- 24,4% ,
,
;
- 40,1 -
; ,

- 28,5% ;

- 7%
. ,
- , ,
,
109
 2017 2 (62)

,
-
2
.
.

---o0o---

90
2017 4 7-
, ,
, (Sc.D), .
.
,
,
,
,
.

110
 ,

.

?

,
?
.
,

. .
.

.


, 1 .
,

, ,

,

.



- 2
.

.

.
,




.

1
.. ,
,
. . 2017.04.28 095 (5662), 2
. 2017 4 .
27- - 2
forum.
parliament.mn/projects/81
.

111
 2017 2 (62)

. ,
, , ,

,
3 .


,






.




.



(20,

21, 22, 25, 27, 28),
.
(23, 24, 26, 29),
,
(31-37),
, (38, 40, 41, 43, 44, 45),
. , (39, 41, 42, 43, 45),
, (42, 43, 45),
, (47, 48, 49, 50, 52, 53, 54),
(49, 51), (56.1),
(56.2),
, (56.2),
, , ,
,
, , , ,
, ,
( )
. (57-
, 63),

. (64, 66, 67), ,
(64, 65)
, .
,

4 . ,
5.4, 5.5-

,


.

. 3
forum.
parliament.mn/projects/81
.
4
- .

112
 ,

5.4- ;
, , ;
, ;

; ,

. 17.11-
.
,

2002

,


. 28.10- 73

, . ,

.
2002

. ,

2002
, 73

.
73 5 .

.

,
.
2002
,

73
,

, .
?,


?

- 4 (
1 )

5
1995 7
3- 41 .

113
 2017 2 (62)

6. 7. , .

,
,
2002 73 ,


8 .
.

. :
(, );

;
.




;
. Status (
)
9.
(legal status)

( , )-

.
, .
( , )

,

,



,

6
,

.
-
-

4.1.4-
; 4.1.5- ,
; 4.1.6- ,
-
. - 2002 72
,
.
,
-
,
-
. 4.2-
4.1-

7
., , ,
. . . ., 136 .

,
8
, 136 .
9
..,
. ,
. 2010 . 11. .39.

114
 ,

( )10
11.
- 5
,
, , ,
, 4 3
, 4
12 ,
. ,

.

, ,
.

, ,
, ,
, ( )
.
.
,
. 13
. .


10
,
, .
...
,
, , .
., : ,
. ., 2010 ., 437 ;
, ,
. . ,
., , ,
. . ., 235 ; ,

,
1990-
.
.
...


. .,
. ., 2006 . 86 .
11
... ,
:
( ). , 2004., 1,
.29-30. ,
12
., , . ., 1998. ,
356-359 ; ., :
, . ., 2010. 398-400
; ., :

, ( ). .,
2017 . 360-362 . . .
( ),
, (
), ,
. .,
. ., 1996 . 91-93 ;.
, . ., 2010 . 184-186
.
13
., , , .
. . ., 213 .

115
 2017 2 (62)

1990
, ,
,
, 1992



,
,
, . ,

.


,
, ,
, ,
, /, /,
/, /, ,
.

,
,

,

.
,

.




,
,
, ,
.
.




,


.
116
 ,

.
/ /- .
..
. ,
,



:
1.

26

26.7- ....
,
,
,




2,
.

8

,
:
,
1. ,


,
, , ;

2.
,
. , ;
3.
;
, 4.
,
, ,
, 3 .
,

.


. .
,



, ,


,
,




.



, .., .., ..
1

. ., 2010. .20.
. 2
. 2002.01.10. //
. ., 2002 . 7.
3

. 2001.02.01. // . ., 2001 . 6.

117
 2017 2 (62)

;

.
,
;
,
, .
, .
, ,
, 1.
,
,
, :
.
,


. ,
() ,
.
.
. .
/registratiom
of juridical person,
. /
,
,


. 4
5
,
.
-
,
.
1

.
,
: ,

,
,

.
,


4
. .
. ( ) ., 2003 . 5
.. . ., 2008 . 526
9 . .

118
 ,

6
.

.
,

, , 9 ,


,
.
/ /-
.
,


,


,

,
. .
. ,

, ... ,

,
7 - ,
..

.


. ,
.
, 2.

,
, : 1926
8 87
.

6
08.08.2001 129-


( .
29.12.2012 282-) // . 10.08.2001.
. 153-154.
7
. 9
26 26.1-
/
... .: , 1988. . 96-97. ,
8
.. : ,
. .: . . / . 2002.01.10. //
, 1999. . 14. . ., 2002 . 7./

119
 2017 2 (62)

10
,
-
1954 12 ,
11- 603
,
,
11
, ,
, .


.
.

,
26
26.2- ...
.
, /
.12,
15.2- ... /-

.13
.
4 )
... :


, . ,
,
,
,
.14
,
.
,
2008

78
.
,
2015 01 , ,
29- ,
10
.. .

(). ., 2002 . 34 .
11
- 1954 12
11 603
,
. 15-
12
. 2002.01.10. // 2009
. ., 2002 . 7.
13
. 2011.10.06.// .
., 2011 . 42.
14
// 15
78 . //
. , 2015 . 8. , ., 2008 .

120
 ,

.
.
, )
/
/ 1 /
/ .

. ,
(: 1).
.


, ,
,
,



2011 .


,
66.5 .
, , 25
56.4 25.1-
. , ,
/, /-
, ,
,

.16 , ,
, , ,
,
,
,
,


,

.
, 2009 54044

. 2015 111337
17.
, 111371
, ,
,
16
.. . 17
,
. ., 2003. . 165. . 2016 .

121
 2017 2 (62)

,
,
19,
4 5- ...
. ,
200 ...20

.
. - 23

2011

23.300, 2015 44.300 21, -

49

.18 ,
22165
, 2015
4100 -
, .
1201 ,

,
,
.22


,

.
3. .

. 126
126.2- ...,
,
, ,

. ,
, ,
,

19
. 2010.06.10. //
. ., 2010 . 28.
. 20
.
1994.05.31. // . ., 1994 .
21
(
... ) 30.11.1994 51- ( . 03.12.2012
231-) //
, . 1994 . 32. . 3301.
22
,
1869 6 21 ,
2014 //
18
2016 02 17 -
www.ndaatgal.mn/view/ //Gewerbeordnung (GewO).

122
 ,

23 ,
,

26,
12 3

2009 6 ;
15- 20
.
, ,
,
, ,
, ,

, ,
,

24. ,
3

,
,
,
27
;
. ;
, .



. 5
2014 285.500 ...,
, 145.200
. ,
,
22 28
, , .
,


, ,

,

.25 , ,


26
, 160. .,
23
. 2002.01.10. // 2003 .
. ., 2002 . 7. 27

24
. ., 2010 . . 2001.02.01.// . 2001 . 6.
99 . 28
. 2007.07.27.//
25
http://www.mofa.gov.mn/ . 2001 . 32.

123
 2017 2 (62)

.


.
,

.
,
,
, , ,

. ,

.




,



,
1921
, 1990 .
, ,

, ,
, ,
.
.
2008 78
,
, ,
,
,


,
-
.

---o0o---

124


.

, .

.

.



,
, . ,

.
,
: ;
, , ;
, , . ; ; ,
; ,
; ; ,
; , ,

,
; ,

,
:
; ,
, ,
;
, , ,
.
. ,
, 1.2

, ,

. .

1.
.
1.1 ,
. ,

.
,
,
.
, , .
125
 2017 2 (62)

2. , , ,
, , ,
, ,

. ,
.

. :
.
,
; 2
; ,
; , ;
. ,


.
.

.



1 ,
,
1. , :
3. 1/ .





( )



.
, .

:



. ,
1992 ,
. .
,
.

. .
, , :

1
Law.edu.ru, .. ,
:
- : 2
50
. http://www.embassymon.at/mn/,
, ., 2005. http://www.mfa.gov.mn/#1485132523196-a01c7d09-78b5

126


.
,

.

7.


. .
, ,
. .
, ,

, . ,
, , ,
,
.
. ,

. .


3. .
(Nidation, Individuation)
4. (In-vitro-
Fertilisation) ( )-
5. .
(Embryo, Nasciturus) ,

6. ,
,

.
.
.

, .
,
.
.


3
Pieroth/Schlink, Grundrechte Staatsrecht II, 6., ueberarbe-
itete Auflage, 1990, S.101.
.
4
.. .
//

, 6, 2015 . , .
5
https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recht_auf_Leben
6
Human Rights in Todays Ethics: Human Rights of the Un-
born (Embryos and Foetus)? (University of Coimbra, Por-
tugal), .100. 7
https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recht_auf_Leben

127
 2017 2 (62)

,

.

. ,
,

8. .
, ,
.

,
.
: ,
Status negativus
, Status positivus ,

, Status activus
.
9.
, , ,

.

7- Status positivus-
, 9- , .
,
Status activus-,
1-
Status negativus-
.
, .


.
:





.

.
.
,


10.
.

,


, ,
8
http://legalinfo.mn/law/details/49?lawid=49
2011, 16 . 10
Schlaich/Korioth Das Bundesverfassungsgericht Stel-
9
https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statuslehre_(Recht) lung,Verfahren,Entscheidungen 5.Auflage 2001, S.18.

128


(1992) .


(1997) .
,
,
11. .
, :
, 1. ,


12. .

(2011) ,
. ,

.
,
,

,
.
13 , ,
,

.14
.
,
. (2016),

,
. (2014)
.
.

15.

,
.
11
http://legalinfo.mn/law/?cat=27&l_name=%D2%AE

12
Horst Saecker Das Bundesverfassungsgericht 1989, S.

48.
13
,
:


. .
14
:
., 2000, . 13.
15
, ,


.
129
 2017 2 (62)

.
2
. . 2017
,

. .
3. , 2017
.
. (2015) ,
,
.

.
. , ,
2. ,
1 ,
,


.

.
,

. .
,
(2013),
(1995) ,
,
. .




/ .
/

.
,
.
2010 .
1 14-


1. -
.
,

.


2012

130


,
.
2. 16.

(2017)
,
. 17.

3.
.



,

.
.

4.
.


.
,
.







.





.
.
.
,
,
18



.

,




. ,


.
.
, 16
finaler Rettungsschuss
, 17
http://legalinfo.mn/law/details/12469?lawid=12469
18
Joern Ipsen Staatsrecht II Grudrechte 18.Auflage 2015
, S.51.

---o0o---

131
 2017 2 (62)

1992
- 1
, ,
. ,

()
.
,
, , , .
. 240 2


.
-
1803 . v. .
.



, ,
.
.



.
.


1
1990 5 10-

, - ,

.
2
2017 5

. ,
.

132
 , ,

m


.

.
. :
1. 1
(, , ,
, , , , ,
()- , , , ),

3 (),

. ,
();
2
,
(, , ,
. , );
3
-


.
, ,
.


();
4
,
.4 ();
5
(),
. ,
1) (abstract norm
review); (, , ),
2) (concrete review);
();
3) (review of legislative
omission); 6
(, )
4) (ex-post review)

.
(),
3
()

, , . 5
, , 5
The European Commission for Democracy through Law.
. General Report of the XIVth Congress of the Conference of
4
., : , European Constitutional Courts on Problems of Legislative
. , 2005 . 113 . Omission in Constitutional Jurisprudence. .5-74.

133
 2017 2 (62)

1.1
8, (
(abstract norm control), )9, 10,
(concrete norm control) 11.

,

. -
, .
:
12,
-
. 13

.
.

.



:

,

66

66.1

, ,
,
.


,
,


-
. 66

66.1
.6




. -
-
,


. : -
. ,
1/3,
27
1/3, 1/5,
27.6-,
20 , 1/4

50

-
,




8
, , ,
-
.7 .
- 9
, , , , , ,
-
.
10
, , , , ,
.
6
Wojciech Sadurski, Rights Before Courts. A Study of Con-
stitutional Courts in Postcommunist States of Central and
11
, , .
Eastern Europe. Second Edition. Springer. 2014. . 13-27. 12
, .
7
Wojciech Sadurski, . 14 . 13
, .

134
 , ,

.
. , actio popularis
,
. .17


, ,
,
.14

.

-
.
.
66 2
.

,

,

, ,

,





15, 16

.




.






.







.


.


,

14
.,
. . 2016. 1(33).

15


(: .., .
. ,
. . 2005 .
.)
, 17


.
16


,
. ..,
. (2005), . . ..

135
 2017 2 (62)

.

.
- , -

. :
- 111.1.1 . : 2015
9 18- 28
41


- . 20
. -

.
7.5-
7.4-
. -

-
-
. : (i) 10.3-
, (ii)


, (iii) .
-
, -

. -
.


-
.18 20

2015 9 18-
28
: . 96
66 96.1, 148 148.3, 181
181.2, 181.3
2
... , .
25
. .
- 14 14.1
. 1992-2017
,

- 3 19 .
-
,
,
18
.
. 10 2
I. .
. 2012. 65 . .
19
2006.4.12, 04 , .
2006.6.15, 02 , 2011.6.15, 02 . http://www.supremecourt.mn/news/127

136
 , ,

1.2 23
.


(ex-post review) .24
(review of negative) .
:

.
. 66.2.1- , , ,
,
,
, 21-

.

.
.
-
(ex-post
review)

. . ,

.



. .
- .

.
.

1964 , ,

.

.


. : - -
3.1- -

22 . - .
59.2-


23

. 1946 .
3
21
24
, ,
.
22
.
. , 1996. . 570-571. .

137
 2017 2 (62)

( .
) .

,



, .
,

.

: .25
-
.

.

.
:
2015 12 23-
16 .
. ,
2
43 43.3.8






43 43.3.8-
(legislative omission)

,

,
., 44

44.3.7



.
.26




1
,
,

.,
.
14
,
,
.

, ...
, ... .., 25
http://legalinfo.mn/law/details/11501?lawid=11501
1 2 26
The European Commission for Democracy through Law.
General Report of the XIVth Congress of the Conference of
European Constitutional Courts on Problems of Legislative
Omission in Constitutional Jurisprudence. . 25.

138
 , ,

.


.

.
;
2)

:
.



.

.

, ,



;
, 3)

. :


,
.

, ,


. .


. :
1)
.

: 3


-





.


.

139
 2017 2 (62)

.


.
: .


4
.27 :

1 -
,



;

2

; .
3

; ,
4

(
. -

); .
:
5
1
, Identification: AUT-
1995-3-009: :
, ;

6


,


,
;28

2
. , Identification: BLR-
2003-B-002: :







;29
.
: , , , 3
, . , Identification:
BIH-2006-3-006: :


28
The European Commission for Democracy through Law.
General Report of the XIVth Congress of the Conference of
European Constitutional Courts on Problems of Legislative
27
Omission in Constitutional Jurisprudence. .74.
. 29
ID. .79.

140
 , ,

;34
8 -
;30 , Identification: GER-
4 1993-M-001: :
, Identification: ,
BIH-2006-3-00: :


. 1.1
, 2.2

;31
5 .
, Identification: CRO-2003-
2-009: : ;35
9
, HUN-2007-3-005:
:
,

;32
6 -
, Identification: 36.
GER-1981-M-001: -
:


.
.
-

.
;33
7 -
, Identification:

GER-1981-M-001:

:


. 1992


.




25 .




. -
30
ID. .88.

31
ID. .90.
-
32
ID. . 92.
33
The European Commission for Democracy through Law. 34
ID. .121.
General Report of the XIVth Congress of the Conference of
European Constitutional Courts on Problems of Legislative
35
ID. .126.
Omission in Constitutional Jurisprudence. . 120. 36
ID. .136.

141
 2017 2 (62)

.
.

, - ,
.


, - . -
,


. -
.


.

---o0o---

. -
- . ,
- - ,
. ,
., -
, ,
. ,
, , ,
.

142
 , ,

( )

.
,

.1

2
.

.

(
), ,
, ,
, actio popularis, .3


.4
5

/
, /

.

.



.
,
. (.
1

., .) ., 2013 , 1819 .
, 2
. ., 2008 , 40
.
3
.
(. .) ., 2015 , 38 .
.
4 .
(. .) ., 2015 , 67 .
5
1992 01 .

143
 2017 2 (62)

.6
,
.
.
/ /
.7

,
.11
.8

9


.
, .12

10


.13
. ,
.14
(
) , .15

,
.
, .16


.
6




4 ,
11
., 2003, 01, 82
1992.05.08., 1992 03, 12

1 ,
9 1 ,
1992 5 15 34
1992 03, 16 1
.
1992 7 1 38
1992 03 . 3 3.2 3.2.2
7
, . 3.2.1
., 2000 , 248 . ( , ,
)
8
.
, , .
(
) ., 2008 , 62 .
13
.
., 1999 , 50 .
9
.
., 2001 , 139 , . 14 . (
, ., 2000 , 324 ) ., 2011 , 580 .
. 15
02/1995.01.18., 1995 03;
10
. 01/1995.05.10., 1995 07
.
VIII, ., 2017 16
(
, 27 . ) ., 2009 , 281 .

144
 , ,

( )17 23

. .
,


.18


19
.
20

.
(03/1998.03.27.,
02/02/2005.03.31.)
, .24
,

.21

,

.22 .

23

( )

. 20
20.1 20.1.1

,
, , ,
,
. 2016 00 .
26 26.2
...
,
, , ,
. 2002 00
. 18 4
, ,


, ,
,
17
: . 1997
( ) ., 2015 , 67 00 .
. 24
:
18
. (. * (,
.) ., 2009 , 41 . , ), (), (, , ),
19
1992 03 . ( , , )
20
1997 06 . .
, ,
21
. ,
., 1999 , 20 , . ,
, . , 01/1993.01.13., 1993 02
., 1993 1
2003 , 51 . 13 01 ,
22
( 1993 02
) ., 2009 , 272 . .

145
 2017 2 (62)

( )

. . (4)
; (5)
, , (
, )
, (,
) .

.
II.


.


I.
(

, ,

) .


,
, .26

,
; ,

26
20 20.3
,

.
, , 20.1.1

,
, ,
, ,
.
,

.25

, .


, , ,
, .
31 31.3
31.1 (
.
(1)
25
() , ), 31.2 ( , ,
; (2)
() ,
25
; (3) )
,
25
.
, ., 2017, 01 (61), 7581
. .

146
 , ,

.33
,27 ,


.

28 (49.4)
.
(6.4),
(16.10),
(46.2),
29 (16.11),
.30 (17.1.2),
, (23.1)
.
.

, .
,
. .

.

III.
.34
, ,

,
.31

, .
,
, ,
.

.32
,
,

(
. 35,
36,
,

27
.
33
.
, ., 2012 , 247 . , ., 2017 , 01 (61), 72
.
28
VIII ( )
., 2017 , 2829 .
34
www.legalinfo.mn (last visited in 2017.04.14) .
29
.
35
25
, ., 2016
, 01(33), 174175 . ,

30
: . 2010 08.
( ) ., 2015 , 72
.
36
8
,
31
. .,
2008 , 52 . ,
32
. - . 2011
., 1988 , 67 . 09.

147
 2017 2 (62)

37)
(

.
( ) .40
38)
,
.
, .
, ,

.

.
IV.

(



) 39
, ,

,
37
27
, ,

. 2012

11. , ,
38
56
,

, ,

, ,

. 2012 11.
39
*


1998 10 16
08 (08/1998.10.16.),
18
18.1 18.1.2
3, 4


2011 1 7 02
(02/2011.01.07.),
65 65.7,
35
35.2
,

2014 3 12 03
(03/2014.03.12.),
3 3.1.3 40
* ,


2015 2 11 2000 11 29 02
02 (02/2015.02.11.), (02/2000.11.29.),

,
,
2001 3 23
2015 10 28 06 01 (01/2001.03.23.),
(06/2015.10.28.), . .

148
 , ,

.41
(.18.4)

.
. ,

, ,
,
. ,
: ,


.
, ,


.

.
**
.
.
18.4
, ,
.

41
1992 7 2017

, 29 ,
, , ,
. : 01/1994.01.07.,
1994 02; 08/1994.08.29.,
1994 10; 05/1995.08.02.,
1995 10-11; 01/2000.02.16.,
2000 09; 10/1996.12.12.,
.
1997 04; 05/1998.05.06.,
1998 06; 08/1998.10.16.,
1998 11; 03/2002.06.26., -
; 2/06/2005.09.29.,
.
2005 37; 04/2014.05.14.,
2014 20; 07/2016.05.25.,
2016 22; 03/1995.03.09.,
1995 5-6; 01/1994.02.04.,
1994 04; 03/1998.03.27.,
1998 05; 02/02/2005.03.31.,
2005 14; 02/2008.02.20., ( )
2008 11; 02/1993.03.13.,
1993 02; 03/1993.05.31., - (.18.4, 23.1.9)
; 02/1994.11.09.,
1994 11; 01/2003.04.30., 2003
20; 02/2006.02.22., 2006

11; 07/2006.06.21., 2006
26; 04/2007.04.18., 2007 ,
15; 06/2007.05.23., 2007
21; 07/2009.11.25., 2010 01;
02/2010.04.02., 2010 17;
07/2010.11.17., 2010 45;
07/2014.12.10., 2014 47;
01/2016.01.29., 2016 06; .
10/1996.12.12., 1997 04;
06/2014.10.22., 2014 41
.

149
 2017 2 (62)

. .



.
, , .
,
, .
,
,
,

, ,
(07/2014.12.10.) ,
. .

.
,
,
, , ,

.

,
, ,

.

.


. , .

---o0o---

, , ,
, -
- , -
2017 5 26-
:
.

2017 7 1-
.

150


-
.




.

1993-2012
- 0.39-0.48
,
. 2013
0.65-0.85
-

, ,
, . 2012
, - 23.5-
, ,
. ,
, - 28
28.5-

1789
- 16
, .1


.
. 2015
1

11 10-

, , - 23
23.5 , - 28
, 28.5
,

.
. .
2017 1
25-
., ., ., .
.
, , 178,
2016 11 22- .
, 6, 2017 1
25- .

151
 2017 2 (62)

.4
,


. . 2012
- 23.5-


,
, - 28
28.5-
.

,
, -
. 2015 .
-


.2 ,

. .







,


.

1993-2012 -

0.39-0.48
.3 ,
-
30-40 ,
. . 1/
:
; 2/
,
; 3/ ,
. .

2010 4
1.
15-
:

- ,
2012

,
4
1/
2
., , ; 2/
( ), (: , 2004), 24 ; 3/ ; 4/
. ; 5/
3
., ; 6/
, 45 . 6 .

152


1.1.
. 5 /
/



.
,
.


,

.
,
.
- [The European Commission
, for the Efficiency of Justice /CEPEJ/]
/ 1- /
.

5
Jesper Wittrup, Budgeting in the Era of Judicial Indepen-
dence, International Journal for Court Administration, April
2010.

153
 2017 2 (62)

2.2 , ,
.
1. ,
.8
6 ,


:

,

.
,
2013 , ,
0.65 , 2014 0.85 ,
2015 0.82 7 2012 ,
,


. ,
1990-
,

,
3.2 , 3.1 ,

2.7 , 2.4 , 1.5


. 9




.


1.2. ,
,

- .
,
40/32
,

,
. 2002 ,
,
,
, ,

.


8
. , , ,
6
The European Commission for the Efficiency of Justice / , /: ,
CEPEJ/, Report on European judicial systems-Edition 2014 2013 /.
/2012 data/: efficiency and quality of justice, . 24. 9
, ,
7
., ., , , ,
2014 , 64 . 2015 4, 54 .

154


,
177
... .
6

.10

.

- 1969 12

-

1970
8 1- 20

; 16.5
8 3-
. 5

. ,
[ ]

. .12 1991

,
. Sol
Watchler
. 966.4


10
.


...
. , Tvind-

889.3
Tvind




.


Guomo-
.11

.13
10
177 ,
https://www.constituteproject.org/constitution/Costa_
Rica_2011.pdf?lang=en. 12
G. Gregg Webb and Keith E. Whittington, Judicial In-
11
Jesper Wittrup, Budgeting in the Era of Judicial Indepen- dependence, the Power of the Purse, and Inherent Judicial
dence, International Journal for Court Administration, April Powers, Judicature 88, no. 1 /2004/, . 15.
2010, 6, http://www.iaca.ws/files/Jesper_Wittrup4-2010.pdf. 13
, 16 .

155
 2017 2 (62)

. ,

,

. ,
,



,
,
.
.15
1.3.
,





. ,
,
- III
,




.
.14
/1990/- 72 3-


14
Jackson, Judicial Independence: Structure, Context, At- ,
titude, 37.\\uc0\\u8220{}Judicial Independence: Structure,
Context, Attitude,\\uc0\\u8221{} 36\\uc0\\u8211{}37.},plain- /1994/-
Citation:Jackson, Judicial Independence: Structure, 110
Context, Attitude, 3637.},citationItems:[{id:724,
uris:[http://zotero.org/users/569746/items/32A6W-
9W6],uri:[http://zotero.org/users/569746/items/32A6W-
9W6],itemData:{id:724,type:chapter,title:Judicial ,
independence: Structure, Context, Attitude,container-ti-
tle:Judicial Independence in Transition,publisher:Spring-
125
er Science & Business Media,page:19-86,source:- , 360 46
Google Books,abstract:Strengthening the rule of law has
become a key factor for the transition to democracy and the
protection of human rights. Though its significance has ma-
terialized in international standard setting, the question of
implementation is largely unexplored. This book describes
judicial independence as a central aspect of the rule of law
in different stages of transition to democracy. The collection
of state-specific studies explores the legal situation of judi-
ciaries in twenty states from North America, over Western,
Central and South-Eastern Europe to post-Soviet states and
engages in a comparative legal analysis. Through a detailed
account of the current situation it takes stocks, considers
advances in and shortcomings of judicial reform and offers
advice for future strategies. The book shows that the im-
plementation of judicial independence requires continuous
efforts, not only in countries in transition but also in estab-
lished democracies which are confronted with ever new
challenges.,ISBN:9783642282997,language:en,-
author:[{family:Jackson,given:Vicki C.}],edi-
tor:[{family:Seibert-Fohr,given:Anja}],issued:{-
date-parts:[[2012]]}},locator:36-37}],schema:https:// 15
., ., ,
github.com/citation-style-language/schema/raw/master/ , , . /:
csl-citation.json} , 2013/ 4.1.

156


.16 , ,
,
5-6
,
.17

, ,


. . , -
Blae Denton- :
-





.
.
, ,
.
. ,

1990-


- 40


16
Jackson, Judicial Independence: Structure, Con-
1969 -
text, Attitude, , . 3637.\\uc0\\u8220{}Judicial Indepen-
dence: Structure, Context, Attitude,\\uc0\\u8221{} 36\\uc0\\ 17.8 .
u8211{}37.},plainCitation:Jackson, Judicial Indepen-
dence: Structure, Context, Attitude, 3637.},citation- 23.9
Items:[{id:724,uris:[http://zotero.org/users/569746/
items/32A6W9W6],uri:[http://zotero.org/users/569746/
items/32A6W9W6],itemData:{id:724,type:chap- 41.7
ter,title:Judicial independence: Structure, Context, .
Attitude,container-title:Judicial Independence in
Transition,publisher:Springer Science & Business

Media,page:19-86,source:Google Books,ab-
stract:Strengthening the rule of law has become a key
factor for the transition to democracy and the protection of
human rights. Though its significance has materialized in .18
international standard setting, the question of implemen- /eastern
tation is largely unexplored. This book describes judicial
independence as a central aspect of the rule of law in dif- district of Kentucky/ Joseph
ferent stages of transition to democracy. The collection of M.Hood
state-specific studies explores the legal situation of judi-
ciaries in twenty states from North America, over Western,
1969
Central and South-Eastern Europe to post-Soviet states and 60
engages in a comparative legal analysis. Through a detailed 19 .
account of the current situation it takes stocks, considers
advances in and shortcomings of judicial reform and offers
advice for future strategies. The book shows that the im-
plementation of judicial independence requires continuous
efforts, not only in countries in transition but also in estab-
lished democracies which are confronted with ever new
challenges.,ISBN:9783642282997,language:en,- 17
.
author:[{family:Jackson,given:Vicki C.}],edi-
tor:[{family:Seibert-Fohr,given:Anja}],issued:{-
18
Blae Denton, the Federal judicial salary crisis, 2009,
date-parts:[[2012]]}},locator:36-37}],schema:https:// . 154.
github.com/citation-style-language/schema/raw/master/ 19
Associate, Latham & Watkins LLP. B.A., Rutgers Univer-
csl-citation.json} sity; J.D., Brooklyn Law School.

157
 2017 2 (62)

/
48.3/. 2012 -
.20 - ,
,

.
.

1989
.
.
,
, .
1993-2012
,
. 0.39-
0.48 .21
2.
,



. , 1994-2002


, ,
36.2-49.5 ,




,
/2003 15

, 79
.
/


,
/


,
/,
.
/ 2

469 /

.22
,





.
.

, , .:
.
,
2.1.
.


.
21
.,
,. 45 .
22
., : ,
, 2 , , 2004 , 146-149
20
. .

158


...
.
... 23 .

[-] ,

.24 -
2014 .27
2013
0.65 , 2014
0.85 , 2015 0.82 25
2012

.

.

3. 4 ,
,
26 .

2012-2015
1-1.5 ,

.
1-2
.


23
, 147 . - ,
24
. ,
, , /:
, 2010 /, 31 .
25
., ., , 27
., : ,
., 2014 , 64 . , 2 , ., 2004 , 147
26
. .

159
 2017 2 (62)

,
. 28 .
,


.

.
2.2.

,
, ,
,
, .
,
2012
,

.





,

,


. ,
.

1/
/ /
,

,
-
; 2/
2009 -
,



; 3/
, -
,

.29
73.3
,

,

. .30
, ,
,
,


. - 27 .

28
,
, ,
, ,
, , 2016 , 84 .
29
Watson R, Wolf M /2008/ comparing judicial compen-
sation: apples, oranges and cherrypicking. http://works.
bepress.com/matthew_wolfe/1, ., , 30
,
, , , /: : , ,
, 2013/, 8 . .

160


4.
31

2010
,

- 2.1.6-
, 1.5-2 -
, 2015 101

,
2-3

.32
. ,

, ,



. .

- 23
23.1


, , .
.


.
. 2013
- 2015

4- . 1.5-2
3

31
2015 , .,
2015 , 46 , http://www.judcouncil.mn/.
32
2015 , .,
2015 , 6 , http://www.judcouncil.mn/.

161
 2017 2 (62)

.

, - 23.1-


. , ,
,
2009-2015
10-
.33
5. 2009-2015

10-
.34
, 2014
-
/
/
23.4 ,
. - 35
23.2- 2015 10
- 2016
-
-
-

.

33
., ,
2014 , ord. 34
- . Judcouncil.mn,
mn, 2016 04 2, 2015 11 6.
http://www.ord.mn/index.php?newsid=963. http://www.judcouncil.mn/main/2413--.html.

162


.35 .37
23.4,
35 - 23.5-
,

- ,
- 23.5-

,
.
-
.36
2.3.

- 23.5
.


.
48


,


, -
,
20.3- ... ,
. -
,
2008 :
,
/

/
,
, ?
,
, , ,
23.1-
, ,

,
, ,
.
,


... .38
,




,




.


.


,
,
,
, ,

,


.
35
2016
, 37
. ,
, 2015 10 16- , : ,
http://www.parliament.mn/news/open/categories/30/pag- , /: , 2015 /, 82
es/25223. .
36
, Judcoun- 38
., ,
cil.mn, 2015 10 16- , http://www. / /,
judcouncil.mn/main/2345--.html. ., 2008 , 5354 .

163
 2017 2 (62)

,
,41
. ,

, 807
/
/ .42


. - 29 29.1
-
-
.
/2015 / -
100 , 41 29 29.4-
46
.39

.
2016 ,
13 7
.43
, ,
,


. , -
7
,
6
-
.
. -
26.1-
, ,
. -
2015 2014
.40 475
16 394
2015 516 421
, .44
2014 81 , 2015
39
, - 95
, ., 2015 .
. - 26.1
40
,
- , 41
2014 100
1954
.
, , 42
2015 , .,
2015 , 21 , http://www.judcouncil.mn/.


43
, -
. Judcouncil.mn, 2016 04 , ., 2015 .
1- , http://www.judcouncil.mn/main/3274--. 44
2014 , ., 2014
html . , 50 , http://www.judcouncil.mn/.

164


. .
2014
,

.
1.
-
, -
1.2 2.2
, 58.4 , .
-
916.5
3.4 ,
0 .45 ,
.

,


. .

, ,
.
2. 48
. 3
.
,




-

,



.


.
,


,
,
-



45
2014 , ., 2014
.
, 65 , http://www.judcouncil.mn/.

---o0o---

165
 2017 2 (62)

, ,

2017 ,
5 24- .

., -

., - .
, .
.



.
,


,

.
.
,

-
.
2016-2020 , .


, .
1960-

. 185
.
160

166


.
88 29
. ,
,
,
, ,
, , , .

.
,
.
. -
. 75-
, , .
,

167
 2017 2 (62)

,


- 2017
5 3- .
11 .

,
, ,
, , , ,

.
-
, . ,
,
, .

.

168


:
.
:
.-
:
, ,
.
:
.
:
1. ( )
2. ( )
3. ( )
4. Mongolian Law Review
5. ( )
6. (
, )
7. ( )
8. ( )
9. , ( )
10. ( )
11. ( )
12. / /

169
 2017 2 (62)

170