Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Doctrine: An insured member may be compelled to arbitration pursuant to the Rules of the
Protection and Indemnity Club, which were incorporated in the insurance policy by reference.
Where there are multiple parties, the court must refer to arbitration the parties covered by
the agreement while proceeding with the civil action against those who were not bound by
the arbitration agreement.
Facts: Sulpicio insures its fleet of inter-island vessels (M/V Princess) with
herein Petitioner through local insurance agent, Pioneer Insurance. In 2005,
the M/V Princess was gutted by fire on voyage from Ilo-Ilo to Zamboanga City,
resulting in total loss of its cargos. Sulpicio claimed indemnity from
Steamship under the Protection and Indemnity Insurance Policy, which
however was denied by Steamship and which subsequently rescinded the
contract on account that Sulpicio was grossly negligent in conducting its
business regarding safety, maintaining the seaworthiness of its vessels as well
as proper training of its crew.
ADR 2017
Domingo, John Rowie, B.
mediation, negotiation, and conciliation are favored over court action.
Republic 9285 expresses this policy.
Sulpicio contented that it was not aware that there was an Arbitration Clause.
Being a signatory to the contract, Sulpcio agreed with all the terms and
conditions of the Insurance Policy it acquired, which included the 2005/06
Club Rules which contains the Arbitration Clause found on Rule 47 of the
2005/06 Club Rules:
ADR 2017
Domingo, John Rowie, B.
adjudication by the Directors. That adjudication shall be on the
basis of documents and written submissions alone.
Notwithstanding the terms of this Rule 47, the Managers shall be
entitled to refer any difference or dispute to arbitration in
accordance with sub-paragraph ii below without prior
adjudication by the Directors.
ii. If the Member does not accept the decision of the Directors, or if
the Managers, in their absolute discretion, so decide, the
difference or dispute shall be referred to the arbitration of three
arbitrators, one to be appointed by each of the parties and the
third by the two arbitrators so chosen, in London. The
submission to arbitration and all the proceedings therein shall be
subject to the provisions of the English Arbitration Act, 1996 and
the schedules thereto or any statutory modifications or re-
enactment thereof.
ADR 2017
Domingo, John Rowie, B.
vi. These rules and any contract of insurance between the Club and
the Member shall be governed by and construed in accordance
with English law.(Emphasis in the original)
ADR 2017
Domingo, John Rowie, B.