Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1
Neuroendocrine Unit, Massachusetts General Hospital and Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts
02114
ORCiD numbers: 0000-0003-1731-2927 (P. K. Fazeli); 0000-0003-4878-0205 (A. Klibanski).
ABSTRACT Anorexia nervosa is a psychiatric disease characterized by a low-weight state due to self-induced starvation. This disorder, which
predominantly affects women, is associated with hormonal adaptations that minimize energy expenditure in the setting of low nutrient
intake. These adaptations include GH resistance, functional hypothalamic amenorrhea, and nonthyroidal illness syndrome. Although these
adaptations may be beneficial to short-term survival, they contribute to the significant and often persistent morbidity associated with this
disorder, including bone loss, which affects .85% of women. We review the hormonal adaptions to undernutrition, review hormonal
treatments that have been studied for both the underlying disorder as well as for the associated decreased bone mass, and discuss the
important challenges that remain, including the lack of long-term treatments for bone loss in this chronic disorder and the fact that despite
recovery, many individuals who experience bone loss as adolescents have chronic deficits and an increased risk of fracture in
adulthood. (Endocrine Reviews 39: 895 – 910, 2018)
normal-weight controls (, ), and these differences in and adult women report a past history of fracture (, Received: 2 April 2018
Accepted: 21 August 2018
microarchitectural parameters have been shown to be ), and a prospective study of young women with First Published Online:
independent of BMD (). Similarly, adult women with anorexia nervosa demonstrated a sevenfold increased 27 August 2018
ESSENTIAL POINTS
· Anorexia nervosa is a psychiatric disorder characterized by self-induced starvation and the inability to maintain a normal
body weight
· Nearly 90% of women with anorexia nervosa have low bone mineral density, and the disorder is associated with an
increased risk of fracture
·· The bone loss in anorexia nervosa is primarily the result of hormonal adaptations to chronic caloric deprivation
Both hormonal and nonhormonal therapeutic strategies may be effective in reducing the bone loss associated with this
disorder
Deviations From Normal Bone Modeling and fact that there is an axial growth spurt during puberty
Remodeling in Anorexia Nervosa and appendicular growth occurs more rapidly before
puberty (, ). These reductions in bone size, coupled
Anorexia nervosa has a lifetime prevalence in women with deficits in bone mineral accrual, which the authors
of ~.% (), with a peak age of onset of to years observed correlated with duration of disease, have
of age (). Adolescence is a time of bone modeling important implications for site of future fracture risk in
and accrual, with peak calcium accretion occurring at a women with a history of anorexia nervosa () and may
mean of . years of age (6. SD) in girls (); explain persistently low BMD in adults who were di-
therefore, alterations in the rate of bone formation agnosed with anorexia nervosa during adolescence but
during adolescence may have lifelong impact with have recovered from the disease ().
respect to bone structure and fragility. Although In contrast to adolescents with anorexia nervosa
histomorphometric data in adolescents with anorexia who have low levels of bone formation markers and
nervosa do not exist, markers of bone formation have similar levels of bone resorption markers as compared
been used as a surrogate for bone formation in this with healthy controls, adult women with anorexia
population, as bone formation markers have been nervosa have suppressed markers of bone formation
shown to be correlated with histomorphometrically and elevated levels of bone resorption markers when
derived mineral apposition rates in adults (). As compared with healthy controls (–). This differ-
compared with normal-weight adolescents, girls with ence may be due to the fact that prepubertal ado-
anorexia nervosa have lower levels of bone formation lescents all have low estrogen levels, whereas most
markers and similar levels of surrogate markers of adult women with anorexia nervosa are hypo-
bone resorption (–), suggestive of overall de- estrogenemic relative to healthy, normal-weight women
creased bone accrual and a low remodeling state. A (see “Hypoestrogenemia” below), and estrogen de-
study by Seeman et al. () exploited differences in ficiency is associated with accelerated bone remodeling
rates of bone growth and accrual in the axial vs ap- and increased osteoclast longevity (–). Therefore, in
pendicular skeleton () before as compared with after contrast to the likely low remodeling state in ado-
puberty to demonstrate differential sites of deficits in lescents with anorexia nervosa, in adult women
individuals with anorexia nervosa, depending on when hypoestrogenemia may result in greater remodeling
anorexia nervosa developed. Girls who developed activity but with resultant bone loss due to decreased
anorexia nervosa before years of age were found to bone formation within each basic multicellular
have similar deficits in bone width in the vertebral unit—a unit of space within bone consisting of os-
body and femoral neck, whereas those who developed teoblasts and osteoclasts where remodeling occurs
anorexia nervosa during puberty (. to years of (). Because histomorphometric data in women
age) had a greater reduction in vertebral body width as with anorexia nervosa are scant—there are a total of
compared with femoral neck width likely due to the six reports in the literature of tetracycline-labeled
896 Fazeli and Klibanski Effects of Anorexia Nervosa on Bone Metabolism Endocrine Reviews, December 2018, 39(6):895–910
REVIEW
Table 1. Hormonal Adaptations to Starvation Potentially Contributing to the Low-Bone-Mass State of Anorexia Nervosa
Levels in Anorexia Nervosa Association With Bone References
IGF-1 Low due to GH resistance Low IGF-1 levels are associated with decreased BMD in anorexia nervosa (42, 43)
Estrogen Low due to hypogonadotropic hypogonadism Duration of amenorrhea is associated with decreased BMD in anorexia nervosa (44)
Testosterone Low Low testosterone levels are associated with low BMD and worsened parameters (11, 45, 46)
of bone microarchitecture in anorexia nervosa
Cortisol Elevated High cortisol levels are associated with decreased BMD and decreased markers (47–50)
of bone formation in anorexia nervosa
DHEA Low Low DHEA levels are associated with low BMD in anorexia nervosa and increased (46, 51–53)
markers of bone resorption
FGF21 Low or similar to normal-weight controls FGF21 levels are associated with worsened parameters of bone microarchitecture (54–57)
Leptin Low Low leptin levels are associated with decreased BMD in anorexia nervosa and (11, 58–61)
worsened microarchitectural parameters
nervosa, treatment with oral estrogen does not im- significant contributor to loss of bone mass in this
prove BMD in women with this disease. Although population.
retrospective studies suggested beneficial effects of
oral estrogen in the form of oral contraceptive pills GH resistance
(), randomized and/or prospective studies of oral Acquired GH resistance is another important adap-
estrogen have shown no difference in BMD in those tation that decreases energy expenditure in states of
receiving oral estrogen as compared with placebo undernutrition (–), but it is also an important
(–), except in the subset of very low–weight contributor to the loss of bone mass in anorexia
patients (,% of ideal body weight) (). Impor- nervosa. GH resistance is characterized by elevated
tantly, compliance with estrogen use was monitored levels of GH coincident with low levels of IGF-, a
898 Fazeli and Klibanski Effects of Anorexia Nervosa on Bone Metabolism Endocrine Reviews, December 2018, 39(6):895–910
REVIEW
subjects dropped out of the study or stopped using the anorexia nervosa as compared with those treated with
treatment due to symptoms of increased hunger and placebo, despite the fact that fat mass significantly de-
all three were randomized to the GHSRa agonist (). creases in those treated with GH (). These data suggest
Therefore, this study suggests that treatment with a that the effects of GH that are critical for survival during
GHSRa agonist can potentially overcome the ob- starvation are maintained, whereas the growth-promoting
served resistance to the effects of endogenously se- effects of GH are minimized in anorexia nervosa.
creted ghrelin and that the resistance does not occur Low levels of IGF-, a bone anabolic hormone, are
downstream from the receptor. Further studies will be also an important contributor to the loss of bone mass
necessary to determine whether this will be a safe, in individuals with anorexia nervosa. IGF- has been
effective, long-term treatment for individuals with shown to be a chemotactic factor, inducing osteoblast
Figure 1. Neuroendocrine adaptations to starvation contributing to loss of bone mass in anorexia nervosa. GH resistance—normal or elevated
GH levels in the setting of low IGF-1 levels—may be mediated by FGF21 in states of starvation (55, 109). Low estradiol levels, secondary to
hypothalamic amenorrhea, are likely a consequence of low leptin levels and elevated cortisol levels. Low IGF-1 levels, low estradiol
levels, and elevated cortisol levels all contribute to the loss of bone mass in anorexia nervosa. Dashed lines represent disruption of
the normal, physiologic pathway. [© 2018 Illustration Presentation ENDOCRINE SOCIETY]
Energy Hypothalamus
intake
GnRH
Energy
Pituitary Leptin
+ LH
GH
Leptin
IGF-1 GH resistance GH LH Cortisol
Adipose
Ghrelin
IGF-1
? Cortisol
FGF-21 +
+
Adrenal
Liver Ghrelin
+
Estradiol
Stomach
© 2018 Illustration Presentation ENDOCRINE SOCIETY
Ovary
normal-weight controls and may be frankly elevated women with anorexia nervosa (, , ). Therefore,
in a subset of patients (–). The hypercortisolemia, increased cortisol levels are observed in states of un-
which is the result in part of a decrease in cortisol dernutrition, including anorexia nervosa, and are likely
clearance and an increase in the half-life of cortisol in the an important mediator of the loss of bone mass.
setting of a normal circadian pattern of cortisol secretion
(), has been shown to normalize with weight recovery Dehydroepiandrosterone
(, ). Importantly, elevated cortisol levels are likely a In contrast to cortisol, women with anorexia nervosa
significant contributor to the loss of bone mass in states have low levels of an adrenal androgen precursor,
of undernutrition. The mechanisms by which elevated dehydroepiandrosterone (DHEA), and its sulfated
cortisol levels contribute to the loss of bone mass include form, DHEA-S (, ), which have been associated
() a decrease in calcium absorption in the intestine and with increased bone resorption () and decreased BMD
likely an increase in urinary calcium excretion (–), (). There have been several studies investigating the
() a decrease in bone formation due to both a reduction effects of treatment with DHEA on BMD in anorexia
in osteoblast proliferation () as well as a decrease in nervosa. Treatment with DHEA for months or year
IGF- synthesis in bone-specific cells (), and () in- did not improve BMD in girls and women randomized
creased bone resorption through inhibition of GnRH- to DHEA as compared with placebo (, ), whereas
induced gonadotropin secretion () and potentially via months of treatment in conjunction with oral con-
increased PTH receptor expression in osteoblasts (). traceptives led to maintenance of both BMD and hip
In clinical studies of individuals with anorexia nervosa, structural geometry compared with the placebo-treated
adolescent girls have been shown to have a relative group in whom a loss of these parameters was observed
decrease in calcium absorption and increase in urinary (, ). Therefore, low levels of DHEA may be a factor
calcium excretion concomitant with increased urinary in the loss of bone mass in anorexia nervosa.
free cortisol levels (). Various measures of cortisol,
including urinary cortisol and pooled overnight cortisol Nonthyroidal illness syndrome
levels, have also been negatively associated with both Individuals with anorexia nervosa have low levels of
markers of bone formation and BMD in girls and thyroid hormone levels (T and T) with normal levels
900 Fazeli and Klibanski Effects of Anorexia Nervosa on Bone Metabolism Endocrine Reviews, December 2018, 39(6):895–910
REVIEW
of TSH and elevated levels of reverse T, which are human leptin increases osteocalcin and bone-specific
hallmarks of the nonthyroidal illness syndrome alkaline phosphatase levels, two markers of bone
(–). Low T and T levels without an expected formation (), and in anorexia nervosa, leptin
increase in TSH suggests a central source of suppression is positively associated with BMD (, ) and
and is likely an adaptive response to decrease energy microarchitectural parameters (). However, an
expenditure in the setting of poor nutrient availability. important potential side effect of treatment with
T levels increase with weight gain in anorexia nervosa recombinant human leptin is weight loss, which may
(, ) and are positively associated with changes in be due to decreased appetite (). In a randomized,
resting energy expenditure (), demonstrating the placebo-controlled study of women with hypo-
reversibility of this adaptive response. thalamic amenorrhea (), one participant had to be
Ghrelin Elevated Ghrelin positively associated with BMD in normal-weight adolescents and inversely (85–87, 97, 98)
associated with change in BMD in adolescent girls with anorexia nervosa
PYY Elevated Elevated PYY levels are associated with decreased BMD in girls and women (98, 139, 140)
with anorexia nervosa
Adiponectin Elevated in most studies Adiponectin is inversely associated with BMD in anorexia nervosa (141–144)
Oxytocin Low Low oxytocin levels are associated with decreased BMD (146, 147)
Sclerostin Elevated No known association between sclerostin and spine or hip BMD in anorexia nervosa (148)
DKK1 Low No known association between DKK1 and BMD in anorexia nervosa (148)
Pref-1 Elevated Pref-1 is inversely associated with BMD in anorexia nervosa (60)
Marrow adipose tissue Elevated Marrow adipose tissue is inversely associated with BMD (136, 137)
902 Fazeli and Klibanski Effects of Anorexia Nervosa on Bone Metabolism Endocrine Reviews, December 2018, 39(6):895–910
REVIEW
deficient compared with their normal-weight coun- those randomized to exercise did not exhibit signifi-
terparts (, ). Therefore, calcium and vitamin cant changes in BMD during the -month study
D deficiency are not important mediators of loss (). Therefore, in healthy populations, physical
of bone mass in anorexia nervosa, unless inadequate activity in the setting of weight loss appears to have
supplementation causes significant vitamin D deficiency. bone-protective effects.
Multiple studies have also investigated the effects of
Protein exercise and physical activity on bone in individuals
Girls and women with anorexia nervosa are in an with anorexia nervosa, but in this population, the
overall state of negative energy balance. Importantly, results have been mixed. A number of studies in both
individuals who consume sufficient calories may still adolescents and adults have shown a positive associ-
Marrow fat and preadipocyte factor-1 levels are low in anorexia nervosa (). Although
Marrow adipose tissue may be an important de- DKK levels have been shown to be positively asso-
terminant of BMD and fracture risk. We have reported ciated with bone formation markers () in in-
that levels of marrow adipose tissue are elevated in dividuals with anorexia nervosa, no associations
anorexia nervosa, a disease state characterized by low between DKK and BMD have been observed in this
levels of subcutaneous and visceral adipose tissue disorder. Therefore, further studies are needed to
(). Although the function of marrow adipose tissue better understand whether sclerostin and/or DKK
is not currently known, the fact that this fat depot are mediators of anorexia nervosa–associated bone
increases in size when lipid is actively being used as loss.
an energy source suggests that marrow fat serves an
904 Fazeli and Klibanski Effects of Anorexia Nervosa on Bone Metabolism Endocrine Reviews, December 2018, 39(6):895–910
REVIEW
Table 3. Therapies That Have Shown Efficacy in the Treatment of Low Bone Mass in Anorexia Nervosa
Duration of
Therapy Change in BMD (Population Studied) Treatment References
Bisphosphonates 3% to 4% increase in spine BMD compared with placebo (adults; no significant increase 12 mo (39, 40)
in BMD in adolescents when compared with placebo)
2% increase in hip BMD compared with placebo (adults; no significant increase in BMD in
adolescents when compared with placebo)
Low-magnitude mechanical No data on BMD. Marker of bone formation (bone-specific alkaline phosphatase) maintained vs 10 min/d for 5 d (203)
stimulation a decrease in placebo group (adolescents)
nervosa onset () may help address the difficult recovered (, ). Therefore, future studies are
challenge of treating long-term loss of bone mass necessary to optimize treatment strategies for the loss
and increased fracture risk in individuals who de- of bone mass and increased fracture risk in anorexia
veloped the disease during adolescence but have since nervosa.
References
906 Fazeli and Klibanski Effects of Anorexia Nervosa on Bone Metabolism Endocrine Reviews, December 2018, 39(6):895–910
REVIEW
anorexia nervosa: a randomized, placebo-controlled 54. Dostálová I, Kaválková P, Haluzı́ková D, Lacinová Z, postmenopausal osteoporosis. Calcif Tissue Int.
study. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2011;96(7):2081–2088. Mráz M, Papezová H, Haluzı́k M. Plasma concen- 1986;38(6):318–322.
40. Golden NH, Iglesias EA, Jacobson MS, Carey D, trations of fibroblast growth factors 19 and 21 in 70. Seeman E, Szmukler GI, Formica C, Tsalamandris C,
Meyer W, Schebendach J, Hertz S, Shenker IR. patients with anorexia nervosa. J Clin Endocrinol Mestrovic R. Osteoporosis in anorexia nervosa: the
Alendronate for the treatment of osteopenia in Metab. 2008;93(9):3627–3632. influence of peak bone density, bone loss, oral
anorexia nervosa: a randomized, double-blind, 55. Fazeli PK, Misra M, Goldstein M, Miller KK, Klibanski contraceptive use, and exercise. J Bone Miner Res.
placebo-controlled trial. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. A. Fibroblast growth factor-21 may mediate growth 1992;7(12):1467–1474.
2005;90(6):3179–3185. hormone resistance in anorexia nervosa. J Clin 71. Klibanski A, Biller BM, Schoenfeld DA, Herzog DB,
41. Seeman E. Reduced bone formation and increased Endocrinol Metab. 2010;95(1):369–374. Saxe VC. The effects of estrogen administration on
bone resorption: rational targets for the treatment 56. Fazeli PK, Faje AT, Cross EJ, Lee H, Rosen CJ, trabecular bone loss in young women with anorexia
of osteoporosis. Osteoporos Int. 2003;14(Suppl 3): Bouxsein ML, Klibanski A. Serum FGF-21 levels are nervosa. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 1995;80(3):
S2–S8. associated with worsened radial trabecular bone 898–904.
starvation does not serve to maintain glucose levels healthy adolescents. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2005; 112. Kling MA, Demitrack MA, Whitfield HJ Jr, Kalogeras
or lean mass but is required for appropriate adipose 90(9):5082–5087. KT, Listwak SJ, DeBellis MD, Chrousos GP, Gold PW,
tissue response in female mice. Endocrinology. 2013; 98. Misra M, Prabhakaran R, Miller KK, Goldstein MA, Brandt HA. Effects of the glucocorticoid antagonist
154(1):263–269. Mickley D, Clauss L, Lockhart P, Cord J, Herzog DB, RU 486 on pituitary-adrenal function in patients
84. Gianotti L, Pincelli AI, Scacchi M, Rolla M, Bellitti D, Katzman DK, Klibanski A. Prognostic indicators of with anorexia nervosa and healthy volunteers:
Arvat E, Lanfranco F, Torsello A, Ghigo E, Cavagnini changes in bone density measures in adolescent enhancement of plasma ACTH and cortisol se-
F, Müller EE. Effects of recombinant human insulin- girls with anorexia nervosa-II. J Clin Endocrinol cretion in underweight patients. Neuroendocrinol-
like growth factor I administration on spontaneous Metab. 2008;93(4):1292–1297. ogy. 1993;57(6):1082–1091.
and growth hormone (GH)-releasing hormone- 99. Grinspoon SK, Baum HB, Peterson S, Klibanski A. 113. Morris HA, Need AG, O’Loughlin PD, Horowitz M,
stimulated GH secretion in anorexia nervosa. Effects of rhIGF-I administration on bone turnover Bridges A, Nordin BE. Malabsorption of calcium in
J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2000;85(8):2805–2809. during short-term fasting. J Clin Invest. 1995;96(2): corticosteroid-induced osteoporosis. Calcif Tissue
85. Otto B, Cuntz U, Fruehauf E, Wawarta R, Folwaczny 900–906. Int. 1990;46(5):305–308.
908 Fazeli and Klibanski Effects of Anorexia Nervosa on Bone Metabolism Endocrine Reviews, December 2018, 39(6):895–910
REVIEW
in anorexia nervosa. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 1975;40(2): Serum adiponectin and resistin concentrations in inhibits OPG expression in human osteoblasts
334–338. patients with restrictive and binge/purge form of through the MAPK signaling pathway. J Bone Miner
127. Croxson MS, Ibbertson HK. Low serum tri- anorexia nervosa and bulimia nervosa. J Clin Res. 2006;21(10):1648–1656.
iodothyronine (T3) and hypothyroidism in anorexia Endocrinol Metab. 2005;90(3):1366–1370. 157. Ealey KN, Kaludjerovic J, Archer MC, Ward WE.
nervosa. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 1977;44(1): 144. Cawthorn WP, Scheller EL, Learman BS, Parlee SD, Adiponectin is a negative regulator of bone mineral
167–174. Simon BR, Mori H, Ning X, Bree AJ, Schell B, Broome and bone strength in growing mice. Exp Biol Med
128. Leslie RD, Isaacs AJ, Gomez J, Raggatt PR, Bayliss R. DT, Soliman SS, DelProposto JL, Lumeng CN, Mitra (Maywood). 2008;233(12):1546–1553.
Hypothalamo-pituitary-thyroid function in an- A, Pandit SV, Gallagher KA, Miller JD, Krishnan V, 158. Arletti R, Benelli A, Bertolini A. Influence of oxytocin
orexia nervosa: influence of weight gain. BMJ. 1978; Hui SK, Bredella MA, Fazeli PK, Klibanski A, on feeding behavior in the rat. Peptides. 1989;10(1):
2(6136):526–528. Horowitz MC, Rosen CJ, MacDougald OA. Bone 89–93.
129. Casper RC, Frohman LA. Delayed TSH release in marrow adipose tissue is an endocrine organ that 159. Björkstrand E, Uvnäs-Moberg K. Central oxytocin
anorexia nervosa following injection of thyrotropin- contributes to increased circulating adiponectin increases food intake and daily weight gain in rats.
173. Barsony J, Sugimura Y, Verbalis JG. Osteoclast re- between 1997 and 2009. Int J Eat Disord. 2012;45(8): postmenopausal women with low bone mineral
sponse to low extracellular sodium and the 970–976. density. N Engl J Med. 2014;370(5):412–420.
mechanism of hyponatremia-induced bone loss. 187. Warden SJ, Robling AG, Sanders MS, Bliziotes MM, Turner 200. Langdahl BL, Libanati C, Crittenden DB, Bolognese
J Biol Chem. 2011;286(12):10864–10875. CH. Inhibition of the serotonin (5-hydroxytryptamine) MA, Brown JP, Daizadeh NS, Dokoupilova E, Engelke
174. Kinsella S, Moran S, Sullivan MO, Molloy MG, transporter reduces bone accrual during growth. Endo- K, Finkelstein JS, Genant HK, Goemaere S, Hyldstrup
Eustace JA. Hyponatremia independent of osteo- crinology. 2005;146(2):685–693. L, Jodar-Gimeno E, Keaveny TM, Kendler D, Lakatos
porosis is associated with fracture occurrence. Clin J 188. Feuer AJ, Demmer RT, Thai A, Vogiatzi MG. Use of P, Maddox J, Malouf J, Massari FE, Molina JF, Ulla
Am Soc Nephrol. 2010;5(2):275–280. selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors and bone MR, Grauer A. Romosozumab (sclerostin mono-
175. Jamal SA, Arampatzis S, Harrison SL, Bucur RC, mass in adolescents: An NHANES study. Bone. 2015; clonal antibody) versus teriparatide in postmeno-
Ensrud K, Orwoll ES, Bauer DC. Hyponatremia and 78:28–33. pausal women with osteoporosis transitioning
fractures: findings from the MrOS study. J Bone 189. Diem SJ, Blackwell TL, Stone KL, Yaffe K, Haney EM, from oral bisphosphonate therapy: a randomised,
Miner Res. 2015;30(6):970–975. Bliziotes MM, Ensrud KE. Use of antidepressants open-label, phase 3 trial. Lancet. 2017;390(10102):
910 Fazeli and Klibanski Effects of Anorexia Nervosa on Bone Metabolism Endocrine Reviews, December 2018, 39(6):895–910