Professional Documents
Culture Documents
8
HUMAN RESOURCE ACCOUNTING
AND INFORMATION SYSTEM
CONTENTS
8.0 Aims and Objectives
8.1 Introduction
8.2 The Concept
8.3 Objectives of HRA
8.4 Advantages
8.5 Limitations
8.6 Approaches to HRA
8.6.1 Monetary Measures
8.6.2 Non-monetary Measures
8.7 Human Capital Management
8.7.1 Management by Objectives (MBO)
8.7.2 Ratio Analysis
8.7.3 Personnel Productivity
8.7.4 Personnel Reports, Budgets and Audit
8.8 Human Resource Information System (HRIS)
8.8.1 Definition
8.8.2 Objectives
8.8.3 Need
8.8.4 Setting up HRIS
8.8.5 Computerised HRIS
8.8.6 Personnel Inventory
8.9 Let us Sum up
8.10 Lesson End Activity
8.11 Keywords
8.12 Questions for Discussion
8.13 Suggested Readings
124
Personnel Management Concepts 8.0 AIMS AND OBJECTIVES
After studying this lesson, you will be able to:
Define Human Resource Accounting
Outline the objectives, and costs of HRA
Describe the various approaches to HRA
State the methods used to control manpower costs
Explain the nature and importance of HRIS
Elaborate the steps involved in setting up HRIS
List the important subsystems of a computerised HRIS
8.1 INTRODUCTION
Human resources, along with financial and material resources, contribute to the production
of goods and services in an organisation. Physical and monetary resources by themselves
cannot improve efficiency or contribute to an increased rate of return on investment. It
is through the combined and concerted efforts of people that monetary and material
resources are harnessed to achieve organisational goals. Human resources, therefore,
are the most important assets of an organisation. Unlike physical assets, human resources
do not depreciate over a period of time. In fact, with additional training and experience
gained over a period of time, they tend to do well on the job. This fact, however, is
ignored when a firm’s balance sheet is prepared. All expenses relating to recruitment,
training and development of employees are charged against the revenues of a particular
accounting period. In fact, as pointed out by Rensis Likert, the expenses on human
resources are fixed in nature and do not offer any immediate return.
Table 8.1: The Costs of Human Resources
Recruitment costs: Include advertising, travel expenses, consultant’s fee, incidental
expenses.
Selection costs: Include costs of application forms, testing and interview expenses
and other administrative costs.
Orientation costs: Costs incurred in offering orientation courses to new employees
(about company policies, procedures, programmes, rules, regulations, etc.).
Training costs: Trainers’ salary, facilities cost, trainees’ time spent in the programme
measured financially, low productivity during training.
Development costs: Costs incurred in enhancing employee skills and expertise.
The returns accrue to the firm over a long period, i.e., as long as the employee remains
with the firm. Hence such costs should be capitalised and amortised over the entire
period so that the balance sheet gives a ‘true and fair’ view of the state of affairs of a
business. Since human resources are capable of enlargement over a period of time,
there should be innovative ways of showing how the organisation makes investment in
its people and how the value of people changes over a period of time. Human Resource
Accounting is one such method which endeavours to measure both the cost and the
value of people to an organisation. In India, several companies in the 1970s began to
show the value of their human resources in their annual reports – such as BHEL, Engineers
India, Associated Cement Corporation of India, ONGC, etc.
125
8.2 THE CONCEPT Human Resource Accounting
and Information System
Human Resource Accounting (HRA) is similar in principle to the preparation of an
accounting statement. Just as financial accounting reflects the cost of assets such as
buildings, land, machinery, HRA tries to place a value on organisational human resources
by formulating a human resource balance sheet. Here human resources are presented
as assets, not as expenses. HRA, thus, shows the investment the organisation makes in
its people and how the value of these people changes over time. According to the American
Association of Accountants (AAA), HRA is “a process of identifying and measuring
data about human resources and communicating this information to interested parties”.
Flamhoitz defined HRA as “accounting for people as an organisational resource. It involves
measuring the costs incurred by organisations to recruit, select, hire, train and develop
human assets. It also involves measuring the economic value of people to the organisation”.
8.4 ADVANTAGES
HRA offers the following advantages:
It throws light on the strengths and weaknesses of the existing workforce in an
organisation. This, in turn, helps management in recruitment planning, whether to
hire people or not.
It provides valuable feedback to mangers regarding the effectiveness of HR policies
and practices. For example, high training costs may warrant a change in policy,
additional recruitment expenses in respect of a particular category of employees
may indicate the need for a better compensation package, high training costs may
compel managers to look at the returns over a period of time, etc.
It helps potential investors judge a company better on the strength of the human
assets utilised therein. If two companies offer the same rate of return on capital
employed, information on human resources can help investors decide which company
to be picked up as an investment.
It helps management in taking appropriate decisions regarding the use of human
assets in an organisation, i.e., whether to hire new recruits or promote people
internally, transfer people to new locations or hire people locally, incur additional
training costs or hire consultants keeping the impact on the long-run profitability in
mind.
126
Personnel Management Concepts 8.5 LIMITATIONS
HRA suffers from the following limitations:
It is not easy to value the human assets in an organisation: There are no
guidelines differentiating the ‘cost’ and ‘value’ of human resources. After valuing
human resources in a specific way, many of them may leave the organisation.
Human life itself is uncertain and hence valuing the asset under such ‘foggy’
conditions is not proper. Like physical assets, human assets cannot be owned,
retained and utilised at the sweet will and pleasure of an organisation. The so
called ‘asset’ – after getting itself enriched within a company – may simply disappear,
causing irreparable loss to the company.
HRA is full of measurement problems: There is no agreement among the
accountants and finance professionals regarding the measurement process. In what
form and manner are the human assets to be included in the financial statements?
To compound the problems further, there is the question of deciding the recovery
rates. How should the HR costs be amortised? Should it be increasing, constant or
decreasing? Should it remain the same or different for different classes of
employees?
Employees and unions may not like the idea, because HRA may lead to division
among the ranks of employees. A group of employees may be valued lower than
their real worth owing to reasons beyond the control of management. The employees
may resist the idea of being treated like second-class citizens, despite their useful
contribution over a period of time. Unions may fight such manipulative practices on
the part of management. They may even demand higher compensation and better
rewards when things turn rosy and employees are valued at a ‘premium’.
There is no empirical evidence to support the idea that HRA is an effective tool
to measure the economic value of people to the organisation. There is very little
data to support the contention that it facilitates better and effective management of
human resources.
Costs of recruitment
Cost per hire (in Rs) =
No. of recruitershired / retained
ii. Recruitment cycle time: It is the time taken from commencement to completion
of recruitment process. It helps to determine the lead time needed to initiate and
complete the hiring process. A careful analysis of time taken at each stage in the
recruitment process will indicate the need for and steps required to reduce the
cycle time. Clear job specification, computerisation of application blanks,
standardising the screening procedures, etc. This will help reduce the cycle time in
the recruitment process.
iii. Cost of turnover: Turnover is expensive. Besides recruitment and selection
expenses, the costs involved in creating new employee records in the HR department
establishing payroll records in accounting, giving new employees training and
providing them with safety equipment also are lost when employees leave a firm.
There are indirect costs also in the form of low motivation and morale. It is not
always easy to determine the exact cost per employee.
The following formula is generally used to calculate the cost of turnover:
No. of separations
Turnover Rate (in %) = 100
Average strength of employees
iv. Cost of Training: The cost of training is usually expressed in the following ways:
Training Costs
a. Cost of training per trainee =
No. of employees trained
Training costs
b. Cost of training per employee =
No. of employees
No. of Training
c. Training ratio
No. of employees
130 It is not easy to evaluate training because of organisational constraints arising out
Personnel Management Concepts
of poor infrastructure, lack of a clear training policy and unwillingness on the part
of managers to initiate changes based on the feedback given by employees. To
complicate matters further, there is the problem of allocating and apportioning the
fixed and variable costs in training such as cost of equipment, building, trainers’
time spent in offering training, etc. The evaluation and allocation problems, however,
should not come in the way of undertaking training programmes in an organisation.
8.8.2 Objectives
Computerised HRIS is designed to achieve the following objectives:
to offer an adequate, comprehensive and on-going information system about people
and jobs.
to supply up-to-date information at a reasonable cost.
to offer data security and personal privacy. Data security is a technical problem
that can be dealt with in several ways, including passwords and elaborate codes. In
the information age, personal privacy is both an ethical and moral issue.
8.8.3 Need
Costly Exercise
Personnel records, when kept manually, do not offer up-to-date information at short
notice. It is difficult to make entries on forms and returns continuously and keep pace
with on-going changes on a daily basis. The clerical work involved is quite labour-intensive
and costly.
Inaccurate
The manual transfer of data from one record to another may increase the chances of
errors. Entries may be made twice, data may be transferred to wrong documents –
leading to confusion.
Fragmentation
Information is not available at a central, easily accessible place since records are kept at
separate locations, handled by different persons in different departments.
Difficult to analyse
The manual analyses of data is time-consuming and quite often not readily available for
decision making purposes. When the organisation grows in size, the manual systems fail
to offer reliable, accurate data at short notice.
A computerised information system offers several benefits, as summarised below:
Table 8.2: Benefits of HRIS
HRIS can process, store and retrieve enormous quantities of data in an economical
way.
The records can be updated quickly.
There is improved accuracy.
HRIS can greatly reduce fragmentation and duplication of data.
Information can be readily manipulated, merged and disaggregated in response to
special and complex demands and presented promptly.
132
Personnel Management Concepts Labour relations HR planning and analysis
8.11 KEYWORDS
Human resource accounting: It is a sophisticated way to measure the effectiveness
of personnel management activities and the use of people in an organisation.
Historical cost: The expenditure incurred to recruit, train and develop an employee
Opportunity cost: The rate (actual or assumed) for capitalising the earnings expected
to be earned by an employee.
Replacement cost: Cost of replacing an existing employee.
Value: The present worth of the services an object is expected to give in future.
Value of human organisation: Present worth of its expected future services to an
organisation.
Productivity: The set of services a person is expected to provide while occupying his
present position.
Promotability: The set of services the individual is expected to provide if and whether
he occupies higher level positions in his present or different promotion channels.
Human resource valuation: The process of finding the value of people of an organisation.
Human resource information system: An integrated system designed to provide
information used in HR decision making.
Forecasting: Identifying expected future conditions based on information from the past
and present.