Accessibility links

 Skip to content

 Accessibility Help
Sign in
BBC navigation
 Menu
Search the BBCSearch the BBC
News
BBC News Navigation
 Home
 Video
 Worldselected
 Asia
 UK
 Business
 Tech
 Science
 Stories
 Entertainment & Arts
 Health
 World News TV







 Moresections
US & Canadaselected

Trump Russia: Democrats say firing special

counsel could cause crisis
 4 hours ago
 Share this w ith Facebook

 Share this w ith Tw itter

 Share this w ith Mes senger

 Share this w ith Email

 Share

Related Topics
 Russia-Trump inquiry
Image copyrightEPAImage captionPresident Trump says he is the victim of a "witch hunt"

Senior Democrats have warned President Donald Trump not to use a controversial memo as a
"pretext" to fire the special counsel investigating alleged Russian involvement in the US election.

They warned that such action could trigger a constitutional crisis not seen since the Nixon era.
The memo, written by Republicans, accuses the FBI of abusing its powers.

President Trump approved the declassification of the memo and said it revealed a disgraceful story.

It accuses the FBI and the justice department of using an unsubstantiated and Democratic-funded report to
obtain the warrant that gave permission to spy on an aide to Mr Trump.

Democrats said the release of the memo was aimed at disrupting investigations into alleged links between
the Trump campaign and the Kremlin. President Trump has consistently denied any such collusion.

The FBI had warned against the memo's release and said key facts had been omitted.

What have Democrats said?

Democrats say the memo, released on Friday, is a "shameful effort to discredit" the FBI and inquiries into
Russian meddling.

In a statement, Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, House Minority Nancy Pelosi and eight other
senior Democrats warned Mr Trump against trying to sack special counsel Robert Mueller or the deputy
attorney general, Rod Rosenstein.
 Key parts of memo - and what it means

"We write to inform you that we would consider such an unwarranted action as an attempt to obstruct
justice in the Russia investigation," the statement said.

They said such action could result in a constitutional crisis not seen since the 1970s when then President
Richard Nixon gave orders to fire justice officials involved in the Watergate scandal.

The White House later said "no changes" would be made at the Department of Justice and Mr Rosenstein
was fully expected to continue in his job.

What is in the memo?

It focuses on the court-approved wiretapping of Carter Page, a foreign policy adviser to the Trump
campaign who was put under electronic surveillance by the FBI.

But the memo accuses the FBI and the justice department of using unsubstantiated evidence to obtain the
October 2016 warrant.
Image copyrightREUTERSImage captionSpecial Counsel Robert Mueller is leading the inquiry into
alleged Russian interference in the US election

It says that they did not tell the authorities their claim to the warrant was partially based on a dossier
funded in part by the rival campaign of Hillary Clinton.

It also says that the author of that dossier, a former British intelligence agent called Christopher Steele,
told a senior justice department official that he was "desperate" that Donald Trump not win the vote.

What have Republicans said?

Republicans who support the release of the memo say it exposes malpractice and political bias within the
FBI and justice department.

Asked about the contents of the memo, Mr Trump said a lot of people should be "ashamed of themselves".
Media caption"I think it's terrible...I think it's a disgrace", Trump said of the controversial memo

Earlier on Friday the president accused top officials of politicising FBI and justice department
investigations to damage his Republican party.

Devin Nunes, who commissioned the memo, has said it shows "serious violations" of public trust and he
hopes it will trigger reforms.

Mr Page said he would use the memo in upcoming legal action against the justice department.
 All you need to know about Trump Russia story
 Meet the cast in the drama to end all dramas

But not all Republicans supported the release of the memo.

Senator John McCain accused his party colleagues, and Mr Trump, of playing into the hands of Russian
President Vladimir Putin.

"Our nation's elected officials, including the president, must stop looking at this investigation through the
warped lens of politics and manufacturing partisan sideshows," he said in a statement.

"If we continue to undermine our own rule of law, we are doing Putin's job for him."

What other reaction has there been?

Former FBI Director James Comey, who was fired by President Trump in May, tweeted that the memo
was "dishonest and misleading".
Skip Twitter post by @Comey
 That’s it? Dishonest and misleading memo wrecked the House intel committee, destroyed trust with
Intelligence Community, damaged relationship with FISA court, and inexcusably exposed classified
investigation of an American citizen. For what? DOJ & FBI must keep doing their jobs.

— James Comey (@Comey) February 2, 2018

Report

End of Twitter post by @Comey

The current Director, Christopher Wray, in an email to staff, said: "Talk is cheap; the work you do is what
will endure.

"I stand by our shared determination to do our work independently and by the book. I stand with you," he
said.

Analysis: Bomb or dud?

By the BBC's North America reporter Anthony Zurcher

The mystery is over, the memo is out, and the results are… pretty much what everyone expected.

Whether the Republican-generated document is as explosive as it had been made out to be depends on how
one views the now-infamous Christopher Steele dossier and whether one believes the memo's assertion
that it was an "essential part" of the Carter Page Fisa warrant's approval - or if there was other pertinent
information the Republican memo-writers omitted.

The memo makes the case that the Fisa judge should have been told about information about Steele that
could call his objectivity into question - including his expressed views about Donald Trump, his contacts
with the press and the fact that his investigation was funded, in part, by Democratic Party interests.

Would such a disclosure have been enough to make the Page warrant request one of only a handful of the
tens of thousands of Fisa applications that have been rejected by judges since the system was set up in
1978? And is the surveillance of Page - who had drawn the attention of US intelligence services as far
back as 2013 - enough to call into question the entire Russia investigation, which had been initiated
months before the warrant was approved?

The answers to those questions will determine whether the memo was a bomb or a dud.
Read more from Anthony

Related Topics
 FBI

 Donald Trump

 Russia-Trump inquiry

Share this story About sharing

 Email
 Facebook
 Messenger
 Twitter
 Pinterest
 LinkedIn
More on this story

Memo reaction - as it happened
2 February 2018


Nunes memo: Key extracts and what they mean
8 hours ago


Video 'A lot of people should be ashamed' - Trump on memo
2 February 2018

US & Canada
 Las Vegas shooting bullets seller charged

 3 February 2018
 From the sectionUS & Canada
Full article Las Vegas shooting bullets seller charged

Temptations singer Dennis Edwards dies

 2 February 2018
 From the sectionUS & Canada
Full article Temptations singer Dennis Edwards dies
 US wants smaller nukes to counter Russia

 2 February 2018
 From the sectionUS & Canada
Full article US wants smaller nukes to counter Russia
Top Stories
Trump warned not to hinder Russia probe
Democrats say release of a controversial memo is aimed at disrupting a probe into alleged Kremlin links.
4 hours ago
Key parts of US memo - and what it means
8 hours ago
Sean Spicer on having Trump as boss
8 hours ago

ADVERTISEMENT
Features
A short history of Life - Afghanistan's lost magazine
Key parts of US memo - and what it means
New Holocaust law threatens 'whitewash' of Polish history
VIDEO
How two gay penguins inspired play
Is the greatest hits album dead?
Putin, power and poison: Russia’s elite FSB spy club
'Fake porn' has serious consequences
VIDEO
Searching for a cult leader in the jungles of Costa Rica
 How Kenyans are coping with TV shutdown

Most Read
 1Russian oligarchs in UK told to explain luxury lifestyles
 2The Spice Girls reuniting to work on 'new opportunities'
 3Trump Russia: Democrats say firing special counsel could cause crisis
 4Newspaper headlines: Marriage shake-up and McMafia crackdown
 5Carillion collapse: UK puts up £100m to back Carillion contractor loans
 6Sprawling Maya network discovered under Guatemala jungle
 7Policeman attacked in Ramsgate church graveyard
 8What’s eating the restaurant trade?
 9Deepfakes porn has serious consequences
 10Bryan Cranston joins the ranks of the no-autograph celebrities
ADVERTISEMENT
Why you can trust BBC News
BBC News Services
 On your mobile
 On your connected tv
 Get news alerts
 Contact BBC News
 Explore the BBC
 Sport
 Weather
 TV
 Radio
 CBBC
 CBeebies
 Food
 iWonder
 Bitesize
 Music
 Arts
 Make It Digital
 Taster
 Local
 Terms of Use
 About the BBC
 Privacy Policy
 Cookies
 Accessibility Help
 Parental Guidance
 Contact the BBC
 Get Personalised Newsletters
Copyright © 2018 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking.