You are on page 1of 18

_ Page 1

Minutes of the Federal Open Market Committee


January 30–31, 2018

A joint meeting of the Federal Open Market Committee Simon Potter, Manager, System Open Market Account
and the Board of Governors was held in the offices of
the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System Lorie K. Logan, Deputy Manager, System Open
in Washington, D.C., on Tuesday, January 30, 2018, at Market Account
10:00 a.m. and continued on Wednesday, January 31,
2018, at 9:00 a.m. 1 Ann E. Misback, Secretary, Office of the Secretary,
Board of Governors
PRESENT:
Janet L. Yellen, Chair Matthew J. Eichner, 2 Director, Division of Reserve
William C. Dudley, Vice Chairman Bank Operations and Payment Systems, Board of
Thomas I. Barkin Governors; Andreas Lehnert, Director, Division of
Raphael W. Bostic Financial Stability, Board of Governors
Lael Brainard
Loretta J. Mester Rochelle M. Edge, Deputy Director, Division of
Jerome H. Powell Monetary Affairs, Board of Governors; Maryann F.
Randal K. Quarles Hunter, Deputy Director, Division of Supervision
John C. Williams and Regulation, Board of Governors

James Bullard, Charles L. Evans, Esther L. George, David Reifschneider and John M. Roberts, Special
Michael Strine, and Eric Rosengren, Alternate Advisers to the Board, Office of Board Members,
Members of the Federal Open Market Committee Board of Governors

Patrick Harker, Robert S. Kaplan, and Neel Kashkari, Linda Robertson, Assistant to the Board, Office of
Presidents of the Federal Reserve Banks of Board Members, Board of Governors
Philadelphia, Dallas, and Minneapolis, respectively
Joseph W. Gruber, Senior Associate Director, Division
James A. Clouse, Secretary of International Finance, Board of Governors;
Matthew M. Luecke, Deputy Secretary Michael G. Palumbo, Senior Associate Director,
David W. Skidmore, Assistant Secretary Division of Research and Statistics, Board of
Michelle A. Smith, Assistant Secretary Governors
Mark E. Van Der Weide, General Counsel
Michael Held, Deputy General Counsel Antulio N. Bomfim, Ellen E. Meade, Stephen A.
Steven B. Kamin, Economist Meyer, Edward Nelson, and Joyce K. Zickler,
Thomas Laubach, Economist Senior Advisers, Division of Monetary Affairs,
David W. Wilcox, Economist Board of Governors; Jeremy B. Rudd, Senior
Adviser, Division of Research and Statistics, Board
David Altig, Kartik B. Athreya, Thomas A. Connors, of Governors
Mary Daly, David E. Lebow, Trevor A. Reeve,
Argia M. Sbordone, Ellis W. Tallman, William William F. Bassett, Associate Director, Division of
Wascher, and Beth Anne Wilson, Associate Financial Stability, Board of Governors
Economists

1 The Federal Open Market Committee is referenced as the

“FOMC” and the “Committee” in these minutes.


2 Attended through the discussion of developments in finan-

cial markets and open market operations.


Page 2 Federal Open Market Committee _

Andrew Figura, Assistant Director, Division of The elected members and alternate members were as fol-
Research and Statistics, Board of Governors; Jason lows:
Wu, Assistant Director, Division of Monetary
William C. Dudley, President of the Federal Reserve
Affairs, Board of Governors
Bank of New York, with Michael Strine, First Vice Pres-
ident of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, as al-
Penelope A. Beattie, 3 Assistant to the Secretary, Office
ternate
of the Secretary, Board of Governors
Thomas I. Barkin, President of the Federal Reserve
Dana L. Burnett and Michele Cavallo, Section Chiefs, Bank of Richmond, with Eric Rosengren, President of
Division of Monetary Affairs, Board of Governors the Federal Reserve Bank of Boston, as alternate
Loretta J. Mester, President of the Federal Reserve Bank
David H. Small, Project Manager, Division of
of Cleveland, with Charles L. Evans, President of the
Monetary Affairs, Board of Governors
Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, as alternate
Andrea Ajello, Kurt F. Lewis, and Bernd Schlusche, Raphael W. Bostic, President of the Federal Reserve
Principal Economists, Division of Monetary Bank of Atlanta, with James Bullard, President of the
Affairs, Board of Governors; Ekaterina Peneva and Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, as alternate
Daniel J. Vine, Principal Economists, Division of John C. Williams, President of the Federal Reserve Bank
Research and Statistics, Board of Governors of San Francisco, with Esther L. George, President of
the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City, as alternate
Camille Bryan, Lead Financial Analyst, Division of
International Finance, Board of Governors
By unanimous vote, the Committee selected Janet L.
Yellen to serve as Chairman through February 2, 2018,
Ellen J. Bromagen, First Vice President, Federal
and Jerome H. Powell to serve as Chairman, effective
Reserve Bank of Chicago
February 3, 2018, until the selection of his successor at
the first regularly scheduled meeting of the Committee
Jeff Fuhrer and Daniel G. Sullivan, Executive Vice
in 2019.
Presidents, Federal Reserve Banks of Boston and
Chicago, respectively
By unanimous vote, the following officers of the Com-
Todd E. Evan F. Koenig, Keith Sill, and Mark
Clark,3 mittee were selected to serve until the selection of their
L.J. Wright, Senior Vice Presidents, Federal successors at the first regularly scheduled meeting of the
Reserve Banks of Cleveland, Dallas, Philadelphia, Committee in 2019:
and Minneapolis, respectively
William C. Dudley Vice Chairman
Carlos Garriga and Jonathan L. Willis, Vice Presidents, James A. Clouse Secretary
Federal Reserve Banks of St. Louis and Kansas Matthew M. Luecke Deputy Secretary
City, respectively David W. Skidmore Assistant Secretary
Michelle A. Smith Assistant Secretary
Annual Organizational Matters4 Mark E. Van Der Weide General Counsel
In the agenda for this meeting, it was reported that ad- Michael Held Deputy General Counsel
vices of the election of the following members and alter- Richard M. Ashton Assistant General Counsel
nate members of the Federal Open Market Committee Steven B. Kamin Economist
for a term beginning January 30, 2018, had been received Thomas Laubach Economist
and that these individuals had executed their oaths of of- David W. Wilcox Economist
fice.
David Altig
Kartik B. Athreya

3 Attended Tuesday session only. 4 Committee organizational documents are available at


www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/rules_authoriza-
tions.htm.
_ Minutes of the Meeting of January 30–31, 2018 Page 3

Thomas A. Connors tion 14(b) of the Federal Reserve Act (“Eligible Secu-
Mary Daly rities”) for the System Open Market Account
David E. Lebow (“SOMA”):
Trevor A. Reeve i. As an outright operation with securities dealers
Argia M. Sbordone and foreign and international accounts maintained
Ellis W. Tallman at the Selected Bank: on a same-day or deferred de-
William Wascher livery basis (including such transactions as are com-
Beth Anne Wilson Associate Economists monly referred to as dollar rolls and coupon swaps)
at market prices; or
By unanimous vote, the Federal Reserve Bank of New
ii. As a temporary operation: on a same-day or
York was selected to execute transactions for the System
deferred delivery basis, to purchase such Eligible Se-
Open Market Account (SOMA).
curities subject to an agreement to resell (“repo
By unanimous vote, the Committee selected Simon Pot- transactions”) or to sell such Eligible Securities sub-
ter and Lorie K. Logan to serve at the pleasure of the ject to an agreement to repurchase (“reverse repo
Committee as manager and deputy manager of the transactions”) for a term of 65 business days or less,
SOMA, respectively, on the understanding that these se- at rates that, unless otherwise authorized by the
lections were subject to their being satisfactory to the Committee, are determined by competitive bidding,
Federal Reserve Bank of New York. after applying reasonable limitations on the volume
Secretary’s note: Advice subsequently was re- of agreements with individual counterparties;
ceived that the manager and deputy manager se- B. To allow Eligible Securities in the SOMA to ma-
lections indicated above were satisfactory to the ture without replacement;
Federal Reserve Bank of New York. C. To exchange, at market prices, in connection
with a Treasury auction, maturing Eligible Securities in
By unanimous vote, the Authorization for Domestic the SOMA with the Treasury, in the case of Eligible
Open Market Operations was approved with revisions Securities that are direct obligations of the United
to incorporate transactions of securities lending into the States or that are fully guaranteed as to principal and
existing operational readiness testing provision and to interest by the United States; and
improve the document’s readability. The Guidelines for D. To exchange, at market prices, maturing Eligible
the Conduct of System Open Market Operations in Securities in the SOMA with an agency of the United
Federal-Agency Issues remained suspended. States, in the case of Eligible Securities that are direct
obligations of that agency or that are fully guaranteed
AUTHORIZATION FOR DOMESTIC OPEN as to principal and interest by that agency.
MARKET OPERATIONS
(As amended effective January 30, 2018) SECURITIES LENDING

OPEN MARKET TRANSACTIONS 2. In order to ensure the effective conduct of open


market operations, the Committee authorizes the Se-
1. The Federal Open Market Committee (the “Com- lected Bank to operate a program to lend Eligible Secu-
mittee”) authorizes and directs the Federal Reserve Bank rities held in the SOMA to dealers on an overnight basis
selected by the Committee to execute open market trans- (except that the Selected Bank may lend Eligible Securi-
actions (the “Selected Bank”), to the extent necessary to ties for longer than an overnight term to accommodate
carry out the most recent domestic policy directive weekend, holiday, and similar trading conventions).
adopted by the Committee: A. Such securities lending must be:
A. To buy or sell in the open market securities that i. At rates determined by competitive bidding;
are direct obligations of, or fully guaranteed as to prin- ii. At a minimum lending fee consistent with the
cipal and interest by, the United States, and securities objectives of the program;
that are direct obligations of, or fully guaranteed as to iii. Subject to reasonable limitations on the total
principal and interest by, any agency of the United amount of a specific issue of Eligible Securities that
States, that are eligible for purchase or sale under Sec- may be auctioned; and
iv. Subject to reasonable limitations on the
amount of Eligible Securities that each borrower
may borrow.
Page 4 Federal Open Market Committee _

B. The Selected Bank may: transaction in such Eligible Securities with the Cus-
i. Reject bids that, as determined in its sole dis- tomer Accounts; and
cretion, could facilitate a bidder’s ability to control a ii. Undertake intra-day repo transactions in Eligi-
single issue; ble Securities with Foreign Accounts.
ii. Accept Treasury securities or cash as collateral Transactions undertaken with Customer Accounts un-
for any loan of securities authorized in this para- der the provisions of this paragraph 4 may provide for a
graph 2; and service fee when appropriate. Transactions undertaken
iii. Accept agency securities as collateral only for a with Customer Accounts are also subject to the authori-
loan of agency securities authorized in this para- zation or approval of other entities, including the Board
graph 2. of Governors of the Federal Reserve System and, when
involving accounts maintained at a Federal Reserve
OPERATIONAL READINESS TESTING Bank as fiscal agent of the United States, the United
States Department of the Treasury.
3. The Committee authorizes the Selected Bank to
undertake transactions of the type described in para- ADDITIONAL MATTERS
graphs 1 and 2 from time to time for the purpose of test-
ing operational readiness, subject to the following limi- 5. The Committee authorizes the Chairman of the
tations: Committee, in fostering the Committee’s objectives dur-
A. All transactions authorized in this paragraph 3 ing any period between meetings of the Committee, to
shall be conducted with prior notice to the Commit- instruct the Selected Bank to act on behalf of the Com-
tee; mittee to:
B. The aggregate par value of the transactions au- A. Adjust somewhat in exceptional circumstances
thorized in this paragraph 3 that are of the type de- the stance of monetary policy and to take actions that
scribed in paragraph 1.A.i shall not exceed $5 billion may result in material changes in the composition and
per calendar year; and size of the assets in the SOMA; or
C. The outstanding amount of the transactions de- B. Undertake transactions with respect to Eligible
scribed in paragraphs 1.A.ii and 2 shall not exceed Securities in order to appropriately address temporary
$5 billion at any given time. disruptions of an operational or highly unusual nature
in U.S. dollar funding markets.
TRANSACTIONS WITH CUSTOMER ACCOUNTS Any such adjustment described in subparagraph A of
this paragraph 5 shall be made in the context of the
4. In order to ensure the effective conduct of open Committee’s discussion and decision about the stance of
market operations, while assisting in the provision of policy at its most recent meeting and the Committee’s
short-term investments or other authorized services for long-run objectives to foster maximum employment and
foreign central bank and international accounts main- price stability, and shall be based on economic, financial,
tained at a Federal Reserve Bank (the “Foreign Ac- and monetary developments since the most recent meet-
counts”) and accounts maintained at a Federal Reserve ing of the Committee. The Chairman, whenever feasi-
Bank as fiscal agent of the United States pursuant to sec- ble, will consult with the Committee before making any
tion 15 of the Federal Reserve Act (together with the instruction under this paragraph 5.
Foreign Accounts, the “Customer Accounts”), the Com-
mittee authorizes the following when undertaken on The Committee voted unanimously to reaffirm without
terms comparable to those available in the open market: revision the Authorization for Foreign Currency Opera-
A. The Selected Bank, for the SOMA, to undertake tions and the Foreign Currency Directive as shown be-
reverse repo transactions in Eligible Securities held in low.
the SOMA with the Customer Accounts for a term of
65 business days or less; and AUTHORIZATION FOR FOREIGN CURRENCY
B. Any Federal Reserve Bank that maintains Cus- OPERATIONS
tomer Accounts, for any such Customer Account, (As reaffirmed effective January 30, 2018)
when appropriate and subject to all other necessary
IN GENERAL
authorization and approvals, to:
i. Undertake repo transactions in Eligible Securi- 1. The Federal Open Market Committee (the “Com-
ties with dealers with a corresponding reverse repo mittee”) authorizes the Federal Reserve Bank selected by
_ Minutes of the Meeting of January 30–31, 2018 Page 5

the Committee (the “Selected Bank”) to execute open $5 billion since the close of the most recent regular
market transactions for the System Open Market Ac- meeting of the Committee. The Foreign Currency
count as provided in this Authorization, to the extent Subcommittee (the “Subcommittee”) must direct
necessary to carry out any foreign currency directive of the Selected Bank in advance to execute the opera-
the Committee: tion if the Subcommittee believes that consultation
A. To purchase and sell foreign currencies (also with the Committee is not feasible in the time avail-
known as cable transfers) at home and abroad in the able.
open market, including with the United States Treas- ii. The Committee authorizes the Subcommittee
ury, with foreign monetary authorities, with the Bank to direct the Selected Bank in advance to execute the
for International Settlements, and with other entities operation if it would result in the overall volume of
in the open market. This authorization to purchase standalone spot and forward transactions in foreign
and sell foreign currencies encompasses purchases and currencies, as defined in paragraph 3.C of this Au-
sales through standalone spot or forward transactions thorization, totaling $5 billion or less since the close
and through foreign exchange swap transactions. For of the most recent regular meeting of the Commit-
purposes of this Authorization, foreign exchange tee.
swap transactions are: swap transactions with the B. Such an operation also shall be:
United States Treasury (also known as warehousing i. Generally directed at countering disorderly
transactions), swap transactions with other central market conditions; or
banks under reciprocal currency arrangements, swap ii. Undertaken to adjust System balances in light
transactions with other central banks under standing of probable future needs for currencies; or
dollar liquidity and foreign currency liquidity swap ar- iii. Conducted for such other purposes as may be
rangements, and swap transactions with other entities determined by the Committee.
in the open market. C. For purposes of this Authorization, the overall
B. To hold balances of, and to have outstanding for- volume of standalone spot and forward transactions
ward contracts to receive or to deliver, foreign curren- in foreign currencies is defined as the sum (disregard-
cies. ing signs) of the dollar values of individual foreign cur-
2. All transactions in foreign currencies undertaken rencies purchased and sold, valued at the time of the
pursuant to paragraph 1 above shall, unless otherwise transaction.
authorized by the Committee, be conducted:
A. In a manner consistent with the obligations re- WAREHOUSING
garding exchange arrangements under Article IV of
the Articles of Agreement of the International Mone- 4. The Committee authorizes the Selected Bank, with
tary Fund (IMF).1 the prior approval of the Subcommittee and at the re-
B. In close and continuous cooperation and consul- quest of the United States Treasury, to conduct swap
tation, as appropriate, with the United States Treasury. transactions with the United States Exchange Stabiliza-
C. In consultation, as appropriate, with foreign tion Fund established by section 10 of the Gold Reserve
monetary authorities, foreign central banks, and inter- Act of 1934 under agreements in which the Selected
national monetary institutions. Bank purchases foreign currencies from the Exchange
D. At prevailing market rates. Stabilization Fund and the Exchange Stabilization Fund
repurchases the foreign currencies from the Selected
STANDALONE SPOT AND FORWARD Bank at a later date (such purchases and sales also known
TRANSACTIONS as warehousing).

3. For any operation that involves standalone spot or RECIPROCAL CURRENCY ARRANGEMENTS,
forward transactions in foreign currencies: AND STANDING DOLLAR AND FOREIGN
A. Approval of such operation is required as fol- CURRENCY LIQUIDITY SWAPS
lows:
i. The Committee must direct the Selected Bank 5. The Committee authorizes the Selected Bank to
in advance to execute the operation if it would result maintain reciprocal currency arrangements established
in the overall volume of standalone spot and for- under the North American Framework Agreement,
ward transactions in foreign currencies, as defined standing dollar liquidity swap arrangements, and stand-
in paragraph 3.C of this Authorization, exceeding
Page 6 Federal Open Market Committee _

ing foreign currency liquidity swap arrangements as pro- FOREIGN CURRENCY HOLDINGS
vided in this Authorization and to the extent necessary
to carry out any foreign currency directive of the Com- 7. The Committee authorizes the Selected Bank to
mittee. hold foreign currencies for the System Open Market Ac-
A. For reciprocal currency arrangements all draw- count in accounts maintained at foreign central banks,
ings must be approved in advance by the Committee the Bank for International Settlements, and such other
(or by the Subcommittee, if the Subcommittee be- foreign institutions as approved by the Board of Gover-
lieves that consultation with the Committee is not fea- nors under Section 214.5 of Regulation N, to the extent
sible in the time available). necessary to carry out any foreign currency directive of
B. For standing dollar liquidity swap arrangements the Committee.
all drawings must be approved in advance by the A. The Selected Bank shall manage all holdings of
Chairman. The Chairman may approve a schedule of foreign currencies for the System Open Market Ac-
potential drawings, and may delegate to the manager, count:
System Open Market Account, the authority to ap- i. Primarily, to ensure sufficient liquidity to ena-
prove individual drawings that occur according to the ble the Selected Bank to conduct foreign currency
schedule approved by the Chairman. operations as directed by the Committee;
C. For standing foreign currency liquidity swap ar- ii. Secondarily, to maintain a high degree of
rangements all drawings must be approved in advance safety;
by the Committee (or by the Subcommittee, if the iii. Subject to paragraphs 7.A.i and 7.A.ii, to pro-
Subcommittee believes that consultation with the vide the highest rate of return possible in each cur-
Committee is not feasible in the time available). rency; and
D. Operations involving standing dollar liquidity iv. To achieve such other objectives as may be au-
swap arrangements and standing foreign currency li- thorized by the Committee.
quidity swap arrangements shall generally be directed B. The Selected Bank may manage such foreign cur-
at countering strains in financial markets in the United rency holdings by:
States or abroad, or reducing the risk that they could i. Purchasing and selling obligations of, or fully
emerge, so as to mitigate their effects on economic guaranteed as to principal and interest by, a foreign
and financial conditions in the United States. government or agency thereof (“Permitted Foreign
E. For reciprocal currency arrangements, standing Securities”) through outright purchases and sales;
dollar liquidity swap arrangements, and standing for- ii. Purchasing Permitted Foreign Securities under
eign currency liquidity swap arrangements: agreements for repurchase of such Permitted For-
i. All arrangements are subject to annual review eign Securities and selling such securities under
and approval by the Committee; agreements for the resale of such securities; and
ii. Any new arrangements must be approved by iii. Managing balances in various time and other
the Committee; and deposit accounts at foreign institutions approved by
iii. Any changes in the terms of existing arrange- the Board of Governors under Regulation N.
ments must be approved in advance by the Chair- C. The Subcommittee, in consultation with the
man. The Chairman shall keep the Committee in- Committee, may provide additional instructions to the
formed of any changes in terms, and the terms shall Selected Bank regarding holdings of foreign curren-
be consistent with principles discussed with and cies.
guidance provided by the Committee.
ADDITIONAL MATTERS
OTHER OPERATIONS IN FOREIGN
CURRENCIES 8. The Committee authorizes the Chairman:
A. With the prior approval of the Committee, to en-
6. Any other operations in foreign currencies for ter into any needed agreement or understanding with
which governance is not otherwise specified in this Au- the Secretary of the United States Treasury about the
thorization (such as foreign exchange swap transactions division of responsibility for foreign currency opera-
with private-sector counterparties) must be authorized tions between the System and the United States Treas-
and directed in advance by the Committee. ury;
_ Minutes of the Meeting of January 30–31, 2018 Page 7

B. To advise the Secretary of the United States nomic and financial policies toward the objective of fos-
Treasury concerning System foreign currency opera- tering orderly economic growth with reasonable price
tions, and to consult with the Secretary on policy mat- stability. These obligations also include avoiding manip-
ters relating to foreign currency operations; ulating exchange rates or the international monetary sys-
C. To designate Federal Reserve System persons au- tem in such a way that would impede effective balance
thorized to communicate with the United States of payments adjustment or to give an unfair competitive
Treasury concerning System Open Market Account advantage over other members.
foreign currency operations; and
D. From time to time, to transmit appropriate re- FOREIGN CURRENCY DIRECTIVE
ports and information to the National Advisory Coun- (As reaffirmed effective January 30, 2018)
cil on International Monetary and Financial Policies.
9. The Committee authorizes the Selected Bank to 1. The Committee directs the Federal Reserve Bank
undertake transactions of the type described in this Au- selected by the Committee (the “Selected Bank”) to ex-
thorization, and foreign exchange and investment ecute open market transactions, for the System Open
transactions that it may be otherwise authorized to Market Account, in accordance with the provisions of
undertake, from time to time for the purpose of testing the Authorization for Foreign Currency Operations (the
operational readiness. The aggregate amount of such “Authorization”) and subject to the limits in this Di-
transactions shall not exceed $2.5 billion per calendar rective.
year. These transactions shall be conducted with prior 2. The Committee directs the Selected Bank to exe-
notice to the Committee. cute warehousing transactions, if so requested by the
10. All Federal Reserve banks shall participate in the United States Treasury and if approved by the Foreign
foreign currency operations for System Open Market Currency Subcommittee (the “Subcommittee”), subject
Account in accordance with paragraph 3G(1) of the to the limitation that the outstanding balance of United
Board of Governors’ Statement of Procedure with Re- States dollars provided to the United States Treasury as
spect to Foreign Relationships of Federal Reserve Banks a result of these transactions not at any time exceed
dated January 1, 1944. $5 billion.
11. Any authority of the Subcommittee pursuant to 3. The Committee directs the Selected Bank to main-
this Authorization may be exercised by the Chairman if tain, for the System Open Market Account:
the Chairman believes that consultation with the Sub- A. Reciprocal currency arrangements with the fol-
committee is not feasible in the time available. The lowing foreign central banks:
Chairman shall promptly report to the Subcommittee
any action approved by the Chairman pursuant to this Foreign central bank Maximum amount
paragraph. (millions of dollars
12. The Committee authorizes the Chairman, in excep- or equivalent)
tional circumstances where it would not be feasible to
convene the Committee, to foster the Committee’s ob- Bank of Canada 2,000
jectives by instructing the Selected Bank to engage in Bank of Mexico 3,000
foreign currency operations not otherwise authorized
pursuant to this Authorization. Any such action shall be B. Standing dollar liquidity swap arrangements with
made in the context of the Committee’s discussion and the following foreign central banks:
decisions regarding foreign currency operations. The
Chairman, whenever feasible, will consult with the Com- Bank of Canada
mittee before making any instruction under this para- Bank of England
graph. Bank of Japan
__________________________ European Central Bank
Swiss National Bank
1 In general, as specified in Article IV, each member of

the IMF undertakes to collaborate with the IMF and C. Standing foreign currency liquidity swap arrange-
other members to assure orderly exchange arrangements ments with the following foreign central banks:
and to promote a stable system of exchange rates. These
obligations include seeking to direct the member’s eco- Bank of Canada
Bank of England
Page 8 Federal Open Market Committee _

Bank of Japan tend to influence economic activity and prices with a lag.
European Central Bank Therefore, the Committee’s policy decisions reflect its
Swiss National Bank longer-run goals, its medium-term outlook, and its as-
sessments of the balance of risks, including risks to the
4. The Committee directs the Selected Bank to hold financial system that could impede the attainment of the
and to invest foreign currencies in the portfolio in ac- Committee’s goals.
cordance with the provisions of paragraph 7 of the Au- The inflation rate over the longer run is primarily de-
thorization. termined by monetary policy, and hence the Committee
5. The Committee directs the Selected Bank to report has the ability to specify a longer-run goal for inflation.
to the Committee, at each regular meeting of the Com- The Committee reaffirms its judgment that inflation at
mittee, on transactions undertaken pursuant to para- the rate of 2 percent, as measured by the annual change
graphs 1 and 6 of the Authorization. The Selected Bank in the price index for personal consumption expendi-
is also directed to provide quarterly reports to the Com- tures, is most consistent over the longer run with the
mittee regarding the management of the foreign cur- Federal Reserve’s statutory mandate. The Committee
rency holdings pursuant to paragraph 7 of the Authori- would be concerned if inflation were running persis-
zation. tently above or below this objective. Communicating
6. The Committee directs the Selected Bank to con- this symmetric inflation goal clearly to the public helps
duct testing of transactions for the purpose of opera- keep longer-term inflation expectations firmly anchored,
tional readiness in accordance with the provisions of thereby fostering price stability and moderate long-term
paragraph 9 of the Authorization. interest rates and enhancing the Committee’s ability to
By unanimous vote, the Committee revised its Program promote maximum employment in the face of signifi-
for Security of FOMC Information with a set of tech- cant economic disturbances. The maximum level of em-
nical changes to update references to other documents. ployment is largely determined by nonmonetary factors
that affect the structure and dynamics of the labor mar-
In the Committee’s annual reconsideration of the State- ket. These factors may change over time and may not
ment on Longer-Run Goals and Monetary Policy Strat- be directly measurable. Consequently, it would not be
egy, participants agreed that only a minor revision was appropriate to specify a fixed goal for employment; ra-
required at this meeting, which was to update the refer- ther, the Committee’s policy decisions must be informed
ence to the median of FOMC participants’ estimates of by assessments of the maximum level of employment,
the longer-run normal rate of unemployment from recognizing that such assessments are necessarily uncer-
4.8 percent to 4.6 percent. All participants supported tain and subject to revision. The Committee considers a
the statement with the revision, and the Committee wide range of indicators in making these assessments.
voted unanimously to approve the updated statement. Information about Committee participants’ estimates of
the longer-run normal rates of output growth and unem-
STATEMENT ON LONGER-RUN GOALS AND ployment is published four times per year in the
MONETARY POLICY STRATEGY FOMC’s Summary of Economic Projections. For ex-
(As amended effective January 30, 2018) ample, in the most recent projections, the median of
FOMC participants’ estimates of the longer-run normal
The Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) is rate of unemployment was 4.6 percent.
firmly committed to fulfilling its statutory mandate from In setting monetary policy, the Committee seeks to
the Congress of promoting maximum employment, sta- mitigate deviations of inflation from its longer-run goal
ble prices, and moderate long-term interest rates. The and deviations of employment from the Committee’s as-
Committee seeks to explain its monetary policy deci- sessments of its maximum level. These objectives are
sions to the public as clearly as possible. Such clarity generally complementary. However, under circum-
facilitates well-informed decisionmaking by households stances in which the Committee judges that the objec-
and businesses, reduces economic and financial uncer- tives are not complementary, it follows a balanced ap-
tainty, increases the effectiveness of monetary policy, proach in promoting them, taking into account the mag-
and enhances transparency and accountability, which are nitude of the deviations and the potentially different
essential in a democratic society. time horizons over which employment and inflation are
Inflation, employment, and long-term interest rates projected to return to levels judged consistent with its
fluctuate over time in response to economic and finan- mandate.
cial disturbances. Moreover, monetary policy actions
_ Minutes of the Meeting of January 30–31, 2018 Page 9

The Committee intends to reaffirm these principles inflation is linked importantly to measures of resource
and to make adjustments as appropriate at its annual or- slack and a measure of expected inflation relevant for
ganizational meeting each January. wage and price setting—so-called Phillips curve specifi-
cations—as well as statistical models in which inflation
Developments in Financial Markets and Open Mar- is primarily determined by a time-varying inflation trend
ket Operations or longer-run inflation expectations. The briefings
The manager of the System Open Market Account noted several factors beyond those captured in the mod-
(SOMA) provided a summary of developments in do- els that appeared to have put downward pressure on
mestic and global financial markets over the intermeet- prices in recent years. These included structural changes
ing period. Financial conditions eased further over re- in price setting for some items, such as medical care, and
cent weeks with market participants pointing to increas- the effects of idiosyncratic price shocks, such as the un-
ing appetites for risk and perceptions of diminished usual drop in prices of wireless telephone services in
downside risks as factors buoying market sentiment. In 2017. The staff found little compelling evidence for the
this environment, yields on safe assets such as U.S. possible influence of other factors such as a more com-
Treasury securities moved up some while corporate risk petitive pricing environment or a change in the markup
spreads narrowed and equity prices recorded further sig- of prices over unit labor costs. Overall, for the set of
nificant gains. Breakeven measures of inflation compen- models presented, the prediction errors in recent years
sation derived from Treasury Inflation Protected Securi- were larger than those observed during the 2001–07 pe-
ties (TIPS) moved up but remained low. Survey riod but were consistent with historical norms and, in
measures of longer-term inflation expectations showed most models, did not appear to be biased.
little change. Judging from interest rate futures, the ex-
The staff presentations considered two key channels by
pected path of the federal funds rate shifted up over the
which monetary policy influences inflation—the re-
period but continued to imply a gradual expected pace
sponse of inflation to changes in resource utilization and
of policy firming. The deputy manager followed with a
the role of inflation expectations, or trend inflation, in
discussion of recent developments in money markets
the price-setting process. In part because inflation was
and FOMC operations. Year-end pressures were evi-
importantly influenced by a number of short-lived fac-
dent in the market for foreign exchange basis swaps, but
tors, the effects of current and expected resource utiliza-
conditions returned to normal early in 2018. Yields on
tion gaps on inflation were not easy to discern empiri-
Treasury bills maturing in early March were elevated, re-
cally. Estimates of the strength of those effects had di-
flecting investors’ concerns about the possibility that a
minished noticeably in recent years. The briefings high-
failure to raise the federal debt ceiling could affect the
lighted a number of other challenges associated with es-
timing of principal payments for these securities. The
timating the strength and timing of the linkage between
Open Market Desk continued to execute reinvestment
resource utilization and inflation, including the reliability
operations for Treasury and agency securities in the
of and changes over time in estimates of the natural rate
SOMA in accordance with the procedure specified in the
of unemployment and potential output and the ability to
Committee’s directive to the Desk. The deputy manager
adequately account for supply shocks. In addition, some
also reported on the volume of overnight reverse repur-
research suggested that the relationship between re-
chase agreement operations over the intermeeting pe-
source utilization and inflation may be nonlinear, with
riod and discussed the Desk’s plans for small-value op-
the response of inflation increasing as rates of utilization
erational tests of various types of open market opera-
rise to very high levels.
tions over the coming year.
With regard to inflation expectations, two of the brief-
By unanimous vote, the Committee ratified the Open
ings presented findings that the longer-run trend in in-
Market Desk’s domestic transactions over the intermeet-
flation, absent cyclical disturbances or transitory fluctu-
ing period. There were no intervention operations in
ations, had been stable in recent years at a little below
foreign currencies for the System’s account during the
2 percent. The briefings reported that the average fore-
intermeeting period.
casting performance of models employing either statisti-
Inflation Analysis and Forecasting cal estimates of inflation trends or survey-based
The staff presented three briefings on inflation analysis measures of inflation expectations as proxies for infla-
and forecasting. The presentations reviewed a number tion expectations appeared comparable, even though
of commonly used structural and reduced-form models. different versions of such models could yield very differ-
These included structural models in which the rate of
Page 10 Federal Open Market Committee _

ent forecasts at any given point in time. Moreover, al- participants emphasized the critical need for the FOMC
though survey-based measures of longer-run inflation to maintain a credible longer-run inflation objective and
expectations tended to move in parallel with estimated to clearly communicate the Committee’s commitment to
inflation trends, the empirical research provided no clear achieving that objective. Several participants indicated
guidance on how to construct a measure of inflation ex- that they viewed the available evidence as suggesting that
pectations that would be the most useful for inflation longer-run inflation expectations remained well an-
forecasting. The staff noted that although reduced-form chored; one cited recent research finding that inflation
models in which inflation tends to revert toward longer- expectations had become better anchored following the
run inflation trends described the data reasonably well, Committee’s adoption of a numerical inflation target.
those models offered little guidance to policymakers on However, a few saw low levels of inflation over recent
how to conduct policy so as to achieve their desired out- years as reflecting, in part, slippage in longer-run infla-
come for inflation. tion expectations below the Committee’s 2 percent ob-
jective. In that regard, a number of participants noted
Following the staff presentations, participants discussed
the importance of continuing to emphasize that the
how the inflation frameworks reviewed in the briefings
Committee’s 2 percent inflation objective is symmetric.
informed their views on inflation and monetary policy.
A couple of participants suggested that the Committee
Almost all participants who commented agreed that a
might consider expressing its objective as a range rather
Phillips curve–type of inflation framework remained
than a point estimate. A few other participants sug-
useful as one of their tools for understanding inflation
gested that the FOMC could begin to examine whether
dynamics and informing their decisions on monetary
adopting a monetary policy framework in which the
policy. Policymakers pointed to a number of possible
Committee would strive to make up for past deviations
reasons for the difficulty in estimating the link between
of inflation from target might address the challenge of
resource utilization and inflation in recent years. These
achieving and maintaining inflation expectations con-
reasons included an extended period of low and stable
sistent with the Committee’s inflation objective, particu-
inflation in the United States and other advanced econ-
larly in an environment in which the neutral rate of in-
omies during which the effects of resource utilization on
terest appeared likely to remain low.
inflation became harder to identify, the shortcomings of
commonly used measures of resource gaps, the effects Staff Review of the Economic Situation
of transitory changes in relative prices, and structural The information reviewed for the January 30–31 meet-
factors that had made business pricing more competitive ing indicated that labor market conditions continued to
or prices more flexible over time. It was noted that re- strengthen through December and that real gross do-
search focusing on inflation across U.S. states or metro- mestic product (GDP) expanded at about a 2½ percent
politan areas continued to find a significant relationship pace in the fourth quarter of last year. Growth of real
between price or wage inflation and measures of re- final domestic purchases by households and businesses,
source gaps. A couple of participants questioned the generally a good indicator of the economy’s underlying
usefulness of a Phillips curve–type framework for poli- momentum, was solid. Consumer price inflation, as
cymaking, citing the limited ability of such frameworks measured by the 12-month percentage change in the
to capture the relationship between economic activity price index for personal consumption expenditures
and inflation. (PCE), remained below 2 percent in December.
Survey-based measures of longer-run inflation expecta-
Participants generally agreed that inflation expectations
tions were little changed on balance.
played a fundamental role in understanding and forecast-
ing inflation, with stable inflation expectations providing Total nonfarm payroll employment increased solidly in
an important anchor for the rate of inflation over the December, and the national unemployment rate re-
longer run. Participants acknowledged that the causes mained at 4.1 percent. The unemployment rates for His-
of movements in short- and longer-run inflation expec- panics, for Asians, and for African Americans were
tations, including the role of monetary policy, were im- lower than earlier in the year and close to the levels seen
perfectly understood. They commented that various just before the most recent recession. The national labor
proxies for inflation expectations—readings from force participation rate held steady in December; relative
household and business surveys or from economic fore- to the declining trend suggested by an aging population,
casters, estimates derived from market prices, or esti- this sideways movement in the participation rate repre-
mated trends—were imperfect measures of actual infla- sented a further strengthening in labor market condi-
tion expectations, which are unobservable. That said, tions. The participation rate for prime-age (defined as
_ Minutes of the Meeting of January 30–31, 2018 Page 11

ages 25 to 54) men edged up in December, while the rate the drilling and mining sector—continued to edge up
for prime-age women declined slightly. The share of through late January.
workers who were employed part time for economic rea-
Total real government purchases rose modestly in the
sons was little changed in December and was close to its
fourth quarter. Increased federal government purchases
pre-recession level. The rates of private-sector job
mostly reflected a rise in defense spending, and the gains
openings and quits were little changed in November, and
in purchases by state and local governments were led by
the four-week moving average of initial claims for un-
an increase in construction spending in this sector.
employment insurance benefits continued to be at a low
level in mid-January. Recent readings showed that gains The nominal U.S. international trade deficit widened fur-
in hourly labor compensation remained modest. Both ther in November after widening sharply in October.
the employment cost index for private-sector workers Exports of goods and services picked up in November,
and average hourly earnings for all employees rose about while imports, particularly of consumer goods, increased
2½ percent over the 12 months ending in December. robustly. Available data for goods trade in December
suggested that import growth again outpaced export
Total industrial production increased over the two
growth. All told, real net exports were estimated to be a
months ending in December, with broad-based gains in
substantial drag on real GDP growth in the fourth quar-
manufacturing, mining, and utilities output. Automak-
ter.
ers’ schedules indicated that assemblies of light motor
vehicles would likely move up over the coming months. Total U.S. consumer prices, as measured by the PCE
Broader indicators of manufacturing production, such as price index, increased about 1¾ percent over the
the new orders indexes from national and regional man- 12 months ending in December. Core PCE price infla-
ufacturing surveys, pointed to further solid increases in tion, which excludes changes in consumer food and en-
factory output in the near term. ergy prices, was 1½ percent over that same period. The
consumer price index (CPI) rose around 2 percent over
Real PCE increased strongly in the fourth quarter. Re-
the same period, while core CPI inflation was 1¾ per-
cent readings on key factors that influence consumer
cent. Recent readings on survey-based measures of
spending—including gains in employment, real disposa-
longer-run inflation expectations—including those from
ble personal income, and households’ net worth—con-
the Michigan survey and the Desk’s Survey of Primary
tinued to be supportive of further solid growth of real
Dealers and Survey of Market Participants—were little
PCE in the near term. Consumer sentiment in early Jan-
changed on balance.
uary, as measured by the University of Michigan Surveys
of Consumers, remained upbeat. Incoming data suggested that economic activity abroad
continued to expand at a solid pace and that this expan-
Real residential investment rose briskly in the fourth
sion was broad based across countries. In the advanced
quarter after having declined in the previous two quar-
foreign economies (AFEs), real GDP in the euro area
ters. Both starts and issuance of building permits for
and the United Kingdom expanded at a moderate pace
new single-family homes increased in the fourth quarter
in the fourth quarter. In the emerging market economies
as a whole, and starts for multifamily units also moved
(EMEs), Mexico’s economy rebounded after being held
up. Moreover, sales of both new and existing homes
back by natural disasters in the third quarter. Economic
rose in the fourth quarter.
growth remained solid in China but cooled off a bit in
Real private expenditures for business equipment and in- some emerging Asian economies after a very strong
tellectual property increased at a solid pace in the fourth third-quarter performance. Inflation in both AFEs and
quarter. Recent indicators of business equipment spend- EMEs picked up significantly in the fourth quarter,
ing—such as rising new orders of nondefense capital largely reflecting a boost from rising oil prices. Inflation
goods excluding aircraft and upbeat readings on busi- excluding food and energy prices remained well below
ness sentiment from national and regional surveys— central bank targets in several economies, including the
pointed to further gains in equipment spending in the euro area and Japan.
near term. Firms’ real spending for nonresidential struc-
Staff Review of the Financial Situation
tures rose modestly in the fourth quarter, as an increase
Domestic financial market conditions eased considera-
in outlays for drilling and mining structures was largely
bly further over the intermeeting period. A strengthen-
offset by a decline in expenditures for other business
ing outlook for economic growth in the United States
structures. The number of crude oil and natural gas rigs
and abroad, along with recently enacted tax legislation,
in operation—an indicator of spending for structures in
Page 12 Federal Open Market Committee _

appeared to boost investor sentiment. U.S. equity prices, mained low by historical standards. Spreads of both in-
Treasury yields, and market-based measures of inflation vestment- and speculative-grade corporate bond yields
compensation rose, and spreads of yields on investment- over comparable-maturity Treasury yields declined
and speculative-grade nonfinancial corporate bonds slightly and remained well below their historical aver-
over those for comparable-maturity Treasury securities ages.
narrowed further. In addition, the dollar depreciated
The FOMC’s decision at its December meeting to raise
broadly amid strong foreign economic data and mone-
the target range for the federal funds rate was transmit-
tary policy communications by some foreign central
ted smoothly to money market rates. The effective fed-
banks that investors reportedly viewed as less accommo-
eral funds rate held steady at a level near the middle of
dative than expected.
the target range except at year-end. While borrowing
FOMC communications over the intermeeting period costs moved up briefly in offshore dollar funding mar-
were generally characterized by market participants as kets over year-end, conditions in money markets were
consistent with their expectations for continued gradual reported to be orderly. In line with recent year-end ex-
removal of monetary policy accommodation. The Com- periences, rates and volumes in the federal funds and
mittee’s decision to raise the target range for the federal Eurodollar markets declined, while in secured markets,
funds rate at the December meeting was widely ex- rates on Treasury repurchase agreements increased. Af-
pected, and the probability of an increase in the target ter year-end, pressures in money markets abated quickly
range for the federal funds rate occurring at the January and rates and volumes returned to recent ranges.
meeting, as implied by quotes on federal funds futures
The broad nominal dollar index declined nearly 4 per-
contracts, remained essentially zero. Over the inter-
cent relative to its value at the time of the December
meeting period, the futures-implied probability of policy
FOMC meeting; the decline was most pronounced
firming at the March meeting rose to about 85 percent;
against AFE currencies, but the dollar depreciated nota-
respondents to the Desk’s Survey of Primary Dealers
bly against most EME currencies as well. EME equity
and Survey of Market Participants assigned, on average,
prices registered substantial gains, in part supported by a
similarly high odds to a rate increase at the March meet-
significant rise in commodity prices; emerging market
ing. Levels of the federal funds rate at the end of 2018
bond spreads narrowed moderately, and flows into
and 2019 implied by overnight index swap rates moved
EME equity and bond funds strengthened substantially.
up moderately.
Market-based measures of policy expectations and
The nominal Treasury yield curve shifted up over the in-
longer-term sovereign yields moved up in most AFEs.
termeeting period amid an improved outlook for domes-
The Bank of Canada raised its policy rate at its January
tic and foreign economic growth. Yields on both 2- and
meeting, largely in response to better-than-expected eco-
10-year Treasury securities moved up about 30 basis
nomic data. The Bank of England, the Bank of Japan,
points. Measures of inflation compensation based on
and the European Central Bank (ECB) left their mone-
TIPS fell in response to the soft reading on core inflation
tary policy stances unchanged, as expected. Nonethe-
in the November CPI release but subsequently moved
less, the ECB president’s optimistic assessment of the
up against the backdrop of an improving global growth
euro-area economy at the press conference following the
outlook, higher commodity prices, depreciation of the
January meeting was interpreted by market participants
dollar, and the stronger-than-expected reading on core
as a signal that monetary policy would be less accommo-
inflation in the December CPI release. On net, inflation
dative than expected. Following those remarks, the euro
compensation moved up at both the 5-year and the
appreciated notably against the dollar and core euro-area
5-to-10-year horizons, and both measures returned to
sovereign yields moved higher. That said, market-based
levels seen in early 2017 before the string of generally
measures of policy expectations continued to indicate
weaker-than-expected inflation readings.
that investors anticipate a gradual pace of monetary pol-
Broad equity price indexes rose substantially over the in- icy normalization in the euro area.
termeeting period, with investors pointing to a stronger
Financing conditions for nonfinancial businesses and
global economic outlook and the supportive effect of
households remained generally accommodative over the
the recently enacted tax legislation on risk sentiment.
intermeeting period and continued to be supportive of
The VIX, an index of option-implied volatility for one-
economic activity. Respondents to the January Senior
month returns on the S&P 500 index, increased but re-
Loan Officer Opinion Survey on Bank Lending Prac-
tices (SLOOS) reported easing standards and narrowing
_ Minutes of the Meeting of January 30–31, 2018 Page 13

loan spreads for large and middle-market firms and at- The staff judged that vulnerabilities from leverage in the
tributed this easing to more aggressive competition from nonfinancial sector appeared to remain moderate, while
other bank or nonbank lenders. Net debt financing by vulnerabilities stemming from financial-sector leverage
investment-grade nonfinancial corporations turned neg- and from maturity and liquidity transformation contin-
ative in December, but the weakness appeared to reflect ued to be viewed as low.
a softening in the demand for credit, possibly related to
Staff Economic Outlook
the anticipation of higher after-tax cash flows and repa-
The U.S. economic projection prepared by the staff for
triation of foreign earnings. In contrast, gross issuance
the January FOMC meeting was stronger than the staff
of speculative-grade bonds and institutional leveraged
forecast at the time of the December meeting. Real
loans remained strong. Credit market conditions for
GDP was estimated to have risen in the fourth quarter
small businesses remained relatively accommodative de-
of last year by somewhat more than the staff had previ-
spite sluggish credit growth among these firms. Credit
ously expected, as gains in both household and business
conditions in municipal bond markets also remained ac-
spending were larger than anticipated. Beyond 2017, the
commodative.
forecast for real GDP growth was revised up, reflecting
In commercial real estate (CRE) markets, growth of a reassessment of the recently enacted tax cuts, along
loans held by banks slowed further in the fourth quarter, with higher projected paths for equity prices and foreign
though CRE loans held by small banks and some types economic growth and a lower assumed path for the for-
of CRE loans held by large banks—construction and eign exchange value of the dollar. Real GDP was pro-
land development loans in particular—expanded at a jected to increase at a somewhat faster pace than poten-
more robust pace. Financing conditions in the commer- tial output through 2020; the staff continued to assume
cial mortgage-backed securities (CMBS) market re- that the recently enacted tax cuts would boost real GDP
mained accommodative as issuance continued at a ro- growth moderately over the medium term. The unem-
bust pace and spreads on CMBS remained near their ployment rate was projected to decline further over the
lowest levels since the financial crisis. Credit conditions next few years and to continue to run well below the
in the residential mortgage market remained accommo- staff’s estimate of its longer-run natural rate over this pe-
dative for most borrowers, though credit standards re- riod.
mained tight for borrowers with low credit scores or
Estimates of total and core PCE price inflation for 2017
hard-to-document incomes. Mortgage rates increased in
were in line with the staff’s previous forecast. The pro-
tandem with rates on longer-term Treasury securities but
jection for inflation over the medium term was revised
remained quite low by historical standards.
up slightly, primarily reflecting tighter resource utiliza-
Conditions in consumer credit markets remained largely tion in the January forecast. Total PCE price inflation
supportive of economic activity. Consumer credit in- in 2018 was projected to be somewhat faster than in
creased notably in November, exceeding the more mod- 2017 despite a slower projected pace of increases in con-
erate volume of borrowing observed earlier in the year. sumer energy prices; core PCE prices were forecast to
Revolving credit expanded in November, while nonre- rise notably faster in 2018, importantly reflecting both
volving credit grew robustly, mainly driven by expansion the expected waning of transitory factors that held down
in student and other consumer loans. In contrast, 12-month measures of inflation in 2017 as well as the
growth of auto lending slowed in recent months, con- projected further tightening in resource utilization. The
sistent with the weakening demand for such loans in the staff projected that core inflation would reach 2 percent
fourth quarter as reported in the January SLOOS. For in 2019 and that total inflation would be at the Commit-
subprime borrowers, conditions remained tight, particu- tee’s 2 percent objective in 2020.
larly in the market for credit cards and auto loans.
The staff viewed the uncertainty around its projections
The staff provided its latest report on the potential risks for real GDP growth, the unemployment rate, and infla-
to financial stability; the report continued to characterize tion as similar to the average of the past 20 years. On
the financial vulnerabilities of the U.S. financial system the one hand, many indicators of uncertainty about the
as moderate on balance. This overall assessment incor- macroeconomic outlook remained subdued; on the
porated the staff’s judgment that vulnerabilities associ- other hand, considerable uncertainty remained about a
ated with asset valuation pressures continued to be ele- number of federal government policies relevant for the
vated; asset valuation pressures apparently reflected, in economic outlook. The staff saw the risks to the fore-
part, a broad-based appetite for risk among investors. casts for real GDP growth and the unemployment rate
Page 14 Federal Open Market Committee _

as balanced. The risks to the projection for inflation also ble goods to replace those damaged during the hurri-
were seen as balanced. Downside risks included the pos- canes in September may have provided a temporary
sibilities that longer-term inflation expectations may boost to consumer spending. In connection with solid
have edged lower or that the run of soft core inflation growth in consumer spending, a couple of participants
readings this year could prove to be more persistent than noted that the household saving rate had declined to its
the staff expected. These downside risks were seen as lowest level since 2005, likely driven by buoyant con-
essentially counterbalanced by the upside risk that infla- sumer sentiment or expectations that the rise in house-
tion could increase more than expected in an economy hold wealth would be sustained.
that was projected to move further above its potential.
Participants characterized their business contacts as gen-
Participants’ Views on Current Conditions and the erally upbeat about the economy; their contacts cited the
Economic Outlook recent tax cuts and notable improvements in the global
In their discussion of the economic situation and the economic outlook as positive factors. Manufacturers in
outlook, meeting participants agreed that information a number of Districts had responded to increased orders
received since the FOMC met in December indicated by boosting production. Against a backdrop of higher
that the labor market continued to strengthen and that energy prices and increased global demand for crude oil,
economic activity expanded at a solid rate. Gains in em- a couple of participants revised up their forecasts for en-
ployment, household spending, and business fixed in- ergy production in their respective Districts. Businesses
vestment were solid, and the unemployment rate stayed in a number of Districts reported plans to further in-
low. On a 12-month basis, both overall inflation and crease investment in coming quarters in order to expand
inflation for items other than food and energy continued capacity. Even so, several participants expressed con-
to run below 2 percent. Market-based measures of in- siderable uncertainty about the degree to which changes
flation compensation increased in recent months but re- to corporate taxes would support business investment
mained low; survey-based measures of longer-term in- and capacity expansion; according to these participants,
flation expectations were little changed, on balance. firms may be only just beginning to determine how they
might allocate their tax savings among investment,
Participants generally saw incoming information on eco-
worker compensation, mergers and acquisitions, returns
nomic activity and the labor market as consistent with
to shareholders, or other uses.
continued above-trend economic growth and a further
strengthening in labor market conditions, with the recent The labor market had strengthened further in recent
solid gains in household and business spending indicat- months, as indicated by continued solid payroll gains, a
ing substantial underlying economic momentum. They small increase in average hours worked, and a labor force
pointed to accommodative financial conditions, the re- participation rate that had held steady despite the longer-
cently enacted tax legislation, and an improved global run declining trend implied by an aging population.
economic outlook as factors likely to support economic Many participants reported that labor market conditions
growth over coming quarters. Participants expected that were tight in their Districts, evidenced by low unemploy-
with further gradual adjustments in the stance of mone- ment rates, difficulties for employers in filling open po-
tary policy, economic activity would expand at a moder- sitions or retaining workers, or some signs of upward
ate pace and labor market conditions would remain pressure on wages. The unemployment rate, at 4.1 per-
strong. Near-term risks to the economic outlook ap- cent, had remained near the lowest level seen in the past
peared roughly balanced. Inflation on a 12-month basis 20 years. It was noted that other labor market indica-
was expected to move up this year and to stabilize tors—such as the U-6 measure of unemployment or the
around the Committee’s 2 percent objective over the share of involuntary part-time employment—had re-
medium term. However, participants judged that it was turned to their pre-recession levels. A few participants
important to continue to monitor inflation develop- judged that while the labor market was close to full em-
ments closely. ployment, some margins of slack remained; these partic-
ipants pointed to the employment-to-population ratio or
Participants expected the recent solid growth in con-
the labor force participation rate for prime-age workers,
sumer spending to continue, supported by further gains
which remained below pre-recession levels, as well as the
in employment and income, increased household wealth
absence to date of clear signs of a pickup in aggregate
resulting from higher asset prices, and high levels of con-
wage growth.
sumer confidence. It was noted that spending on dura-
_ Minutes of the Meeting of January 30–31, 2018 Page 15

During their discussion of labor market conditions, par- participants generally viewed the economic effects of the
ticipants expressed a range of views about recent wage decline in the dollar and the rise in equity prices as more
developments. While some participants heard more re- than offsetting the effects of the increase in nominal
ports of wage pressures from their business contacts Treasury yields. One participant reported that financial
over the intermeeting period, participants generally market contacts did not see the relatively flat slope of the
noted few signs of a broad-based pickup in wage growth yield curve as signaling an increased risk of recession. A
in available data. With regard to how firms might use few others judged that it would be important to continue
part of their tax savings to boost compensation, a few to monitor the effects of policy firming on the slope of
participants suggested that such a boost could be in the the yield curve, noting the strong association between
form of onetime bonuses or variable pay rather than a past yield curve inversions and recessions.
permanent increase in wage structures. It was noted that
Regulatory actions and improved risk management in re-
the pace of wage gains might not increase appreciably if
cent years had put the financial system in a better posi-
productivity growth remains low. That said, a number
tion to withstand adverse shocks, such as a substantial
of participants judged that the continued tightening in
decline in asset prices, than in the past. However, amid
labor markets was likely to translate into faster wage in-
elevated asset valuations and an increased use of debt by
creases at some point.
nonfinancial corporations, several participants cautioned
In their discussion of inflation developments, many par- that imbalances in financial markets may begin to
ticipants noted that inflation data in recent months had emerge as the economy continued to operate above po-
generally pointed to a gradual rise in inflation, as the tential. In this environment, increased use of leverage
12-month core PCE price inflation rose to 1.5 percent by nonbank financial institutions might be difficult to
in December, up 0.2 percentage point from the low rec- detect in a timely manner. It was also noted that the
orded in the summer. Meanwhile, total PCE price infla- Committee should regularly reassess risks to the finan-
tion was 1.7 percent over the same 12-month period. cial system and their implications for the economic out-
Participants anticipated that inflation would continue to look in light of the potential for changes in regulatory
gradually rise as resource utilization tightened further policies over time.
and as wage pressures became more apparent; several
In their consideration of monetary policy, participants
expected that declines in the foreign exchange value of
discussed the implications of recent economic and finan-
the dollar in recent months would also likely help return
cial developments for the outlook for economic growth,
inflation to 2 percent over the medium term. Business
labor market conditions, and inflation and, in turn, for
contacts in a few Districts reported that they had begun
the appropriate path of the federal funds rate. Partici-
to have some more ability to raise prices to cover higher
pants agreed that a gradual approach to raising the target
input costs. That said, a few participants posited that the
range for the federal funds rate remained appropriate
recently enacted corporate tax cuts might lead firms to
and reaffirmed that adjustments to the policy path would
cut prices in order to remain competitive or to gain mar-
depend on their assessments of how the economic out-
ket share, which could result in a transitory drag on in-
look and risks to the outlook were evolving relative to
flation.
the Committee’s policy objectives. While participants
With regard to inflation expectations, available readings continued to expect economic activity to expand at a
from surveys had been steady and TIPS-based measures moderate pace over the medium term, they anticipated
of inflation compensation had moved up, although they that the rate of economic growth in 2018 would exceed
remained low. Many participants thought that inflation their estimates of its sustainable longer-run pace and that
expectations remained well anchored and would support labor market conditions would strengthen further. A
the gradual return of inflation to the Committee’s 2 per- number of participants indicated that they had marked
cent objective over the medium term. However, a few up their forecasts for economic growth in the near term
other participants pointed to the record of inflation con- relative to those made for the December meeting in light
sistently running below the Committee’s 2 percent ob- of the strength of recent data on economic activity in the
jective over recent years and expressed the concern that United States and abroad, continued accommodative fi-
longer-run inflation expectations may have slipped be- nancial conditions, and information suggesting that the
low levels consistent with that objective. effects of recently enacted tax changes—while still un-
certain—might be somewhat larger in the near term than
Many participants noted that financial conditions had
previously thought. Several others suggested that the
eased significantly over the intermeeting period; these
Page 16 Federal Open Market Committee _

upside risks to the near-term outlook for economic ac- activity had been rising at a solid rate. Gains in employ-
tivity may have increased. A majority of participants ment, household spending, and business fixed invest-
noted that a stronger outlook for economic growth ment had been solid, and the unemployment rate had
raised the likelihood that further gradual policy firming stayed low. On a 12-month basis, both overall inflation
would be appropriate. and inflation for items other than food and energy had
continued to run below 2 percent. Market-based
Almost all participants continued to anticipate that infla-
measures of inflation compensation had increased in re-
tion would move up to the Committee’s 2 percent ob-
cent months but remained low; survey-based measures
jective over the medium term as economic growth re-
of longer-term inflation expectations were little changed,
mained above trend and the labor market stayed strong;
on balance.
several commented that recent developments had in-
creased their confidence in the outlook for further pro- Members expected that, with further gradual adjust-
gress toward the Committee’s 2 percent inflation objec- ments in the stance of monetary policy, economic activ-
tive. A couple noted that a step-up in the pace of eco- ity would expand at a moderate pace and labor market
nomic growth could tighten labor market conditions conditions would remain strong. In their discussion of
even more than they currently anticipated, posing risks the economic outlook, most members viewed the recent
to inflation and financial stability associated with sub- data bearing on real economic activity as suggesting a
stantially overshooting full employment. However, modestly stronger near-term outlook than they had an-
some participants saw an appreciable risk that inflation ticipated at their meeting in December. In addition, fi-
would continue to fall short of the Committee’s objec- nancial conditions had remained accommodative, and
tive. These participants saw little solid evidence that the the details of the tax legislation suggested that its effects
strength of economic activity and the labor market was on consumer and business spending—while still uncer-
showing through to significant wage or inflation pres- tain—might be a bit greater in the near term than they
sures. They judged that the Committee could afford to had previously thought. Although several saw increased
be patient in deciding whether to increase the target upside risks to the near-term outlook for economic ac-
range for the federal funds rate in order to support fur- tivity, members generally continued to judge the risks to
ther strengthening of the labor market and allow partic- that outlook as remaining roughly balanced.
ipants to assess whether incoming information on infla-
Most members noted that recent information on infla-
tion showed that it was solidly on a track toward the
tion along with prospects for a continued solid pace of
Committee’s objective.
economic activity provided support for the view that in-
Some participants also commented on the likely evolu- flation on a 12-month basis would likely move up in
tion of the neutral federal funds rate. By most estimates, 2018 and stabilize around the Committee’s 2 percent ob-
the neutral level of the federal funds rate had been very jective over the medium term. However, a couple of
low in recent years, but it was expected to rise slowly members expressed concern about the outlook for infla-
over time toward its longer-run level. However, the out- tion, seeing little evidence of a meaningful improvement
look for the neutral rate was uncertain and would de- in the underlying trend in inflation, measures of inflation
pend on the interplay of a number of forces. For exam- expectations, or wage growth. Several members com-
ple, the neutral rate, which appeared to have fallen mented that they saw both upside and downside risks to
sharply during the Global Financial Crisis when financial the inflation outlook, and members agreed to continue
headwinds had restrained demand, might move up more to monitor inflation developments closely.
than anticipated as the global economy strengthened.
After assessing current conditions and the outlook for
Alternatively, the longer-run level of the neutral rate
economic activity, the labor market, and inflation, mem-
might remain low in the absence of fundamental shifts
bers voted to maintain the target range for the federal
in trends in productivity, demographics, or the demand
funds rate at 1¼ to 1½ percent. They indicated that the
for safe assets.
stance of monetary policy remained accommodative,
Committee Policy Action thereby supporting strong labor market conditions and
In their discussion of monetary policy for the period a sustained return to 2 percent inflation.
ahead, members judged that information received since
Members agreed that the timing and size of future ad-
the Committee met in December indicated that the labor
justments to the target range for the federal funds rate
market had continued to strengthen and that economic
would depend on their assessments of realized and ex-
pected economic conditions relative to the Committee’s
_ Minutes of the Meeting of January 30–31, 2018 Page 17

objectives of maximum employment and 2 percent in- of Treasury securities maturing during each cal-
flation. They reiterated that this assessment would take endar month that exceeds $12 billion, and to re-
into account a wide range of information, including invest in agency mortgage-backed securities the
measures of labor market conditions, indicators of infla- amount of principal payments from the Federal
tion pressures and inflation expectations, and readings Reserve’s holdings of agency debt and agency
on financial and international developments. Members mortgage-backed securities received during
also agreed to carefully monitor actual and expected in- each calendar month that exceeds $8 billion.
flation developments relative to the Committee’s sym- Small deviations from these amounts for oper-
metric inflation goal. Members expected that economic ational reasons are acceptable.
conditions would evolve in a manner that would warrant
The Committee also directs the Desk to engage
further gradual increases in the federal funds rate. They
in dollar roll and coupon swap transactions as
judged that a gradual approach to raising the target range
necessary to facilitate settlement of the Federal
would sustain the economic expansion and balance the
Reserve’s agency mortgage-backed securities
risks to the outlook for inflation and unemployment.
transactions.”
Members agreed that the strengthening in the near-term
economic outlook increased the likelihood that a gradual The vote also encompassed approval of the statement
upward trajectory of the federal funds rate would be ap- below to be released at 2:00 p.m.:
propriate. They therefore agreed to update the charac-
“Information received since the Federal Open
terization of their expectation for the evolution of the
Market Committee met in December indicates
federal funds rate in the postmeeting statement to point
that the labor market has continued to
to “further gradual increases” while maintaining the tar-
strengthen and that economic activity has been
get range at the current meeting. Members continued to
rising at a solid rate. Gains in employment,
anticipate that the federal funds rate would likely remain,
household spending, and business fixed invest-
for some time, below levels that were expected to prevail
ment have been solid, and the unemployment
in the longer run. Nonetheless, they again stated that the
rate has stayed low. On a 12-month basis, both
actual path for the federal funds rate would depend on
overall inflation and inflation for items other
the economic outlook as informed by the incoming data.
than food and energy have continued to run be-
At the conclusion of the discussion, the Committee low 2 percent. Market-based measures of infla-
voted to authorize and direct the Federal Reserve Bank tion compensation have increased in recent
of New York, until it was instructed otherwise, to exe- months but remain low; survey-based measures
cute transactions in the SOMA in accordance with the of longer-term inflation expectations are little
following domestic policy directive, to be released at changed, on balance.
2:00 p.m.:
Consistent with its statutory mandate, the Com-
“Effective February 1, 2018, the Federal Open mittee seeks to foster maximum employment
Market Committee directs the Desk to under- and price stability. The Committee expects that,
take open market operations as necessary to with further gradual adjustments in the stance
maintain the federal funds rate in a target range of monetary policy, economic activity will ex-
of 1¼ to 1½ percent, including overnight re- pand at a moderate pace and labor market con-
verse repurchase operations (and reverse repur- ditions will remain strong. Inflation on a
chase operations with maturities of more than 12‑month basis is expected to move up this year
one day when necessary to accommodate week- and to stabilize around the Committee’s 2 per-
end, holiday, or similar trading conventions) at cent objective over the medium term. Near-
an offering rate of 1.25 percent, in amounts lim- term risks to the economic outlook appear
ited only by the value of Treasury securities held roughly balanced, but the Committee is moni-
outright in the System Open Market Account toring inflation developments closely.
that are available for such operations and by a
In view of realized and expected labor market
per-counterparty limit of $30 billion per day.
conditions and inflation, the Committee de-
The Committee directs the Desk to continue cided to maintain the target range for the federal
rolling over at auction the amount of principal funds rate at 1¼ to 1½ percent. The stance of
payments from the Federal Reserve’s holdings monetary policy remains accommodative,
Page 18 Federal Open Market Committee _

thereby supporting strong labor market condi- Brainard, Loretta J. Mester, Jerome H. Powell, Randal K.
tions and a sustained return to 2 percent infla- Quarles, and John C. Williams.
tion.
Voting against this action: None.
In determining the timing and size of future ad-
Consistent with the Committee’s decision to leave the
justments to the target range for the federal
target range for the federal funds rate unchanged, the
funds rate, the Committee will assess realized
Board of Governors voted unanimously to leave the in-
and expected economic conditions relative to its
terest rates on required and excess reserve balances un-
objectives of maximum employment and 2 per-
changed at 1½ percent and voted unanimously to ap-
cent inflation. This assessment will take into ac-
prove establishment of the primary credit rate (discount
count a wide range of information, including
rate) at the existing level of 2 percent. 5
measures of labor market conditions, indicators
of inflation pressures and inflation expectations, It was agreed that the next meeting of the Committee
and readings on financial and international de- would be held on Tuesday–Wednesday, March 20–21,
velopments. The Committee will carefully 2018. The meeting adjourned at 10:50 a.m. on Janu-
monitor actual and expected inflation develop- ary 31, 2018.
ments relative to its symmetric inflation goal.
Notation Vote
The Committee expects that economic condi-
By notation vote completed on January 2, 2018, the
tions will evolve in a manner that will warrant
Committee unanimously approved the minutes of the
further gradual increases in the federal funds
Committee meeting held on December 12–13, 2017.
rate; the federal funds rate is likely to remain, for
some time, below levels that are expected to
prevail in the longer run. However, the actual
path of the federal funds rate will depend on the
economic outlook as informed by incoming
data.”
_____________________________
Voting for this action: Janet L. Yellen, William C. James A. Clouse
Dudley, Thomas I. Barkin, Raphael W. Bostic, Lael Secretary

5The second vote of the Board also encompassed approval seasonal credit under the existing formulas for computing
of the establishment of the interest rates for secondary and such rates.

You might also like