You are on page 1of 104
Central Intelligence Agency r Washington, D.C. 20505 7 November 2017 Mr. Mitchell Kotler ‘MuckRock News DEPT MR 35175 411A Highland Avenue Somerville, MA 02144-2516 Reference: F-2017-01128 Dear Mr. Kotler: ‘This is a final response to your 21 March 2017 Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request for copies of all materials (including but not limited to boards, cards, and rule books) for the CIA training game “Collection Deck.” We processed your request in accordance with the FOIA, 5 U.S.C. § 552, as amended, and the CIA Information Act, 50 U.S.C. § 3141, as amended. We completed a thorough search for records responsive to your request and located two documents, consisting of five pages, which we determined can be released in their entirety. Copies of the documents are enclosed at Tab A. We also determined that seven documents, consisting of 94 pages, can be released in segregable form with deletions made on the basis of FOIA exemptions (b)(1), (b)(3), (b)(4), and/or (b)(5). Copies of the documents and an explanation of exemptions are enclosed at Tab B. Exemption (b)(3) pertains to information exempt from disclosure by statute. The relevant statutes are Section 6 of the Central Intelligence Agency Act of 1949, as amended, and Section 102A(i)(1) of the National Security Act of 1947, as amended. As the CIA Information and Privacy Coordinator, I am the CIA official responsible for this determination. You have the right to appeal this response to the Agency Release Panel, in my care, within 90 days from the date of this letter. Please include the basis of your appe If you have any questions regarding our response, you may contact us at: Central Intelligence Agency Washington, DC 20505 Information and Privacy Coordinator 703-613-3007 (Fax) Please be advised that you may seek dispute resolution services from the CIA's FOIA Public Liaison or from the Office of Government Information Services (OGIS) of the National Archives and Records Administration. OGIS offers mediation services to help resolve disputes between FOIA requesters and Federal agencies. You may reach CIA’s FOIA Public Liaison at: 703-613-1287 (FOIA Hotline) The contact information for OGIS is: Office of Government Information Services National Archives and Records Administration 8601 Adelphi Road ~ OGIS College Park, MD 20740-6001 202-741-5770 877-864-6448 202-741-5769 (fax) ogis@nara.gov Contacting the CIA’s FOIA Public Liaison or OGIS does not affect your right to pursue an administrative appeal. Sincerely, Wf Allison Fong Information and Privacy Coordinator Enclosures TABA 06711361 ‘Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 CO6711961 UNCLASSED//FOUO Collection Deck is a training game designed to teach about various collection capabilities. Students playing COLLECTION tre game use cards representing various collection DECK _ techniques to solve inteligence problems, but their efforts to do so may be hindered by other players using cards representing challenges or obstacles that analysts face when driving collection. Collection Deck has been described as a cross between classic card games like Bridge, Hearts and Whist and collectible card games like Magic: the Gathering and Pokemon. 7 - | “Teoreswe i — oh i [==] | ae | | = |= hse | | | Rae uy Tae i ‘ces sea ty —_— a i | \ (Sees | | | me Intelligence Problem Cards Collection Technique Cards Reality Check Cards uncassit/7v0 [Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 06711361 06711365 7 A ‘Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C06711365 UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO (\COLLECTION DECK ©) SS=// Game Instructions PREMISE Players use intelligence collection techniques to solve intelligence problems. COMPONENTS COLLECTION TECHNIQUE CARDS (66) Each Collection Technique card lists the name of the technique as well as: What collection discipline it falls under: GEOINT, HUMINT, MASINT, OSINT, or SIGINT ‘A description of the technique ‘The types of intelligence aspects it can be used against: (Political, (Military, (E)conomic, and (W)eapons ‘The difficulty range of problems it can be used against ‘Some technique cards may have additional language if they are immune to certain | reality cards or have restrictions on the kinds of intelligence problems they can be used against INTELLIGENCE PROBLEM CARDS (46) REALITY CHECK CARDS (55) Each Intelligence Problem card lists the name of the problem as well as: How many Collection Technique cards must be used to solve it (this is also how many points the card is worth) ‘The intelligence aspects ofthe problem: (P)olitical, (M)i (B)conomic, and (W)eapons ‘The problem’s difficulty rating Reality cards can have a positive effector negative effect on a player's ability 10 use Collection ‘Technique cards against an Intelligence Problem card, either by affecting some aspect of the cards or outright countering the card’s use. There are a few special Reality Check cards: Collection Manager Challenge: If a Collection Manager Challenge card is played against a player's Collection Technique card, the player has to provide an explanation of how that technique could actually Updated May 2012 (v4.3) UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 CO6711365 ! [coszazses gore for Release: 201711701 C0671 1365 “ot UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO i Tbe used against the issue identified on the Intelligence Problem card in the real IMgNFORMED | world, Ifthe facilitator (ina facilitated gum) or other players (ina non, i uF |, facilitated game) find the explanation feasible, the challenge thas been defeated | and the Collection Management Challenge card is discarded. Otherwise, the seuy Colleton Management Challenge cad counters the Colleton Technique card 1 ne | both are discarded, and the player must replace the Collection Technique card or CN sumer ctecten | | "temive "Think Outside the Box: Players can use one ofthese cards to defeat any Realty “ox gnmteeay | Check card that another player uses against one oftheir Collection Technique | EUS | cards, with the exception of Collection Manager Challenge. INITIAL SETUP Separate out the Intelligence Problem cards from the deck, and shuffle the remaining cards (Collection Technique and Reality Check cards) together. Deal seven cards from the Collection Technique / Reality Check deck to each player. Place ten cards from the Intelligence Problem deck face up on the table between the players; this is known as The Field. PLAYING THE GAME Players will have in their hands some combination of Collection Technique and Reality Check cards. Players use their Collection Technique cards to solve Intelligence Problem cards on the Field, nd can use their Reality Check cards to help them do so, or hinder their opponent's ability to do so. However, not every Collection Technique card can be used against every Intelligence Problem card. In “onder to use a technique against a problem, the Collection Technique card has to meet two conditions. 1. The imelligence aspects listed on the Collection Technique card have to match atleast one of the intelligence aspects listed on the Intelligence Problem card. 2, The range listed on the Collection Technique card has to cover the difficulty rating ofthe Intelligence Problem card Reality Check cards can be used to modify a technique or a problem to create matches that would ‘otherwise not be possible. ‘The player who most recent talked with someone in a collection organization gets to go first. PLAYER TURN On their tur, each player or will announce which (if any) of the problems on The Field they want to solve, and Collection Technique cards and any Realty Check cards to do so. This is the player's ‘Collection Strategy. A player can only target one Intelligence Problem card a tur, but should play as tnany collection techniques cards as they need to solve the problem (i. if t's 2 point card, they should play two techniques). Players may also choose to pass and not target any problem, at which point it's the next player's turn. UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO ‘Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C06711365 op6711365 Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C06711365, UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO Once a player has played his Collection Strategy, the other players then have a chance to act as “the system” and try and disrupt the strategy. Up to three cards can be played by all the other players combined to disrupt the played Collection Strategy. After each disruption attempt, the playet whose tum itis has the opportunity to respond to the disruption by either playing his own Reality Check cards or replacing a countered Collection Technique card with another one from his hand. Countered techniques and associated Reality Check cards are placed in the discard pile; Reality Check cards which are used to ‘modify an Intelligence Problem card stay on the Field until the Intelligence Problem is solved. If the player still has an intact collection strategy after all disruption attempts have been made (or if none. of the other players attempt to disrupt his strategy), the player keeps the Intelligence Problem card, and ‘counts the number of techniques required to solve the problem (as identified on the Intelligence Problem card) towards his point total. Play then continues to the next player. Ifa player is unable to respond to a DECK /EaBEC © © COLLECTION COLLECTION © © COLLECTION COLLECTION /aRECK (ER ©) } { } ©) COLLECTION COLLECTION (WS Hm) ©)) L©)) © WS Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C06711962 cog7ii3g2 PROVIDE FUNDING TO. ACOLLECTOR REALITY CHECK Expand a collection technique range by one “Money makes the worl ‘90 our" PROVIDE FEEDBACK REALITY CHECK Expand a collection technique’s range by one You reat the mer ‘Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 08711362 UP Sone} ‘SUPPORT FROM IC. LEADERSHIP REALITY CHECK Expand a collection technique's range by one “Wheles fo nave tends in igh paces ROTATION TOA COLLECTOR REALITY CHECK Expand a coll techniqu range by one “Wal amie my ‘shoes someday.” oop JUSTIFICATION REALITY CHECK Expand a collection technique’s range by one “Sometimes, ijt takes ite ‘convincing. * —— THINK OUTSIDE THE BOX REALITY CHECK Counter any other Reality Check card except Collection Manager Challenge “Some rules are meant "oe broken” “TOP SEGRE __ Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 06711362 O19) LEVERAGE PERSONAL RELATIONSHIP REALITY CHECK Expand a collection technique’s: range by one Hi Bob” 8) THINK OUTSIDE THE BOX REALITY ‘CHECK Counter any other Reality Check card ‘except Collection Manager Challenge “Some rules are meant To be broken” C0,6711362 ee OL / ‘7 ‘ (©) COLLECTION /PARECK (© ©) eA (NO ©) ©) Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 CO6711362 COLLECTION /ZERECK COLLECTION . ©) Se Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C06711362 C0el11362 THINK OUTSIDE THE BOX REALITY ‘CHECK Counter any other lity Chock card ‘except Collection Manager Challenge “Some ules are meant to be broken THINK OUTSIDE THE BOX REALITY CHECK Counter any other Reality Check card ‘except Collection Manager Challenge "Some rules are meant Tobe broken” ‘Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 CO6711362 THINK OUTSIDE THE BOX REALITY CHECK Counter any other Reality Check card ‘except Collection Manager Challenge “Some rules are meant to be broken” THINK OUTSIDE THE BOX REALITY CHECK Counter any other Realty Check card except Collection ‘Manager Challenge “Some rules ae meont tobe broken” THINK OUTSIDE THE BOX REALITY CHECK Counter any other Reality Check card ‘cept Collection Manager Challenge “Some rules ae meart "abe broken” COLLECTION MANAGER CHALLENGE REALITY CHECK Player must explain hhow the technique would be used against the problem "You want to WHAT? "TOP SECRET ‘Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 06711362 THINK OUTSIDE THE BOX REALITY CHECK Counter any other Reality Check card ccept Collection ‘Manager Challenge “Some rules ave meant Toe broken” COLLECTION MANAGER CHALLENGE REALITY CHECK Player must explain hhow the technique would be used against the problem “You want to WHAT?!" (29) 06711362 ’ Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C06711362 COM EADECK penny COLLECTION ae REC © see OECR oe © oO | COLLECTION on = “DEC © ‘Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 CO6711362 06711362 COLLECTION MANAGER CHALLENGE REALITY CHECK Player must expl how the technique would be used against the problem You wont to WHAT? COLLECTION MANAGER CHALLENGE REALITY CHECK Playor must explain how the technique would be used against the problem “You want to WHAT? COLLECTION MANAGER CHALLENGE REALITY ‘CHECK Player must explain against the problem You want to WHAT?! COLLECTION MANAGER CHALLENGE REALITY CHECK Player must explain how the technique would be used against the problem “You want fo WHAT? ‘COLLECTION MANAGER CHALLENGE REALITY CHECK Player must explain how the technique ‘would be used against the problem “You want to WHAT?" | __] COLLECTION MANAGER CHALLENGE REALITY CHECK Player must explain how the technique would be used against the problem “You want to WHAT? [teers 8) COLLECTION MANAGER CHALLENGE REALITY CHECK Player must explain hhow the technique ‘would be used against the problem “You want to WHAT? [ O18) COLLECTION MANAGER CHALLENGE REALITY CHECK Player must explain how the technique would be used against the problem You want to WHAT “TOP SECRET Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 CO8711362 c06711362 Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C087; COLLECTION CK COLLECTION ome DECK ? COLLECTION ane ~DECK © COLLECTION ©) ©) = COLLECTION Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C06711362 COLLECTION MANAGER CHALLENGE REALITY CHECK Player must explain how the technique ‘would be used against the problem “You want to WHAT "PAKISTAN NUCLEAR SECURITY INTELLIGENCE PROBLEM TECHNIQUES REQUIRED ‘Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 06711362 —— COLLECTION MANAGER CHALLENGE REALITY CHECK Player must expl how the technique ‘would be used against the problem “You want to WHAT IRAN MISSILE TESTING INTELLIGENCE PROBLEM TECHNIQUES REQUIRED ont NORTH KOREA NUCLEAR TALKS: INTELLIGENCE INTELLIGENCE PROBLEM PROBLEM Tecwmaues REQUIRED _TECHMUES REQUIRED P prrcury] [P| | oarcuLr | Ww 7 E 6 | | @ CHINA, IRAN CHEMICAL MISSILE WEAPON TESTING PROGRAM Iwrewucence INTELLIGENCE PROBLEM PROBLEM TECHMQUESREGURED _TECHMQUE REQUIRED DIFFICULTY 9 DIFFICULTY T DIFFICULTY i) = DIFFICULTY 4 “TOP SECRET ‘Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 606711362 €06711362 Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C06711362 COLLECTION PnDEC K 7% ©) COLLECTION ~~ ae COLLECTION COLLECTION ECK nents ee (~*" CON zaRee noe “DEC © Approved for Releas se: 2017/11/01 CO6711362 cog71131 ‘Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 CO8711362 SYRIA RUSSIA CHINA CHINA POLITICAL, INTELLIGENCE CYBER COUNTERSPACE UNREST ACTIVITIES WARFARE ‘CAPABILITIES INTELLIGENCE INTELLIGENCE, INTELLIGENCE INTELLIGENCE PROBLEM ‘PROBLEM PROBLEM PROBLEM TECHNIQUES REQUIRED «TECHNIQUE REQUIRED —«TECHNIQUEREQURED TECHNIQUE REQUIRED PM ]orncury) [P| M | owricuTy P DIFFICULTY | MJ irricucry 5 13 | 8 wi 6 Isis TALIBAN AFGHANISTAN IRAQ LEADERSHIP RESURGENCE ‘OPIUM INSTABILITY NETWORK INTELLIGENCE INTELLIGENCE, INTELLIGENCE INTELUGENCE ‘PROBLEM PROBLEM PROBLEM PROBLEM TECHNIQUES REQUIRED TECHNIQUES REQUIRED «TECHNIQUES REQUIRED ——TECHNIQUES REQUIRED PM | birricutry | P[M | oricury 9 E 74 DFRCULTY Taal P| M | owricucry | 8 ‘Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C06711362 Rg) C06711362 COLLECTION aS ~DECK (7a\ COLLECTION NZ COLLECTION DECK XZ © ee Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C06711362 COLLECTION CK ia \e) seaeanes COLLECTION DECK COLLECTION fooDECK COLLECTION ECK (ee Y Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C06711362 06711362 Approved for R ISRAEL RUSSIA INDIA PALESTINIAN GEORGIA MISSILE ‘CONFLICT CONFLICT PROGRAM INTELLIGENCE INTELLIGENCE INTELLIGENCE INTELLIGENCE PROBLEM PROBLEM PROBLEM PROBLEM TECHNIQUES REQUIRED ‘TECHNIQUES REQUIRED «TECHNIQUES REQUIRED TECHNIQUES REQUIRED (PLM yoru] [P]Myorncun) [—[M]orrcun MW oFricucTy ce 6 6 Tw ul | wi 8 CASPIAN "AL-SHABAAB UAE ENERGY ‘ATTACKS IN REFORM L CRISIS KENYA CRACKDOWN INTELLIGENCE INTELLIGENCE INTELLIGENCE, INTELLIGENCE. PROBLEM PROBLEM PROBLEM ‘PROBLEM TECHNIQUES REQUIRED TECHNIQUES REQUIRED «TECHNIQUES REQUIRED TECHNIQUES REQUIRED Pl lorry) [P[M]orncuw) [P[M]orrcun) [P| M | orncur i 8 E 6 5 | 5 "TOP SEGREL. [Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C08711362 od Oo) (its) ont) C06711362 Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 06711362 COLLECTION /RRECK (©) esses COuE RSE &) COLLECTION © COLLECTION “en ~DECK ‘7G \ COLLECTION io = ~DECK {fo © COLLECTION (ERE © COLLECTION ECK tee COLLECTION 7a © Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 08711362 06711362 Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C08711362 ____| (PK) | HIZBALLAH RUSSIA, KURD (ext) WEAPON NUCLEAR ACTIVISM ACQUISITION WEAPON DESIGN IN TURKEY \—pretuiceNce——_ INTELLIGENCE. INTELLIGENCE INTELLIGENCE PROBLEM PROBLEM PROBLEM PROBLEM TECHNIQUES REQUIRED ‘TECHNIQUES REQUIRED —«TECHNIQUESREQUIRED ——TECHNIQUES REQUIRED My] orrcuy| [| Mi] orricucry M[orrcu] [P| | prricurv wl 5 | (er, 6 wi 9 | fe, | 4 (oie) ‘RUSSIA EGYPT ISLAMIST RUSSIA VENEZUELA DEFENSE POLITICAL, MILITARY FOREIGN REFORM PARTIES SALES POLICY INTELLIGENCE. INTELLIGENCE, INTELLIGENCE, INTELLIGENCE PROBLEM PROBLEM PROBLEM PROBLEM TECHNIQUES REQUIRED «TECHNIQUES REQUIRED «TECHNIQUES REQUIRED TECHNIQUES REQUIRED [MJ oFricucty Pp DIFFICULTY P | M | oricuty Pl DIFFICULTY Tw] 7 I _4 Elw| 7 E| 6 Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 08711362 C06711362 Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 06711362 COLLECTION EC - COLLECTION ECK {fmm ff COLLECTION o EC ss COLLECTION (nRECK or (©) N= COLLECTION DECK COLLECTION (ia ‘Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C06711362 co6711362 ‘Approved for Release: 2017/1101 C06711362 L (PX) BOLIVIA CHINA WEAPONIZED G8 ECONOMIC TAIWAN av ‘SUMMIT REFORM POSTURING PROLIFERATION INTELLIGENCE INTELLIGENCE, INTELLIGENCE INTELLIGENCE ‘PROBLEM ‘PROBLEM PROBLEM PROBLEM TECHNIQUEREQURED -—«TECHNIQUEREQUIRED «TECHNIQUE REQUIRED TECHNIQUE REQUIRED P DIFFICULTY PM | oricuty M/orrcury| [P DIFFICULTY E 4 5 wi 7 (Ee 4 J —] ee) EUROPE GLOBAL INDONESIA IRAQ CRIME AND WARMING TSUNAMI on CORRUPTION SUMMIT INFRASTRUCTURE INTELLIGENCE: INTELUGENGE INTELLIGENCE, INTELLIGENCE ‘PROBLEM ‘PROBLEM PROBLEM PROBLEM TECHNIQUE REQUIRED -—«TECHNIQUEREQUIRED —=«TECHNIQUEREQUIRED TECHNIQUE REQUIRED Pl joerc) [Pp] ]orncun) [P]]orncuw Mp orrcuy | E 6 (EL 3 ce 4 E 5 “TOP SECRET. ‘Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 08711362 C06711,362 COLLECTION 4 pone Se fy ee al COLLECTION COLLECTION /ZRDECK if } © COLLECTION OR ©) Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 CO6711362 COLLECTION eo DECK f NS COLLECTION e=DECK COLLECTION DECK if % COLLECTION DECK ©) a Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 06711362 06711342 Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 06711362 MACEDONIA Bi cHINe BK} ETHNIC YUAN | VIOLENCE REVALUATION INTELLIGENCE. INTELLIGENCE INTELLIGENCE: INTELLIGENCE ‘PROBLEM PROBLEM PROBLEM PROBLEM TECHNIQUEREQUIRED -—«‘TECHNIGUEREQUIRED «TECHNIQUE REQUIRED TECHNIQUE REQUIRED PL) owrcury P[M]orrcun) [P DIFFICULTY P DROOL Ce 5 is 3 ae he 5 —a l (x8) ATROCITIES ‘SYRIA CHEMICAL ZIMBABWE (xt) IN DARFUR WEAPON UNREST TESTING INTELLIGENCE INTELLIGENCE INTELLIGENCE INTELLIGENCE PROBLEM PROBLEM PROBLEM PROBLEM TECHNIQUE REQUIRED —-—«TECHNIQUEREQUIRED «TECHNIQUE REQUIRED TECHNIQUE REQUIRED P | M | oricuty P “DIFFICULTY M]orrcury| [P| M | oricury 5 E 4 wi 8 { 5 TOP SEGKE_ ‘Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 06711362 C06711,362 Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C06711362 COLLECTION / (73 CK COLLECTION {GRRECR ©) Noe COLLECTION EC nett {fm (©) COLLECTION ~~ DECK oN reece J COLLECTION CK anne, COLLECTION (CaRECK nn COLLECTION (©) Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 06711362 « €06711363 aintaeas k ses ? otneus? Mate seagsatTst 01 o087 1138 Testers cI ine Misie T i [ren sie Te a E (ox) [enh Kore B. a Pana E um [rabon! B. a Tota 5 ¢ 2 7 z. z 2 2 (owt) @ 2 7. 2 = 2 7 2 2 2 7 2 2 z cout) 6 2 (ex) ‘Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 CO6711963 « €06711363 Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C06711363, Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 06711363 (ox) (ot) (1) (1) (ox) (ot) «06711363 Fone Approved for Release! 2047/11/01 C06711363 sara renee hee ter a Stove — : - ‘Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C06711363 (x1) (ox) (x1) (ox) 0) (oy) (ox) (ox) (ox) (ext) « €06711363 Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 CO6711363, ‘TOP SEGRET_ ‘Cord Name ie [aggressive Counternotigence [Counter a HORAN eotecion Techave [Persona Non-Grata Imisinformes Source fEncrypion [Counter SIGINT colecion technique [Gnguiss Reassigned [Counter a SIGINT or OSINT collection echnigue. [Baa Weather [Counter a GEOINT Technique. [Satetite Waring [Courier a satelite-Dased GEOINT covecion echigue [Sstoite Faire [Counter a sate based GEOINT of SIGINT colecion Technique [Groupe Station Fare [Counter a saelie based GEOINT or SIGINT colecion lechnique [Gon Sani Daub [Counters MASINT colecton technique [os m a [Counter an OSINT colecion technique. [Counter an OSINT collecion technique Media Blackout [Counter an OSINT colocion technique. [Compentmented [Counter a non-OSINT collection technique [Denia and Decepton [Counter ¢ nor MASINT collection technique No Expionaton Resources [Courier any colecion technique [Competition [Counter any colecion technique. [Red Tape. [Counter any colecton technique. POEs [Counter any colecion technique fd Target [increase oificuty of problem by T [Hara Increase ficuty of problem by 1 [Son Tage [Decrease cficty of probiem by 1 Sof Target [Decrease dffculy of probiem by 1 [Realy Had Tanger Increase GfReuiy of problem by 2 ‘Sot T iffy of probler by Z Provide Feedback xpand a colecion technnique’s specium by 7 toa Colecior [Expand a colecton techanique's spectrum by 1 te Intligence Reguremenis 2. colecton fechnnique's specrum by 1 [Coordinate requirements Across IC xpand ¢ collection techniques spectrum by 1 [Cotiecton Management Challenge [Working Group Meeting xpand a colection techoniques spectrum by 1 [Provide Targeting Help [Expand a colection technnique’s spectrum by 1 [Prowde Funcing toa Coleco [Expand a cotecton echanigues spectrum by T [Support from IC Leadership [Expand ecolecion technnique's spectrum by 1 Justiaton [Expand a collesion techonique’s spectum by 1 Personal Relationship [Expand s colecion technnique’s spectrum by [Think Outside the Box [Counter ay other Reaity Check card except Colecion Manager Chateoge [Think Outsie the Box [Counter any other Realy Check card except Colection Manager Challenge [rink Outsie the Box [Gounier any other Realy Check card except Collecion Manager Chal ‘Outside the Box [Counter any other Really Check card except Colecton Manager Chetenge [Think Outside te Box [Counter any otier Realy Check card excep! Colecion Manager Ch irk Outside the Box eo oF i ack on eae Comcior sree Cates —| challenge ink Outside the Box Sour ny cher Rely Check card excopt Coleen Manager Caterge ik Outside the Box cour any cer Rel Chak cart eet Clacton [Collection Management Chatenge [Pi in how the tecnnique would be ee Trt Sco ow ts WeSvigus would be used agit he proien [Gotection Mane Chal must expain how the technique would be used against the problem Pee sbi haw We teciige woud be vse east pcb ——| must explain how the technique would be used against ihe “TOP-SECRET ‘Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C06711363 | I | | | coeyi1363 Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C08711963 606711364 AGT TTT/OT Co6711964 (oa) (ox1) (ox(1), ox (by) | peo cout ox (ox) (ox cout) ~ TOP SEGRET_ Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 06711364 -C064J1364 ase. 2071/7701 C08711964 a (0x3) “TOP SEGRET_ ‘Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 06711364 oem oe Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C06711966 _ (0103) Collection Deck Technique Cards Updated June 2016 (v6.1) Geospatial Intelligence Cards (15) Technique Description Airborne Imagery Piloted and unmanned aircraft carry 2 (b)(3) variety of imagery sensors, providing unique access to targets - (b)(1) (b)(3) Commercial Multispectral imagery Commercial collection of color and the (b)(3) non-visible spectrum (e.g. near-infrared) ‘Commercial Panchromatic Imagery Private companies collect medium and high (b)(3) | white imagery (b)(1) : (03) Handheld imagery [Human collectors and sources can take (b)(3) pictures of places or activities of interest (b)(1) (b)(3) (b)(3) _ - (b)(3) | (pS) (b)(3) ‘Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C06711366 'c06711366 * l Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C06711366 eee ‘Open Surveillance Imagery Collection Low elevation angle imagery may defeat satellite warning programs Vibrometry This geospatial analytic technique uses radar to detect vibrating targets, like operating machinery Human Intelligence Cards (18) Technique Description Defense Attaché Offices US military representatives overseas overtly collect information of intelligence interest Document and Media Exploitation Captured documents and electronic media can provide many intelligence insights Foreign Material Exploitation _ The acquisition of foreign equipment or technology for intelligence purposes Homeland Security Fusion Centers IFBI and DHS work closely with state and local authorities across the US Leadership Debriefing TAnalysts can debrief other USG employees to find ‘out unreported information Legal Attaché Offices BI representatives overseas interact with foreign police and investigative services ‘Non-Title 50 Agencies US agencies that are not funded by the intelligence budget can provide useful foreign formation State Department US diplomats overseas encounter information of interest in the course of their normal duties ed ‘Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C06711366 (by(3) (b\(3) (b\(3) (o{b)(3) (by(3) (b)(3) (b)(3) (b)(1)8) (b\(3) (b)(3) (b)(1)3) (b)(3) (b)(3) (b)(3) (b)(3) (b)(3) (b)(3) (b\(3) C06711366 Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 06711366 Tactical Military HUMINT access to “ground” intelligence Deployed US combat forces can provide excellent Measurement and Signature Intelligence Cards (8) Technique Description Biometrics The collection of characteristics in order to identify a specific person or group of peonle Open Source Intelligence Cards (11) Technique Description Analytic Outreach |__/Analysts can tap into the insights of US. ____| academics and other experts through outreach ‘Commercial Databases | _IC agencies subscribe to databases with data on foreign companies and transactions Contract Open Source Exploitation Contractors can be hired to exploit open sources : —— Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C06711366 (b)(3) (b(b)(3) (b)(3) (b\(3) (b)(3) (b)(1) (b\(3) (b\(3) (b)(3) (b)(1) (b)(3) (b)(3) (b)(3) (b)(3) C06711366 Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C06711366 a Foreign Media Transcription English-language foreign media products can be [provided directly to the IC without transiation Foreign Media Translation The translation of openly available foreign media sources like newspapers, radio and TV broadcasts Gray Literature Foreign open sources that are unclassified, but hard to get to, like school textbooks or military brochures Internet ‘Analysts with internet access can do their own Tesearch into open source material ‘National Virtual Translation Center This organization provides translation services. Wire Services "Many analysts rely on the timely reporting of [services like AP, AFP and Reuters ence Cards (14) Description COMINT Mapping This technique uses satellites to geolocate foreign transmissions Computer Network Exploitation ~__ [Accessing a foreign computer system remotely or through physical access "[Satellites monitor and collect foreign ‘Overhead COMINT _ voice and data communications (Overhead ELINT Satellites collect and classify signals from J radar and electronic warfare systems Overhead FISINT Satellites collect data transmissions (telemetry) associated with testing military systems Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C06711366 (b)(3) (b)(3) (b)(3) (b)(3) (b)(3) (b\(3) (by(1)8) (b)(3) (b)(3) (b)(3) (b)(1)3) (b)(3) (b)(3) (b3) (b)(3) (Kb)(3) (b)(3) (b\(3) C06711366 a for Release: 2017/11/01 C06711366. (b)(3) (by(1) (3) itary forces deploy with their own ‘that can sometimes be leveraged Tactical Military SIGINT (b)(3) Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C06711366 (by(3) 06711366 Approved fr Release: 20171101 608711968 Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C06711366 "C06711367 Aci eae, 207101 Om 887 TOP SEDHEL * ‘Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 CO6711367 .£06711367 Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 606711967 — Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C06711367 .€06711367 setvcherberbebe set | at hi ‘Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 06711367 (b)(1) Coy Approved for Release: 2017/1101 CO6711967 ‘Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 06711367 (b)(1) Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 06711367 "c06711367 pete Carel, esheets ‘Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C06711367 (06711367 sop oRoease 207101 CoB 807 rao an wey Saute stoner Eee SS isha 2 Mag Bae a | an ete, Ors Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 CO6711367 606711367 Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C06711967 “TOP SEGRE! _ ‘Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 06711367 CO6T11368 Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C0671 1368 Cloaks, Daggers, and Dice: How the CIA Uses Games CIA Panel at South by Southwest Conference Prepared Remarks, Talking Points for Anticipated Questions, and Slides Panel Participants: © Carolyn R (moderator) © David © Volko R © Rachel G mt “iiPage ‘Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C06711368 c06711368 f Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C06711368 “UNCLASSIFIED Opening Statement - David The year is 2008. It’s a beautiful spring day in the Washington DC metro area. The sun is shining, the birds are singing, and I've recently Emo . ene nerueS ORC) been promoted to the ClA’s senior fete analytic service. So, as you can Be imagine, I'm feeling pretty good PEA. about myself. Then, I get a call from

You might also like