Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1. You can opt out at any time from anything without challenge
2. You are encouraged to ask questions. Please ask questions.
There are no stupid questions. QUESTIONS.
3. You can be irreverent but being irreligious is just killing the party,
dudes.
4. We know Judaism is weird compared to Christianity. Weird
things can have power and significance, and be important unifying
factors. You're allowed to find things foreign and odd but please
understand that they have been important to millions of people for
thousands of years
5. Jewish humour involves a lot of self-deprecation. Pesach is a
festival with a lot of opportunity for this humour, because it is a
festival about discussing our heritage. We're going to play around
with stuff a lot, and for tonight you can too, because you're our
guests. We just ask you to be mindful that these are jokes of
cultural ownership, and that Judaism is a frequently maligned
minority. Please be respectful and understand that outside of the
seder it is not your place to mock our customs (and inside the seder
it's not your place unless there's respect in your jokes)
Candle lighting - Hadlakat Nerot
Traditionally candles are lit to begin the seder, marking the beginning of this
festival
The Shehecheyanu prayer usually follows the first blessing when we celebrate a
unique or a cyclical event.
Following the Exodus from Egypt Miriam has a gift for finding fresh sources of
water, and is therefore essential to the survival of the Israelites in the desert.
We therefore share a cup of water in her honour during the seder.
This is the cup of Miriam, the cup of living waters, a reminder of the Exodus from Egypt
[Pour water from the kos Miryam into every guest’s cup]
Let our telling pour forth like water, strengthening spirits, refreshing souls.
Greens - Karpas
One of the symbolic elements on the seder plate is the karpas, a green
vegetable dipped in salt water. This salt water symbolises the tears of our
people in slavery, and of and other people who are slaves. The green vegetable
represents spring and renewal of life.
The head of the seder divides the middle matzah and designates the larger
piece to be the afikoman. This is to be hidden, and traditionally the children of
the family will later go looking for it. The afikoman is supposed to be eaten
after the meal, and its recovery is a symbol that what seems broken may be
repaired, and what seems lost may yet be recovered.
Once the afikoman is found, the head of the seder bargains with the children to
get it back. This activity is supposed to keep the children awake and curious
throughout the evening. The afikoman gives closure to the seder.
During the seder the words ‘next year in Israel’ are invoked (this is repeated at
the end of the seder to leave it as a lasting thought in our minds). As the
symbol of Judaism’s covenant with God Israel represents more than land; it
represents an ideal of community, of belonging, and of freedom and autonomy
to control our own destiny. Until we are able to help every person achieve
these things then there are still bonds binding us.
This year we are still slaves. Next year we hope that we will be truly free.
Telling the Story - Magid
The Bread of Affliction
[Lift up the matzot]
Eating matzah on Pesach reminds us of the suffering of all people who are
enslaved. It is the symbol of our forebears’ slavery in Egypt, and a reminder
that we still struggle against suffering today. The seder meal is an opening of
the community to welcome in all who are hungry or without a sense of
inclusion. It is a way of honouring where we have come from and a reminder
to empathise with those less privileged than us.
[Put down the plate of matzot and cover it]
Four Questions
[Pour the second cup]
How is this night different from every other night of the year?
Every other night we eat bread or matzah. Why do we eat only matzah tonight?
Every other night we eat all sorts of vegetables. Why do we eat maror tonight?
Every other night we eat vegetables as part of the meal. Why do we eat vegetables dipped in
salt water and maror dipped in chopped fruit before we even start the meal?
Every other night we may sit upright or lean at the table. Why are we supposed to lean
tonight?
This story reminds us that we have the luxury of freedom, and it is our
responsibility to ensure that we are grateful for our privileges and are willing to
strive for their universality.
Rabbinic Tales
Rabbi Eliezer, Rabbi Yehoshua, Rabbi Elazar ben Azaryah, Rabbi Akiva and Rabbi Tarfon we so
involved in talking about the Exodus from Egypt that they didn’t notice the time. They had
debated all through the night. Their students finally came to tell them that it was already
light outside and time to say the morning prayers.
Rabbi Eleazar ben Azariah said, “Behold: I am like a seventy-year-old man, yet I never
understood why we tell the story of the Exodus from Egypt at night until Ben Zoma explained
it, saying, “In order that you will remember the day of your Exodus from Egypt all the days of
your life”. Had it meant only the days, it would have been written, “the days of your life”. But
“all the days of your life” includes the nights as well.
In order to attain freedom we must allow people to develop to the full extent
of their capabilities, choices and responsibilities. We must be willing to
understand and support the true uniqueness of every person and allow their
ability to grow as an individual. Through this we can hope that one day we lose
The Talmud says that Jews teach our children to ask because in the womb, each of us knows
all the secrets of the universe, but just before birth, an angel touches us above our lips to
make us forget. It is therefore that it is the business of the rest of our life to question and
learn.
The wise asks: “What are the teachings and commandments? What are our
responsibilities to those less fortunate than us?”
The wise child is curious, interested, and eager to learn. It is important to note
that they are not yet full of knowledge, but that wisdom is defined by an
interest in learning more. Our responsibility is to praise the child who engages
with social issues, encouraging them to take an active place in the community.
The wicked asks: “What meaning does this have for you? And why should I care
about others?”
The wicked child takes a step back, removing themself from their responsibility
to others. Judaism suggests that we respond ‘with pointed teeth’, reminding
them that a person who does nothing for others cannot expect others to
support them.
The artless child asks: “What is this? What can we do to help these people?”
And what do we say to the child who does not know how to ask?
We tell them that there is a commandment: ‘Thou shalt not stand idly by the
shedding of the blood of thy fellow man’. In Hebrew the word is not specific to
other Jews but refers to our fellow human beings, Jewish or not.
[refer to NA Haggadah for commentaries]
The story goes…
[refer to NA Haggadah for story and commentaries]
The Plagues
When Moses went down to Egypt to ask for the release of the Hebrew slaves
Pharaoh’s heart was hardened and he prevented our ancestors from leaving.
As a result God sent plagues to punish the Egyptians until he was broken down
and let us go. We do not rejoice, however, over his downfall and defeat. We
cannot be glad when any person needlessly suffers, even our enemies who
seek to destroy us.
The custom of removing a drop of wine for each plague dates back to medieval
times, and reminds of the misery of the innocent Egyptians. We diminish our
joy as we recount the suffering of these people.
[We remove a drop of wine from our cups as we recall each plague.]
Blood Dam
Frogs Tz’fardei-a
Lice Kinim
Pestilence Dever
Boils Sh’chin
Hail Barad
Locusts Arbeh
Darkness Choshech
If He had carried out judgments against them, Ilu asah bahem sh'fatim
and not against their idols v'lo asah beloheihem,
Dayeinu, it would have been enough! dayeinu!
If He had split the sea for us, Ilu kara lanu et hayam,
and had not taken us through it on dry land v'lo he'eviranu b'tocho becharavah,
Dayeinu, it would have been enough! dayeinu!
If He had taken us through the sea on dry land, Ilu he'eviranu b'tocho becharavah,
and had not drowned our oppressors in it v'lo shika tzareinu b'tocho,
Dayeinu, it would have been enough! dayeinu!
If He had drowned our oppressors in it,
Ilu shika tzareinu b'tocho,
and had not supplied our needs in the desert for
v'lo sipeik tzorkeinu bamidbar arba'im shana,
forty years
dayeinu!
Dayeinu, it would have been enough!
If He had supplied our needs in the desert for
Ilu sipeik tzorkeinu bamidbar arba'im shana,
forty years,
v'lo he'echilanu et haman,
and had not fed us the manna
dayeinu!
Dayeinu, it would have been enough!
If He had fed us the manna, Ilu he'echilanu et haman,
and had not given us the Shabbat v'lo natan lanu et hashabbat,
Dayeinu, it would have been enough! dayeinu!
If He had brought us into the land of Israel, Ilu hichnisanu l'eretz yisra'eil,
and not built for us the Holy Temple v'lo vanah lanu et beit hamikdash,
Dayeinu, it would have been enough! Dayeinu
What does this mean, ‘It would have been enough’? Surely no one of these
alone would indeed have been enough for us. The key is that we should
celebrate each step toward freedom as if it were enough, and then to start out
on the next. If we reject each step because it is not the whole liberation we
will never be able to achieve the whole liberation.
This does not give us permission to be passive. We celebrate each step but we
must continue to strive towards tikkun olam, our obligation to repair the world.
An alternative Dayeinu should then be considered:
If we were to ensure the Jewish people never return to slavery, but not to protect other
minorities from violence, it would not be enough for us
If we were to protect other minorities from violence, but not to treat them with honour and
respect, it would not be enough for us
If we were to treat other minorities with honour and respect, but not to make an effort to truly
understand their struggle, it would not be enough for us
If we were to make an effort to truly understand the struggle of minorities, but not to end their
oppression, it would not be enough for us
The singing of Dayeinu varies in different cultural groups. It is traditional in Afghanistan and
Iran to beat your fellow seder members with spring onions during the verse about the
manna. This recalls the passage in the Torah where the wandering Hebrews complain that
they have nothing but manna to eat, where back in Egypt they had many different foods,
including spring onions. This is by far one of the best stories in the Tanakh and ends in a
spiteful flood of quail. By hitting one another with onions we remember that though the
food in Egypt was more exciting, it had the drawback of being the food of slavery.
It is also tradition to sing the chorus of Dayeinu during Israeli productions of Rocky Horror
Picture Show, after the line “if only we hadn't made this journey...if only the car hadn't
broken down...oh, if only we were amongst friends...or sane persons”.
Second Cup of Wine - Kos Sheini
The second cup of wine represents God’s promise to free us from slavery.
Pesach
[Point to the bone but do not lift it]
This bone represents the sacrifice that our ancestors ate in the time of the
Temple. This sacrifice commemorated that sacrifice made by our ancestors in
Egypt, where they marked their doorposts with blood so that God would pass
over their houses and spare them.
Matzah
[Raise the broken middle matzah]
At the beginning of our Seder we say ‘this is the bread of affliction which our
ancestors ate in the land of Egypt. Let all who are hungry come and eat’. What
hospitality is that, offering guests the bread of affliction?
Matzah has two different symbolisms. At the beginning we call it the bread of
affliction, but at this point in the Seder we describe it as the bread of freedom
which our ancestors consumed as they were leaving slavery. How do you
transform the bread of affliction into the bread of freedom? By sharing it with
others. When we share our bread with others, we have taken the first step
from affliction to freedom. Sharing our vulnerabilities, we discover strength.
Reaching out to others, giving help to the needy, food to the hungry, we bring
human solidarity; which is the beginning of freedom.
Maror
[Lower the matzah and raise the maror]
Traditionally we eat the bitter herb to remind us of our time of slavery. Cruelty,
violence and oppression plague every human society, darken our world,
embitter our lives, and challenge us to raise our voices in the name of justice.
It has also been suggested that bitter herbs are eaten in order to awaken the
senses and make the eater feel more alive.
Why do we have an orange on our seder plate?
There are two versions of the origin of this tradition. The best known tells of a
rabbi responding that “a woman belongs at the bimah like an orange on the
seder plate” when asked about the place of women as rabbis in Judaism. The
alternative and original version is more convoluted, but no less important. It
deals with an early feminist Haggadah suggesting the inclusion of a crust of
bread on the seder plate, referencing a rabbinical sneer that queer women
“have as much a place [in Judaism] as a crust of bread on the seder plate”. Dr
Susannah Heschel, two whom this plan was proposed, instead suggested an
orange, as adding bread would render the whole seder chametz. The orange
represents the fruitfulness of queer Jews, its seeds representing their rebirth
into their own community.
In every generation…
In every generation a person is obligated to see themselves as if they were the
one who went out of slavery in Egypt. This legacy of freedom is not a thing of
the past; it is relevant to all of us here in the present, and it is our responsibility
to ensure that we continue to strive for the freedom that we have been given.
The telling alone is not enough; it must lead us to act in the world
Motzi/Matzah
We eat matzah tonight, as this was the food which our ancestors ate leaving
Egypt, as they did not have time to wait for their bread to rise. It reminds us
that when the chance for liberation comes we must seize it, even if we do not
feel ready. If we wait until we are fully ready we may miss our chance or not
act at all.
[hand around some maror between pieces of matzah to every member of the seder]
[hand around a hard boiled egg (in salt water if you like) to every member of the seder]