Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PROJECT 1:
Auditorium : A Case Study on Acoustic Design
1.Introduction
1.1 Architectural Acoustic Design
1.1.1 Literature Review
1.1.2 General Principle
1.1.3 Acoustical Phenomena in Enclosed Spaces
1.1.4 Acoustic defects (echo, delayed reflected sound, sound shadow)
1.2 Site Introduction
1.2.1 About SDCC
1.2.2 Background
1.2.3 About SDCC Auditorium
1.2.4 Auditorium Floor Plan
1.2.5 Auditorium Sectional Plan
1
INTRODUCTION
A Case Study on Acoustic Design : Sime Darby Convention Centre Auditorium
Architecture acoustic is defined as the study of a sound in space. It is the science and
engineering of achieving a good sound within a building for example, achieving good speech
intelligibility in a theatre, restaurant or railway station, enhancing the quality of music in a
concert hall or recording studio, or suppressing noise to make offices and homes more
productive and pleasant places to work and live in. Architectural acoustic design is usually
done by acoustic consultants.
With proper design efforts, wanted sound can be heard properly an unwanted sounds(noise)
can be attenuated or masked to the point where they do not cause annoyance.Achieving good
acoustics, however, has become increasingly difficult for a variety of reasons. To lower
construction costs, the weight of various materials used in many of today’s buildings has
been reduced. Since light structures generally transmit sound more readily than heavy ones,
lightweight buildings have the potential for major acoustical problem.
Building owners and tenants are aware that quality acoustic environments are required for
high productivity and comfort in buildings and hence competitive rental or purchase values.
The architect is expected to provide such acoustic quality. Proper acoustic design responses
early in the design process are critically important, as after-the-fact acoustics “repair” is
often difficult and sometimes impossible without substantial structural alterations which
are very costly.
A Case Study on Acoustic Design : Sime Darby Convention Centre Auditorium
The main driver behind acoustic design in auditoriums comes down to the phenomenon above: Strive
to keep and enhance ‘early’ reflections to arrive at the listener no more than 50 milliseconds after the
direct sound; and dampen and reduce ‘late’ reflections that would arrive at the listener more than
50ms after the direct sound. At a given listener location, if there is more early acoustic energy than
late, speech will be intelligible. To that end, surfaces should be provided and shaped to provide such
early reflections, and reflection paths that provide late acoustic energy should be made acoustically
absorptive. The auditorium, as a place for listening developed from the classical open-air theaters.
An auditorium includes any rooms intended for :
- Listening to music including theaters
- Classrooms
- Churches
- Meeting Hall
The design of various types of auditoriums has become a complex problem, because in addition to its
various, sometimes conflicting, aesthetics, functional, technical, artistic and economical
requirements, an auditorium often has to accommodate an unprecedentedly large audience.
Sound in the outdoors, travelling room their source in a continuously extending spherical wavefront
rapidly attenuate as the distance from their source increases.
In designing rooms for various purposes, the architect will encounter acoustical problems associated
with enclosed spaces.
The propagation and behaviour of sound in enclosed spaces however are more complex than in the
open air.
A Case Study on Acoustic Design : Sime Darby Convention Centre Auditorium
To give satisfactory results without introducing complications in the acoustical treatment of the hall
is the FAN-SHAPED PLAN.
Sound waves change their direction of travel through four categories of phenomena : reflection,
refraction, diffraction and diffusion. These phenomena can occur when changes occur in a sound
wave's medium of travel.
To avoid acoustical defects, sound should rise to a suitable intensity without echoes or
distortion of original sound delivered to the listener, with correct reverberation time.
A Case Study on Acoustic Design : Sime Darby Convention Centre Auditorium
1.2.2 Background
Officially launched on 6 Dec 2007 by the Prime Minister of Malaysia, Sime Darby Convention
Centre (SDCC) caters to meetings, incentives, conventions and exhibitions and is well
known for weddings and celebrations. Since then, SDCC has had a new look with new
facilities.
Set in the vicinity of the prestigious Kuala Lumpur Golf & Country Club, SDCC brings a new
level of charm and sophistication to the art of meetings, exhibitions and banquets.
With a beautiful backdrop of lush greenery and undulating fairway, the SDCC offers a perfect
setting for business and social events in an elegant and exclusive environment.
A Case Study on Acoustic Design : Sime Darby Convention Centre Auditorium
The fan shaped 180-seater auditorium is an ideal venue for award presentations, seminars
and training. The state-of-the-art audio visual system and the luxurious seating in a
conducive set up allows full view of the presenters and perfect for a plenary session or
stages theater production.
Auditorium
A Case Study on Acoustic Design : Sime Darby Convention Centre Auditorium
STAGE
APRON
SE
CA
AIR
ST
AUDIENCE (HOUSE)
CONTROL ROOM
MAIN ENTRANCE
MAIN ENTRANCE
EXIT
STAGE
AUDIENCE (HOUSE)
2
ACOUSTIC DESIGN ANALYSIS
A Case Study on Acoustic Design : Sime Darby Convention Centre Auditorium
WALL
In this auditorium, the walls are designed with specific angles to reflect sound and they are also
covered with different material such as timber wall frame, acoustic cushion panels and hollow timber
wall frame, in order to achieve the acoustic requirement as a speech hall.
Wall panel
A Case Study on Acoustic Design : Sime Darby Convention Centre Auditorium
Material of wall
1
1. Entrance Wall
2. Stage Wall
3. Side Wall
Gypsum Wall
Acoustic Timber
A Case Study on Acoustic Design : Sime Darby Convention Centre Auditorium
CEILING
FLOOR
Carpet floor
Carpet
Carpet Padding
Cement Slab
Room acoustics describes how sound behaves in a space. That means the listener and the sound
source are in the same room. If the room has nearly no sound absorbing surfaces (wall, roof and
floor), the sound will bounce between the surfaces and it takes a long time before the sound dies
out. The listener in this kind of room will then have a problem registering the speaker because he
hears both the direct sound and repeated reflected sound waves.
If the surfaces instead are covered with sound absorbing material, the reflected sound will decrease
much quicker and the listener will only hear the direct sound. Also, the general sound level in the
room will decrease.
FABRIC PANEL
Fabric Panels
Fabric panels are cloth wrapped acoustical panels are designed to absorb unwelcome background
noise inside a hall, reduce echoes and deliver premium sound quality back to the hall
Characteristics: The fabric panels are class A fire rated, decorative, durable, and easy to self install.
A Case Study on Acoustic Design : Sime Darby Convention Centre Auditorium
PADDED SEATING
Padded Seats
Experts in acoustics says that “if you can’t see, you will think you can’t hear”, so sightlines
are a critical element to a successful venue
Fire Barrier
Steel
Fabric FCAM
(Optional) Frame
Padded seats add to the acoustical absorption of an empty auditorium and allows the space to achieve
a similar quality of sound whether the auditorium is filled to partial or maximum capacity.This can only
be achieved if the material is a padded fabric. A solid, hard material changes the acoustic performance
of the auditorium depending on the number of occupants and the reflected sound vibrations.
A Case Study on Acoustic Design : Sime Darby Convention Centre Auditorium
CARPET
Carpet
The nylon carpet flooring in the auditorium prevents hard contact with the floor, although there are
no help against airborne sound transmission, and thus attenuates impact sounds. It is, in fact, the
only floor finish that absorbs sound. The noise reduction coefficient (NRC) for typical commercial
carpets is around 0.20. The absorptivity is confined mainly on high frequency. However, it also
helps to absorb the bass.
Acoustic design began as far back as Ancient Greece — the origin of performance and auditoriums.
Before the advances of microphones hanging from the ceiling or fingernail-sized microphones hidden in
performers’ wigs, builders had to learn how to design their amphitheatres to allow sound from a
performance to be heard all the way in the back. This was achieved through “stepped” seating
arrangements that are still used for theatres and auditoriums today, with the first row at the same
level as the stage, the next row a little higher, and so on and so forth. This “stepped” design is used for
the ceiling in many auditoriums too. This is to let audience have the same distribution of sound.
Smooth walls have a tendency to direct sound waves in a specific direction. Subsequently the
use of smooth surface in an auditorium will cause spectators to receive a large amount of sound from
one location along the wall; there would be only one possible path by which sound waves could travel
from the speakers to the listener. The loudspeaker illuminates its entire view but only a tiny fraction of
the sound actually hits the target, the ears of the people below, the “direct sound”. The rest of the
sound crashing into the walls, floors and carpet, the people, coats, and chairs, the walls, windows and
doors. Everytime some part of the indirect sound hits a surface, it reflects.
Acoustic treatment is the act of stopping the sound bouncing off the various surfaces of the room. A
diffuser jumbles up these reflections so they don’t return back into the room directly.
The uneven spacing of dented surface helps diffuse sound waves to different direction, hence
reduces the sound intensity.
A Case Study on Acoustic Design : Sime Darby Convention Centre Auditorium
FABRIC CURTAIN
Fabric curtain
Acoustically absorbing
Acoustically reflective surface (curtains,
surface (wallboard, wood) carpets)
Diagram of how sound bounces off and absorbed
Fabrics include a wide range of textiles that are used on their own (as curtains) or as coverings for
other materials that may or may not be sound absorbing. The curtains used on the stage of the
auditorium can be considered absorbing as they are reasonably heavy (around 500g/m2). A heavy, low
resistant fabric may rate NRC 0.70 or more. Provided they are not airtight, the fabrics make an
acoustically excellent finish that fully preserves the absorptivity of the substrate.
A Case Study on Acoustic Design : Sime Darby Convention Centre Auditorium
Airborne sound, from human activities in adjacent living spaces or from mechanical noise, travels
through air, walls, floors and ceilings. Building-transmitted sound can come from occupants in
living spaces above, or low frequency noise transferred through the ground and buildings.
3.2.1 Interior
Sound source
When there are event happening in the Sime Darby Convention Center’s auditorium, sound
may come from the music from speaker, person who is giving speech and etc.
Presenter
Speaker
A Case Study on Acoustic Design : Sime Darby Convention Centre Auditorium
The interior sounds are enhance via the public address (PA) system, include input and output
components which are the microphone, mobile speakers as well as the mixer.
Microphone PA speaker
Mixer
Mixer
Speaker
Microphone
Location of components
A Case Study on Acoustic Design : Sime Darby Convention Centre Auditorium
Unwanted sounds are the sound that is not produced to purpose of the event. These sounds
are categorized as noise. Noises may be coming from the air conditioner, audience chit
chatting, walking down the steps, the opening and closing of the seats and etc.
Air-conditioner
Audience
2.2.2 Exterior
Sound Intrusion
Noise entering from the exterior of the auditorium is also known as sound intrusion. From the
diagram below, the yellow highlighted area shows the corridor outside the hall. We conclude
that when there are no event happens at the hall, there are minimal sound intrusion from the
exterior due to the enclosed spaces and lower user at the lower ground floor. They are no
openings at that corridor that allow sound intrusion from exterior into the hall. All the doors at
other rooms are closed. Also, the flooring materials used at the corridor are carpets that
absorbs sound.
Corridor
Sound Intrusion
The red highlighted shows the sound intrusion that there are users at that level. The sound
intrusion at the corridor are when people passing by the hall. There are minimal sound
intrusion into the hall but it only intrude before the seatings. The other possible sound
intrusion is from the right side of the hall, which has a door next to the stage. Sound intrusion
happens when there are users using the room and the sound intrude from the door.
A Case Study on Acoustic Design : Sime Darby Convention Centre Auditorium
When a person is giving a speech, the coverage area where the audience can hear clearly is only
focused at the center area of the seats.
Speech
However, when the presenter is giving speech using the microphone, the sound comes out from
the 2 speakers cover a wider area as compared to speech without microphone.
Sound path is the path showing the direction of sound travels out of different sources. Sound path is
controlled within an enclosed area whereas sound path of outdoor sounds are affected by spreading,
absorption, ground configuration, obstacles, wind, pressure and etc.
Sound reflection through tilted ceiling, properly tilted ceilings can contribute more useful sound
reflections. Reflections may be used in room acoustics to distribute and reinforcements sounds.
Sound shadow is a region of relative silence behind a screen opaque to sound waves,area that is blocking
sound transmission by a non-transmitting object. The sound shadow cast by the head enables humans to
locate the source and direction of the sound.
The collected data shown that the intensity level at this two area is 44 dB which drop from 54 dB. This is
because this two area is located at the left and right corner of the auditorium, this area is blocked by the
timber wall and created a small angled corner which only transmits weak sound wave to here.
A Case Study on Acoustic Design : Sime Darby Convention Centre Auditorium
4
SOUND METER READING
A Case Study on Acoustic Design : Sime Darby Convention Centre Auditorium
5
REVERBERATION TIME (RT)
A Case Study on Acoustic Design : Sime Darby Convention Centre Auditorium
The reverberation time can be said to be a measure of a room’s echo since it is the time that it takes
for a sound to decrease with 60 dB from its original sound level.
3360mm
5300mm 4930mm
Ceiling
Wall
Openings
Flooring
Others
The reverberation time (T) can be calculated simply from the room’s volume (V) and absorption area (A) through
Sabine’s formula,
6
CONCLUSION
A Case Study on Acoustic Design : Sime Darby Convention Centre Auditorium
6.0 CONCLUSION
6.1 Recommendation
In a conclusion, there are few functions in acoustical design consideration of rooms for speech
when rooms are used primarily for speech, intelligibility must be given top priority.
The reverberation time for SDCC Auditorium is 0.75sec. Since it is used as a small usage of
speech purposes (RT0.75), the RT is considered in range.
Throughout this project, we have learned the importance of architectural acoustic design.
Acoustic plays a role in enhancing the quality of sound and silence noise and undesired sound. A
successful acoustic design should depend the types of usage and function of the place then
apply corresponding acoustic design element that involved in types of construction materials,
types of absorption material, types of acoustic features. After site visit and carry out our
research, we learnt about material absorption coefficient, sound reflection, sound propagation
and others, that we also learnt calculation of reverberation time. We have a fruitful lesson from
this project.
SDCC Auditorium is a fan shape (with straight walls) auditorium that have a less diffuse early
sound field that causes larger seat‐to‐seat variations in acoustical quality and a systematic
variation in acoustical characteristics from the front to the rear of the hall. According to the
research above, SDCC Auditorium is a successful acoustical speech hall as it qualified the
recommended range of speech hall RT (0.75RT) by achieving in acoustical materiality and
acoustical features.
A Case Study on Acoustic Design : Sime Darby Convention Centre Auditorium
7.0 References
Mishra, P. (2015, August 08). Importance of INTERIOR ACOUSTICS for Architect and Interior Designer.
Retrieved from
https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/importance-interior-acoustics-architect-designer-praveen-mishra/
Acoustical Requirements for Auditorium Design | Auditorium Acoustics Design. (2018, April 09).
Retrieved from https://www.controlnoise.com/2017/09/29/auditorium-acoustics-design-now/
Indoor noise – Daylight, Energy and Indoor Climate Book. (n.d.). Retrieved from
https://www.velux.com/deic/acoustics/indoor-noise
Theatre Solutions Inc., & Theatre Solutions Inc. (2017, June 30). Auditorium Design: Complete Intro
Guide. Retrieved April 25, 2018, from http://www.theatresolutions.net/auditorium-design/
J., N., Chauhan, R., S., & Theatre Solutions Inc. (2017, June 30). Auditorium Seating Layout &
Dimensions Guide. Retrieved May 27, 2018, from
http://www.theatresolutions.net/auditorium-seating-layout/
Gade, A. C. (1970, January 01). Acoustics in Halls for Speech and Music. Retrieved May 1, 2018, from
https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-1-4939-0755-7_9