Professional Documents
Culture Documents
To cite this article: Thomas S. Noonan (1977): Pre-970 dirham hoards from Estonia
and Latvia, I: Catalog, Journal of Baltic Studies, 8:3, 238-259
This article may be used for research, teaching, and private study purposes.
Any substantial or systematic reproduction, redistribution, reselling, loan,
sub-licensing, systematic supply, or distribution in any form to anyone is
expressly forbidden.
The publisher does not give any warranty express or implied or make any
representation that the contents will be complete or accurate or up to
date. The accuracy of any instructions, formulae, and drug doses should be
independently verified with primary sources. The publisher shall not be liable
for any loss, actions, claims, proceedings, demand, or costs or damages
whatsoever or howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in connection
with or arising out of the use of this material.
PRE-970 DIRHAM HOARDS FROM ESTONIA AND LATVIA, I:
CATALOG
This catalog constitutes the first of several articles on the dirham hoards from
Estonia and Latvia whose most recent coins date to the period before 970.1
Subsequent articles will discuss some of the basic problems involved in the
analysis of these hoards and will provide a detailed, numismatic examination of
the Estonian and Latvian hoards during the period c. 800-c. 900 and 900-970.
The catalog of the pre-970 dirham hoards from Estonia and Latvia is meant
to serve several purposes. First of all, it is an essential source for any discussion
of the hoards themselves. The catalog provides the interested reader with the
data from which the introduction, analysis, and conclusions were all derived.
Secondly, the materials on the dirham hoards from the southeastern Baltic are
found in a variety of studies, some of which are not readily accessible. The
catalog thus attempts to assemble in one place the materials contained in num-
erous works published over the past century or so. Henceforth, those interested
in these hoards will hopefully find the information they seek in the more readily
available form of this catalog. Finally, l have attempted to provide as much
data as possible about each hoard. Most of the studies published since World
War I which treat the dirham hoards from Estonia and Latvia have tended to
describe these hoards very succinctly. As a result, much important and necessary
information about the coins in these hoards is simply omitted. The limited data
found in these overly abbreviated accounts is not adequate for serious research.
While our catalog does not provide all the available data on each dirham, it is
designed to meet the needs of those readers who wish and need all the essential
information on the coins from Estonian and Latvian dirham hoards. In short,
the catalog is both a necessary complement to the detailed analysis found in
this series of articles and an independent work which can be utilized by all
those wishing to study the pre-970 dirham hoards from the southeastern Baltic.
Short of describing each dirham in great detail, there is no perfect way to
itemize the coins in any hoard. Since space limitations have made it impos-
italicised and the total coins from the reign are given in parenthesis after the
name.
At times, we possess numerous dirhams from a given mint issued during the
reign of one ruler. In such cases, I have abbreviated the description by simply
giving the total number of dirhams and the dates of the oldest and most recent
identified dirhams. Parentheses are placed around a ruler's name if the dirham
dates from his reign but our sources do not give his name for some reason
(i.e., the name was effaced, illegible, cut off, etc.). The sources often use a
question mark to indicate that the name and/or mint and/or year, while probable,
cannot be defin!tely determined. In so far as possible, I have retained these
question marks. It is hoped that this format will provide all the essential informa-
tion in the most expeditious fashion. The above format has been modified where
the few remaining dirhams from a hoard are described in the text.
In conclusion, a few comments on terminology would be appropriate. Dirham
was the name given to the silver coin in the Islamic monetary system-the gold
coin was called a din~r. The earliest Arabic dirhams were imitations of Sasanian
drachms but, following the monetary reforms of 'Abd al-Malik in 698, the use
of Pahlevi was abandoned and all inscriptions were in the Kfific style of Arabic
script. As a result, scholars have long referred to the post-reform dirham as a
Kfific coin. In recent years, however, many specialists in medieval Muslim
numismatics have preferred the more accurate term dirham to the traditional
appelation of Kfific coin. The standard weight of the post-reform dirham was
2.97 grams although, starting in the mid-ninth century, the weight of the dirham
began to vary. For further information see G. C. Miles, "Dirham," Encyclopaedia
of Islam, n.e., 2 (1965), 319-320.
NOTE
1 These articles are based on a paper presented to a session on ancient and medieval
Baltic history at the Fifth Conference on Baltic Studies, Columbia University, New
York City, May 20-23, 1976. Professor Archibald Lewis of the University of Massa-
chusetts, who was the discussant at that session, offered several very useful suggestions.
The author would like to express his special thanks to Michael Bates of the American
Numismatic Society who kindly agreed to evaluate both the original paper and this
catalog. His extensive comments have been of great assistance. Finally, I would be
remiss not to thank Joan Fagerlie and the staff of the Inter-Library Loan Division
at the University o f Minnesota who have obtained so many important numismatic
publications for me over the past several years.
Downloaded by [Instituto De Ciencias Matematicas] at 05:55 09 December 2011
tO
4~
O
Livonia
dated from 751/52 to 871/72. The mints included: al-KUfah, Surra man
ra'a, Madinat al-Sal~m, al-Basrah, N i . s ~ , H~ron~bad, Arminiyah, al-Muh.m-
madiyah, Isbah~n, Zaranj, Ni-s~bUr, Mary, Balkh, and Samarqand. References:
Fraehn, p. 30, No. 27; Markov, pp. 20-21, No. 117; Arne, p. 77, No. 5;
Paxomov, 1 (1926), p. 77, No. 256; Janin, pp. 100-1, n. 1 & p. 102, No.
26; Mugurevi~s, p. 22, n. 2.
Latvia
period 833/34-852/53 were found on the farm Ilgi, near Grobi0a. References:
Fraehn, p. 110, No. 23b; Frank, p. 387, No. 18; Markov, p. 15, No. 85; Ame,
p. 77; Friedenthal, No. 107; Janin, pp. 100-1, n. 1 & p. 102, No. 27; Urt~ns
1964, p. 49 & p. 71, No. 14; Mugurevi~s, pp. 24-25, No. 3 & p. 23.
The 3 dirhams were: al-Ma'mfin, Madinat al-Sal~m, 833/34; al-W~thiq, Surra
man ra'a, 844/45 ; al-Mutawakkil, Madi-nat al-Sal~m, 852/53.
The circumstances of the find are not described. As a result, it is not clear
whether these 3 dirhams composed part of a hoard which has now been lost,
Downloaded by [Instituto De Ciencias Matematicas] at 05:55 09 December 2011
6 dirhams between 907/08 and 913/14; Samarqand, 907/08, 9t2/13 (3); Andar-
~bah, 912/13. Nas.rb. Abmad(19): al-Sh~sh, 9 dirhams between 913/14 and 932/
33; Samarqand, 7 dirhams between 913/14 and 936/37;Nis~bfir, 913/14,934/35;
al-Mul~ammadiyah, 928/29. Nab b. Nas.r (4): Samarqand, 952/53; Bukh~ra,
946/47,947/48, 951/52. Imitation-S~m~mid dirhams (5).
IV. Miscellaneous (53): 53 dirham fragments.
Frank's description
I. 'Abbdsid (1):
al-Mutawakkil, Madinat al-Sal~m, 857/58.
II. S afy~rid (1):
'Amr b. Layth, Shiraz, 895•96.
III. Samanid (60):
Ism~'il b. Ahmad (t5): al-Sh~sh, 10 dirhams between 895/96 and 906/07; un-
known mint, (893/94-901/02); Samarqand, 901/01; Balkh, 906/07; fragments
(2). Abroad b. lsm~'t7 (13): al-Sh~sh, 6 dirhams between 907/08 and 913[14;
Samarqand, 907/08, 911/12, 912/13 (3); Andar~bah, 912/13; unknown mint,
907/08. Nas.r b. Ah.mad (20): al-Sh~sh, 9 dirhams between 913/14 and 932/33;
Samarqand; 7 dirhams between 913/14 and 936/37; Nis~b~r, 934/35; Bukh~r~,
year unknown; fragments (2). N~ab b. Nasr (4): Bukhar~,946/47,947/48, 951/52,
953/54. Other Sdm~nid (7): unknown arnir, Bukh~r~, xx5 H.; fragments (6).
IV. Miscellaneous (43):
Barbarian imitation of a SAm~niddirham; fragments (42).
According to Vasmer, this hoard consisted of 1 'Abb~sid, 1 Saf~rid, 100
S~m~'aid, and 6 imitation dirhams. I have followed Vasmer's figures for the
dynastic distribution. Since the differences between Markov and Frank are
not substantial, I have followed Markov's account, which reflects the analysis
of Tiesenhausen.
11 Riga, 1950. During construction work, a large clay jug with around 300 coins
was found. Only one coin from the hoard was identified: a SAm~niddirham,
N~l. b. Nasr, Samarqand, 944/45. References: N.D. Mec, A.S. Mel'nikova,
"Klady monet (zaregistrirovannye Gosudarstvennym Istori~eskim Muzeem
v 1955-1958 gg.)," EJ~egodnik Gosudarstvennogo Istori~eskogo Muzeja
(Moscow: 1961), p. 80, No. 89; Mugurevi~s, pp. 24-25, No. 8; Kropotkin
1971, p. 94, No. 199.
12 Talsi, 1822 or 1882. Mugurevi~s, with references to Frank and Markov, lists a
hoard containing one dirham of 901-932 found here in 1882. Frank mentions
246 Journal of Baltic Studies
a Sasanian drachm of Khusraw which came from Talsi in 1822, while Markov
reports that an Ispahbad coin was discovered in 1823 near Talsi. Our sources
do not make it clear what kind of coin was found at Talsi, when it came to
light, and, most important, why it should be described as part of a hoard.
References: Frank, p. 388, No. 25; Markov, p. 14, No. 81; Mugurevi~s, pp.
24-25, No. 14.
13 In Livonia, near Riga, around 1790. Thirty-six "Kufic" coins were reportedly
unearthed near Riga. No further information on these coins is available. This
Downloaded by [Instituto De Ciencias Matematicas] at 05:55 09 December 2011
is the first recorded dirham hoard from Latvia. References: Fraehn, p. 29, No.
24; Markov, p. 21, No. 118; Arne, p. 77, No. 4; Urt~ns 1964, 70.
14Berkava (Borkowitz), Dist. of R~ga, no date given. A hoard of 140 dirhams,
which was buried sometime in the tenth century, was discovered here. No
further information is available on this hoard. References: Friedenthal, No.
98; Urt]ns 1970, 98.
Estonia
al-Sh~sh, year unknown; Madi-nat al-S-al~m, 897•98; mint and year unknown.
al-MuktajZ: Madinat al-Sal~m, 903/04. al-Muqtadir: al-Bas.rah,924/25; Madinat
al-Sal~m, 909/10, 931/32, year unknown; al-Maw.sil?,908/09. al-Qahir: al-Bas.rah,
933.
II. s~jia (1):
Y~suf b. D~wd~d, Barda'a, 901/02.
III..Safj~r/d (4):
'Amr b. Layth: Shiraz, 897/98; Nisa-bQr, 897/98. Ab~ .Hafs and T~hir b. Mu-
h.ammad: Mary, 897/98. Ah.mad b. Muh.ammad and .Husayn b. Bil~l: Sijistgn,
932/33.
IV. AmTr al-Umard' (1):
Tfizfin, Wgsit, 944/45.
V. Buwayhid (6):
'Aft b. Buwayh: Shirgz, 934/35,937/38, 935/36-937/38. 'AII b. Buwayh and
'Abu al-IJusayn b. Buwayh: [Aydaj], 939/40. 'lmad al-Dawlah and Mu'izz al-
Dawlah: al-Ba.srah, 947/48. 'Imad al-Dawlah and Ah.mad b. Buwayh?: mint and
year unknown.
VI. S~m~nid (715):
Ismd71 b. Al~mad (116): Andargbah, 10 dirhams between 902/03 and 907/08;
Madinat Balkh, 902/03 (3); Balkh, 904/05 (2), 905/06 (5); Samarqand, 23
dirhams between 895/96 and 906/07; al-Shgsh, 67 dirhams between 895/96
and 907/08; Mary, 900; Ma'din, 905/06; Nisgbgr, 906/07 (2); Uncertain mint,
893/94-901/02, 900/0~-901/02. Abroad b. Isrn~'t-I (84): Andar~bah, 9 dirhams
between 908/09 and 913/14; al-Bij~r, 910/I 1; Samarqand, 17 dirhams between
907/08 and 913/14; al-Sh~sh, 56 dirhams between 907/08 and 913/14; Nis~b~r,
911/12. Is'baq b. Ah. mad (1): Samarqand, 913/14. Nas.r b. Abmad (432):
Andar~bah, 26 dirhams between 914] 15 and 940•41 ; Balkh, 32 dirhams between
912/13 and 939/40; Panjhir, unknown date (2); al-Khuttal, 926/27; Samarqand,
178 dirhams between 911 / 12 and 942[43 (913/14-920/21 = 35, 921/22-942/43
= 143); al-Shgsh, 154 dirhams between 914/15 and 942/43 (913/14-920/21 = 23,
921/22-942/43 = 131); Farw~n, 926/27, 927/28 (2), 935/36; Fir~m, unknown
date; al-Mubammadiyah, 935/36; Ma'din, 11 dirhams between 912/13 and
935/36; Nis~bQr, 16 dirhams between 914/15 and 941/42; 6 unknown or unclear
dirhams, 922/23-940/41. Yaby~ b. AOmad (1): Bukh§ra, 930/31. Ngth. b. Nas.r
(80): Bukh~rK 31 dirhams between 945/46 and 951/52 and 1 between 952•53
and 954/55; Samarqand, 39 dirhams between 943•44 and 951/52; al-Sh~sh, 9
248 Journal o f Baltic Studies
dirhams between 943]44 and 947•48. IbrahFmb. Abroad (1): Samarqand, 946]47.
VII. Volga Bulgars (24):
Amir "B~rm~n" (3). M - ~ b. Ja'far (19): Madinat Bulgar (2); al-Sh~sh (3);
Nis~bar, 920/21 (3); mint and year unknown (8); fragments (3). T~lib b. Ah.mad
(2): Suvar, 949/50; unknown mint, 949]50.
VIII. Barbarian Imitations (137):
IX. Unminted Blanks (8):
16Saue, Harjumaa 1913. A hoard of 13 dirhams was found. The coins were
Downloaded by [Instituto De Ciencias Matematicas] at 05:55 09 December 2011
identified by Ernst Frey who believed the hoard might also have included
a few Russian and/or Byzantine coins. The oldest dirham dated to 895]96 and
the most recent to 935]36. Vasmer felt, with good reason, that these 13
dirhams formed part of the large VanamSisa hoard (No. 15 of this catalog).
Therefore, while listed as a separate hoard in this catalog, the 13 dirhams
are considered as part of the VanamSisa hoard in the analysis and tables.
My description of the hoard follows Vasmer, whose account differs somewhat
from that of Frey. References: Frey, 84; Vasmer 1925, 114-6;Vasmer 1928;
Vasmer 1926, p. 292, No. 40; Vasmer 1929, p. 293, No. 46; Janin, p. 118,
n. 2 and p. 120, #45; Kropotkin 1962, p. 40, No. 330; TSnisson, No. 7-8, p.
189 and pp. 240-1; Kropotkin 1965, p. 181, No. 101 (330).
I. S.affgrid (1):
"Amr b. Layth, ShTr~z, 895]96.
II. S~m~nid (9):
Ism~'il b. A.hmad (3): al-Sh~sh, 899/900, 903]04; Samarqand, 905/06. Al~madb.
Ism~'~ (2): Andar~bah, 907]08; NTs~bQr, 908]09. Nas.r b. Abmad (4): al-Sh~sh,
916[17,928/29; Ni-s~b~r, 935]36; B~miy~n, year unknown.
III. Imitations (3):
17 In the former Estland province, near Tallinn, before 1841. An earthen vessel
containing 12 dirhams was found. The coins, described by T. C. Tychsen,
were preserved in the Museum of G6ttingen Univ. The oldest coin was an
Umayyad dirham of 716/17 and the most recent dirham dated to 942/43.
References: Fraehn, pp. 32-33, No. 31; Markov, p. 56, No. 324; Arne, p.
79, No. 4;Janin, p. 120, #42 and p. 128, n.1.
According to Markov, the hoard contained 7 Umayyad and 'Abbasid
dirhams, 4 S~m~nid dirhams and 1 Izlamd~niddirham (Fraehn says 8 Umayyad
and 'Abb~sid dirhams and 4 S~m~nid) while the mints represented included:
Dimashq,-W~sit, Madinat al-Sal~m, al-Muh.ammadiyah, al-Sh~sh, and Andar~-
bah. Although the mint on one coin was effaced, it was most likely an African
dirham struck in Bad'a.
18 Paunktila I, Harjumaa, 1956. A neckline with 10 dirhams hanging from it was
found. The coins were identified by A. A. Bykov. The oldest coin was an
'Abb~sid dirham of 803/04-808]09 and the most recent coin was a S~rn~nid
dirham of 934/35. References: A. A. Bykov,"Kufi~eskie monety o~erel'ja iz
Paunkjula," Izvestija Akademii Nauk Estonskoi SSR, X, Serija ob~estven-
nyx nauk, 1961, No. 2, 178-81; T5nisson, No. 24, p. 191 and pp. 242-3.
Pre-970 Dirham Hoards 249
I 'Abb~sid (2):
(H~rQn al-Rashid?): mint unknown, 803/04-808/09?. al-Muqtadir: Madinat al-
Sal[m, 915/16.
II. S~rnanid (6):
Ism]'il b. Ah.mad (3): al-Sh~sh, 901/02, 907/08. No amTr: al-Sh~sh, 907/08.
Ahmad b. Ism]"d (1): MadTnat Balkh, 912/13. Nasr b. A.hmad (2): Samarqand,
914/15,934/35.
III. Imitation Dirhams (2):
Downloaded by [Instituto De Ciencias Matematicas] at 05:55 09 December 2011
Some scholars would not consider this a coin hoard; coins attached to
jewelry are sometimes viewed as part of a treasure hoard.
19 Kavastu II (Kawast), Virumaa, 1882. A hoard of almost 1000 dirhams was
found, of which Prof. Erman saw about a tenth. Among these dirhams were
many S~m~nid as well as some 'Abb~sid and Buwayhid coins, almost all
from the first-half of the fourth century H. (912/13-961/62). The most
recent coin seen by Erman dated to 969/70. Among the coins which he
observed, Erman noted a dirham of the 'Abb~sid caliph al-QT~hir, I.sbah~n,
933, the fragment of a S~m]nid dirham from Balkh, 932•33, with the names
of am~r Nasr b. Ah.mad and his son NGh, and the fragment of a barbarian
imitation. Frank listed six coins which seem to have come from this hoard:
Buwayhid (1): Mu'izz al-Dawlah, 'Askar rain al-Ahw]z, 941/42-950/51 ;
'Abb~sid (5): ar-R~.di, unknown mint, 934/35.2 'Abb~sid? fragments.
al-MansQr? al-Ma'mGn, al-KGfah, 815[16. Friedenthal indicates a hoard of
29 Arabic coins buried c. 975 but gives no source for this information.
References: Frank, p. 391, No. 39; Markov, p. 56, No. 323; Arne, p. 78,
No. 3; Friedenthal, No. 42; Janin, p. 77, p. 120, ~62, and p. 128, n.l;
T6nisson, No. 27, p. 192 and pp. 242-243.
20 Kohtla (Kochtel), Virumaa, 1923. A hoard of some 500-600 dirhams was
found of which 481 were identified. The oldest coin was an Umayyad dirham
of 715/16 and the most recent coin was an 'Abb~sid dirham of 837/38. W.
Anderson and R. Vasmer published the bulk of the hoard (470 dirhams) in
1926. Two years later they published an additional 11 dirhams from the
hoard. References: Anderson; Vasmer 1926, p. 292, No. 42; Walter Anderson
& Richard Vasmer, "Elf weitere Dirhams aus dem Chalifenmtinzfund yon
Kochtel," Opetatud Eesti Seltsi Aastaraamat 1928 (Tartu, 1929), 89-95;
Paxomov, 2(1938), pp. 76-77, No. 625; Janin, p. 100, n.l and p. 102, No. 28;
TGnisson, No. 50, p. 196 and pp. 244-5.
I. Umayyad (14):
Sulaym~n."Wgsit, 715/16. Hish~m: W~sit., 729/30, 741/42,725-738? Hishgm or
al-Wali'd II: W~sit., 742/43. al.Wali-d II, Yazid III, or Ibr~ihirn: Wgsit.,743/44 (2),
743/44.744/45? Marw~n II: al-KQfah, 746/47; Wgsit, 746/47 (2); al-S~miyah,
748/49 (2); Mary, 750/51.
II. 'Abb~tsid (454):
al-Saffah. (9): al-Kfifah, 5 dirhams between 749•50 and 751/52; Ardashir Khurra,
751/52; al-Bas.rah, 751/52 (2); Ramhurmuz, 751/52. al-Safjffb or al-Mans.ftr (4):
250 Journal o f Baltic Studies
al.Ba.srah, 753/54 (4). al-Mans~r (93): at-Basrah, 16 dirhams between 755/56 and
764[65; unknown mint, 750-757, 757-765?; al.K~fah, 15 dirhams between
757/58 and 765; MadTnat al-Sal~m, 51 dirhams between 765•66 and 774/75; al-
Muhammad/yah, 9 dirhams between 765]66 and 771172. al-Mahd?(73): Mad/nat
al-Sal~m, 50 dirhams between 775/76 and 785/86; al-Ba.srah, 776]77,777]78 (3);
al-Muhammad/yah, 8 dirhams between 776]77 and 784/85; Tudgha?, 779]80;
al-'Abb~s~yah?, 780/817; al-'Abb~sTyah, 785/867; Kirman, 781/82, 783/84;
Adharb~yjgn, 782/83,784/85; Qasr al-Sal~m, 784/85; al-H~rfiniyah,785/86; un-
Downloaded by [Instituto De Ciencias Matematicas] at 05:55 09 December 2011
hof at the same time: 'Abb~sid: (H~rfin al-Rash~d), Mad~nat al-Sal~m, 802/03;
S~mi,aid: (Isma--'il b. Al~mad), al-Sh~sh, 902/03. Many of the dirhams from
Rathshof mentioned by Frank coincide with those from Markov's account.
26Meckshof (Maxhof, Mekshof, M~iksa), Tartu raion, Ugandi, 1878. A hoard
of about 200 dirhams was found of which 150 were identified. The oldest
coin was an 'Abb~sid dirham of 802]03 and the most recent was a S~m~nid
dirham of 947/48. References: Frank, p. 393, No. 49; Markov, pp. 17-18,
No. 98; Ame, p. 77, No. 1; Vasmer 1925, 41; Friedenthal, No. 74; Janin,
p. 76, p. 120, ~39, and p. 128, n.1; T6nisson, No. 83, p. 199 and pp. 244-5;
TAAM 13751/86.
I. 'A b b~siaL(5 ) :
H~rfin al-Raslffd: Batkh, 802/03. al-R~d$: Ni.m-bin, 841/42 [al-R~qi was caliph
933/34-940/41]. al-Mu'tamid: 'Abbag, 890/91. al-Mu'tadid: al-Basrah, 893/94.
al-Muqtadir: I.sbah~n?, 931/32.
II. Buwayhid (2):
'Im~d al-Dawlah ('Aft b. Buwayh): ShTr~z,938/39? Mu'izz al-Dawlah (AI~.mad b.
Buwayh) and 'ImSd al-Dawlah CAN-b. Buwayh): al-'Askar min al-Ahw~z, 944/45.
III..Hamd~nid (1):
N~.sir al-Dawlah and Sayf al-Dawlah, Maw.sil, year unknown.
IV. S~m~nid (137):
lsma"?l b. Abmad (22): al-Sh~sh, 12 dirhams between 897/98 and 905/06;
Samarqand, 6 dirhams between 898]99 and 902/03; unknown mint, 893/94-
901/02,902/03-907/08 (3). Abmad b. Ismff~l (14): al-Sh~sh, 7 dirhams between
907/08 and 913/14; Samarqand, 909• 10, 91 O/1 I, 912/13 (2); Andar~bah, 907•08,
913/14; unknown mint and year. Nas.r b. Abmad (63): al-Sh~sh, 26 dirhams be-
tween 913/14 and 940/41 ; Samarqand, 20 dirhams between 913/14 and 942/43;
Andar~bah, 922/23; Balkh, 924/25,929/30? 932/33,925/26 or 934/35; Ma'din,
925/26?; Nis~b~r, 932/33 (2), 936/37, 939•40; Badakhsh~n, year not known;
mint, 927[28?, 922/23-931/32 (2), 933?, year not known. Probably Nas.r b.
Ah. mad (7): al-Sh~sh, 934/35; Samarqand, 917/18,934/35; Nis~bfir, 934/35; un-
known mint, 924/25,925/26 (2). N~b b. Nas.r (11): Bukh~r~, 946/47,947/48
(3); Samarqand, 944/45 (3), year not known, unknow mint, 943/44, 944/45,
unknown year. Miscellaneous and/or probably Sam~nid (17): al-Sh~sh, year not
known (2); Samarqand, year not known; unknown mint and year (14)-some of
these may not be S~m~nid. Imitation S~m~nid (3).
V. S.afJ~rid (4):
254 Journal of Baltic Studies
('Amr b. Layth?), ShTr~z, 896/97.3 imitations.
The above account follows the description of the hoard found in the archives
of the Numismatic Section, Institute of Archaeology, Estonian Academy of
Sciences, TAAM 13751/86. The accounts in Frank and Markov are a little
different. Frank is fairly close-150 total dirhams, predominantly S~rn~nid, with
5 'Abb~sid, 2 Buwayhid, and 1 H.amd~nid dirhaha. Frank, however, notes 2
Volga Bulgar dirhams Of AmTr Barmat [B~rm~n?] and only 1 .Saff~rid coin which
leaves 139 S~m~nid dirhams. There are also minor discrepancies in the description
Downloaded by [Instituto De Ciencias Matematicas] at 05:55 09 December 2011
of the coins within each dynasty. Frank, for example, gives the earliest 'Abb~sid
coin as a dirham struck in Balkh in 783/84 (167 H. rather than 187 H.), provides
no mint f o r t h e Mu'tamid and Mu'tadid dirhams, dates the Mu'tamid dirham to
267 H. rather than 277 H., and omits the mint and Sayf al-Dawlah's name for the
tzIamd~nid coin. The only Saff~rid dirham he lists is of 'Amr b. Layth, ShTr~z,
896/97. The discrepancies in the accounts of S~m~nid dirhams are also not
serious: Frank notes 15 dirhams of Ahmad b. Ism~'il (not 14) and he only gives
the date of one. There are minor differences in the number of coins per mint
for each SSm~nid amTr and 4 barbarian imitations (not 3) are mentioned. Ac-
cording to Frank, one of the S-arn~nid dirhams from Samarqand bears the name
of Mik~71 b. Ja'far who was, in fact, an anaTramong the Volga Bulgars.
Markov's account is based on the 93 dirhams sent to Baron Tiesenhausen fo~
identification. Among them were 3 'Abb~sid, 1 Saff~rid, 1 Buwayhid, and some
68 S~n~nid dirhams. In addition, there were 20 miscellaneous coins: 2 imitation
dirhams of Nasr b. A.hmad, 1 Mik~'Tlb. Ja'far without year or mint, 14 completely
effaced coins, and 3 barbarian imitations of S~rnSnid dirhams. Markov also
mentions the 4 whole coins and 4 dirham halves of Na.sr b. Abmad discovered
at the find-spot in Meckshof.
Based on the above information, it appears that about 150 dirhams from the
hoard were identified. The 5 'Abb~sid, 1 I:Iamd~nid, and 2 Buwayhid dirhams
were most likely those listed above. It seems there was only 1 Saff~rid dirham
('Amr b. Layth) while at least one (Mika-'il b. Ja'far) and perhaps 3 dirhams
(2 anaTr Barmal = B~rm~n?) were Volga Bulgar rather than S~m~nid. The number
of S~m~nid dirhams is unclear since many of the completely effaced and illegible
dirhams seem to be catalogued, in some accounts, as S~m~nid. It is perhaps best
to state that the hoard was overwhelmingly composed of S~rn~nid dirhams
struck between 897/98 and 947/48, primarily in al-Sh~sh and Samarqand.
Vasmer noted that no accurate catalog of the Mekshof hoard was published
with the result that it was impossible to compose a completely accurate picture
of its contents. Vasmer's description of this hoard is: mainly S~rn~nid, a few
imitation dirhams, 2 pieces of "B~rm~n", 1 Mike"r, 1 .Saffarid, 1 Hamd~nid, 1
or 2 Buwayhid and a few 'Abb~sid.
Given the three divergent accounts, the figures for this hoard found in the
analysis are only approximate.
27P01tsamaa II, PSltsamaa raion, M6hu, 1939. A hoard of about 500 Arabic
coins (196 whole and 320 fragments) was found in a clay pot. No further
Pre-970 Dirham Hoards 255
information is available and the hoard has apparently not yet been identified.
Reference: T6nisson, No. 107, p. 203 and pp. 246-7.
28 Lihula (Leal), L~i~inemaa, 1924. Four S~m~nid dirhams, 897/98-913/14, and
one Byzantine miliaresion, 945-959, were found in a sand grave along with a
tenth century silver filigree pendant of Gotlandic work. References: W.
Anderson, "Der Miinzfund yon Leal," in Anderson, 115-118; Vasmer 1926,
p. 292-3, No. 5; Friedenthal, No. 15; Kropotkin 1962, p. 49, No. 325;
T6nisson, No. 123, p. 204 and pp. 246-7.
Downloaded by [Instituto De Ciencias Matematicas] at 05:55 09 December 2011
I. S'dm~nid (4):
Isma--'il b. A.hmad: al-Sh~sh, 897/98; Balkh, 905/06. Ah.mad b. Ism~'il: al-Sh~sh,
911/12,913[14.
II. Byzantine (1):
Constantine VII and Romanus II, 945-959.
29Valjala, (Wolde) Saaremaa, around 1922. A hoard of 36 Arabic coins was
found of which 13 were identified. The oldest coin was an 'Abb~sid dirham
of 867/68 and the most recent coins were S~m~nid and 'Abb]sid dirhams of
934/35. References: W. Anderson, "Der Mtinzfund yon Wolde," in Anderson,
109-114; Vasmer 1926, p. 292, No. 44; Friedenthal, No. 7; Janin, p. 118, no.
2 and p. 120, #44; Tfnisson, No. 133, p. 206 and pp. 248-9.
I. 'Abb~sid (2):
al-Mu'tazz: MadTnat al-Sal~m?, 867/68. al-R[~: MadTnat al-Sal~m, 934/35.
II. S~m~nid (11):
Ism~'il b. A.hmad: Samarqand, 899/900. Ah.mad b. Ism~'-fl: Andar[bah, 912/13;
at-ShUsh, 912/13. Nasr b. Abmad: Balkh, 915/16, 932/33; Samarqand, 916/17,
922/23,934/35?; Badakhsh~n, 925/26?; al-Sh~sh, 927/28,934/35.
30 The former Livland province, along the shores of Lake Peipus, Ugandi, 1885.
A hoard of around 60 dirhams was found and sent to Baron Tiesenhausen
for identification. The oldest coin was an Umayyad dirham of 705 and the
most recent coin was an 'Abb~sid dirham of 861/62. References: Markov, p.
18, No. 99; Arne, p. 77, No. 2;Friedenthal, No. 70: Janin, pp. 100-1, n. 1 and
p. 102, #25; T6nisson, No. 146, p. 207 and pp. 248-9.
I. Umayyad (2):
(al-Waffd I?): Sfibfir, 705 or 714/15. (YazTd II?): W[si.t, 721/22.
II..Tdhirid (3):
(ruler not given): al-Muh.ammadiyah, 816/17. (T-'ahir b. al-H.usayn?): Sur[diq
Abrashahr, 821/22. ('Abd Alllh?): al-Shish, 840/41.
III. IdrTsid (1):
(Idr]s II?): Bad'a?, 802?
IV. 'Abb~sid (43 or 55):
(al-Mansffr?): al-Rayy, 763[64; Madl-nat al-Sal~m, 765/66, 767/68. (al-MahclT?.):
Madi'nat al-Sal~m, 774/75, 776/77?, 777/78, 778/79, 779•80, 780/81; al-
Ba.srah, 781/82; al-Muhammadiyah, 781/82. (al-HgdT?.): IfffqTyah?, 785/86.
(Hgrffn al-RashTd): Madi-nat al-Sal~m, 795/96, 796/97, 797-98?, 802, 803/04,
807/08; al-Muhammadiyah, 791/92; al-'Abb~Tyah or IfriqTyah, 793/94?, 786/87-
256 Journal o f Baltic Studies
795•96; Sijist~n, 791/92; Balkh, 800/01; Ma'din al-Sh~sh, 805/06. (al-Am?n?):
Madi-nat al-Sal~m, 808/09, 809/10; al-Muh.ammadiyah, 809/10, 811/12; Samar-
qand, 808/09; mint unknown, 810/11. (al-Ma'mfm?): Madinat al-Sal~m, 813/14,
814/15, 818/19,823/24; Samarqand, 814/15,816/17. (al-Mutawakkil?): Madi"nat
al-Sal-am, 847/48. (al-Muntas.ir): al-Ba.srah?,861/62.3 effaced 'Abb~sid dirhams.
2 imitation 'Abb~sid dirhams.
In his account, Markov specifically stated that there were 55 'Abb~sid dirhams
although he only enumerated 43. The identity and whereabouts of the 12 missing
Downloaded by [Instituto De Ciencias Matematicas] at 05:55 09 December 2011
'AbbSsid dirhams is not clear. Most later authors have followed Markov's figures
without noting that 12 'Abb~sid dirhams are unaccounted for.
31 Kunda, the former Viru-Nigula (Mahotm) parish, near Odenp/ih, 1885. A hoard
was found of which 9 dirhams were identifed. Further details are not pro-
vided. [Note that Kunda and Maholm are not in fact near Otep~/i/Odenp/ih.]
The oldest coin was an 'Abbasid dirham of 963/64 and the most recent coin
was a Hamd~nid dirham of 945•46. References: Frank, p. 391, No. 40;
Paxomov, 2(1938), p. 77, No. 626.
I. "Abb~sid (2):
al-Mustaq'n: Arm'i-nTyah,863/64. al-Muqtadir: mint unknown, 924/25.
II. Hamd~nid (1):
N~ir al-Dawlah al-H.asan and Sayf al-Dawlah: al-Mul~ammadi'yah,945/46.
III. S~m~nid (6):
-Isrn~'ilb. A.hmad: al-Sh~sh,903/04; Balkh, 907•08. Ahmad b. Isrn~'~: Samarqand,
913/14. Na.sr b. A.hmad: al-ShSsh, 913/14; Samarqand, 913/14; unknown mint,
914/15.
32 The former Livland province, Ratshof farmstead, near Tartu sometime before
1910. Several S~rn~nid dirhams dating from 895/96 to 952/53 were found.
Janin considers these coins a hoard although the circumstances of the find
are not described. References: Markov, p. 23, No. 133; Janin, p. 120, #41 and
p. 128, n.1.
I. S~m~nid (5):
Isma--'i1 b. Al~mad: al-Sh~sh, 895/96. Ah.mad b. Ism~'il: al-Sh~sh, 909/10. Nas.r b.
A.hmad: mint unknown, 915/16. Nul~ b. Na~r: al-Sh~sh, 945/46; Samarqand,
952/53.
33The former Livland province, near Tartu/Dorpat, 1885. Fourteen dirhams
were found in different places in the ground ("v razli~nyx mestax v zemle")
and shown to Markov. The oldest coin was an 'Abb~sid dirham of 768/69
and the most recent coins were S~rn~nid dirhams of the tenth century.
Janin considers the 'Abb~sid and Idffsid dirhams as part of a hoard tentatively
dated to the first-third of the ninth century. There is nothing in Markov's
account to indicate that some of these coins came from an early ninth century
hoard. In fact, Markov's description suggests that the coins may have come
from several different places around Tartu. Thus, we cannot be certain that
these coins, or even some of them, were ever part of a genuine dirham hoard.
References: Markov, p. 20, No.113; Janin, p. 86, #21 and p. 90, n.3.
Pre-970 Dirham Hoards 257
I. 'Abbdsid (9):
(al-Man.sfir?): Madi'nat al-Sal~m, 768/697 (al-Mahdi?): MadYnat al-Sal~m, 778[79.
(al-HSdY?): al-Mul~ammadiyah, 785/86. (I-I'arfin al-Rash~'d?): al-Mut~ammadi'yah,
786]87, 791192; Madinat al-Sal~m, 806]07; Balkh, 796]97-804/05. (al-Am]'n?):
Madi-nat al-Sal~m, 809/10. Unknown caliph and mint, 1"7 H.
II. IdrTsid (1):
(Idffs II): Wal~a, 799/800.
III. S~m'dnid (4):
Downloaded by [Instituto De Ciencias Matematicas] at 05:55 09 December 2011
Anderson, Walter: Der Chalifenmiinzfund yon Kochtel; mit Beitr~en yon Richard Vasmer
(Eesti Vabariigi Tartu Olikooli Toimetused, B7, Pt. 2 [ 1926] ).
Arne, T. J.: La Subde et l'Orient: Etudes archdologiques sur les relations de la Subde et de
l'Orient pendant l'age des Vikings (Archives d'l~tudes Orientales, 8); Uppsala, 1914.
Fasmer see Vasmer
Fraehn, C.M.: "O vostoEnyx monetax naxodimyx v Rossii," in P. S. Saverev, Muxam.
medanska]a numismatika v otno~enii k russko/ istorii (SPb., 1847), 3-52 (originally
"Topographische Obersicht der Ausgrabungen yon altem arabischen Gelde in Russland,"
Bull. Scientifique publi~ par l'Academie Impdriale des Sciences de Saint-P6tersburg, No.
212-3, Vol. 9, 301-32). The Savel'ev book updates Fraehn's topography on pp. 107-26 &
149-70. References to Fraehn include references to these appendices.
Frank, Hermann: "Die baltisch-arabischen Fundmiinzen," Mitteilungen aus dem Gebiete
der Geschichte Liv-, Est- und Kurlands, 18, (1908), 311-486.
Frey, E.: "Zwei Funde kufischer Miinzenin Estland," Opetatud Eesti seltsi aastaraamat 1912-
1920, (Tartu, 1921), 81-84.
Friedenthal, A.: "Baltische Miinzfunde des 9.-12. Jahrhunderts an der Hand einer Miinz-
fundkarte," Sitzungsberichte der Gesellschaft fiir Geschichte und A ltertumskunde zu Riga
(1934), 142-54.
Janin, V. L.: Dene~no-vesovye sistemy russkogo srednevekov~a: Domongol'ski] period
(Moscow, 1956).
Kropotkin 1962: V. V. Kropotkin, Klady vizanti]skix monet na territorii SSSR (Arxeologija
SSSR; Svod arxeologi~eskix istoSnikov, E4-4); Moscow, 1962.
Kropotkin 1965: "Novye naxodki vizantijskix monet na territorii SSSR," Vizanti#ki]
Vremennik, 26,166-98.
Kropotkin 1971: "Novye naxodki sasanadskix i kufi~ekix monet v Vosto~noj Evrope,"
Numizmatika i Epigrafika, 9, 76-97.
Markov, A. K.: Topografi/a kladov vosto~nyx monet [sasanidskix i kufi~eskixJ (SPb., t910).
Pre.970 Dirham Hoards 259
Vasmer 1925: Richard Vasmer, "Der kufische Miinzfund yon Friedrichshof in Estland,"
Opetatud Eesti seltsi aastaraamat 1925 (Tartu, 1926-27), 26-118.
Vasmer 1926: R. R. Fasmer, "Spisok monetnyx naxodok zaregistrirovannyx Sekciej numi-
smatiki i gliptiki Akademii istorii material'noj kurtury v 1920-1925 gg.," Soob§~eni/a
Gosudarstvenno] akademii istorii material'no] kul'tury, 1 (1926), 287-308.
Vasmer 1928: "0bet dreizehn in Privatbesitz verbliebene Miinzen des Friedrichshofer
Fundes," Opetatud Eesti Seltsi Aastaraamat 1928 (Tartu, 1929), 84-88.
Vasmer 1929: "Spisok monetnyx naxodok, II," Soob~eni]a Gosudarstvenno] akademii istorii
matertal'no] kul'tury, 2 (1929), 281-324.