Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2TOIXEIA
THE HARMONICS OF
ARISTOXENUS
BY
'
OXFORD
1902
HBNRY FROWDE, M.A.
LONDON, EDINBURGH
NEW YORK
WvfciLuV.
Ajm**-"*v.
310 10
PREFACE
including of
the readings H as and
givenby Westphal, recting
cor-
HENRY S. MACRAN.
Trinity College, Dublin.
\ Sept 1902.
CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION-
PAGE
Text-
book I 95
"
II .122
III 149
"
translation-
book i 165
"
11 187
in 2"9
"
NOTES 223
INDEX 295
INTRODUCTION
and we
analyse, can never expferience.
2. The same contrast appears when we consider music
in relation to and
painting the other arts of
imagery.These
latterappealto the emotions no less than music,but they
do so in the firstinstance mediately,
throughthe representa-
tion
of certain objects.It is quitetrue that here,as in the
case of the emotions indirectlyraised by language,the culti-
vation
of a habit is a necessary condition of
certain mental
our receiving
the proper impression from any work of art.
But in paintingand sculpture the mental habit consists
primarily
in our attitude not to the
of the sentation
repre- manner
absurdly
that melody is meaninglessif it means
a nothing
to us, and it forgets with equalabsurdity that the beautyof
a system in which
sound-relations, each member has its
relation to every other determined through the common
in the -q~
flk g or progression3k
~Tzr
B 2 3
INTRODUCTION
relations. Universally
elementary recognized
as belonging
to this class are the relations between any sound and its
octave above
below, either beingregardedas tonic ; the
or
From
multiplied. these considerations resulted one of
the firstlaws of Greek melody. The scale that beginswith
any note, and ends with its Fourth above is at most a
6
THE DEVELOPMENT OF GREEK MUSIC
TABLE 1.
OF THE TONIC A.
" J J J rl
OF THE TONIC A.
" J J*^ m
SCHEME OF THE DIATONIC TETRACHORD SCALE
OF THE TONIC A.
""J J J '*
In this table the
followingpointsare to be noted : "
(3)Several possible
divisions in the Chromatic and
are
9
INTRODUCTION
music)but of tetrachords.
10. According to the firstof these answers, the tetra-
chords
s
TABLE 2.
INDEFINITELY EXTENDED.
Enharmonic
Chromatic .
I
Diatonic
i ;,J^4^
""*.
3f ^P
If in the Ionic scale of any genus we take any con-
secutive
TABLE 3.
Enharmonic jc I %
-3~ J J 1 1 tj
i 1 1
Chromatic
*tic jc
x 2 3 2 S I I
Diatonic
i 1i 1
2
*
S "
f
55.
j -1 j j 1 "J J ^
11. These names were derived not from the pitchof the
ii
INTRODUCTION
1. 3 2
I I
"
I
3
I
S H fc fc
jj J J .MJ J ^
and transposeit,
say, a tone higher
' S
3 ft i
x " a s H " a
I
fjr^-^++
the individual notes of scale will bear the
the,resulting
same names as the members
corresponding of the original
12
INTRODUCTION
Chromatic g
ill
iS 3 S I 5 " 85
,
(f.
1 ,11 1 | J.^
s i i I "
" "" Js $ 1 2 I
Diatonic " " 3 g | " fi fe
i(|
I i j 1 1 I^M
The scale of this Harmony, when indefinitely
prolonged,
resulted in the following
succession :
"
TABLE 5.
Enharmonic
Diatonic
^ J ^J
The appearance of the octachord scale necessitated an
alteration in the nomenclature. The old names were ployed
em-
'
next the middle,'
givento the note above the Mese.
was
TABLE 6.
Diatonic
I J J^
-.1 A i J
i
"
-zK
P^^
The alternation of
conjunction which is
and disjunction
the characteristic of this Harmony is exemplified
in the
TABLE 7.
Enharmonic
i J J ^^FE*"
j- j- A
"
15
INTRODUCTION
Chromatic
'rf
1 tj 1 I d
Diatonic
a j j j, j^^
14. If we employ modern nomenclature we may guish
distin-
the first two Harmonies from the last by saying
that the former give rise to
modulatingscales,the one
passingover into the flat, the other into the sharpkeys,
while the latter maintains the same key throughout.But
we must examine more closelyinto the nature of this
difference. In the scale of the firstHarmony we have a
follows : "
j j J J 1 r f \ r
":
3= ^^
1
The relation of a note to its octave above or below approximates
to identity,
C 17
INTRODUCTION
i i J ii r r r r
^ ^^ ^
in each case supplyingthe most fundamental relations of
the scale in the form of a bass.
1 6. From the comparisonabove instituted between the
three earlyHarmonies music, it was clear that
of Greek
the third possesseda consistencyand unity which were
wantingin its rivals. Accordingly we are not surprised
to
find that they fell into disuse,while the Aeolian won its
QUINTILIANUS.
" 3 j j ^ r t c
g;^i" ^=^ j r^
Here we have a scale which,though containing
two dis-
junctions
(between D and Ey and between A and B\ yet
producesan octave by combining conjunctionwith dis-
junction
at A, and in so doing embodies the distinctive
THE DEVELOPMENT OF GREEK MUSIC
* j 1 j j pnnm
18. Aristides Quintilianushas preservedfor us several
other examplesof these perverse scale-readings.
Composers
found room for varietywithin the Aeolian Harmony by
employingnow one, now another segment of the indefinite
c 2 19
INTRODUCTION
Aeolian not of
scale, course with any change of tonalityor
but simplyas
modality, the melody requiredthis or that
number of notes above or below the tonic. Thus there
arose a seriesof scales which offered material for the analysis
of the theorist analysis
" that was not by any means
an so
Q rL
$ IZ2I
-rj
It is most to be
carefully noted that,in order to conceive
of these scales as did the
entirelyabstract Greeks,we must
cles the Athenian saw that the Mixolydian scale had its pointof dis-
junction,
not where it was commonly supposed to be,but at the top ;
and accordingly established its figureto be such a series of notes as
from the Paramese to the Hypate-HypatGn.'
22
THE DEVELOPMENT OF GREEK MUSIC
""
*=t="
j j J
^
OLD HYPODORIAN SCALE.
-i j d ^
$ j m ""
TABLE 11.
S4i.
"3
INTRODUCTION
TABLE 12.
OLD HYPOPHRYGIAN SCALE.
^-H^-
i j rj | r^
(g)does not appear in the oldest listsof scales. Perhaps
the extreme of
position the tonic made such a segment of
rare occurrence. The same fact may have helpedto obscure
the analysisof {a). Certain itis at any rate that not only
TABLE 13.
ENHARMONIC MIXOLYDIAN SCALE OF ARISTIDES
QUINTILIANUS.
i
OLD DIATONIC MIXOLYDIAN SCALE ON THE ANALOGY OF
THE PRECEDING.-
I "T77Jc r.Tg^
="
$ 4 w pg=^
5=^
and 1 1 j j ^^^
34
THE DEVELOPMENT OF GREEK MUSIC
genus.
TABLE 14.
(a)Mixolydian.
Enharmonic
J-3^J J J
"J; J. J
Chromatic
EgE
J; ^ "" 3ip
Diatonic
i. j j ""
"a J- -J y
(")Lydian.
Enharmonic
J J ^ ;m
J^
Chromatic
.i "j *
a^
"" See*
~'J J
25
INTRODUCTION
Enharmonic to PHRYGIAN
Enharmonic
W Hypodorian,
Chromatic
[f-j-^-^^M
26
THE DEVELOPMENT OF GREEK MUSIC
Diatonic
j "J "4.
."$
j. J \ I -i
(/) Hypophrygian.
Enharmonic^
j ,j j J J, K^L^LgL
"j)
J rL
Chromatic
Sj-rJ J tj *j_
Diatonic
i-J. XZl^
j .1 A
27
INTRODUCTION
12345678
and of the Phrygian: "
12345678
If then we suppose the limitof practically
possible
sounds
to be two octaves, from
to
and as Phrygian
again,
one mighttake as Lydian
i j j i 1 J ^^
28
INTRODUCTION
but serving
relative, as the ground of an absolute ethical
character ; not leadingto such an order of the scales as
but
series, preciselytothe reverse order.
24. To understand the possibility of such a determination
we must take into account an important distinction between
ancient Greek melody,and the melody of modern music.
We have seen that the essential feature of music is the
relation of all the notes of a scale or system to its central
pointor tonic. To maintain the sense of this relation,
it is
TABLE 15.
Hypophrygian
4 7)eh-^-H-jLJ:
j
Hypodorian
mm ," 7 1 j i^
31
INTRODUCTION
MlXOLYDIAN
_
Tonic Tonic
. j I
Dorian
Tonic
,
I J
Phrygian
4 I ,j ,i i 1 "^^
Lydian
****'""" Tonic
1UDK .
I m 1 :'-*-J
(b) High Lydian
$ j 1 j 13E^S"
Another example is the well-known scale of Terpander
[seeAristotle iV""/. xix. 32 and Nicomachus (Meibom,
^ J J j S
In the passage in which Aristides quotes these defective
scales he promisesto supplyon a later occasion the reasons
ihnMHi *""%
out of seven-stringed
a constructed
lyreoriginally to meet
the heptachord
1 j
" 4 j j .1 "j
33
INTRODUCTION
The would
Ionian scale of Aristides Quintilianus seem to
i r t r L
34
THE DEVELOPMENT OF GREEK MUSIC
TABLE 16.
MlXOLYDIAN.
Enharmonic
Tonic
Chromatic
Tonic
Diatonic
Tonic
$ 4 u J J J .L-J.
Lydian.
Enharmonic
Tonic
Chromatic
Tonic
OI11C |
i ^f*f 3^P
Diatonic
Tonic ,
i
t
"'
Id j j j. J ' .'
D 2 35
INTRODUCTION
Phrygian.
Enharmonic
_
Tonic .
30-j1 J J p^
Chromatic
"
Tonic .
Tome .
Dorian.
Enharmonic
_
Tonic .
| j, j | p j. s
Diatonic
Tonic
. l
Hypolydian.
Enharmonic
" .
Tonic
i(f
i j i j" 1 J '"'*
Chromatic
Tonic
Diatonic
.
Tonic
. l
36
INTRODUCTION
LYDIAN n Tonic
ionic . I
Phrygian Tonic
hU-J-
" A 8 U 1 '^
Dorian in xonic
Tome i
" g "i=^
.
j .i j iJ
Hypolydian
-YDIAN Tonlc . I
Hypophrygian
"TCIAM
Tonic I J
g I ^^
, , ,
"f.1 J J
Hypo dorian
j T7 j ij j |^
From this table it appears that the
Hypodorianwith its
tonic J? is the lowest of the modes, andthe Hypophrygian,
common whole.
Again,it is a distinction of pitch, but not such as exists
between our keys,for it arises immediately from the order
of intervals. The Mixolydianis a high mode because any
pathetic
song, a scale in which the tonic laynear its upper
and
extremity, for his sentimental,
one in which itsposition
was the reverse 1.
2
I " 1
1 !
I
"
I
3 s
i
" g
x a
i
$
were added at its upper extremity tetrachord
a conjunct
r r
$ i' r
$ * i a J
that modulation of key was introduced for the sake of higher or lower
voices ; for this difference can be met by the raising
or lowering of the
whole instrument, melody
as the unaffected whether it is
remains
40
THE DEVELOPMENT OF GREEK MUSIC
TABLE 18.
THE GREATER COMPLETE SYSTEM WITH THE NAMES OF
ITS NOTES.
Diezeug- Hyper-
Hypatdn Mesdn mendn bolaedn
|l "
| 3 v
| 3 % a *
TABLE 19.
$ i j g gg j
jij a
1
Literallyof '
the highest.' The highest
or of
top string the lyre
gave the lowest note, a Also called Neton.
4i
INTRODUCTION
TABLE 20.
Hypatdn Mesdn
1 !
I
p*
1
1
MlXOLYDIAN
^=fe
ggjg I r g $3E
Hypatdn Mesdn
I " i 2
a
1
"
i"
H8
Lyoian
m ^?^ ^^"
IS
Mesdn mendn
SI
"JUS W 0" S
Phrygian
""A r I I I T"j j j
Mesdn Diezeugmendn
Si
s 53
Dorian
a.^ j r r
^^^
43
THE DEVELOPMENT OF GREEK MUSIC
Mesdn Diezeugmendn
" I B bi
Hypolydian
^
mm p^^ ^
Diezeugmendn bo)
bolaedn
1-
II S I B
Hypophrygian
r
r r
1 ^
Diezeugmendn Hyperbolaedn
Hypodorian
43
" INTRODUCTION
TABLE 21.
MlXQLYDIAN
^"yrlrrrrrr
^,|jj,)rr
Lydian
ggfe
"g"r flrrrrrT-j,
jijj^
Phrygian
.) Jplrc
"ei? rrr(fj
jjUJJ -rzr-
DORIAN
^j.irrirrffjJJt)|JJ
Hypolydian
Hypophrygian
Si ^jrHJrrirrrTi j ^j
Hypodorian
nifUUURIAN
.Q
ZEE
TABLE 22.
Hypatdn
"
x s
"j" r
1"
\
**-
"
"() c p n 1
F C u D "
as
Chromatic
JM^
^sfc ^ ^S
w "t" c p n 1 e h u
FC UD" V"Z
Diatonic
E^EE^
"a.;J" f f
jf^T-^
"(" C P M I 0 r u
e c o n " v n z
Enharmonic
mi^-F-P-^-tfTJ j^
X T c n K T H A
R C D " " A
2
"" Chromatic
I" "
^g s^ inHI
o
W J 4-^L-^l
x T c n t I H A
*\ =1 C 3 A ""\
P"
Diatonic
K
e=t|tg 1 r
rjr,=fip=i
x T C O I Z A
T C K A " C \
THE DEVELOPMENT OF GREEK MUSIC
TABLE 22.
f
2 s I s
a .5
s I
j u r j J
r Hi r -
jj
1
br i"
wn"f r r T f
* * M' e a " r "' H' U'
A X T M * \ "' V"' Z'
u r i H t" r 1 r r^^
a " M' e a M- v "' r ir
a \ t *i /, n' "' v' n' z'
-J nJ 1 fJ J-J_ f^Jg-"=^
U * O' * e 1 K' I' H' A'
Z X K' X M \ A' "'"' V
" ^^^F=^=^
u e o' * e o' K' r z' a'
Z M K' X M K' A' "' C V
47
"
by \jOOC
Digitized
INTRODUCTION
Hypatdn Mesdn
is
Enharmonic
""6
"
P4
!i 3
W r '"
^fy-p
?mf
n"|"YTM AKT
A Fu.=in -" A N
" Chromatic
3
"" ""A" j g rT^ bbJ ^
"^ H "J" Y TMA A K r
W A F u. 1 -"; A N
PL.
""
Diatonic
^ I r-^ j j ; j
n 4" y n ,M AHT
I* F u. o n -" " N
Enharmonic
m= "" ^ rfi,j
w n X"|)TO =NZ
r^FTK^"C
Diatonic
^ r 1 r i ^#7T 3=
n x "(" c o h i z
r^vFCK^"C
4s
THE DEVELOPMENT OF GREEK MUSIC
si " g s g s a g 2
"c a " s *c a " *c 3 "
H ft fc A H ft 55 H ft fc
J U 1 nJ 1 J f T F^=
B A " U A * M' A'K' r
/ \ \ Z X X H '
xi'A' N'
B ^ J. U A j. M' A'H' r
/ X X Z X \ T "'"' N'
t,jhj I p j iJ=p r *r r
E A e A U * O' H' N' Z'
U J "1 \ Z X K' *' 51' r
iJ J 1 p J j r r r r'
E u e A U "D O' H' I' Z'
U Z *l \ z V K' *' "T
B
m 49
INTRODUCTION
Hypat6n Mesdn
is
3
*
I 2
Enharmonic
ri
pviyr j "f-r | A
y n y x n O N H
K " "
Chromatic
-fefel
fefe^=g:
^
rr pj EEJ~^
y nyxn onh
o
Q
a*
w Diatonic
^%r l r r
Ff^^
y n y t n O K H
K A "
Enharmonic
"fc
r^J r "- :^=g="
7 n R v c p n i
i- r l b c u D "
Chromatic
"b
^ f^gE
p n i
5^ 7 H R V C
I- r L b C
Diatonic
^SE" =P= ^^
7 1 R * C P M I
I- T L F C u n "
50
THE DEVELOPMENT OF GREEK MUSIC
Synemmendn Diezeu$mendn HyperbolaeOn
S 2
S 2 g Z
j "J 1 i J J J
-r r
13=
,j j | lrj-^i
j J r r r
Z A * r B * -L O' K' H'
E \ X N / X A K' A' "'
"f"j
bJ 1 nJ j j"1111?!!!
6HUZEAeA"l'
V " Z EU3V1^\"'
i bj a 1 hj j ^^ r 1 i3-
0H U Z E A e r
a j.
V"Z EU3"1^\"'
"
#bJJ J nJ1^ 1 r r n
eruzEuexMi'
VNZEUZvl""n'"'
" 2 5i
INTRODUCTION
Hypatdn Mesdn
i: I 8
I I I I
Enharmonic
-^-
r
/le'tft
i j j r 1 T
ri y 1 V T C n K
anrti cda
Chromatic
,HROMATIC U
Q
5 r^t"
K
t\ rl y 1 V T C n K
"
3nrt=iCDA
Diatonic
J1ATUNIC
,,q.
e:i|tt =
i r r_ g r r r
H y 1 X T C O K
anr^q cka
Enharmonic
'i, n I r ^
rb'j,p g i
"^ r r T
-7FY"t"TTM
E I- " H F "-=in
Chromatic
UJHAllt I I
^ q
""
S
-7Fy4" ytm
a, E I- J. H F u-^T
Diatonic
-7Fn"("YnM
E H J. A F u-DH
5"
INTRODUCTION
{lypatdn Mesfta
ii I III ill
Enharmonic ^
/
wh J T7~j ^ j r n
s7
Nri7yX "DTO
h 3 h H A F 3 K
Diatonic
"h j g 1 r r r r r
H ri 7 1 X "DCO
h 3 h l~ A FCK
Enharmonic
(1^% J 1 J- r I ,cr r r
m _n"rinrxn
R E ui 3 A f *\ 3
Chromatic
M .oriHYXn
R E ui 3 A f A 3
DlATONIC
2
2 S B 55
^
i J- -l ^ fJ-U * "
J
Xi
J
= N Z K I H A U * O'
* " C A " " \ Z X K'
i J ,J J J ^
j
?tt" i z a u e o'
* " C A " E \ Z *1 |C'
J
i j. J- J p J
J J
3 J J J
J
-
ONHMAKTBA-L
K)l"nxiAN/\\
*
iU * J * j JTT
O K H M A H T B * 1
K A " n -" " n / x \
55
INTRODUCTION
Hypatdn Mesdn
is
I
II " 1 "
I I i
Enharmonic
5 a i *
a I
m
"
9 w v * n r v c
H h x h r L t C
2 Chromatic
Q
5- I 1 J j! i B^
o
9 H V * T R V C
a: h h x h r L fc C
Diatonic
j J J J EjEEjEEg
g
9 W V 7 T R 0 C
h h x k r L F C
Enharmonic
"^Hf I I I I j j f f
3RhriHrtl
Chromatic
UMW*y-|VT
3 HhH HTtT
Diatonic
P"pi
UMNri
y TXT
3Hh3Hr*\T
5"
THE DEVELOPMENT OF GREEK MUSIC
1,1Y
pni
% *0
11
H N
j
Z
i
EAe
a "'
UD" K * " C U 3 *1
^
Pni OHNZEAe
PMI 0 = 1 ZEu"
UT" K * " C IJ Z "I
?E*=E
-J-:
JjJJ-
jU-^
c n k n*o N H Z A *
C D A D K " " C D X
cnic nON H Z A *
CDA D K " " E D X
CO K nOKH Z A *
C K A D K A " C \ X
57
INTRODUCTION
Hypatdn Mesdn
J"8
S3
J8 I I -
I I
1 3 ft 13
Ph ffi pi, ^ S3
Enharmonic Ph 2
(m j i j j r t e f"
3 Q W M 7 F y "|"
" H H R I- -L H F
" Chromatic
o
j J s j r p^
o
3 Q W M 7 Fy"("
" H U R I-
s -LHF
Diatonic
fet
"" j a J I j r r r
\
3 0W-7 Fn"t"
e H U E H- i. A F
Enharmonic
/l^" 1 j j J 1 g r f
HnQMri 7 X
y
T3HR3 l-H^
Chromatic
2^
^^ j j bj l I 'r r
a.
HnQMri 7 X
y
T3HR3 l-H^
DlATONK
^r" j I J J 1 J r r
h n 9 n ri 7 1 X
T 3 H h 3 I- r "\
58
OF GREEK MUSIC
THE DEVELOPMENT
Diezeugmendn Hyperbolaedn
Synemmenftn
z
S I
S " is
fe^=
Z?E
i^^jj
p n I 0 H U
Y T M C
" V " Z
u. =1 1 C
"fMy r I ^^
w^* O H U
T M C p n i
Y
3 " V " Z
u. =| 1 C o
"=f=^ I u-r*-^
P M i " r u
y n M C
" v n z
1 C
-**:
=E
'" P
illJ J
'
O T
r^f^ H A
C D A " " \
F =1 K
fr r lr fT| ^g
O T c riik I H A
"t"T A " " \
F T K =1 C D
HypatSn Mesdn
i i
i I 8
Enharmonic
/Pig j j J r
J J J' j
-a 3 b u _ ri"HXl
o. " co 3 E uj 3 A
2 Chromatic
^S t^
j J JhJ J gjj fL
-o 3 by " mrifl
o. " w 3 E uj 3 h
Diatonic
{^v j " j j^
\ .a 3 b M -
o. e co p e uj H A
6o
INTRODUCTION
*
to the latterof the term /caret Svvafuvin respectof function/
TABLE 23.
Hard Bioiv
MlXOLYDIAN
I I
/caret tofoafuv
" " s
i
Pk
Hypatdn Mesdn
a
Kard. 04"riv 3 g
* Ph
Lydian
4=i
m i iF^
icarcL tifoa/uv
1 1 *"8
'fil
ll
Pi Pi H8
-r
Hypatdn Mesdn
INTRODUCTION
Be r (' g I r#J J J
3
J f,
Hard, duvafiiv K " g
3K P-4
Oh
Mesdn Diezeugmendn
Dorian * ^ S
f r
'^ 1 EE jJ J J "'
8
*arcl bvvafjuvft g
I 53
AfSdn
s
*ard 0far
Hypolydian * " i is
SE
"n 3^ ^^
I I
g
5*
g
Mesdn Diezeugmendn
Hard 0foiy | ft
Hypophrygian b * 2
^ r r r
" ^
H I
Kara hvvapiv.gg " g
64 Hyperbolaedn
THE DEVELOPMENT OF GREEK MUSIC
w" j 1 | I*
% j .1=
"ar"i bvvafuv
s I S
Diezeugmendn Hyperbolaedn
TABLE 24.
THEORY.
MlXOLYDIAN
(a) Mcse (b)Tonic
""
jL^ J J J J
J I^PEgE^
Lydian
Mese (*)Tonic
,
-H+"
$ I^s d j j m j ^
Phrygian
ia) Mese ,(6)
Tonic
-hU"
Dorian
(a) Mese I I (6)Tonic
JJ^
66
THE DEVELOPMENT OF GREEK MUSIC
Hypolydian
(a) Mese
lese i I J (b)Tonic
3 J j J
p 3=" ^^
^f ^
Hypophrygian
(") Mese
HH s ^^^
Hypodorian
J J J -J-fflTo"
in ^^ ^^^ Efefc
and according
to this system the fourth note of every scale
was itsMese.
Nevertheless
37. this plausible hypothesis is absolutely
untenable,as the followingconsiderations will show.
In the firstplacewe must note that the modes are not
"o o
i
_
"fJ J ^-*g m
(a) Plato,Republic,iii.398 e:
Ttvcs ovv OprjvwSusapfwvtai ; , . . . Mt^oXvSwrrt, Kal
tyrj,
SwtovoAvSiot! Kal roiavral rives. " TtVcs ovv fiaXaKatre Kal
aufxiroTLKal
r"v ap/j.ovL(av ^ "
; 'lacrrt, os, Kal AvSlotl,oitivcs
KaXovvrai.
^aXapal
'
'
What then are the scales of
mourning? '
Mixolydian,'
said he, 'and High Lydian,and some others of the
c
same character/ Which of the scales then are soft and
convivial?' 'The Ionian/ he replied,
'and Lydian, such
as are called slack ' (i.e.
low-pitched).
71
INTRODUCTION
(")Aristotle, vi (iv).
Politics^ 3. 1290 a 20:
'O/iooas 8' Z\"i /cat TT"pi rag dp/xovtds," ^acrtrtw /cat yap
according
to which of systems there are but
perfect
one, or two, while the rest in the one case
are deviations,
ttjv Sidvotav,
/xaAa/carrepcDS olov 7rpos rds dvet/tcva?.
'
To beginwith there is such a distinction in the nature
(d)Aristotle, v (viii).
Politics, 7. 1342 b 20 :
vwofidWei
ap/jbovias,a\Xa tols avci/Aevas rj"/"vcri$ rot? ttjXikovtols.
in pitch. The
differing connexion of these names with
certain modes or scales of different figures
arose in his
opinionat a later periodfrom the fact that tions
limita-
practical
restricted composers and performers to a certain
a^ j.iffr rir^.jj.Li^
Now suppose that a composer or
i TT
^V1 I r f
r"L J J "'
which is of the form
|e-Zr^r-t J J rJ
'
"M
m* t rfe=7~TT7
74
THE DEVELOPMENT OF GREEK MUSIC
$ j J J " ' J r r r
of their silence,
it,in spite it cannot
surely have been exact.
Absolute and exact determination would presuppose the
universal of a
recognition conventional standard embodied
in some authorized instrument,or expressedin a matical
mathe-
formula; the firstalternative is precludedby its
and
absurdity, there is no evidence for the second. But
if the determination,
thoughabsolute,
was not exact,while
we might admit an absolute difference of Ethos between
a scale of extreme heightand one of extreme depth,there
could have been no such absolute difference between scales
separatedonlyby a tone or semitone ; for let there be but
variation between the tuningof one day and another,
a slight
the is
regardof posterity that they stretched the stringsof
their lyrea littlemore looselyor a little tighterthan did
their predecessors?
41. Returningnow to the which
hypothesis we have above
proposed we shall consider a few passages which seem to
offer striking
confirmation of its truth.
(a)Heraclides Ponticus apud Athenaeum^ xiv. 624 c :
'Hpa/cXciS^s8* 6 UovTiKos iv TpOnoirepl MovcrLKrjsov8'
fkiv #caA."wr0at
dpfwvtav"f"r}cr\ ovSk
naOairtp
rrp^ "pvyiov, ttjv
AvSlov,apfxovLds yap c?vatt/dcis* rpiayap Kal ycvitrOai
'EAXi^vcdv
yivrj,
Acopiets, AtoActs,*Ia"vas (625d) Kara"j"povrjT"ov
ovv iw
. . .
ras fikv
Kar etSos$La"f"opa"s
ov Swayxcvwv hraKoXovOovvTwv
6(.wp"iv"
i
rovovy Ttftwvrcs to KaXbv avrov. With regard, too, to the
tetrachord Hypatdn, it is plain that it was not through
ignorancethat they* (olirakaiot, the ancients) 'abstained
from this tetrachord in the Dorian Scale. The fact that
" 1 J J ,|_-J-^-f-F=
was added at a later perioda conjunct tetrachord at its
exception
was made in the case of the Dorian scale because
it was felt that such an alteration would imperilits Ethos.
Mr. Monro endeavours to reconcile this statement with his
of
hypothesis keys by pleadingthat the character
the of
moderation inherent in a key of middle pitchwould be
sacrificedby the addition to it of a series of lower notes.
To which reply Would not the pathetic
we may character of
'
*
a high pitchedscale suffer equallyfrom such an extension?
But on our hypothesisPlutarch's statement is quite in-
telligible.
J
j-j j T? g j J
i
for a treble voice ; or as the scale
i T~3
"
*
Tonic
ionic i i
M
for a tenor voice ; or as the scale
Tonic
i I I J
will have the effectof making the old Greek hymns as clear
and convincingto our ears as the songs of Handel and
Mozart Verycurious isthis delusion,
thoughnot astonishing
to any one who has reflected on the extraordinary
ignorance
of mankind about the most spontaneous and universally
beloved of the arts, and their no less extraordinary
difference
in-
to its potent effects on the mental and moral
character. Who would take up
Egyptianor a book on
throughHypate, Lichanus,Mese, by
$ g "
J '*
0 H C CCCC1 R "J)
fiov "T-Shr rep* -
FWK
R 0 C P M I M
jive -
TO-96-ra,
M I E Z r m p C M
Aa " rods f6-V", At} - \t - t
MIZM I "J"c c
cd-ftc-v" T y irdp-ta
-t* fio"
P^mmmmm 'A
......
ad
r n "
-
ct - 8c fiov -
/mm "f"i \tj -
fioK -
jtrp 8*!/*-
"% Wi^iMi^i^i^
r1? nr r
^ J. .d ^ ^ ji;
#=tfe^f r.7ririr7
w
1
Professor Prout has suppliedthe harmonies ; but he is not wise
other-
responsiblefor this well-intended mutilation.
84
INTRODUCTION
1
For everythingthat is known about the life of Aristoxenus,
and
for the references to the ancient authorities,
see the excellent article
pp. i-xii.
vol. ii,
in WestphaTs Aristoxenus,
8*
ON ARISTOXENUS AND HIS EXTANT WORKS
present Aristoxenus,
to that of a system or organicwhole
of sounds,each member what it does,
of which is essentially
and in which a sound cannot become a member because
merely there is room for it,but only if there is a function
which it can
discharge.
The then, of
conception, a science of music which will ^
accept its materials from the ear, and carry its analysis
no
kwv a, but the a is crossed out, and ftwritten beside it; the
headingof the third book is 'ApMrro^eKov
aro^Umv apfjuovucwv
flywith the p crossed out and y written beside it
* '
(c)The text of the Three Books contains matter of
three distinct classes ; firstly,
introductory
matter or tion
exposi-
of the scope and divisions of the subject
; secondly,
of primarylaws and
or expositions
generalprinciples facts ;
thirdly, propositions of details,followingone another in
presentvolume :
The (referred
dp/xovtKiy
Eio-aya"yi) to in this volume as
2TOIXEIHN IIP"TON
Meibom.
1 Sidrovopfti
^ x?"atjLariK^v
con*. ex -a? th ff-kQp S " iS^XtuS
3 Marquard : apfMviK"vH
ivapfiovliov faeyevR
: relL
bppoviSiv 4
fxeytBav conieci : ytp"v codd. 5 r"v post "rxnp"ra"vaddidi
tc om. R 6 obfoU ante oh? ponunt B R B V (ex
4iccx*ip*i
I"*x0 : inexdp** ^ : 4*ix*ip"rell. 7 7^0$ et $4 seclusi
8 T"Tolr)K"R -KovyiMrioofB B
9 tre ("suprascr.) 8* om.
MVbS obM S
TerpayiUrcvvrai
*v* BV (v fortasse postea
rell.
additum): *cirparyfidr"vrtu o68i]Hi H 11 Brt (c
B
suprascr.) taK"y*ovn*vH : iwHnanrovfitvR la off/Aqy "XA.' R
14 Ikoo'to*']
"rr Mb e corn 16 ^/uypost ^ovc/^vadd. B, rubra
linea subscn R ""rr" R .17 deinde lac. 3 litU M
4"rriv]
19 /a^AAovti M alniirom. H 20 1V supra lineam S
33 ivtffrtv
B R : ^orfv rell. I)B
96
APMONIKGN 2TOIXEIGN a' I.3
kclO'fjV6"6 re Kal papb yiyvkrai "AA' " ov ctbos 15
|tclvtov
T7JS KLVrj(T"a"S
iKdT"paS""TTIV, 6' Ovbtvl Tr""TTOT"
iirifJLcKks
yeyivrjrai ircpl tovtov bioptaai tLs kKaripas avT"v fjbiafyopfa
KCiCTOl TOVTOV ftf) buOplO-QtvTOS OV Tx6.W pqblOV"lTT"LVI 7T"pl 20
rell. B V S : 'Eiriyopfloop
'E*iyovloov sed ti e corr. M iiuurxov
R 9 "ra"pts Meibom \eytiv addidi 13 obfe voeircu M S :
oW 4yvour"u BR 14 ffvyK"xvfi4yws Marquard : ovyicexv/icVa
codd. 15 5iarc((re"yB S R 178^0111.VS \ckt4ov
conieci : Sticcuovcodd. : post Mkouov add. chrcti' H 19 ante
"rvarfifiaros add. tov Vb B li*\66vra Marquard : Bit\6vra codd.
20 p4\ovsex pepovs corr. M
MACRAN |J 97
1.4 API2T0EEN0T
iv tols KivovpiivoLs
t"v "f"d6yy"i"v,
airoboTtov b% Kal tovs 10
98
APMONIKGN STOIXEIXIN a' I.5
0$ yCyverai rj {eI)
avarrjfiaTa tovto aopiorSviorur Ttcpl
yap rovnav oir awobcucriKos ovt avaitobtiKros w' oibcvbs
Tt"Ttor "Xpr)Tai
\6yos. oiarjsb" Oavp^xrrrjs rrjst6"""*"$
TT"plTTfv rov "riaracriv| ara^CasrAefonj
fiikovs /xovo-1/07?25
5 w* hfCtav
KariyvcDarai bia rovs p"TaKexei.pio'pJvovstt)i"
dprjpJvrjv irpaypLarcCav. To"ra6rr]V
ovbh" $" t"v ai"r0T/rG"i/
lx"trd"w ovte Toiatirrjv. iorai 8* fjplv
brjkovrovff \o$rm 3"
"X"v,orav eV airrfj yev"ficda rfjTrpaypLOTtta. vvv 8e rh
*
konra. t"v jiep"v keKriov. ATtob"xOivTtoV yap t"v acrvv-
10 Qimv biaarrfpATQiv bv rp"nov11 irpbs"kkrjkaovvrCOerai 6
TF"pl t"v crva-T"VTMV i" avr"v "rv(TTrifiiTa"v keicrtovw"pl
T" t"v "kk"av Kal tov rckeCov,i" iicelvcDVaTtobtiKvivras
Tt6"ra iorl Kal itoi | irra, r"$ re Kara iiiyeOosavrQv aito- "
bibovras Kal
faa"f)opas t"v ptyeO"v kKdarov ras re Kara
15 aivBtcw Kal ras Kara [to] btaqbopas
cryripua Sims prjbevt"v
fxektobovpLhxov
pu/jr*piycOosfwyre o^ijpafwfre |"r6v0""n$ 10
[pdJT"
04"ri$]
avairobeiKTos fj.tovtov 8e tov pipovs
rrjswpa-
"kko$ jutev ovbels TTfiSTro^'
ypxiTtias rfyaro*'EparoKkrjs 8'
"Tie)(slpri"T"v
avawobtCKTMs tfcapiOpeiv iirC n pJpos* on
20 8* ovbtv etprjKev
| akka n/wra \jrcvbrj
Kal t"v (f"awopdva"v
15
rjjal"rdrj"T"ibirjpL"prrjKe,
retfecJpqrai
p.\vt-pppocrOtv St avrfjv
Ka6* avrr\v i"r)T""op."V ttjv Trpayparelav Tavrqv. raw 6'
"kk(ov KaOokov /zh"| KdOimepipTrpotrOev eliropev ovbth 20
rfTrrai, ivbs 8e "rv"rTrjp.aTos
'EparoKkijsiit"y"ipri"r*Ka(F $z"
25 yivosi"api0p.rj"rai.
ra oyripara tov 8ta Traa"v avairobcua'"s
tcatra rb "rxrjpatiicupop"s
H : om. rell. Kal Kara dfoip add. Marquard
post "rivd""Ttr 04"risom.
17 /*^T" H ava^teiicrov H f H :
faroteucTiKus codd.
H 2 99
1.6 "
API2T0EEN0T
25 TjjTrepKfropfl I btiKwis,
t"v biaaT7]fjL6.Ta"v ov KarajxaOcbvon
2 Monro
TTpoaroSfixdevrow : itvoticixMrrw
irpbs B : TpovcnroSeixOtv-
rcov rell. t"v re tow] rovratv M : suprascr. Mc : tow
rovrcov cum re
100
I* API2T0EEN0T
ivcurrhas"f"aiverai,
luvcurOar yap t"mr]"riv
biafiaivovva avrr\v
iiilpuas raVca"$ elra tt6Xlv i"f"*
he pas Kal tovto iroiovo-a
yop.iv""v
yap fjfx"v
oirrcos f)"fovr\Kwevrai Kara tovov "are
25 boKelv tarao-dau
firjbapiov Kara be \ttjv eTipavfjvovopA-
"opevbiaarrffxaTtKYiv
ivavrCoasTtityvKe aXXa
ylyvecrOai' yap
taraaOaC Te boKet Kal irivrestov
"\"au"6pevovirotelv tovto
"j"e6yopL"v
to hv prj bta ts"Oos tsot\ els
la-Tivatrqv "j)0)vrjv,
VS,
kicartpas B in marg. 18 5^] 6 in ras. M 33 W^wcf]
vkc in ras. M H
26 To-rao-^at : ^ry ttrrdvcuV, B in marg., S
APMONIKGN STOIXEIGN a' I.9
10 fiev lirtraVcts
re ml aviveis acfravets
TroieicOai tcls be t6l-
(rets QOeyyopLe'vrjv
avras KaOioT"vai, ine^tfrbv 15
\ "f"avepas "
rfrnov bv bie^ipyerai
fxev tov StaonJ/utaroy ore p!evavi"\xiv7)
6re by iTnTeiPopAvrj
kavd"vew avrqv bel bie"ovo-av,tov? be
dpCCovras "f"06yyovs
ra biaorrma\Ta re Kal k"rn)K"ras
ivapyels 20
103
I.n AP12T0EEN0T
tiryofxcv xfi^vop
5 *
restitiiitMarquard
. . 5, 6 ttfrrrrar^v x"P^v
tiryofxtv
re Kal fxercucivovficv (is om, Ma R : in marg. add. M b : sed
perfod.Mc : praeterea el 8* ch ex els Mx : "/ 8* eh VS, B in marg.
7 Kal ante ovk add. R ye om. B
9 ttjs om. R ay ay oto^s
Marquard : codd.
hyovaris Kipetrai B S
10 13 ante Tavra
104
APMONIKGN 2TOIXEIGN a' Lia
f}rjo*"raC
itore tjjKivrjo'ei,KivelcrOaidAA' Tjpep.e'iv
fJLrj re Kal
kor"vai. |
AuiQipeiyap oibev rjfuv to Xiyew o/uaAorryra 10
77 tfxavrj'
KtvetTai fiev yap iv ra" bi"orrjfJL6. Tt 7rot,eiv, torarat
15 I oyebbvyap brj\6v
Sia"f""poi. icrrivSti r/fiels \4yopevkCvtjo-Cv 30
20 rjpefiCav
(fxovfjs,
tcls Ifiirpoo-Oev 6' iv toIs
evpopev ovcas
25 be Kal ttjsT"o-eoosripefitas
twos TedeCoTjsoibev pJaXkov
iKeCvoav iKaripaTairbv t"o-isioriv,iK t"v prjOrjo-Ofx^voiv
3 *l om. R rb
(vplaKoi B R 5 avrty S : ainb R : abr^i
relL 7 voiovvres ex xoiovyras Mx tovto to tvopaTi64fi.
ex
24 a"piKOfx4vT) in
Vb, hxpiKo ras. Mx : Va B
aQucPovptrri S : R
a"f"iKovfi4vri
a6 conieci : itcarfpuv
iK"xT"p"f, codd.
105
1.18 API2T0HEN0T
15
lorai (fxxvepop.
Act bffKarafxavOivav | oti rb p\v kor"vai
r^v (Ixavrjv to [xivewiirl puis T"acds ion, crypptfo-erai
6' avrfj tovto, iiv r iiiif}ap6rr\TOS idv r eV d^irqTos
iorijnu. EJ b* fjpkv t"cis iv apcpoTtpoLS xnr"pfctkclL "
I{w6"ycodd.
106
APM0NIKX2N 2T0IXEIX1N a' 1. 14
1 M (0*ante t
8icurrdUrc"vs S,B
eras.), in marg. : tiictrtoeusR, Vb
fort, e corn, B 5 t\ om. B 6 efrc ante parvislitt.
9t4"r*a"s
supra Mc, in marg. B,
lin. add. R : om. rell. 9 tiardurcus B S R
ia 8ia"TT"lff"ci"s~\
tr ante t eras. M : hardffects BR 13 cf ("r
suprascr.)T" B 15 els]ix H voi^f^]"x^ 16 H 17 ct
107
Lis API2T0EEN0T
ttjttw buHJnpim
elireip, bfAa-rrjfiaical c"cu rao-cow to
10 6 | A"fyos
oJ6s T" yivrjTai
IpfSifi"a-cn, ciy to ctvpUp"u to
3 R
"pi(6vroov t6 tc R
Sidorrifia ix S
ol6ficpoi elpflffBcu
S is ""i"c""rai
R 7^kijtcu]
i^-cu in ras. Mb r^ \ey6fievor\
rb : post J)ras. M 13 ante pep una litt.eras. M /t^] cTveu B R
r"y] rb R : rbv V B S rvv $" om.
fiKiara. . .
H 14 \6yuv M
15 "f"66yyupR 16 BR
owr^/taros]Sicurrfifiaros 18 SieXciv V S
sed "tp Vb in ras. : $i"\6uv M ticup"rets
om. B sed in marg. add.
J9- XPV^f^ov H tireiTa in ras. Vb : ko2 "rt in ras. Ma
ao ^taar^fiarosdeinde
hicupeatis nuraeri d. /".ktI. in marg. Mb
Vc 33 $ia"p"p(i
om. H \6ywv B R : ^ijt^t"v dA^wv in
ras. Mb
108
Li8 API2T0HEN0T
pikovs
ircpl ftv "ltf
rjpXvveipariov
{nr"ynrjr"(rat
tC ttot
iorlv r)"pv"rts
avrov, *On
pkv oiv biaorrfpLaTiKriv
h" avr"p
5 5^] S
r\ 6
r"v 4v rots Meursius : t^ 4p rois codd. 7 6rcl
J' B R : %x"ira rell. 8 crvyiardvcuB 9 tOxus R '3 bpB"s
. .ircpl
. r^v parvislitt.supra lin. Mc, in marg. Vb 14 rb restituit
Marquard koB6\qv conieci : icd-rovH : xai vov rell. Kal seclusit
Bellermann 15 i*l rfjs \4$ewsBellermann, duce Anonymo
(P" 55) : iviniliclus codd. 16 BicurrrifxariKy xpV^ai Meibom :
iuurriifiartKcxpyvdcu codd. 18 B
9iafxafyrrifx4vov ao 6 om. H
a 1 S
ctpeladu 34 raMv] M
rabrb (postb litt.eras.) : ravrbv V :
rabrb relL B
iurcupwji4vriP om.
1XO
APM0NIKX2N 2T0IXEI"N a I.19
To jxivoiv povcnicbv
rrjsTrpayiACLTctas. pdkos airb tQv
"W"ov o$tg)$
VTrokqirriov
dffxmpio-Ooa. 8e tov elpr\p.ivov
aQopurfjibv
Ttfora) oOrm ""s/mr^Tra)
d^rjcrOai t"v nad* cKaara 15
Toi irdvra. To p,ev oiv tkdxiorov Kar avrrjv ttjv t^s (fxavrjs
""fwpl"r6oo
2 ex fopapteiffOaMa rhv]rh M (corr.Mc) 3 el-
ex Mc
prj"r6ai elpfiffdw elpiiaQai
: S tKourrov R 6 els om. S
8 rahrh conieci : rb codd. conieci
7jp/j.o(rix4y"ay 7}ptio"r/j."vov
: codd.
,
hiwp"vnv
tiia"p4p"i
in marg. add. Mb Vc 17 \iprrfov rel re om. B :
"c S 22 ""poopl"T6ai
ex Mb : "r
iuf"wpici(rOai in ras. Vb fihv
om. H 34 rb om. B : supra lin.add. Mb rijyom. B : supra
lin. add. Mb
I.i8 API2T0HEN0T
iT"pl
ptkovs far eltf vaparlovVTrorvnwai
r)pxv tC ttot
tarlv f\"pv"ris
avrov. pkv otv biaaTrjp.aTiKr)v"On
h" avrti
10 Khrqatvtlvai TTpotCprjTai,
btl tt)v rrjs"fxf"\vrjs "ot" tov ye
Xoyvbovs K"x"pUTTai rainy rb pjowiKov pJkos'ktyerai
yap by Kal koy"bh n rb ovyKeifievov
p.4ko$, in r"v Trpoa"p- 5
1 irepl in
fi4\ovs marg. Mb Vc licirvTrSxraiR a hurrqiiariK^v
B 3 ye] y S 4 B sed in marg.
\4ytrcu . . . p"os
add. om.
KexpyvOcucodd.
"8iatrr7)fiart 18 B
Bia/j,aprrifi4vov
so 6 om. H
si S
elpeiffda 24 ravr6v]rc"rb (postb M
litt.eras.) : rabrby V :
rahro rell. B
"jrcupovji4vriv
om.
110
APM0NIKX2N 2TOIXEIX2N a' 1.19
Tb fiev
rrjsTTpayixaTelas. pA\os airb t"v
pLOvarucbv ovv
hQwpladco
2 ex Ma
iupapielffOa rbv\rb M
3 el- (corr.Mc)
prjcrOai
ex S
Mc : clpeiadcu
elfyffffda ticaffrovR 6 els om. S
8 rabrb conieci : t^ codd. conieci
ripfuxrfi"av codd.
: ripyuofffiivov
rh els rb fipjjLo"rfi4vov
Marquard 10 yhp Marquard : re codd.
bvOp"vov] ayvv S Vb R S ; irporvyx"v*i"
irpoffTvyx"vei. reW-
ii ve"rarrov H 12 rb 4vapfi6yiop
ex Mb
r^v apfxovlav 14 8t-
"pptlfifpop B 16 (nctycurdcu
R naff %v rh, atfHfmvarwv
iicupdvwv in marg.
Siacpepfi add. Mb Vc
17 \rixr4ov rel re om. B :
S( S 22 iufKoplffOcu ex Mb
","pa"pi"7"xdai"r
: in ras. Vb fity
om. H 24 rb om. B : supra lin.add. Mb r^v om. B : supra
lin. add. Mb
ill
1.20 API2T0EEN0T
"5pioTcu,
"j"v(rf.v to o$t"o fxiv[oZv]
8e [lAyuTTov OVK ioiK"V
"^
^J^ J^ L in marg. Mb Vc 11 rb y"pVbBRSz
I
_
kl*aic\(L."Jiov
rod yhp M (yhpin ras. Ma ut vid.): fi4xpl 7"P T"v Marquard : yhp om. H
fpaUop"pvpioy4v rtp elsappoviich add. in marg. H
farofirfifiart oine4riex
olv i"rriMa B
Hiarclvufttv ia SidraffipR r6ic"fWestphal :
r6vtpcodd. 13 irap8evia"vM Vb R icapB. adA.. linea subducta S
14 rbv om. R Marquard : fiapvrdrav
fiapvrcerov codd. 15 rov
R : rovr' rell. M H
KarcunraOelffijs 17 n-oi^creie Sido-TTj/xa
rod
rp\s 5tA icaff"v Ziaffr^fxaros
clprjfxevov H fa04vros\ post p ras. M
18 y ante ircuSbsadd. et "pwv)) post /uicpov ponit H
112
APM0N1KX2N 2TOIXEIX2N a' I.21
t6 pAyiarovdpl("TCU bvv6.fx"f.,
oxcb"vbr)\ove* t"v dp-q-
5 pAvw 6ti 8'6kt(o fxeyddr)
arvpL^voav biaorriyAToav
ovpifiatoi
yCyvecOat pqbiovovvib"W.\
8' ovroav
yvcapCficav
TovTOiV to Tovtaiov bi6.aTr\p.a
ttcl- 20
*Eoti 8t)tovos
paTiov""f"opC(TCU. fjt"v irp"Ttov
ovp."f""bv""v
Kara \xiye6os btaxfropd. AiaiptCada)8' cis rpciy biatpicreis'
10 /x"Aa"8cfo-0a)
yap | avrov t6 T" rjpaov
Kal to Tptrov fxiposKal 25
{to)T^TapTov to. 8e rot/raw iKirrova biaxrrfjfiaTa irivra
Ioto) apL"\"abriTa. KaAcfo-flco8e t6 p.\vi\d\Lorov bCecis
ivapjxSvLos i\axCorr}, to 8' i\6p."vov | bUais xP0)lxaTiK*l3"
ikaxCorrj,to be fiiyiorov f}fiiT6viov.
15
Tovroav 8'
a^oipto-fxivoDV
ovrm ras t"v ytv"v bia"\"o-
KivovfjLtvdL
dcrt Kal tcl r)p"fxodvraiv rals t"v yevQvbuupopats.
3 S
rrjfip4pa 5 hark Westphal : 4k rQv codd. ftey40ct
MVRS Kcd ante Hiaarrtfiairav
BR, parvis litt.in marg. Mc
7 tpos r6vov add. Mb Vc in marg. 8 ^ om. S 11 rb restituit
Marquard Z\ e corr. M
""popi"r/A4va"y
15 S 17 9h]" in
ras. B 18 Karexfawov conieci:
rb restituit Marquard
Ka\o6/xevovcodd. 7c conieci : om.
H : re rell. ao seqq. riva
.
Kivovvrau
. .
seclusit Westphal ut glossema ao riva 5^ rdj^iv
R :
rur Sal rd"iv(5alrd
(a suprascr.) in ras.)Mc : riva icpa^ivV S, B in
marg. : riva 5^ rd"ivB : riva irpa^ivH post ohff"v add. x"P^v
supra lin.Mc, x"P^v cum duobus punctispraepositis, punctisin marg.
repett B, %opS"vcum cruce R, ovyxopSi"vWestphal
mackan 1 113
1.2* API2T0EEN0T
da w iv rats t"v
ytv"v biacfropcus,bio V ol ir"pi"x6pL"V0t
klvovvtcu.] Tovro pkv ofa?o$tg" fce""r0a".t"v de ovyypp-
buav Trk"i6va)vr ovor"v t"v t^v elpt]fxivr]p t""ivtov bua |
15 T""r"rapa"i"Karexpwr"v Kal 6vop.acriv lbCois iKiarrjs avr"v
""pL"rixivri$,
fxCatCs ivriv fjjxeVrjs
Kal Ki\avovKal irapwirqs5
Kal vTrirrjs oycbov yycopifUDran; rots aTrroyAvois paver iktjs
20 iv fjtcls I t"v yev"v bia"f"opa$ avayKaiov imo-Ktyao-Oai
rlva Tpoirov ylyvovrat."Ori p"v oiv at t"v iav"i"r$ai
pi"i(ov
birovov. Tovrwv 8e pkv t"v
to pikviXarrov irapa
rjbrjKaravtvo-qKOTOiv to bufoovov yivos \pv\\ opLokoyelrcu,15
"4
1.34 API2T0EEN0T
io KettrOoatovto
iflut(|"reos, "v etvcu t6
pAyeOos. Uviarbv Sk
Xeyia-Boa rb Ik bio btaarrjfjL6,T"av
ovv""m)Kb$a ovvT"$4vra
4\cLTTov bidarrjiiaircpU"itov Xcurofiivov biaarrjfjLaros
h
X.rj"j)64vTairoKva \i\avolclprjvrai'
6p((ovo-ai ffSk rb TpOrov
25 irvKvbv dpC"ovo-a ||\ixav"$ XPa"lxaTU^l f^v i"rrtv,/caXcircu
bk to xp"p-aiv " iarlv f}pu.6\iov. eH bk Tb T"TapTOV ttukvov
116
APMONIK"N 2TOIXEIX2N a' I.25
20 TdrrjbidrovosTtjspaptrrdrris
biarovov 8icVci iori ovvtovod-
M V S
3 HcedcicamifLoplov 4 /j."i(d"v M S
Vb : fiu(ov Hoc loco
in marg. M et Va et H multa adscriptasunt, quae videas in Comm.
5 frirep4x*iv]
y supra lin. add. Mb 6 Kcd post xpvfiaTlK"dac*d"
M R Va 8 r"y i\ax^ru"vH S
"/j."\d"rrjTa 10 tavrh
ex kcarrw Mb ry ante ffvffrimartadd. H n, ia in marg. Mx Vc
haec : ^ aft^ K "XpSofia iffrlrb 0 fitrh. rod 4i 13 rifilrovov H Air']
4v* R 14 tUffis ex SUffiv Mc : ZUffiv V B S 16 ZtKar-q-
fUpiovH in marg. Mx Vc haec : 4vap/j.6v. SUvis r (r6vw ?) rb
reraprov 17 rpuov supra lin. Mb tiattieicarrifioplov
Ma, sed wv
supra ov scr. Mb 18 rrjs om. Ma: ins. Mb ai "nfaroi]
rrfwi B in marg. aa Meibom
frapvripa : codd.
fiapurdrT}
33 spir.in
ivap/i6yios] a eras. 4v supra lin. add. Mb fj re]
"7
1.26 API2T0EEN0T
30 Kotvbs tov tc hiarovov Kal tov xP"Wf0** " " trcpos IBios
TtjsapuovCas* KouHovei yap to. Wo y4vq t"v vapvvar"v. 15
ivapp.6vios i"v oiv iorl irapwirqira"ra fjfiapvripa Tr)s
27 PapvTarrjs xpMHWucfjs, xP(0tJljaTil^l
"^ Ka* bi"To\\vos r)Aotirif
Traa-a lUyjp1rrjsa^pitrp^vqs. TQv bi buxvTt\pATw to fxkv
intirqs
Kal kix"*vov
Trapvirarqs V701 foov t$ TrapVTrarrjs Kal
5 r)lkar\Tov,
fiekubelTai to Kal kix"vov t"
b% irapvirirrfs 20
kix"wovKal pAarrjs
Kal Icrov Kal tvicov
fyx^oW/xo?.tovWov
b' aVtiov Tb Kowas elvai tcls irapwriTas
t"v yev"v,yCyverai
10
yap %np*kh Terpd\opbov re x^M01"1**?* ('"fc)
4k Trapv\irdTr)s
Kal biardvov kixavovttjsovvTOVtoT"Trjs.
PapVTarr)s 'O 6e
I *"cwf"f
xp(a^aTlK}l "
l"rrirestituit Marquard
" " 4 rhs\robs sed
supra 0 ras. in qua a fuisse vid. Ma : robs V S, B
(sed ov in ras. et
a suprascr.) ot ex oh Mc : ov VS tov "Ko"c9"iyp4pov t6tcgo
kiX"w Ma, sed w supra tov, 00 supra tootieiciy/ievov et ov supra \ix"u"6i"
add. Mc : rbicta\ixdvaV S : r"rov (" suprascr.) \ix"*vov B 5 d']
yhp H 8 fxovov H 9 Zlrov6s Meibom : Sidroyfo codd.
in marg.) : fiapvr^pas
rivbs rrjs Tj/xiroyialas Taptnrdrrjs
ante add.
Marquard
H8I
APM0NIKX2N 2TOIXEIX2N a' I.27
rijsTrapvTrirqs ion
r"nos "f"avep6s iic t"v Ipflrpooticv,
buupefckre Kal ovvt"Oc\s 6Vos ioriv. \
tis]tis
rtfiflUrrr; aXm\ S tij om. B 16 ypafifidrotv
t"rjs S 17
ex l( ff Mc
4" fo V : ^e^y H
: dAA^Xoy post KtiffBu ponit H
19 od "y^" ^yov r" /i^Zfaxurtou9. 6. ie. "?.I. /AcAy8ei"r0cu ^(Tt^k
t^j ""*"v?)j
Marquard 5ri conieci : rod codcL /tj)seclusi 8vraT"K conieci :
S^Ka"r6cu codd. tiifois
B so yu"Xy5^"ra* conieci : /i"\(p9u"r$cu
codd. 24 8i^"ri"f]
81 in ras. Mb
119
1.28 API2T0EEN0T
iXarrov,iirlbe
ap.ek"abrJT(a fiapvt"v bvo bteae"ov Toviaiov
to
irpbs
tols [bk](buret iirC tc rd 6"i"ml t6 fiapv.
laroistcl
'Tttokc^o-^o)8" Kal robs rots t"rjs "f"06yyois oviufxovovvTas
bia ttjs avrrjs k"jsavrois tlvai. 'AovvOctov be 25
avfi\"l"(""vCas
VTTOKtbdoi h l#c(i(7T"j)y4v"ithai bi"orrjpja Kara pJ\ost"fj
5 n"k"abov"ra
"f"(t)vr] firjbfoarai biaipsiv efc biaarrjfjiaTa.'Yiro-
Keio-00)b% Kal tQv ovn"f)("\v"i)V Ikclotov fxrjbicup"i"r$ai efc 30
aaivOera irivra [xeylOr). 'Ayaoyr) b* 2otg" fj81a t"v k"fj$
"fr06yym" ("v),lorcaBcvtQv "Kpmv9["v]iv (Ik(""jtov) lica-
ripwOcva"ruv0"Tov KCtrai biAarqfxa' cvOela 8' ffiirlrb avr6.
ex rh Mc : rh V S crv(x"poavovvras ex rbs Mc
ovft"f"""vov : ovfup""vov
rbs V S : koI t" ovfifdvov rhs in marg; B 3 adrois Marquard :
avroTs codd. 4 ante t una litt.eras. M fjsupra lin. add. Mx :
om. V S ^ ante ^ add. B 5 0"i^] ^ in ras. Vb Htdtrrrifia
B sed in marg. Stafrift/uara 7 ircta-a supra lin. add. Mc : om. V S
8 S"v addidi tauQtv conieci t\u"0(v
codd.: conieci
bepcov : hfx*"v
codd. ""p seclusi : supra lin. B x*v "v et acc- ^ Mc Vb
m
1
2TOIXEIilN AETTEPON
tW ol p,"V VTTOKaX"(f"p6vOVV
TOV TTpdyfJLCLTOS
ol 8" KCLT"- 1 5
TC
lx"fjL"f"ovTO. oiv Th aVnov; ov Trporjb"o-av,
AAA' tio-ircp
fjfiels
(pafiev tt)v "po"vr}v KW"o-Qai Kal
kCvtio'iv "rux* ovx ""$
5 6' 17 TTpayfxareCa
| els bio,els T" ti\v okotjv Kal els tt\v bvir
voiav. rfjixev yap aKofjKpCvofiev ra raw biaarr\yArmv
ixeyidrj, bi buwolqdetopovfiev
rfj ras t"v ("f"06yya"v) Siwi/xeis.
10 Act oiv iireOio-Ofjvai Ijcaora |aKpifimKplveur. ov yap iorw
axriTtp M tQv biaypanii"T"i"v etdiorai \4y"O'0ac lora" rovro 20
25 pLovo-ucrjs
avayKaiov Kal iv tois irepl
to fjppioo-pAvov
"rvw-
"5
11.34 API2T0EEN0Y
Oto-Ofjvai
Trp" re bidvoiavkcu tt\v al"rOr\"ru"
Kak"t t6
KpCv"iv
30 T" \UvOVKCU TO *Airk"$ p"V 0$V "llF"lVTOWLVTrf
KL\VOV*fJL"V0V.
rk iortv ffhpjMOviKT) iiturnfjiAf]
Kkrf$"l"ra otav bukTjkvOapw
i1 aMfV buupdaOai d$
ovixp4f}riK" lurafxiprj.
\\
35 *X2i"i"rrlv$v p"v kcu irp"Tov rd biopUrax
ra yivq icot 5
"f"av"p6v,
Troirjcai tLv"v wore pevovroiv kclItCvmv ku"ovu4vo"v
5 al bia"f"opal
avrcu ylyvovrcu.Tovjroyap ovMs ir""vor"
buapurerp"irov two, eifcora)?*
ov yap iTTpayfiareiovro irepl
w bfo y"v"v,akka wept airrijs tt}$apfwvCas' ov fiifv akX9
IO oty"biaTp(^OVT"S TO. SpyOVabVQaO"VOVTO
TT"p\ | pkv kK"OTOV 10
t"v y"V"v,avrb 8e to wore ip\erail" ap\wvias yfi"pArt
ylyvto-Oai, ovbels ovb* eWj8A.o/re itditoT avr"v. ovrc yhp
Kara Ttu"rav \p6av iK"o-TOv t"v yev"v biyo-dApovro bia to
oiv
Ylp"Tov"ikv t"v p*p"v eWt to "tprjp.4vov btvrepov
$" TO TT"plbiaO-Trjp"TWVtllTUV,fM7jb"fllaV T"V VTTOp-
30 \ovv"v avrols bia"f"op"v eis bvvap.LVirapakipL\ir"vovra
2\"bov b4,a"s avk"s threw, al irktCovsavr"v eloiv "$"""-
pT]TQL. ov bel b' ayvoelv,6V1 Ka0* rjv av yev"pueOa t"v 25
u6
APM0NIKX2N 2TOIXEIJ2N 0' II.35
"K\ifnravov"T"v
re Kal adtMprjT"v
b(.a$op"v,
Kara Tairrqv
ayvorj"ron"v
11 ras ncktobovfUvois
iv biafopk.
tow 36
'Eircl"' iarlv ovk avripKr] ra dtacrny/utara irpbs rqv t"v
"\"06yyaw bi"yvGxnp irav yip,m ch-A"s d*n"wf bia\oTri-
"
5
T"\p0VT(io-"t9TLvistio-lV,
"0"JF"p ol TToXXol VTT0kafX^6,V0V(TLV, IO
TTpayfjiaT"V0fi4va"v. |
TcrapTov 6* hv ehj \iipos tcl o-vcrr^/utara Oecoprjcrat15
Troo-a t tori Kal not arra Kal tt"s Ik T" tQv btaarqiiAnov
Kal "f"06yy(ov aweary KOTa. Ovbfrcpovyap t"v TpoTtaw
15 reflceS/oijrai to pJpostovto wro |t"v ipTrpoarOwovre yap el 20
irivra TpimovIk t"v fttaorq/zaYaw avvriBerat.to, ovarr/paTa
Kal fi-qbefila tQv owOio-twv irapa tfrfoiv iarlv liri"rx^r"a"s
T"Hi\riK"V, oiB' at bia(f"opal navai vzr'ov- 25
tQv avarrifjLi\T"t)v
btvbs i$rjpCOfArjvTai. Yleplfikvyap ifx^kovsrj iKfxekovs
20 air\"a$ ovbiva \6yovireiroCrivTai. ol irpbfjfMov,
tQv fe avarr)-
127
11.37 API2T0EEN0T
5 bia\4y""r$ac
ov yap Tti.v\ra Ik t"v
rp6irov avr"v ypap.-
"rwTi$"ii4vri
Ix"tcov gvkkafiri
yiyverat,
akka iri"spJv,ttws
6' oi. 5
ml irivra rpoirov
mt/Kvaxns Ik/xcAt}? eV 5
4"o.\v*pbv
ixprjoros,
avrrjsiarai rrjsTrpaynareCas.
'Eireib% t"v ia-rltcl p"v airka tcl 8e fxc-
ix"k"abovp.iv"ov
T"f$o\a, ireplp."Taftokfj$ \zkt4ov,irp"Tov|pLtv avrb
hv elrj 10
IIcpl
6w3urr?7/Ltara. yap tovtoov ovbtls oibtvbs clprjrai
koyos 15
oir cLTrobeiKTUcbs
(At avaitobtiicros.
10 TeAevratoy Qxep"vlort) rb irtpl
5e t"v dvTrjs rrjs/ute-
koiroitas. 'E7relyap iv rots avrols "f"06y\yois ah tacpopois 20
toiovtov krj\j/"TaiT^kos.
"On b9 i{ari) rb "vvi"vat. t"v p."k"abovixiv"i)v
ttj re amy
ml ttjbiavoia Kara ita"av bia"f"opav
tois yiyvop.i\vois
irapa- 3"
KokovOeiv {brjkov) iv ywitrei "
yap bf)to fxtkos, mOdnrep
20 ml tcl Xoiira ixiprj Trjspjovo'iKjjs "
MACSAN K I39
11.39 API2T0EEN0T
5
AA 6^ rikq rrjs| appovLKtjs
tiv"$ itoiovvrat. ko\ov~
to Mb B
fx6v(f) ao (ncapxovcrav H : IvvTapxowr"vex
iwirapxAvTuv Ma avroTs supra lin.add. Mc 21 "i in ras. Mb
tih supra lin. add. Mc : om. V B in marg. 8t" 5' S
T""r"rdpov~\
33 " post vheloya add. Marquard ^] ^ R avvBeruy B
24 \6yvv S
130
U.4I API2T0EEN0T
"f"av"p6v
ri ipyov insotovrat avairakiv Ti$4a"rur iravrbsyap
10 ipyoviripas
6(f"6aXfjLO(f"avovs iorlv r)"6vz"n$. | rb yap eVi-
OTarovv itaai Kal Kplvovtovt lorf [rj] tcls {be) \elpasr)
rj to oro/uta r)rb %vev\ia
tt)v(poovrjv [rj]Saris oUrai Trok6 rt
13a
APM0NIKX2N 2TOIXEI"N p II.42
iinTelvovres
Kal avievres Kal reus "kkais airbus ivepyovvres*
"or elvai J "f"avep6v,
6Vt oibev bt,a"f"4pei
kiyeivto koX"s iv 15
TOls CLVkoiS TOV KCLK"S* OVK l""t d" TOVTO OVflfZaCveiV,
efaep
rt 6"f"ekos%v Trjsels Spyavovtov r]pp.ocr\xivov avayayrjs,
5 aAA' "pa t els \ tovs avkovs avrjyfiai rb p.ikos Kal evOvs 20
rov6J evpr^o-etv
to r)ppLOvp"vov iv avrofc btap.4vov re Kal rr)v
134
APM0NIKJ2N STOIXEI12N fl II.44
firjr
apx6fX"Voi, ivrbs
ai k"ixtttovt"$ irok \Xh tQv oUdrnv 20
airo\ifjLTriva"fi"V
15 irkelovselcrlirpbs
avfi(f"(iv(i"v SXXrjkabia"f"opal, fiCaris fj|
avr"v iKKciaOoo(Trpdrrj)'
yvooptfJLooT"TT] aUrqb9iarlv fjKara 5
pAytQos. *E"rra"br\t"v ovpL"f"""v"av
oktco fieyiOrj9 i\dxL(rT0V
pkv rb bia T""r"r(ipa)v"-"rvp.fiaiv"i
b\ tovto (avrfj) rfjtov
(jxi\ov$)^riJcrcii\"\i.oTov eTi/ar 077/moi/ 8" | rb peXipbtiv 10
flrol ex % t" Ma
(b?) 7 4k om. M V B R S 9 i"rr\v post
iiwmiix"Tuv ponit H post itrrl una litt.eras., vid. fuisse itrrlv M
ia Siatpdywy ex Ma
tiatyopvv 13 ^ ante r$ add. H 14 iravrbs
om. et fuydOci ante Sto^vou ponit H 5pa Iloptyvpiov4v rep els
'Apfiovuca in marg. H
rod TlroKcpaiovforofuriifiari 16 wpx"rri
restituit Marquard,sed ante iiacetffOu
ponit 18 avfifi4firiK"
5^ H
adrj)restituit Westphal tJ om. B tow B : outou M V S R :
a"rov H 19 pe\ovs restituitWestphal ao vote* om. R
33 B
Ai/^ fiiffoav ^crraiH : cTvourell. post cTvoiadd. \4yofiev
Marquard 8* restituit Marquard 33 "rwre$bf H
135
11.45 API2TOEENOT
Toriroav
ava pAaovbiiufxava lorai. Tavra p.ev oiv kiyofxev
a napa t"v ifXTTpoa-Oev irapeikricpaixev,ire pi be rdv konr"v
TTJSOVv04"T""i)$ ytyV"T"U*
(TVp(f)C0VOV TOLS be TTp"TOlS CTVjUt-
(fx"vois ov (TVfxfiaLveitovto, ovt" yap to laov *Kar4p"*"
rb Ik t$"v elprfpJvaiV
bia"pu)vri"rei ovyKeCpievov.
oi}fA"f"("v(av
46 ToVos 6' iorlv $ to dia Ttivre11tov bia T""r"rapa"i"
pL"i"ov
to Tecciptov
be bia bv*o tovoov Kal r^ilo-eos. T"v be tov
t6vov \xepQ"v fteAwdctrai to o KakeiTai tjplltoviov,Kal 15
rjfuov,
5 to Tpbrovp.ipos, | o icaXeirat blecis xpoaimriKri kkaylor-q,
Kal to T^TapTOVt o KakeiTai bCeais ivapp.6vto$ iXaxtorrr
tovtov 6' ikarrov oibev p.ek^bevraL bi"orrjixa. Act 8e
10 TtpitiTov
p.ev tovto airb /uitjayvoelv,art | -TroXAoirjbrj birj-
Haprov vTrokaf}6vre$ fjfmskiyew Sti 6 tovos eh (rpla^) 20
Tiaa-apa faa biaipov*iievo$ fxektobeiTai. awifiriV atrrols
tovto irapa rd /uw)Karavoelv Sri irepovlori kafielv to T"
15 t6vov Kal to
Tptrov[i^pos biekovra eh Tplat6vov piektobeiv.
etvai Sioottj/uuz
iitevraairk"s p.ev ovOev virokapLp"vofiev
ikA.yj,vrov. 25
I "?" H
fi4(T(oy cTrai \ey6fxcv.
tiukfwva Tavra fiivoZv irapk
Marquard (8.". \ey6pevar. /". o. it. Porphyrius) i"rrai H : ctvai
rell. 3 /Ay supra lin. add. Mb 4 t$] rb S H B in marg.
5 iroctircu H peyedovspost ft.ci(ovos
7 add. H ytyv4ficvov
Marquard : \ey6fxevov
codd. : ywoptvov Porphyrius 9 od supra
lin.add. Mb ircC0os
post touto add. H n Sis rcOtvros post
afc-a? add. Meibom del Jm^coHjo-ft] M V B S : ^
^ 8ia"p"i"vn"ris
R
$ia"pd"vr)(ris 13 tow]kccIR 14 tifxUwsB H 17 #coi
. . . iXayifrrfi
om. H ftR : om. rell. 20 {rwo\a06vT"$ex
irwoXa"dvrasMb tpfe^ restituit Marquard ai o^toTj post
tovto ponitH 94 lirciO'
av\"s S
136
APM0NIKX2N 2TOIXEIX2N ft II.46,
cdrrr\M V B S : ctfrHjj
R 8i y 91 in ras.
fiapvrdrri Mb ^ om. S
io jraTfarttrtys
restituit Marquard n tXarrov Mc in marg. B :
137
11.47 APISTOEENOT
rh 6v6fxarakwsZv /utijfeeYi
Kakovvras ki\avovs ras ko lira's,
iircvbav f\blrovos {ki\avbs)
KkrjOfjrj twv tikkcovfiCarjris
20 ttotoiv. hew yap | tripovs
"ivai "f"06yyov$
rovs to Irepov
pJyeOos6pl(ovrarwo-atJrcosb" beiv tyeivKal rh avri-
olroi H
6 TotoCror) ^Ae'x^crfu'] ^ in ras. Mc (?) 9 xa/Jov^rijs
ex Mb
irapairf)T7)v 10 8' post ircUiy add. H 11 irapvirttTifs]
vt("t^sR dir^T^s]
ia H t^rris13 a^rMi/ supra lin. add.
corr. B 14 tvt rb conieci : iv r$ codd. 15 9icurrn/idrwv H
17 oko\ov0"iv Bcriov conieci : aKo\ovdrrr4ov codd. 18 "/ *ai] ical
om. H 4\drro(riyS 19 (nriitrufiev M V S B ao 8ci}"r"(/Ac0a]
ij"T(Jin ras. Vb ai Tt/xvfrcu post ro/tctjponit H "s
a\7i6us . tiicup4"rcwy
. . legg. in codd. post $ia/j.4v"iv
in p. 140, 1. 1 :
ordinem mutavi aa Mc
trpovBuro ttpovBoiro xpoaBolro
ex : V B S
hy^nr^itroinav B
(vsuprascr.)
138
11.49 API2T0EEN0T
biaa-rrjfjAToov
Spovsavayicaiov elirelvtovs ovtovs* KaOoXov
8' dirciv,eW ia" fi4vrjra t"v TrepiexpvToav ovoyxura Kal
livKvbv 8e
AeyeV"opi\pirofcov eW ftv iv Terpaxppby15
biJa.
T""r"rapwv ovp,"jxavov,vTa)v t"v "Kpa)v tcl bvo biaorrjpLaTa
del.Marquard iv add. Mb
ivapfuwiov] restituit
17 ticaripa
Marquard (lac.
a syllab.
R) 19 t(Jvos
post cTvatponit H ao Stal-
15 KaTavorjo-euv, el TrapvTriTrjv
\ pikvk"fioirqv tov poXaKov
a avrrjs Marquard : ahrris codd. 8 Ziar6vov
Hialpctris
H 9 olv om. R 10 ante yfjuTovicuov 5 fere litt.eras,
M
(vid.xpw/ta fuisse) i"m om. R ia icalin marg. Mc : om.
rell. 13 tovuuov ex Ma
Tjfjuroviaiwv roviai6v post iicArcpoir
ponit H l|
14 r4rrap"s
.
in marg.
. .
Mb : om. R 15 #"ra*
ex 8"ra Ma 16 -Kapwdrou fc Wrropciseclusit Marquard vapv-
B : irapxnca (t'suprascr.)
irdrris S tvciv M : 8uo*i/V S 19 ftfa
H : Wios rell ai r$ TrapinrdTTis
om. R 23 "f"avepbv . . .
Ziar6vw restituitWestphal
142
APM0NIKX2N 2TOIXEIX2N ^ 11.5a
M3
11.53 API2T0HEN0Y
fxkvoiv aKpi/Br}
\6yovtov oiim pqbiov
"$fjs airobovvcu,loas
airobodwo-w
ta" al ovvOeo-eist"v biaorrjixiTaiV 6Vi b9 l"rri
20 n k"rjs kcu T$ Travrek"s cnreCpv"f)avepbvyevovfhv \ bia
rouxcrbd tivos YliOavbv
iirayooyfjs. yap to clvcu
fxrjbev
bida-TrjfjLa " fie\(^bovvres els iireipa rifivofiev, dAA.' etvai 5
elprjue'vovs
apiQpxybs avveo-Tdvai.,
iKfie\"sto, ovarrjixaTa
macran L 145
11.55 API2T0EEN0T
1 elrci]
ffrf a Htr* M B : eh* iv\ in marg. B : elfr M S rb
Biaircvrc]
rb supra lin.add. Mb 4 "p"6yyos MVS rb del. Meibom
7 ante a"paip"07)
una litt. eras. M : at in ras. Mc : c in ras. Mb
MVS:
8 cupripelffdu ^"p^fft\ffd"oBR 9 rod]rrjsH 8ia restituit
Marquard 11 Zir6vov\
post 1 litt a eras. M : Biar6vov B ia yap
om. B
Spoi]01 in ras. Mb : bpOolR, B in marg. 15 ctra . - .
restituit Meibom
recrffdpofv rbv Meibom:
17 rb codd. 18 tV
restituit Meibom 19 H
o-v/x"p(vvovs 5ta in ras.
hi"L"po"vov] Mb
34 titrovovMeibom : cvfupwyov codd.
146
11.57 API2T0HEN0T APM0NIK12N 2T0IXEmN p
148
API2TOHENOT APMONlKnN
2TOIXEIX1N r
3-4 5rav . . .
tnav " re, r* to* supra lin. add.,re con*, in Svo,
Svo]erat
et re inscr.,reliquain marg. Mc
: om. V B, R (sed'postea alieno loco
2-5 Arc pro trav StJoleg.,ifis
'
interponuntur v. Herwerden)
. . . crxntxa om. S 5 ir6repov om. H 7 rcraproi B : 8 rell.
evpp"vtovtyres H 9 $6i Meibom :ri codd. 12 rciJepost
add. H
i"r}s 14 fUvovMc R
(supra lin.), H : tpovMBS rp"*ov\
rpi"w e corr. V xarh, om. H 8* ei Marquard : 5" codd.
16 $))H : $" rell. roiovr6v B 17 "tv(Tt^iuito "n/"rr^/ia
ex
Mb
M9
III.59 API2T0HEN0T
30 "v ffToi
tovos ava iorlv r)oi
|jiicov opoi iiraXXiTTOvortv,
"ot" k"fj$
ret ofjLOca8vra r)
T"Tpd\opba ovvrjixixiva
hvayKaiov
etvai rj 8ie"evy/x"a.""afikv8" belv t"v k$r}$
TtTpaxppbcov
60 tJtoi "?||rai
hirk"s firjbev ava fiivovT"Tpa\opbovrj fir)15
avofioiov. p"v ovv ofiolmv
t"v kot etbosTerpaxppboov
oi
tCSctcliav6fioiov ava fiicovTtrpaxopfoov, t"v b9 avofioConv
rcfliyo-erai.
J
10 9Aoiiv0"TOV b9 iorl
biAarrffia
to virb t"v i"r}s"t"06yy"av
TT"piex6fi"vov.cJ yap k"r)s
ol TrcpUxovres, ovbeisIjcAijuwrdi/ei,
fir)iKkiinr"v"v b9 ovk ip.ir"o-"iTcu, b9 ov biai-
fir)ifnrCirraiv
15 b fe fir)biaCpeo-iv
prjo-ci, !xe*"^^ cvvOto-w \ ifcv irav yap 25
1 clalvin ras. Ma : om. V B S twaWdrTovffiv ex iir"\arrov(riv Mb
(lit
vid.) a naif . . . Uposrestituit Meibom 3 b^vrcpov B
. 4 tyvripov
om. B 6 Marquard :
rpStrtav 6pwv B : Spar rell.
Koivwvovcriv H 7 Meibom
lipoid codd.
: iivSfioia i"rriw om. H
11 H/moia2 litt.eras. M
ante roiavraMarquard: ravra codd.
ovfifiaiveiB 13 ff\
IjroiH Meibom : c/ /*^e/ /*^B :
15 fjfify
c/ /i^rell. 16 ikv6fioiov
Meibom : codd.
Sfioiov 17 ri6c"r$cuH
"v6fxoiov Meibom : Zfxoiovcodd. 17 r"v 5* rerpdxopSor
. . .
150
APM0NIKX2N 2T01XEIX2N y III.60
ponit Meibom
rfTpaxdptovpost fipfjLOffp4vov ao rwv rod $i" addidit
Westphal ai H
fx6vov aovvdcrw seclusi 33 fy*1
Meibom : *x0'codd. irapa ravra}irapa post ravra eras, et supra
lin. add. Mc ravra irapa V B S rb supra lin.add. Mb (?)
151
III.6I API2T0EEN0T
TOVOV d"uT"pO$
1t"pie)(6vT"jW T"V TO T"Tpd\opboV 1T"pLe)(6vT(i"V
to fiapvrtpov t"v iv Tjjbia(eu""i Ktcfiivodv [6fu"((""$
8']rjv5
(8s) [koI]
obros aidprjTos ip rals t"p yev"v bia"f"opais* 6 b9 [
Xovres aKlvrjTol
d"nv iv reus t"v brjkovStl
ycv"vbia"f"opai$9
kefaroiT av avra ra tov 8ta Ttcrcr"fxov
piprjfwva KivticrQax
iv tclis dprjfjUvacs
buufropaZs.
||
62 9Ev "K"ioT"t) Too-avrd iorw
bk yivei {to)Trkciora "ovv0"Ta
oca iv T"p 8ta tt4vt". Ylav jikvyap yivosrJTOi iv ouvaQfj 15
a ro7s om. V B S
3 rbv restituit Marquard 4 r6voov
BR 5 irepiextvTwppost fiapvrcpov ponit H dpolcos* et teal
5
seclusit,et B* addidit Westphal 7 rhv restituit Marquard
fiapfrrcpos ircpiex^vTay
" .
in marg. Mc:
. om. VB : r6vov ircpicx"tn-w
T"cro-"p(i"v
ovp."fxovovvT(av
avayKaiov iv KeiaSai
p,4ir"p to
om. R 18 B,
sed in marg.
fiapvrepos fiapinaros 20 K"t"rOcu
om., et efrcu post Zirovov add. H ri] rfcyVS Si om. S post
jca} add. "/ rp "rwatpyin marg. Mc, rjj (rwacpfj R r5 ante 5tctreo-edpoov
add. H ai post t" litt.v eras. M : rbv V S B
153
III.63 API2T0EEN0T
TlOeaOai.
'Ev bk
apfwvCa Kal xp^ari bio toviala k$r}s
ov TeOrjo-erai.
154
III.65 API2T0EEN0T
Icrrcutov
p"v ovv lKfjL"\rj$ fj6i"n$.
fjfxiToviatov iav b9 iirl
TO 6$ T"$rjTOVVTT"pXOVTOSj "n"Ol,"OT" bij\0V"TL
XP^tjLCL
iv biarovv bvo fjfAiToviata ov k"rj$.Ilota fxev \
T"$rj"rerai "
1 M V
^/i/tcA^r B rod post y ponit H
r)p.iTovialov 5 tivv"fkeva.
M H : Bvrdfxfda
rell. 6 $" om. R 8 rb
lin. rb
fiaph] supra
add Mc (?): om. S Kal M icai iirlrb ofr ponit H
rb fiapbpost
10 Zri H : om. rell. 12 r$ ante add. R iir6vtp
13 rb om. B
"Tv^j8^(T"Tot] fifoercu in ras. Ma 15 dpifa S 17 avr^v supra
lin. add. B vticvb.B 18 r6vov Meibom : rovrov codd.
Zirovialov iKfiekij ex Sitovicuov iKfie\^s Mc : Strovtcuov 4kjul"\^s VSB
21 ixl supra lin. add. B rb airrb post xd\tv ponit H 22 avr^y
in marg. add. B tcotcTtcu post f"aptiraros ponitH 24 t6vov
Meibom : rovrov codd.
156
APM0NIK12N 2TOIXEIX2N / 111.66
'Er
hiarovtp b\ tovov e^'iKarcpatjixltoviovov /ziAadttrat.
*2viiprj"r"Taiyap |pyre tovs T"T"prov$ t"v ""fjsbta rctro-apaw 20
p.rJT"
"rvix"f"a)V"Xv tovs 8uz irivre. Av*o 8" tov"ov
TripLTTrovs
rj Tpi"v fjfXLToviov i"ffl/carcpa/leA^detrai* ovp,(fxavrio'Ovo'L
5 yap 77 01 riraproL ^ oi irifiTTTOi
81a r"(r"n"[/)a)z" 81a irivre. 25
['A-7TOTjflLTOvCoV p"V "TtIT" 6"v bvo 6bol KCU M T"" ficLpV
bvo,}oltto be tov bvrovov bio ph" iirlto 6"v,fiCa 8' iirlto
fiapv. Aibeucrcu yap iirl p"v rb | d"v ttvkvov TcOeiiAevov 3"
""fj$
ov "ore brjXovon
TlSerat, fxovai bio obol lowrat airb
157
III.67 API2T0EEN0T
158
"3I"
APMONIKGN 2TOIXEIGN y' 111.68
a iKeXtol]
ante X litt 7 eras" M : ^hx9^ V B 6 ** deI"
Marquard "s del. Meibom 7 neyeOciH
Kanfldvctv 8 rabrh
in marg. B, R : avrb relL 10 t" Marquard : 5i codd. 11 rod
om. H ia ylvcrcu(m in ras.)M 8c? 7^ skoxttov
13
Meibom : ffi"7^Ikoattov codd. 14 ante ko^ ras. M vcir^paffTai
(xc in ras., fuisse vid. KaOdtrtp ttpaarai)M : xcirtparai R : T"JT"pa"r0at H
15 t" Marquard : 7c codd. conieci codd. dSol quard
Mar-
jj : cJ ao at
158
Digitized
by
APMONIKGN 2TOIXEIGN / 111.68
peyiOrj cti/ai
(paCvovrcu tov re |axratJrws. Upbs br)20
ttvkvov
5 or/m^o-erat
"T"\pavt"v 6b"v iirupapcyidrf kapfiiveiv
kcu 25
t"v airb tov bvr6vov [6']
["$]" t6 t" yap tolovtov
axravra"y
olov t6 p.4vrjs
bi"orrjfjLa kclIki%cLvovaVetpa Xapfiavu p."yiOr\
TO T" TOIOVTOV olov \ T" TTVKvbv TOVrb ItivyjU TT"0OS T^ ""
tfnrpoo-Oev elprjphfdtaarq/xart,akk' o/ma"? ovbev rjrrovair6
10 T" tov yCyvovrai
ttvkvov obol iirlto ftapvxai airb tov
bio
biTovov iirl rd 6"6,ghtclvtw 8e Kal airb tov t6vov pia
yCyvcTCLt licaVepa
i"j"* ob6s. \\KaO9 iKdorrjv yap yj"6av i"fS 69
IkcTotovy4vovsXtjttt4ov iorl ras dbovs* 8et yhp licaoroy
Ka0* b TT"Tr4paarai
t"v iv rfjfJLOv"LKfj Kara tovto TiOivai
airlal at ovvap"f"6T"pai.
oboC,tt}$StafctJfccoy.^Ort 8' iv
159
III.69 API2T0HEN0T
1 iTix*ipfi
ex Mc (?)
i-Kixcip*? rell.
: ixtxttptt 7 tvkvov fiipos]
V S in marg. B
wvKPotfjLcvos R
1jti]Ijroi 9 6pi(ovrcs Mar-
quard : hiopi(ovres
codd. Movrat post \6yovponit H io t6vov~\
r6vov R 11 rov ante ttvkvov add. R 12 rb supra lin. add.
Mc V B S
: om. \oixoov S Marquard
fiapirnpos : fiaadraros
codd.
in
btvraros marg. add. B 13 6 b* add. Mc : om. VBS 6^vr"oos
Marquard btfnaros codd.
: 14 iuruvOtra R : arfoBerarell. 15 "?]
r"v B S, B (sed fitrcx^ m marg")
/x"t4x*l* J6 8f}W . . .
160
III.71 API2T0HEN0T
"pB"YYavM""rovcodd.
Marquard : rav tlpniiiivoov 8 r"v r factor
conieci : t" t6t"pcodd. dh coniecit Meibom M fc ante Ty, et
abrf ante r6xcfadd. Marquard 10 avr^v ""rr" om. R " . .
Meibom:
fj.4"rcp pevovcodd. "vt" Marquard : ^scodjd. 11 ""r)s
rldcadat] ifisH
yiveaBat 5' Marquard : 8^ codd. ia fiiasupra
lin. add. corr. B 13 rov restituit Meibom
fiapvrdrov 15 ""rr"u
ante ponit H
4"p*liedrcpa 18 riB4"rd"a . . . tV aMiv rdtraf in
marg. S H : om.
6 (anteffaptraros) rell. ao ^KfxtXh']
t/xfickks
M VB 21 M r)iv .
addidi
bvopoiovs
. . 33 $' om. B "6-
potot Marquard : codd.
Zpoioi
162
APMONIKGN 2T0IXEIGN / m.72
t""t"(o$
avrrjs
Trjs KOivtovrjo-ovo-r
ipifiek"s rpeis yap avayKaxov
bUo*"is i"v
Tl\0c"rOcu t"rj$, re fZapurarosiiv r S^Hraros25
t6,"T"o"$.
ttjsavrrjs/uterdcrxj?
r$ /xeV"j"
"Ort 8e rb bidWovov otJyiceirai
rjroi in bvow rj rpi"v r) "
Tplalorat p.eyiOr)
i" "v rb biarovov yivos awearrjKbs
lorai,t6 t lAarror Kal t6vos
r)p.iTo\viov Kal rb pd(ov 10
15 tovow iav bi iravTCLTa tov bia tt4vt"p.eyi"q
"vi"rayivrjrai,
riaaapa lorai p,"yiOrj {i""v) to dprjpiivov yivoslorat
ovv"ot7)k6s. "X2ot' etvai "j"avepbv ori rb bub.Tovov| tjtoi 15
in bvout i)Tpt"vr)T"o-"rdpa"v aovvdirtov"rtfyK"rai.
"On bi {to)XP"pa Kal i)appovCatJtol in Tpi"v rj in
20 T"o-o-"pa"v oiiyKciTai, bcucriov. *Ovt""v b\ t"v pikv{tov)
bta tt4vt" aovv\6iT"av reo-o-apaw tov aptOpbviav p"v to. 2o
tov ttvkvov fjjprjlara jj, TpCalorai fxeyi"q i" "v ra elpxj-
pJva yivr\ovvwrriKOTa lorai,to re tov ttvkvov pApos8
Ti b\v rjKal tovos Kal to tolovtov oXov p.icrr\s Kal | ki\avov25
25 SidoTTj/uta. iav bk to. tov ttvkvov pApr\ivwa jj, Tiaaapa
1 B
Koirf)(rov"Ti 3 rdcrtoosin marg. B : arrdtrewsrell. 4 Ijroi]
^ rb H Hvoiv ^ rpi"v Meibom codd.
: rpi"v % tivcliv 5 farivBerov
MVBS 6 bavvQerov H 7 #"ra restituit Meibom 9 rb
8% rdraprov "vktov rovro " 8^ ytyuercu Marquard : rb 8^ tffovytyrircu
codd. (nisiquod ycvrjTat om. H) 10 Siarivy ora. R 14 f}fiir6viov
MVBS 16 ficyddeiH ^{ Sv restituit Meursius 18 Hvo?v
Marquard : 5uo codd. 19 rb restituit Marquard " ante r*"r"rdpwv
om. VBS ao 8i]yu^yo2v H tow restituit Marquard 21 rov
M 2 163
III.73 API2T0HEN0T APM0NIKX2N 2TOIXEI12N y
avvrlBerai wore.
10 Mcra \"kt4ov tL Iotl Kal | irola tis fj Kar
be Tavra
ethosbiacpopdbia(f"4p"i
6' 7jp.lv
ovbev elbos \iyeiv
"
rjo-xfjfia,
"f"epop.ev
yap oW/mara ravra iirl to avro.
auxf"0Tepa
tcl
164
THE ELEMENTS OF HARMONY
BY ARISTOXENUS
BOOK I1
165
ARISTOXENUS
ignored,and
absolutely in dealingwith them we shall be
167
ARISTOXENUS
previous
treatment of them worth mentioning.
5 Intervals,first simple and then compound, will next
with melody.
We have now set forth the nature and number of the
employed in singing.
It is evident that the voice must in
singingproducethe
tensions and relaxations inaudibly, and that the pointsof
pitchalone must be audiblyenunciated. This is clear from
the fact that the voice must pass imperceptiblythroughthe
compass of the interval which it traverses in ascendingor
descending,while the notes that bound the intervals must
be audible and stationary.Hence it is needful to discuss
tension and relaxation,
and in addition height and depth of
pitch,and finally
pitchin general.
Tension is the continuous transitionof the voice from a
lower position
to a higher,relaxation that from a higherto
a lower. Height of pitch is the result of tension,
depth
the result of relaxation. On a consideration of
superficial
these questionsitmightappear that we distinguish
surprising
four phenomena here instead of two, and in fact it is usual
to identifyheightof pitchwith tension,and depth of pitch
11 with relaxation. Hence we may perhaps with advantage
observe that the usual view implies
a confusion of
thought.
In doingso we must endeavour to understand,by observing
the phenomenon itself,what precisely takes placewhen in
sistence,
as it were, or stationary of the voice.
position
And let us not be alarmed by the theory which reduces
notes to motions and asserts generalto be a
sound in
motion,as though our definition involved the proposition
that under certain circumstances motion will,instead of
moving, be stationary
and at rest. The definition of pitch
as a certain condition of motion " call it 'equability*
or
will not affect our position. We shall none the less describe
the voice as stationary when our senses assure us that it is
neither ascending nor descending, simplyfixingon this
term as of such
descriptive a of the voice without any
state
*
stationary
on the note. Now if we use the term '
motion
'
and say '
the voice moves in cases where, accordingto the
it undergoes
theory,
physical a changein the rate of motion ;
' * ' '
and if,
again,
we use and say the voice rests
the term rest
the discriminate,
ear any interval smaller than the smallest
so as to determine what fraction itis of a diesis or of
diesis,
any other of the known intervals. In the progress in
magnitudinemthe power of the ear may perhapsbe con-
sidered
diminution. Whether,regarding
infinitesimal the constitution
of melody in abstract,
thewe are bound to admit such an
infiniteprogress, isa questiondemandinga differentmethod
of reasoningnot required for our present purpose, and we
shall accordingly
reserve itsdiscussion for a lateroccasion.
i75
ARISTOXENUS
questionof distance on
The the line of pitchbeing
disposedof,we shall proceed to define a note. Briefly,
it is the incidence of the voice upon one pointof pitch.
Whenever the voice is heard to remain stationary
on one
melody.
An interval,on the other hand, is the distance bounded
by two notes which have not the same pitch. For,roughly
speaking, an interval is a difference between pointsof pitch,
a space potentiallyadmitting notes higher than the lower of
the two pointsof pitchwhich bound the interval, and lower
than the higherof them. A difference between pointsof
supplied
a mere outline without as the details.
yet reviewing
Our next step willbe to enumerate the genera into which
That
variation of genus arises throughthe raisingand
loweringof the movable notes is obvious ; but the locus
of the variation of these notes requiresdiscussion. The
locus of the variation of the Lichanus is a tone, for this
note is never nearer the Mese than the intervalof a tone,
and never further from it than the interval of two tones.
or whether
of any lower intervals, it is incommensurable
is givenin my chapteron ' Intervals ascer-
with them all, tained
by the of Concord.'
principle Here we shall assume
that itsapparent value is correct,and that it consists of two
x
and a half tones. Again,we shall applythe term Pycnum
to the combination of two the
intervals, sum of which is
less than the complement that makes up the Fourth. Let
us now, from trje lower of
starting the two fixed notes,
take the least Pycnum : it will consist of the two least
enharmonic dieses; while a second Pycnum, taken from
the same note, will consist of two of the least chromatic
dieses. This givesthe two lowest Lichani of two
genera "
throughout.
186
BOOK II
It willbe well
perhapsto review in anticipation the course 30. 10
relate,
of most of the audience that attended Plato'slectures
on the Good. They came, he used to say, every one of
them, in the conviction they that would get from the
lectures some one or other of the things
that the world calls
good ; riches or health,or strength, in fine,some ordinary
extra-
no importance,and actually
preferto remain totallyun-
acquainted
we endeavour
supplyproofsthat willbe in agreement with
to
accuracy of
sense-perception is a fundamental requirement.
For if his sense-perception is deficient,it is impossible for
him to deal successfully with those questions that lieoutside
the sphereof sense-perception altogether. This willbecome
clear in the course of our investigation. And we must bear
in mind that musical cognition impliesthe simultaneous \
cognition of a permanent and of a changeable element,and
that this applies without limitation or qualification to every
189
ARISTOXENUS
supplythis deficiency
if we are to follow the differences
that presentthemselves in works of musical composition.
Such is the firstbranch of Harmonic. In the second we
to the best of
shall deal with intervals,omitting, our ability,
none of the distinctionsto be found in them. The majority
of these,one might say, have as yet escapedobservation.
But we must bear in mind that wherever we come upon a
tion,
that an interval canpossess is common to several
musical functions " the .third part of our science will deal
with notes, their number, and
recognizing the means of
them; and will consider the questionwhether they are
certain pointsof pitch, as is vulgarlysupposed,or whether
theyare musical functions, and also what is the meaning of
'
a musical function/ Not one of these questions is clearly
conceived by students of the subject
The fourth part will consider scales, firstlyas to their
jis
past In no other way can we followthe phenomena of
{music.
Now some goalof the science called Harmonic
find the
in the notation of melodies,
declaring this to be the ultimate
limit of the apprehension of any given melody* Others
activity
as the consummation of intellectualapprehension
;
for,as a the ultimate factor in every visible activity
fact, is /
the intellectualprocess. For this latteris the and
presiding 1
*
determining ; and
principle as for the hands,voice,mouth,
or breath " it is an error to suppose that theyare very much
more than inanimate instruments. And if this intellectual
is somethinghidden deep down in the soul,and is
activity
not palpableor apparent to the ordinaryman, as the
operations of the hand and the like are apparent,we must
not on that account alter our views. We shall be sure to
miss the truth unless placethe supreme and ultimate,
we not
in the thingdetermined, that determines.
but in the activity
No less preposterous is the above-mentioned theory
o 2 195
ARISTOXENUS
and immutable
eternally order " this is sheer folly.For 43
as there isharmony in the strings
no save that which the
cunningof the hand confers upon them, so is there none in
the finger-holes
save what has been introduced by the same
if it were
supposed that harmony should be based on some
[sense-perception
as one of the primarytruths of Harmonic
JForwhat requires
science. demonstration cannot stand as
; and in generalwe
[afundamental principle must be watch-
iful ^determining
our highestprinciples,lest on the one
hand we let ourselves be draggedoutside the proper track
the sum is a concord. But this is not the case with thfe
"two smallest concords. For the doublingof a Fourth or
is peculiar
to the Enharmonic genus, while the Diatonic
and Chromatic between them employ three. Of the in-
tervals
in the tetrachord,
that between the Hypate and
Parhypatemay be equal to that between the Parhypate
and Lichanus,or less than it,but never greater. That it
condition
indispensable of the melodious collocation of
intervals. Whatever be the genus, from whatever note one 54
lation of which is
destructiveof harmony. A law,in some
holds with regardto the relative position
respectssimilar,
of tetrachords. If any two tetrachords are belong to
to
208
ARISTOXENUS
be similar,
onlyon condition,however, that the separating
interval is one tone. Thus we are led to conclude that two
similartetrachords are if theyare either separated
successive,
by a tone, or if their boundaries coincide. Consequently
similar successive tetrachords are either conjunctor dis-
junct
undergochange.
All harmonious scales
consisting
of more than one tetra-
chord were divided into conjunct
and disjunct. But conjunct
scales are composed of the simpleparts of the Fourth alone,
so that here at least itwill be the partsof the Fourth alone
that will undergochange. Again,disjunct scales comprise
besides these parts of the 'Fourth a tone peculiarto disjunc-
tion*
If then it be proved that this particular tone does
not alter with variation of genus, evidently the change can
affect onlythe parts of the Fourth. Now the lower of the
.
notes containing the tone is the higherof the notes con-
taining
melodious.
The lowerofthe notes containing the ditone is the highest
note ofa Pycnum^ and the higherofthe notes containing the
ditone is the lowest note ofa Pycnum.
For as the Pycna in conjuncttetrachords form Fourths
with one another, the ditone must lie between them;
since
similarly the ditones form Fourths with one another,
the Pycnum must lie between them. It follows that the
Pycnum and the ditone must succeed one another ately.
altern-
Therefore it is evident that of the notes containing
the ditone,the lower will be the highest
note of the Pycnum
is satisfied,
it must be unmelodious. But that
neither of them will be
is clear. For
satisfied, if it be
tones is impossible.
In the Diatonic genus three consecutive
tones are permitted
;
order.
A ditone can be followedbyascending
a tone
scale in the
only. For suppose such a succession in the descending
66 order. The result will be that the highest
and the lowest
note of a Pycnum will (allon the same pitch. For we saw
214
THE ELEMENTS OF HARMONY
that the note that forms the lower boundaryof the ditone
was the
highestnote of a Pycnum, and that the note that
forms the upper boundaryof the tone was the lowest note
of a Pycnum. But if these notes fall on the one pitch,
it follows that there is a succession of two Pycna. As this
latter succession is unmelodious, a tone below
immediately
a ditone must be
equallyso.
possible
progression
upwards,to the ditone.
From the tone thereisbut progressionin eitherdirection :
one
70 nus. The case of notes that bound the partsof the Pycnum
requires no proof;itis immediately evident that theypartici-
pate
in the Pycnum. And we provedalready that the notes
containing the tone are both the lowest notes of a Pycnum ;
we showed also that the lower of the notes containing the
remaininginterval was the highestof a Pycnum, and the
higherof them the lowest of a Pycnum. Now as these are
the onlysimpleintervals, and each of them is contained by
notes both of which participate in the Pycnum, it follows
that every note in the Chromatic and Enharmonic genus
in the Pycnum.
participates
One will readily
see of the notes situated
that the positions
in thePycnum are number^ since,as we know, a
three in
Pycnum cannot be followed by another Pycnum or part of
one. For it is evident in consequence of this latter law,
that the number of the said notes is so limited.
// is required
to prove that from the lowest onlyofthe notes
downwards, one
progressions to the tone, and one to the
was proved that from a Pycnum there is but one pro- gression
upwards. But to say that there is one progression
upwards from the Pycnum is (forthe reason givenin the
former proposition) the same as saying that there is but
of three dieses.
It is requiredto prove that the Diatonic genus is composed
aaa
NOTES
Disjunction.
Disjunction.
divergesinto and
Similarly
at the descendingmelodic progression
avtrrqfiaTOS,
1. 22. The questionhere raised is one of great importance.
Are there any affinitiesbetween scales and keys ? By scales we
mean so many series of notes in which abstraction is made of
pitchand regard is had solelyto the order of intervals. By
keys we mean so many series of notes, in which the intervals
and their order are identical,while each series is situated at
a different pitch
from every other.
See Introduction A, " 22.
P. 101, 1. 1. Aristoxenus here contrasts two by
principles
329
ARISTOXENUS
Lydian
Phrygian
Dorian
Hypolydiam
Hypophrygian
Hypodorian
indirectly from any one to any other. (See note on p. 129, L 4.)
Once more let us again take the same seven enharmonic
modes, but changingthe keys let us arrange them as follows :
Tonic
MlXOLYDIAN
Lydian
Phrygian
Dorian
Hypolydian
Hypophrygian
Hypodorian
3e"
J.
that
quarter-tones, a modulation from one to another of them is
impossible.(See note p. 129, 1. 4.) on *
principle intermodulation
of possible ; the second onprin-
ciple the
of KciTairvKvaxris, or arrangement at the closest possible
intervals. It is obvious that the former is the true of
principle
music. The unbroken series of small intervals may satisfy
the eye, but to use the words of Aristoxenus [p.129, 1. 1]it is
"Kfi"\r)s
km navra axprforos, that is,at variance with the
rp6itov
nature of melody which forbids a succession of more than two
1.3. yhp hv
Probably5"rq" . . . noirja-a^v, the readingof B and
R, is right.
1.16. emraa-is and signify
averts the processes
',not the states,
of tension and relaxation. Though properly applyingonly to
strings,
they are used of the human
metaphorically voice and
the sounds of wind-instruments.
P. 104, 1. 14. eV! t6v ivavriovr6novythe readingof B, is un-
doubtedly
fiapvTcpov irpbs
to 6(*vri rod d"vrepov npos to fiapvto civt6*
'The nature of concordant sounds is that when theyare struck
or blown simultaneously, the melodic relation of the lower note
to the higher is identity, as likewise the relation of the higher
the resulting
impressionis that of the reconciliationof differences,
the merging of particularnatures in an identical whole. This
is well illustrated by the concord called the Octave, where the
relation of is so predominant that
identity regard the notes
we
ovpxfxovtat,
tcl rjdurra
ra"v xpo^iarmv ftrai boKovvra. 'The most
agreeablecolours,like concords,depend upon the easily calcu-
lable,
relationsof their ingredients.'
Later theoristsintroduced vapd^pos as an intermediate term
between "rvpxf"a"vos and did^tapos. According to Gaudentius
[ed.Meibom, p. II, 1.30],irapdcpoovoi dc ol pecroi psp avpxfratpovteal
bta"l"6Htov'iu Be rfjKpovvei "f"aiv6p."voi ovpxfrwvoi, voire p cVl rpi"v
t6v(ov ^otpcrcu, airb napvTrdrrjs fieaav cVl vapatieaTjPf kol cVl 8vo
euro pea-cap oult6pov *Vt napapidrjv.
'
t6vg"v, Paraphone sounds stand
midway between concords and discords ; when struck [this '
'
probablymeans when not prolongedby voice or wind instru- ment,
but sounded momentarily on strings'] 'they give the
impressionof concord ; such an impressionwe receive in the
case of the intervalof three tones between the ParhypateMes6n
and the Paramese ; and in the case of the interval of two tones
'
between the Lichanus '
[theterm Diatonus '
is sometimes used
for Lichanus] Mes6n '
and the Paramese.'
The term is appliedto notes which differin function,
opoffxovoi
but coincide in pitch. Thus the Dominant of the key of D and
the Subdominant of the key of E fallalike on A. See Aristides
Ace be prjb* ivravBa biapaprelp, dyporfBepros tov t" prjrov kcu tov
aX6yov}Tipa rponop ep tois irepl pvBpovs
tovs Xapfidperau *Qorrep
ovp ep biaorrjpaTtKols
toIs o-Toixcioisto pep Karh pekosprjfrbp e*Xrj"t"Brjf
o 7rpa"TOp pep etm peXabovpepop, crretra yp"pipop Kara peyeBos, rjrot
as to. Te avpcfxova fjas ra tovtois
koll 6 t6pos, avpperpa, to be Kara
a38
NOTES
l
ZvpvBpLov. Every foot is determined either by a ratio (between
its accented and unaccented or by
parts) an irrational relation
such as lies midway between two ratios familiar to sense.
a third foot
besides, having its accented part equalto the ac- cented
: ^
' '
the double [q ] Nor must
" "
we"
be led astray here by
" "
ignoranceof the principle
on which the conceptions rational
and "irrational" are determined in matters of rhythm. In the
"
Elements of Intervals we assumed on the one hand a rational
"
in respect of melody which is firstlysomething that can be
sung, and secondly,something whose size is well known, either
[directly]
as the concords and the tone, or else [indirectly]
as
clear from these remarks that the mean between the two accented
un-
irrationalis,that though ^ .
is a possiblerhythmical
element,
and though the relation of ^J to Q is known as that .
of 3 to 4,
q, incommensurate.
is rhythmically For their common measure,
apria pev ra els ura ditupovpeva, cas fjpirovtov teal t6vos* ntpirra
toera elsoVicra"cos kg\ nevre
at y dteo-et? /cat f,and [Meibom, p. 1 4,
1. 20],In tq)VSt p*v io-rivapaia St8c irvicvd'
diaa"njndTa"M irvicva pep
ra iXaxurracos at Sic'cms", dc
dpcua ra. peyurra a"s to dta reaaapcDV.
P. 100, L 7. tovt6v y" t"i/Tponov k.tA. Aristoxenus implies
by this reservation the possibility of dividing scales into those
which are composed of other scales (as for instance an octave,
which is a compound of a Fourth and a Fifth), and those which
decides in any case whether any given sounds may or may not
succeed one another.
P. Ill,L 7. r"v cfctqvto is my
r)ppo(Tfxci"a"v suggestionfor the
of the MSS.
impossiblerS"v cU to fippovpipov Aristoxenus is
obligedto add this qualifying
phrase to show that his division
of the tUXos is not inconsistent with mixture of genus. Thus
*
the meaning is every melody that observes one genus through-
out
fallsinto one of the three classes of chromatic,and
diatonic,
enharmonic'
1. 8. didrovov iarw
ffroi *"**"*"Aristides Quin-
fjxPaxPaTlK^)V
tilianus (ed. Meibom, p. 18, 1. 19),gives the followingderi-
vations
of these names : Enharmonic, aarb rov awqppoV"u, i.e.
from the close fitting
of intervals exhibited in its Pycnum ; Dia-
tonic,
cneidrj(r(po8p6Tfpovr) (fxavrj
tear avrb dtarciVcrtu(Bidrovosis
to dtamVa) as (rvvrovos to "rvprety"); Chromatic, a"s yap t6 fxera^i
Acvkov kcu fUXavosXP^P*1fcoXctroi*ovto" kcll to ftiapivatpdp."f"oip
6u"povptvovxp"fiavpoo-ciprjTcu,
Cp. Nicomachus (ed.Meibom, p. 25, 1. 32),kol "k tovtov
y(
toiaropiKovJcoXeirai,
cVerov npox^pclvdta tS"p t6p"op avro popwrarop
tS"p SKKoop. (p.26,1.27),"arr"avriKeiaOair6 nj"btarovia*
(vapp.6viov
piaovff avrSiP vnapx*w to xpa/um/eo'i'.
pxKpbv !"
yap itaptTpvfytp,
p6pOVTJpiT6vtOV
OTTO TOV dtaTOPUCOV*Zp6*P b* KOI XP^P0'%XetP
X^yOfUP
tow "vrp"irrovs apQpanrovs*
Cp. also the
interpolated passage in Aristides Quintilianus
(Meibom,p. Ill, L 8),xPtaPariK0V "* KakeiTai napa rd xpafeoravTO
ra. \oma diaarffpaTa,
prj bciaBai tictipos ck"lpwp, [Accordingto
Bellermann {Anonymi Scriptio, p. 59)xp*"(eiv Ta Xoorck biao-rtifwra
= attingere
cetera genera ; the pfjfclaOai de tipos cm/mop is unin-
telligible]
. . . to b0 (vapp6viov
dia to cv rjjrov Siijppoa-pevov
TcXet?
touurrcurei
Xapftdixcr"ai'
ov yap totropovwXeop,otfrc8Uo~""asIXarrop
cMx*rai (MSS edex*")Kara qutOtjo'ip ra, SuwTTjfiara
Xaficiv i.e.
the Enharmonic genus derives its name from the fact that it
uses to the fullthe of variation permitted
liberty by the laws of
Harmony. It uses quarter-tones,than which there is no smaller,
and ditones, than which there is no greater (simple)interval.
' '
L 1 1. If avwrarop be correct,it means highest in the process
ofdevelopmentand so furthest from the state of nature. But
the readingof H, is very tempting.
p""totop,
242
NOTES
1.24.
t6 p*w iXaxitrrov. The Greeks did not the
recognize
Greater or Lesser Thirds as concords.
P. 112, 1. 1 1, rb yap rplsic.r.X. Marquard reads f**XPl y"P T"v*
sense.
learn that the effect of the operation a"a"nra" Tqv avptyya was
The offered by
onlydifficulty these passages is in the ently
appar-
indifferentuse of dpaawdp and Karaawap to signify the same
(or operationswith the
operation same effect).
Mr. Howard
thinks that the might have
"rvpiy" been covered when not in use
by a sliding
band, which in some instruments was pushed up to
open the
hole,and in other cases pulleddown for the same
purpose. I might suggest that possiblydvaairdu and Karacnrdp
in these passages are not direct opposites ; that Karaairdp may
be used in its primarysense *
of to draw down,'and dpaarrav in
its secondarysense of 'to open' (beinganswered in (2) by
'
Kkipttp to shut ').
,
'
be seen from his own of
explanation it. also,auf
Der Theil
welchem man nach Abnahme der Syrinx weiter blasen kann,
heisst selbst Syrinx,
und das Blasen darauf ovpirretp.9
P. 313, 1.5. okt" is the excellent emendation of Westphal
for c jc t"p of the MSS. The eightconcordant intervals are, The
Fourth : The Fifth : The Octave : The Fourth and an Octave :
245
.
ARISTOXENUS
'
1. 21. For meaning of the
the terms variable '
and 'fixed*
notes, see Introduction A, " 8.
P. 114, 1. 14. Tot/rap fa t6 ftey Tkarrov k.t.\. Accordingto
Marquard'sexplanation(accepted
by Westphal)of this difficult
sentence, t6 tXarrov and ful(ovare used by brachylogyfor t6
rb
' '
ovk tkarrov d^torarai/ and to ov ful(ovaffHtrraTcu,'
and thus
'
as rjdurr6vre icolyo"p"rarov.'
p. 139, 1L 29-30.
"47
ARISTOXENUS
Pycnom
^__
"* K'r^"
1. 17. x?"dllaTiKh There are two loci of the Parhy-
pate;
the line 4 in the above table,which is peculiarto the
Enharmonic genus, and the line consistingof 5 and 6 which
is common to the Chromatic and Diatonic. The meaning of
this last assertion is that the Diatonic and Chromatic genera
borrow one Parhypatae,so that you may melodiously
another's
combine in a tetrachord any Parhypate in 5 and 6 with any
Lichanus in the lines from 8 to 18 inclusive with this important
exceptionhowever that the lowest interval ofthe tetrachord must
never be greater than the one above it. See Introduction A, " 7.
U. 18-21. Of this most importantlaw Aristoxenus offers no
proofbeyond an appeal to the ear yiyvtrat
"
yap epfieXcs
rerpd-
\opdovicr.V.
1. 21. apicrov
'
unequalin both
dfitfioreptos, ways
'
that is * greater
and less.'
1L 23, 24* The substitution of irapvndrrfs
re xpctytart/ci);
ttjs /3apv-
rdrrfsfor the vapvndrris
T" xpayiariKqr of the MSS
Trapvirdrrjs
completelyrestores the sense. Aristoxenus proves his state-
ments
that the Chromatic and Diatonic genera borrow each
other's to the
Parhypataeby appealing extreme case. A dious
melo-
tetrachord is obtained from the combination of the lowest
Chromatic Parhypate,and the highestDiatonic Lichanus.
P. 119, L 2. I retain avmtiek the reading of MVBRS.
Aristoxenus means that he has exhibited the extent of the locus
of Parhypate,both as divided into the loci peculiarto
the
certain genera and colours,
and as a whole embracing all those
divisions. In p. 1 1 5,1.19, he says that havingdetermined the loci
as wholes (r"vo\"v r6n"v)he must proceed to determine their
divisions accordingto genus and colour. Here he sums up his
account of the locus of the
Parhypate by statingthat he has
dealt with it from both these pointsof view.
Marquard, followed by Westphal,reads ivrt8tisy and trans-
lates,
'The locus of the Parhypate is clear (fromthe above
remarks)as to itsdivision and its placeof insertion.' But this
translation convenientlyignores the words 8o-os "mV, which
show that the size of the locus is what is here considered ; and
the space of a locus is not affected by its place.
1. 15. Aristoxenus here returns to his criticismof the method
251
ARISTOXENUS
is a continuous
legitimately scale, A, though it does not form
a with c, forms a Fifth with e
Fourth ; 2?,though it does not
form a Fifth with xe, forms a Fourth with e ; xB does not form
a Fifth with f9 but forms a Fourth with xe ; c does not form a
Tifth with a, but forms a Fourth with/; * forms a Fourth with
a and aFifth with b ; and so on.
is not a scale ;
legitimate for b forms neither a Fourth with fc
nor a Fifth with/
1. 22. if Iffird 7roXv i.e. in the Enharmonic and Chromatic
scales,but not in the Diatonic.
1. 25. ivavri"s ridcaBai *c.t.A.,
ra "vo taa are the two" equal
intervals of the Pycnum : " 860 avtara are (i)the complement
of the Fourth disjunctive
and (2)the
tone. Now in the scale
descendingfrom the Pycnum
the disjunctive
tone lies next Pycnum, and the complement
the
of the Fourth second from it; while in the scale ascendingfrom
the Pycnum
of systems or scales,
no smaller musical magnitude
than a quarter-tone exists for ear or voice. But the ditone
though a simpleinterval in this scale, since the voice in this
scale cannot is not by
dividejt, any means simplemagnitude.
a
"Upavfor apx**, *v for ev, and cvaBcv for t""6*"; insert hv after
and omit it after
(f)Q6yy""v, aKpvv, and insert Udcrrov before
"KCtr*p"0"V.
It must be remembered that of (j"66yyoi
cftjs are not sarily
neces-
consecutive or immediately
successive notes ; the phrase
appliesequallyto notes that in the
of succession
are same line
even if at a distance from one another. Thus, in our major
scale of C, the notes Dy A, B, are igrjs,because members of
the samelegitimate
scale. Now an is a sequence
dy"oyrj of
consecutive or immediatelysuccessive notes, and this could
not be expressedby saying merely that it proceeds8ta rS"v
igrjs"f"36yyvp.The is givenby
further necessary qualification
the followingwords: the successive notes must be separated
from one another by simpleintervals ; must, in other words,
be the nearest possible notes to one another in their scale.
Direct sequence is a speciesof sequence in general. Thus
is a direct sequence.
tcrw0(i"
tZ"v fapavmeans 'within the extremes,'that is 'between
the firstand last notes.' The firstnote of a sequence is not
preceded,the last note succeeded,by a simple interval.
not
*55
ARISTOXENUS
p. 132, 1. 24.
1. 13. There may be an allusion here to such a doctrine
as we find in the Philebus,or possiblyto iripasmay -be an cusative
ac-
'
in to the following
apposition sentence, and mean as
is elliptical.
ox^eXfiv The completestatement which Aristoxenus
had made was ort r) fiiv
roiavrrj 9 de rotavrq
/3Xa7rre(
fiova-ucfj
ax^XeZ,Kaff oa-ov fiovvucr) dvvarai The careless listeners
a"$eX"2"".
justcaught the firstpart of the statement 6Vt fjfiep toi- . . .
In
altogether. such a sentence as this 6V1 serves the same
1. 1 8. t"v "f)B6yya"v.
tovtuv of the MSS is wrong. The
Aristoxenus
iiaarrjfmra always regards as mere distances ;
functions he attributes only to the notes. Cp" p. 127 '"1. 3, owe
avrdpKrjra diaarfjpaTa
k.t.\.
and
s 2 259
ARISTOXENUS
/
A A I ",y"wwg/i"fuytBu
the
(taking crotchet as the unit).
A m m \ "v T"rpacrt)ijucp
/x*y"#"i.
In these three we have as permanent the Dactyliccharacter
with itsratio of equalitybetween the arsis and thesis ; while the
lengthsof the their difference beingdue to the different
feet differ,
rate of movement.
rb lapPinbv
yivosrb iv rq" i'
biirkaviod\6y"o \ " J J
Here we have the fiey"3os
permanent, six crotchets ; but the
4 '
genus varies,the first being dactylic with the arsis equal
the second being ' iambic
to the thesis, '
with the arsis double
the thesis.
(7)1. 19. [kcurb avrb p-iyeBos
n6ba k.t.X.].
Compare (a)and (b).
(a) \ ^ 1 (5) 1 / ^
, / ^
I"k A A I IA J J IA J J
Here the quantity,
same appears in (a)as
eightcrotchets, a single
in (b)as a pairof feet.
foot,
(8) 1.20. [atdiafopal dtatpcVcai']. . " .
semibreves,
or four minims,or one semibreve and two minims,
or eight crotchets,
or one semibreve, one minim, and two
"c.
crotchets,
(9)1.20. [aliia"f"opa\ "r;p}fu$r"i""].
. . .
E is actuallylowest,xE actually
the the middle and F actually
the highestnote of the Pycnum E-xE-F. Similarlyb,xb and c
are respectivelythe lowest,middle,and highestnotes of the
Pycnum b-xb-c. Similarly e is the lowest note of the Pycnum
of the conjuncttetrachord by which we might extend the scale
upwards. FinallyA, though not actually participating in any
Pycnum in the above scale,does so potentially as the lowest
note of the Pycnum A-xa-bb, in the possible conjuncttetra-
chord
LP MP HP LP LP MP HP LP
LP MP HP LP LP MP HP LP
MlXOLYDIAN
Mese
MP HP LP MP HP LP LP MP
Lydian """*="
4 j, i. j
j
Mese
HP LP MP HP LP LP MP HP
Phrygian
Mese
LP MP HP LP LP MP HP LP
Dorian
Mese
MP HP LP LP MP HP LP MP
Hypolydiam
j W f" " J J g ^=
Mese
HP LP LP MP HP LP MP HP
Hypophrygian
Mese
LP LP MP HP LP MP HP LP
Hypodoriam
elements.
Five tones separate the Mixolydianand Hypodorian. Here
we have E and e as common elements,and direct modulation
is p ssible.
generalresult we arrive at is that when two scales are
The
1.6. I read "W for MSS tip6s. \eyq "' introduces an native
alter-
statement, and the alternative statement of a questionis
a question.
1. 7. diaarfifiara.
Kara The answer
iroaa to this questionas
If we generaldefinition of *rXo*j},
accept this more and regard
the more particulardefinition givenin the Isagogeas descriptive
of one specialcase of the class,it is easy to see that every
melody is capableof beinganalysedinto these four figures as
c"fcfa iycuedfiwrovira
nXoxfi
Tort vXorcfi
fonuc"iivrovaavAo/r^
(3) w\otcfi
"v$"ia "*ya"*rt
""p*0"M5
w\oicf)
TOvfl
m
"-E^-M ^^
dyojyfj
"v$"ia vkotcrj c"Octa
dyory^j
NOTES
'
L 6. Skov tip6sis governed by of one
dirjiuiprrjK"ros, who has
' '
missed some whole missed something completely.' But
=
and construe
dfidprrjfjLa, nv6s in agreement with 8irjfiaprrjK6To^
1. 7. Marquard,followed by Westphal,inserts an ov between
eJriand ittpas,
being ignorantapparentlyof the use of ov% 0W1 ="
ov p6vov ov,
1. 13. Marquard is wrong in bracketing
ov yap avayKaiov
ecm
. . . ton to "f"pvyiov
fieXosas a gloss. He does so on the sup-
position
that its presence in the text involves a petitio
principii\
'
because,he would say, Aristoxenus proves his statement that
the capacityto notate a melody does not necessarily imply the
'
understandingof it by appealto a parallel
an case in metrical
science ; and then his analogyby assuming
proceedsto justify
the truth of the statement
But Marquard has missed the course of the which
reasoning,
is as follows : You admit that to mark a metre is not the
end-all of metrical science. On what groundsthen ? Because
it is a fact that a man may mark a metre, and yet not under-
stand
its nature. Very well then. The same fact holds good
withregardto melodic science (asI shall prove hereafter)
; it is
namely (yap)a fact that a man may notate a melody without
understanding
its nature. Therefore you are logically
bound
to admit that to notate a melody is not the end-all of melodic
science.
1.17.
This argument is based on two premises; (1)Notation
takes account of nothingbeyond the bare magnitudesof intervals.
(2)Perceptionof the bare magnitudeof intervals is no part of
musical knowledge.
In support of the first premisshe appealsto the following
facts :
T O
table 22 in Introduction A] the notes 1 7^ stand for the
,j J J
to
w
m g=
"z==
interval I whether in the scale
Hypatfin Mesfin
or in the scale
Hypatdn Mesdn
271
ARISTOXENUS
has the fatal defect that these intervals are not Fourths.
Fifths,
Sense might be obtained by readingwith Westphalt6 yap pqrip
ko\ r6 fi""rrjsteal vndrrjsf
kcl\wapafUoijs but this is rather far from
the MSS.
P. 181, 1.6. oCt" yapyp"pipop.An anacolouthon.
. . "
of the following
passage by changingthe order of the sentences.
In fact,the readingof the MSS calls for very littleemend-
ation,
be inserted in 1. 22 ; and I have omitted
ntpas must
ijbefore rds in P. 182, 1.3, and inserted b* after it; and omitted
272
ARISTOXENUS
'
observation of the contingent
and constant ; by Westphal' so
muss der Sache gemass erkannt werden was sich (erst)als
Schlussfolge ergiebt,und was in die Kategorie des allgemein An-
of the buxfropa
between concords and discords contains
the connotation of the but the denotation of the
of size,
dia"f"opd
duKpopd of size contains the denotation of the duxfropdbetween
concords and discords.
1.18. The MSS are corrupt here. It is absurd to say that
the Fourth is determined as the smallest interval by its own
nature. It is so determined by the nature of melody or song,
inasmuch as all the smaller intervals which the latter produces
are discords. The correction is due to Westphal.
P. 138, 1. I. ravra fiep ovp \eyoptp6.irapa t"p Zpirpoafap
irapet-
\t)(f)aix"v.
Marquard this sentence
rejects on the ground that
T 2 '75
ARISTOXENUS
*
the sense requiredis not learned,'
but
we say what we have
'what we say, we have learned.' But, just as ravra \cyopep
a\r}6rj
means 'in saying this we are speakingthe truth' (the
predicative force lying in the akrjQri),
so here the meaning is
'
in the above statements we are what
repeating we have learned*
from our predecessors.'
1. 6. nddos. Cp. the use of irwrx" in P* x45" !" J7 " P- 156,
1. 5 ; p. 159, 1.8.
1. 10. o0T6 rb i" Uaripov k.t.\. Meibom, Marquard and
Westphal alike find this sentence unintelligible.
Is it not
notes. We hold
equally,by simple conversion of this
that different notes
proposition, must bound different intervals,
or that a difference in the containing notes necessarilyimplies
277
ARISTOXENUS
when they are Mese and Nete, and the notes a and e in the
scale
their of
possession common Thus
qualities. the juxtaposition
of two small intervals produces on the ear an impressionof
a certain sort,which remains the same whatever the exact size
of the intervals may be ; and Pycnum
one uses the generalterm
for this juxtaposition. But on your principle, one has no right
to employ this term, since Pycna are of differentsizes. Similarly,
preceding
sentence asserts that A is not a necessary result of B ;
nor, continues Aristoxenus, must we allow that B is a necessary
'
result of A. But aicoXovSclvcannot mean to assert a necessary
dependence.'
rovvavriovwcdKovBelp =' the opposite order of dependence/
1. 21. 6"ff d\7jS"S " . .
"P "KCLT"pq. T"V biatp"(T""$"V*
I have
this
transposed passage from its unintelligible positionafter
in p. 140, Li.
biapevetv In its proper placeit is most serviceable
in answeringthe certain objection that to talk of an infinity
of
Lichani is mere casuistry.
P. 139, 1. 2. It is quiteunnecessary to insertwith Marquard
and Westphal ov irdw pabtov(rvvtbelv."are very well
may
introduce a conclusion pressedagainstan adversaryin the form
of a question.
Xcycobe is parenthetical,
1. 13. and riBelva agrees with eKeitnj
and stands in apposition to els6fioi6rtfTapXewovo-a. . . .
1. 1 8. dyayrjs:
cp. p. 121, L 7. The term is here used,not of
a melodic
particular figure,but of the general consecution of
melody.
1. 19. I omit the wordsyhp dia togovtw
ov bvvqBcir) ns av as
lw) j J r"=.
scale J the next note above xe is f.
(b)Sometimes the next note to a given note is separatedfrom
it by an interval of considerable size,
as for instance in the same
Consequently,
the true is
of continuity
conception not derived
from the notions of the minimum, the equality,
or the inequality
of intervals.
P. 144, 11.8-9. After much hesitation I have acceptedMar-
quard'sreading,though I believe his interpretation of it to be
x y z
a ! ! i "
the notes of any one tetrachord form some one concord (Fourth
or Fifth or Octave) with the correspondingnotes of any
other.
Again, in the Lesser Complete System (seeIntroduction A,
" 29)
c
Mesdn Synemmendn
Hypatdn
the corresponding
notes of the
Hypat6n and Mesdn tetrachords
form Fourths with one another ; as do also the corresponding
notes of the Mes6n and Synemmen6n tetrachords. But what
about the Hypat6n and Synemmen6n tetrachords? They
evidently belong to the one scale,and yet the notes of one
process :
ARISTOXENUS
(a tone being the excess of the Fifth over the Fourth). Take
4th 4th
defect.
P. 151, 1.4. For lv fori I read o
y iari for two reasons. Firstly,
the sentence is thus made
exactlyparallel to the next; and
Aristoxenus is fond of such parallelism.Secondly,if we read
'
ov, the meaning is People take the ditone as simple and then
' *
wonder how it can be divided ; but we requirerather People
know that the ditone can be divided, and then wonder how it
'
can be simple; and this sense is secured by readingo y'iari
The which Aristoxenus here resolves arose
difficulty from the
common misconceptionby which one decides an interval to
be simpleor compound by its dimension,without taking into
account the scale to which it belongs,and the functions of its
containing
notes.
1. 17. I omit rb $* Ibiovrrjsdiaf"v""a"?
dKiprfrdv
iariv. The feet
that the interval (thetone) does
disjunctive not vary is used
to prove the theorem,and therefore cannot be part of the
statement of it.
1.22. The interval is constant
disjunctive because the notes
that contain it are fixed notes.
P. 152, 1. 14. For MSS davvStra H-Actora I read curvvOera ra
nXc'iara. 53, 1. I.
Cp. p. 1
LP MP HP LP
LP HP MP LP
the two participles bwdfuva and ura Zvra,which are not co-ordinated
U 2 *9*
ARISTOXENUS
"f"36yyovs,
P. 163, L be t6 bidrovov avyiceiTcu rjroi
4. on k.tX. The pro-
position
of this paragraph seems at first sight inconsistent
with Aristoxenus'expositionof the shades (seep. 142, 11.9-14);
accordingto which exposition there are only two shades of the
Diatonic genus, (a)the soft Diatonic, the tetrachord of which
is thus divided
6: f I 8
a .
6 " 9 a r5 3
i i i i
(inwhich 1 "
-^ of a tone)
(b)the sharp Diatonic with the tetrachord
" i
6
a g " a
'
13
T" i i 1
393
NOTES
J*
3 I I "
I
a 4 " 14 a " 3 5
11 1 * 1
12
which may be called Diatonic from its character.
prevailing
In it there are three dimensions,4, 12, 14.
' '
P. 164, 1. 13. "i"os here = schema = the figure or order of
of
disposal the given parts of a whole.
294
INDEX
125. 1.
dxpl$cia
dyaBSs122. 8, io, 13.
103. 6; 108. 9;
'Arfvoap127. 25. dxpiPfc97. 8;
124.5; 144. 1; 145. 19; 146.
dyrotw125. 3 ; 126. 26 ; 127. a ;
136. 19; 144.31. 23.
ixpifio\oy4ofiat 126. 15.
ciyvoia131. 12, 14; 151. 7.
"yw 104. 5, 6, 9, 24; 128. 11; "*pi0ws119. 3 ; 124. 19.
diepodo/uu 123. 2.
144. 16; 159.22.
105. "*p6a"rtt122. 8.
d7"7^="rate of movement' 141.
14; 125.17. dxpos 121. 8; 137. 2; 2;
"" 121.
sequence* 7; 143. 18. 147.8,2o; 148.7.
'
observance
'
dKXoiwns 130. 24; 164. 17.
"
'
keeping,'
128. 10. AWoTpioXoyiw 124. 4.
129.
dZtdipopos 11. dWdrpios 124. 8.
dZwarlw 106. 25. dXoyos108. 23 ; 109. 12.
132. 13.
dfidprrjiw.
g"w 102. 25.
128.
dfjLapria 5.
Mip 134. 27.
126. 127. 1. dufK^drp-os113. 1 2 ; 117. 8 ; 120. 1.
"0""*)pT)Tos 25;
188. 22.
d/ut"ia$Tfriu
128.
'AOrjvatos 11.
98. 20;
cdaSdvofiou 125.1, 2, 7; dfi^iofi^Ttjais
118. 7.
drdyo 124. 15 ; 132. 14 ; 133. 5,
129. 22.
"95
ARISTOXENUS
155. 6, 8. t"
dpnovt/cd, 123. 7.
"hr*x"137. 7 ;
dirAovy 109. ao, 3a; 110. 35; 125. 3 ; 107. 33 ; 110. 8 ;
104.
"P/x6ttcj
34; 129.3; 131.9.
133. 17, 18,19; 139. 1 ; 147. 13.
dw\w$ (1) 'in plainspeech,
* not dpxcu/cds 115. 3.
in accordance with strict sophicaldpxh
philo- 98. 13; 108. 14; U9. 4;
troth' 102. 14. 123. 4; 124. 11, 37; 131. 5;
184. 19, 30; 145. 3; 146. 31
(2) 'roughly speaking,
-" ;
overlookingparticular
excep-
tions' 147. 31.
- (5) 'in the abstract' 136. davvforos (see note on 108. 22)
34. passim,
"vo0"Mo) 139. 6. Arabia99. 4.
"vo0\tira"104. I. droTria181. 19.
122. 18.
diroyiyvdta/coj "Tovos 131. 14, 21; 182. 13, 13;
AwMfcvvfu 99. 9, 1 1 ; 118. 4 ; 124. 140. 17.
atotw 112. 16; 130. 5 ; 134. 3, 3.
13 ; 153. 9.
AvofoiKTiKos 99. a ; 129. 9. avKovoita 134. 8.
"v6tei"is 124. a, 10 ; 184. 35. av\6s (seenote on 112. 13) 112.
dvoStiojpu 98. 9, 10; 99. 13; 103. 13; 128. 17, 18; 180. 4; 132.
15; 108. 8; 113. 3; 119. 16; 13,16; 133.3,5,7; 134.1,4,7.
I28.9; 131.175 143. 17; 144. at"dvw106. 20; 112. 2 ; 137. 14.
296
ARISTOXENUS
cfcof
97. i ; 189 ; 150. 9, 16, 19 ; tmcrrfiM95 ; .101.1 1 ; 180. 8, 15 ;
159 ; 164. 131.16,20; 134.18; 159.15.
Mraais (see note on 103. 16)97.
iKartpirt**121. 8.
6,16. 10; 103; 104; 106. 11 ; 114. 9.
3"*ft/"u 12 ; 135.
95.
110.
kKKXivw 124. 4.
kmrtlvot 108. 13 ; 104. 3, 4;
6; 115.16; 123.23; 182. 19;
108. 7.
l/ckafifidvw
133. 137. 16.
1 ;
UktfJtwdroj 4; 150. 24, 25.
124.
the laws of 98. 21 ; 99. 18.
'EpaTO/c\r)s
('violating
iKfitK^s
melody ')passim. tpybv131. 18 ; 132. 1, 2.
122. 17.
tpi"JTuc6s
117. 7.
ifCTTjfiSfuow 108. 14.
ipfirjrtia
^AAttoktis97. 10; 188. 18.
122. 1 1.
tvtaifiovia
108. 12.
kp0i0"(a)
') 114.
"vfo)\os 21.
('musicallylegitimate
tp/icXfc
cftfos 125. 6 ; 159. 19.
128. 13 ; 124. 12 ; 126. 14. "v$vs 121. 9 ; 124. 21, 23.
tuvetpos 123. 14.
134. 27 ; 150. 24; 160. 3.
ifwiwroa "vtca.Ta"pp6vT]Tos
"V"TVVOTTOS 96. 12.
139. 15, 17.
k/ujxuyofuu
IwiAAaf102. 18 ; 154. I ; 156. 9.
108. 14. ZaxvyOtot 127. 25.
ivapyfjs
kvapjiSvios(see Intr. A, " 6)
115. 10; 128. 7, 10; 131. 13.
ijflos
passim.
Im/a 96. 23. ifXuda112. 20.
ivcpyiu133. I. 4/^pa 128. 10 ; 133. 13.
102. 10. 116. 14 ; 117 5 141 ; 148.
4)Hi6\ios
hlcTTT)fJU
Iwota 95. 20 ; 98. 12. 4, 5 ; 155. 7.
Ijfuavs118. 10 ; 115. 14 ; 116. 1 ;
Irrcfiw 133. 13.
Irrts 185. I. 136. 14, 15 ; 146. 22 ; 147. 10,
130. 20. 12.
Ivxrrdpxoo 142
tfUTovtcuos ; 143. 4, 12.
*"a8waW""107. 3 J 119. 23.
141. 4.
l"alf*Tos ^furdvioy
passim.
99. 19, 24; 100. 8 ; 124. Ijpcpiw104. 13 ; 105. 1, 12, 23 ;
I"apt9fxia"
113. 21.
10; 127. 19, 2i} 24.
99. 22; 115. 21 ; 146. 22. 105. 13, 16,20,
IffKlda 25.
*"cr"fa" 95. 3) 97.
tits 7 ; 123. 19.
98. (seenote on
{jp/juxr/Uvos
115. 5. 23 ; 110. 8, 22" 23, 25 ; 111. 8 ;
go/rf("
125. 25 ; 129. 14 ; 132 ; 133 ;
MyolU. 16; 115.1. 18.
97. 23 ; 144. 4. 184. 5 ; 145. 3 J 151.
Ivcc/ory*}
IwaW"TTV 115. 14; 150. I, 12.
151.
Oav/i"fa 158. 22.
3;
kmw"ya)147. 9. 99. 3 ; 122. 11 ; 133. 9,
98. 2.
tvcupdofULi 0av/ia"rr"
21.
kv"$l(w124. 19.
126. 12; 159.3. 0l"m 99. 17 ; 145. 5 ; 156. 1, 24 ;
tm0\4vu
159. 18.
'Em7^""M 97. 6. 101. 18 ;
$"wpio)95. 11, 14 ; 98. 4;
Impckfa 96. 2.
kmnKtiov 105. 17. III.4; 112.21; 124.18; 127.
lirivoAQs 164. 7. i*" 15.
111. 18; 127. 17, 23. Bccjpnrucos95. *J.
ima/ccif/is 95. 8; 101. 10; 128. 22;
iwtffieovicj96. 11; 98. 25; 108. 0"a"pia
114. 7; 130. 18; 124. 14 ; 130. 4.
22; 107. 19;
160. 2.
130.
ta/i0iic6s 11, 12.
ImcrraWu 132. 3; 188. 10.
298
INDEX
tcoivdrqs
151. 3. 125.14; 129.4,
jt"ra"oX4l01.8;
Kotvwvio) 118. 15 ; 150. 6; 168. 1. 5,7; 131.9.
Kopiv9ios
128. 11. 129. 3.
fierafiokos
Kpbu 106. 24, 25 ; 107. 13 J 124. fUTOKlvfa104. 6.
17, 19; 126. 1; 181. 22; 132. 133. 9
pcTaXa/tfava) ; 158. 14.
3, """ 11. fMTax*ipi(ofuu99. 5 ; 100. 19.
MfH-Hjt
181. 20. AicWx* 160. 5-17 ; 163. 3.
299
ARISTOXENUS
6"pOa\no"idrjs
131. 17.
6"p0akfMxf"arfis
132. 2.
(seeIntr. A, " 11) 125.
vifrrj 10;
138.9; 144.ii. fyts124. 33.
vapvvoXan"dvj122. 6. wpofftica
95. 9; 104. 9; 132. 21 ;
vavofuu 142. 6. 134. 19.
bid wtm, r6 ("the Fifth ')passim, vp6"TK"tncu
147. 24; 148. 5.
ntpaivoj
106. 15; 159. 14, 19; vpotrrarraj 145. 20 ; 141. 5.
161. 3, 16. vpoarvyx"yv 111. 10.
vtpas 101. 23 ; 107. 9 ; 112. 12 ; wpoaytila
110. 5.
115. 15, 17; 122. 13; 180. 3, 134. 14.
7rpoUjra/"x"y
7 ; 131. 16,22 ; 132. 2, 10. vp6x*ipo*
132. 6.
npiypaxtf98. 5. 107. 21.
in-awis
vAcwio/icu
184. 7. J*vty""
125. 15, 23. "
151.
irXdyrj 2 ; 158. 21.
xXaros 97. 7. aa^s 105. 17.
nAartuv122. 8. acup"s97. 9.
r\"ovax"s164. 21. arjpjxivo)
100. 22; 125. 23.
vXrjOos143. 19. crjuttov
95. 20; 115. 7; 130. 19,
vAovtos 122. II. 20; 131. 1, 2; 135. 19.
wtvfM 132. 4. 25. atcwTT^
101. 24.
wotTjTiicfi
95. 12. ovrtyis
102. 10.
woXAawAfiatos 120. 8. aT"""r"('stopping') 104. 22.
rroXXarrXovs 109. 21, 22. arocxerov1 20. 12; 184. 12.
voXvpcpfis 95. 3. 95. 6.
"rrocx""cy"75
vopctopcu 122. 5; 129. 15. OToxt"C0/1'*'
115. 7*
Topporrtfw 96. 9; 131. 3. (TvyK"ificu110. 5 ; 117. 17.
woiis 125. 15-23. ffvyMxvpbws97. 14; 103. 25.
xpayfiarela
and vpayfiartvofiat cvyxop"a 114. 2.
passim, 114. 16, 1 7 ;
"Tvyx""pia" 148. 3.
111. 9.
rpta"vrcLTOs 125.
"rv(vyla 19.
100. 2.
irpoavoteiKWiu 104. 25.
avfivivra)
vp6$XriiM134. 1 8, 22; 151. 2; avixvXrjpfa
152. 20.
301
ARISTOXENUS
'regionor direction of
ow"xSk 101. 24; 102. 3, 19.
(Tvv$""ji9,avv$"Tos,and ffwrlBrj/u the voice-series*)passim.
ropv"vrfji 124. 25.
passim.
avyiffTfjfu99.il; 110. 8,11; 144. rpis 141. 12.
24; 151. 19; 163; 164. rplrtj (seeIntr. A, " 11) 138. 11 ;
158.
ffwop"u106. 16 ; 113. 6 ; 114. 16 ; 20.
'
164. 23. of composition/ (3) ' character
ffwrclvo* 95. 8 ; 101. 9 ; 144. 14. or motive *)passim.
'
117. l6.
T"TapTTJfl6plOV "pavkos 114. 20.
"pv"ruc6s
110. 6; 119. 10, 13; 123. 112. 7
Xf"fj"rts ; 129. 13.
24. Xf"6a ('shade,''subdivision of
ffois97. 21, 22 ; 98. 3 ; 100. 22 ; genus'; see note on 116. 4);
110. 2; 111. 10, 22; 112. 1,3; 115. 20; 126. 13; 188. 23;
113.2; 119.5,7; 120.4; 125. 152. 22 ; 158. 15, 19 ; 159. 12 ;
(seenote
"pwvii on 96. 18)passim, X"wpif"w
102. 12 ; 110. 4 ; 128. 20;
150. 8.
Xa\en6s106. 16; 108. 13. 98. 1.
X"upi"rfi6s
X*ipovpyia132. 7, 18 ; 188. 17,
18; 134.8.
Xoptf104; 183. 13, 16. \ptvM)*
99. 20.
a*3
M
I-*
OXFORD
its ra 013 b
'7 2 I
QUALITY CONTROL MARK