____

0 RI____
..... 41 AJ,4
I

L, FILED IN OPEN
ON Y /'2UJ/ I
7 df{J
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT c;~:tr,~~,tr., Clerk
FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF NORTH CAROLINA Eastem District of NC
SOUTHERN DIVISION
No. 7:14-CV-180-BR

JOYCE MCKIVER, et al., )

)
Plaintiffs, )
)
v. ) VERDICT
)
MURPHY-BROWN LLC, )
)
Defendant. )

1. "Did the defendant substantially and unreasonably interfere with the plaintiffs use

and enjoyment of his or her property?"

Joyce McK.iver Answer:~

Delois Lewis Answer: j£,~

Daphne McKoy Answer: ~es

Alexandria McKoy Answer: '-/ 65
Antonio McKoy Answer: "/ 6
Archie Wright, Jr. Answer: YfS
Tammy Lloyd Answer: 'I ES
Deborah Johnson Answer: "}ES
Ethel Davis Answer:
{(25,

Priscilla Dunham Answer: '/ES

Case 7:14-cv-00180-BR Document 267 Filed 04/26/18 Page 1 of 3

-,. .

2. "What amount of damages, if any, is the plaintiff entitled to recover from the

defendant?"

Joyce McK.iver Answer:$ 7~,ooo

7

Delois Lewis Answer:$ IS1000

I

Daphne McKoy Answer:$ IC; ooo

Alexandria McKoy Answer:$ -;f 1 oco I

Antonio McKoy Answer:$ 7~,ooo

I

Archie Wright, Jr. Answer:$ 7~, Odo

I

Tammy Lloyd Answer:$ IC'.I ooo

Deborah Johnson Answer:$ 75 I I
000

Ethel Davis Answer:$ 7~ 000

I

Priscilla Dunham Answer:$ 75; )

()() C)

3. "Is the defendant liable to the plaintiff for punitive damages?"

Joyce McK.iver Answer: l__~

Delois Lewis Answer:~

Daphne McKoy Answer:jp

Alexandria McKoy Answer: _j_ff5

Antonio McKoy Answer: yes
Archie Wright, Jr. Answer: 'I 6
2

Case 7:14-cv-00180-BR Document 267 Filed 04/26/18 Page 2 of 3

 Tammy Lloyd Answer:~

Deborah Johnson Answer:~

Ethel Davis Answer:j£S

Priscilla Dunham Answer: j_65

4. ''What amount of punitive damages, if any, does the jury in its discretion award to

the plaintiff?"

Joyce McKiver Answer:$ '5 r 0I C)O .,Q()Q

I

Delois Lewis Answer:$ 5, ood, DOO

I /

Daphne McKoy Answer:$ ~, oco,

7
000
Alexandria McKoy Answer:$ s, ooa, ooo
., I

Antonio McKoy Answer:$ 5,7 000)

./
oc;o
Archie Wright, Jr. Answer:$ 51r 000,
I
000

Tammy Lloyd Answer:$ 5)T 000) I ct)C)

Deborah Johnson Answer:$ 5,I

OOC, OOC)
/

Ethel Davis Answer: $ S-,7 000I 1 dOO

Prjscilla Dunham Answer: $ SI / COO,} ooc)

Forepei'pp;r- ) -
Date
v:::i: la-0 ~ aot£
3

Case 7:14-cv-00180-BR Document 267 Filed 04/26/18 Page 3 of 3