You are on page 1of 7

Tourniquet Injury: A Case Report

and Review of the Literature


Melissa Hoffer, DVM1
Michael Estrin, DVM2
1
University of Illinois
Urbana, Illinois
2
Metropolitan Veterinary Referral Services
Eden Prarie, Minnesota.

KEY WORDS: tourniquet, injury, limb. Circumferential foreign bodies caus-


ischemia ing tourniquet injury can cause local edema
and can be difficult to identify within ede-
ABSTRACT matous tissue and fur. The purpose of this
This is the first report in veterinary medical report is to increase awareness of this condi-
literature of a dog suffering from tourniquet tion in dogs and cats. This report includes a
injury due to a circumferential foreign body discussion of a similar injury affecting
of the distal limb. A 5-year-old male human infants as well as a review of the
neutered Bichon Frise presented for evalua- human and veterinary literature of tourni-
tion of bilateral distal forelimb swelling, quet application.
lameness, and licking/chewing of his
forepaws. Upon closer inspection, a rubber CASE REPORT
band was found within the edematous skin A 5-year-old male neutered Bichon Frise
and fur of each forelimb at the carpi. This was presented for evaluation of bilateral dis-
report includes a discussion of a similar tal forelimb swelling, lameness, and lick-
injury affecting human infants as well as a ing/chewing of his forepaws of 10 days
review of the human and veterinary litera- duration. Previous treatment with an antibi-
ture of tourniquet application. otic (cephalexin 250 mg PO BID), an anti-
inflammatory corticosteroid (prednisone 5
INTRODUCTION mg PO q24h), and an Elizabethan collar had
There are many anecdotal reports of tourni- not alleviated his clinical signs. A physical
quet injury in dogs and cats. Veterinarians exam showed severe bilateral distal fore-
have reported instances of animals suffering limb edema. There was cutaneous erythema
from tourniquet injury secondary to rope, and crusting on the palmar aspect of both
wire, string, bandages, blankets, hay, and forepaws. There was a circumferential
rubber bands. However, there is only one lesion around both carpi with bilateral full-
report of a circumferential foreign body in thickness palmar lacerations.
the veterinary literature.1 In that case, a cat Upon closer inspection, a rubber band
presented for respiratory distress and was was found within the edematous skin and
later found to have been suffering from a fur of each forelimb at the carpus (Figures
rubber band around the neck. This is the 1–5). Both feet were warm, superficial nerv-
first report in veterinary literature of a dog ous sensation was present, and digital pulses
suffering from tourniquet injury due to a were palpable distal to each rubber band. A
circumferential foreign body of the distal diagnosis of tourniquet injury was made.

Intern J Appl Res Vet Med • Vol. 4, No. 1. 2006 67


Figure 1: Sedation was achieved using intramus-
Clipped
forepaws cular administration of 0.2 mg/kg hydro-
showing the morphone and 0.02 mg/kg acepromazine.
circumferen-
tial lesion and The rubber bands were removed with cold-
the distal sterilized suture scissors (Figures 6–8). The
edema and
erythema. wounds were flushed and bilateral pressure
wet-to-dry bandages were placed. A 25-
µg/hr fentanyl patch was also placed on the
Figure 2: wounds. Given the presence of peripheral
Close-up of pulses and intact superficial nervous sensa-
Figure 1.
tion, the prognosis for return to full function
was good. However, the depth of circumfer-
ential skin lesions of each carpus was
unknown, and the prognosis for healing
without skin sloughing was guarded.
The patient was presented the following
day with an intact blood supply, superficial
Figure 3: nervous sensation, and normal skin color of
Close-up of
the palmar the paws. There was no ligamentous insta-
aspect of the bility. The bandages were replaced with dry
forepaw
showing the wraps. The patient was presented again 2
depth of injury days later with further progression towards
and crusting.
healing. The bandage was not replaced at
that time.

Figure 4: DISCUSSION
Following for-
eign body To the authors' knowledge, this is the first
removal. Note report of a tourniquet injury in the veteri-
the relative
size of the rub- nary medical literature. However, a very
ber bands in similar injury occurring in human infants is
relation to
standard well documented.2–4 The injury is termed
thumb forceps. hair-thread tourniquet syndrome, ischemic
hair syndrome, toe tourniquet syndrome, or
Figure 5: acquired constriction ring. The syndrome
Following for- occurs most commonly in infants less than 6
eign body
removal and months old and the etiology is human hair
flushing of the or thread that becomes encircled around one
wounds.
or more digits.2–4 Infants are presented to
their physician for evaluation of irritability
and/or inappetance. Physical examination
shows edema and erythema and may also
show serous drainage, crusting, and lacera-
Figure 6:
Close up of
tion of the superficial tissues of the affected
Figure 5. digit. Close examination reveals the
entrapped hair/thread, which is very difficult
to identify given the local edema. Adjacent
skin may also re-epithelialize over the con-
stricting object thus further obscuring it.2

68 Intern J Appl Res Vet Med • Vol. 4, No. 1. 2006


The constricting object acts as a tourniquet MUSCLE
by blocking lymphatic drainage causing Muscle damage may result from direct com-
lymphedema, which reduces local blood pression of the tissues beneath a tourniquet
supply and results in ischemic damage.3 If or ischemia of the tissues distal to a tourni-
treatment is delayed, vascular compromise quet. Muscle seems more severely damaged
and necrosis may warrant amputation of the by ischemia versus compression. Rupture of
digit. Treatment is aimed at removing the muscle is an uncommon event with tourni-
hair or thread under general anesthesia. quet injury and has been reported only once
Making incisions along the medial and lat- in the human literature.8 Both primary and
eral aspect of the affected digit to relieve secondary forms of ischemic myopathy
edema and to sever any remaining have been described. Primary ischemia is
hairs/threads has been frequently immediate, related to local metabolic
described.2,3 The prognosis following treat- changes, and characterized by myofibril
ment depends on tissue compromise at the degeneration and cell necrosis within 2 to 3
time of diagnosis, but is generally excellent hours after the onset of ischemia. Secondary
with normal development of the digit in ischemia is delayed, developing gradually
most cases.2–4 following tourniquet release, and is charac-
Although foreign objects described as terized by microvascular congestion and
tourniquets can cause injury as described in muscle autolysis.8 This is significant when
this report, surgical tourniquets (Esmarch considering wound management with
tourniquet, pneumatic tourniquet, blood tourniquet injury in that necrosis may con-
pressure cuffs, etc.) have been used for cen- tinue even after tourniquet removal in mus-
turies.5,6 The purpose of a tourniquet in sur- cle tissue that initially appears viable.
gery is to provide a bloodless field allowing Several studies evaluating muscle tissue in
the surgeon to view the anatomy, operate ischemic conditions have been performed.6,8
quickly, and reduce blood loss. The poten- Researchers have found that ischemia pro-
tial complications of tourniquet use in sur- duces myocyte damage characterized by
gery have prompted several studies that inflammation, necrosis, calcium ion channel
evaluate the effects of tourniquet application disturbances, muscle weakness, and changes
on local tissues and blood flow, as well as within the mitochondria of myocytes,
metabolic changes that occur with pro- including disorganized christae, swollen
longed tourniquet use. These changes are mitochondria, and electron-dense material
applicable to tourniquet injury as described within the mitochondria.6,8 These effects
above, because the physical processes of vary in severity with the length of the
intra-operative tourniquet use and tourniquet ischemic episode and the pressure of tourni-
injury are similar. quet inflation. It has been theorized that an
increase in muscle capillary permeability
SKIN contributes to local edema in tourniquet
Reports of hair-thread tourniquet syndrome syndromes.8
in humans, as well as the report presented
above, show that skin laceration may occur NERVES
secondary to tourniquet injury. Reports of Tourniquet paralysis syndrome has been
skin necrosis following improper bandage described in humans. The syndrome is
usage have also been reported.7 defined as an abnormal function of peripher-
Conceivably, the degree and type of injury al nerves distal to a tourniquet and is mani-
would be related to the width of the tourni- fested by a loss of motor function, touch
quet, pressure of the tourniquet, and dura- sensation, vibration, position sense, and the
tion of application. inability to discern light pressure.6,8 The abil-

Intern J Appl Res Vet Med • Vol. 4, No. 1. 2006 69


ity to detect warmth, coldness, and pain is duration of application lead to more tissue
maintained, as is sympathetic function. The compromise and a greater degree of tourni-
syndrome can last for days to months but the quet injury.9
long-term prognosis for recovery is good.6,8,9
Tourniquet paralysis syndrome may occur in BLOOD FLOW
veterinary patients suffering from tourniquet As previously mentioned, the function of a
injury, but it may be difficult or impossible tourniquet intra-operatively is to reduce
to diagnose. Nerve paralysis, however, can blood flow distal to the tourniquet site. The
be diagnosed easily in veterinary patients effects on blood flow distal to a tourniquet
and is one of the most common complica- are very pronounced, and this has severe
tions following intra-operative tourniquet implications affecting an animal suffering
use.6 Nerve paralysis is defined as the loss or from tourniquet injury. Blood flow distal to
impairment of motor function and is more a tourniquet diminishes to less than 1% of
commonly known as palsy in the human normal, and venous return diminishes to less
medical literature.10 Nerve paralysis may be than 0.2% normal.6 Following tourniquet
due to either direct compressive forces release, an increase in blood flow 10-times
beneath a tourniquet or to ischemic condi- normal was consistently noted in humans.6
tions distal to a tourniquet. The effects of Following an ischemic episode of 2.5 hour-
tourniquet application on nerve function duration, perfusion returned to normal 1.75
have been under debate for decades.5,6,8,11 In hours later in a study using dogs.6
vitro studies using sections of nerve, nerve A study performed on rabbits demon-
conduction studies, and sensorimotor evalua- strated that blood flow to the skin was com-
tions have supported ischemia as the major promised at lower external pressures
cause of nerve palsy.5,6,8 Electromyography, compared to muscle. Blood flow to skin and
theoretical models using stress analyses, muscle was compromised when tourniquet
anecdotal experience, and studies evaluating pressures exceeded 30 mmHg and 50
microscopic changes within nerves under mmHg, respectively.12 Thus, pressure necro-
compression have supported compression as sis may occur to skin despite adequate
the major cause of nerve palsy.5,6,8 It is cur- peripheral pulses. This is most applicable as
rently supported that nerve palsy following a precaution to the use of bandages and
tourniquet application is due primarily to intra-operative tourniquets; however, this
mechanical compression; however, it is may also be relevant in wound management
accepted that ischemia may also contribute. during treatment of tourniquet injury in that
The primary injury is thought to be displace- skin necrosis may have occurred or may
ment of the nodes of Ranvier, demyelina- occur despite adequate peripheral pulses.
tion, and stretching of the paranodal Early reports of increased bleeding ten-
myelin.8,11 dencies in dogs following tourniquet appli-
Studies in human medicine have shown cation prompted evaluation of coagulation
that motor impairment is more common than function in primates during tourniquet appli-
sensory, and that large myelinated fibers cation.6 In addition, a study performed in
(sciatic, femoral) are more prone to injury 1966 showed local clotting time in humans
than smaller fibers.11 These findings may to be increased to 16 minutes (normal =
help explain potential physical exam find- 20–40 seconds ) following tourniquet appli-
ings when evaluating a patient suffering cation of 1-hour duration.5 Tourniquet appli-
from tourniquet injury. Studies have support- cation reportedly activates the extrinsic,
ed the intuitive hypothesis that tissue dam- intrinsic, and fibrinolytic pathways.
age is related to the pressure of the Compression of tissues causes local
tourniquet and the duration of application; ischemia and hypoxia leading to acidosis
higher tourniquet pressure and increased and tissue damage. Tissue thromboplastin is

70 Intern J Appl Res Vet Med • Vol. 4, No. 1. 2006


released that activates the extrinsic coagula- tourniquet inflation that may permit the tis-
tion pathway, and damaged endothelium sues to recover briefly from the ischemic
activates the intrinsic coagulation pathways, episode. There is controversy within human
as well as the fibrinolytic pathway.6 Studies medicine regarding the efficacy of breathing
did not find any effect on platelets. The periods in reducing tourniquet injury fol-
increased coagulation and fibrinolytic activ- lowing intra-operative use.
ity are characterized by reduced fibrinogen, Post-tourniquet syndrome, also known
antithrombin III, and plasminogen, and as Volkmann's contracture, has been
increased fibrin split products and fib- described in the human medical literature.5,7
rinopeptide A concentrations. Following The syndrome is due to ischemic injury
tourniquet release, hemostasis is quickly leading to metabolic derangements second-
achieved by ingress of clotting factors, dilu- ary to tourniquet application. This syndrome
tion of fibrin split products, and removal of is characterized by changes in local pH,
fibrin split products and fibrinopeptide A by CO2, and O2 that are manifested by edema,
venous drainage.6 stiffness, pallor, weakness (without paraly-
sis), and numbing sensations. This syn-
METABOLIC CHANGES drome occurs following injury to a fascial
Local metabolic changes in tissues distal to compartment causing increased intercom-
a tourniquet include hypoxia, hypercarbia, partmental pressure, collapse of arterioles
increased creatine phosphokinase, increased and venules, venous obstruction, and muscle
lactate, hypoglycemia, hypocalcemia, and damage, the end result of which is limb
hyperkalemia.6 The local pH may drop from deformity (contracture). There is one report
7.4 to 6.8, the partial pressure of oxygen of Volkmann's contracture in a dog follow-
(pO2) may drop from 22 mmHg to near ing a ballistic injury.7 However, the syn-
zero, and the partial pressure of carbon drome is rare in veterinary patients
dioxide (pCO2) may increase from 38 presumably due to the presence of collateral
mmHg to 62 mmHg.6 Changes were relative circulation and less defined osseo-fascial
to the duration and pressure of tourniquet compartments in dogs.7
application. There was a significant differ- Depending on the location of the tourni-
ence between 1 and 2 hours of application quet (ie, amount of tissue affected) and the
and also between tourniquet inflation pres- duration of application, one may need to be
sures of 250 and 500 mmHg.6 Local concerned about ischemia-reperfusion
hypocalcemia may contribute to impaired injury. A discussion of ischemia-reperfusion
nerve function.6 Hyperkalemia has been injury is beyond the scope of this report.
shown to have vasodilatory properties in However, it has been shown that following
humans and rats, with increases in local intra-operative tourniquet application for sti-
muscle blood flow of 5- to 10-times normal fle surgery of 2-hour duration in dogs, there
following tourniquet release.6 It has been were increased local toxic oxygen products
shown that capillary permeability increases in the form of hydrogen peroxide (H2O2).13
when tissue pO2 decreases to 10 mmHg and In an animal with a tourniquet injury affect-
the volume within the tissues increases by ing relatively greater body mass (especially
100%; thus, hypoxia may greatly contribute above the stifle or elbow), immediate
to local edema.6 Creatine phosphokinase did removal of the tourniquet may not be war-
not increase when "breathing periods" of 10 ranted and pre-treatment for reperfusion
minutes were allowed at 1-hour intervals.6 injury may be indicated. Treatment of reper-
Breathing periods are used periodically dur- fusion injury is controversial as ischemia-
ing intra-operative tourniquet application reperfusion injury is a complex process.
and are periods of time during which tourni- Treatment modalities that may be useful
quet deflation is allowed between periods of include neutrophil blockers (anti-ICAM-1

Intern J Appl Res Vet Med • Vol. 4, No. 1. 2006 71


antibodies, anti-β2 integrin antibodies, CD- Based on the studies discussed above, it
18 blockers), allopurinol, deferoxamine, and is surprising that the dog in this report
dimethyl sulfoxide.14 maintained deep blood flow and nervous
function to both feet considering the foreign
CONCLUSION bodies had been present for 10 days.
The intra-operative use of tourniquets has Although the rubber bands appeared small
prompted several studies to determine the and would be assumed to exert great pres-
local effects of tourniquet application on sure, they had elastic properties allowing
skin, muscle, nerves, blood flow, and the them to stretch. Also, although the rubber
local metabolites. Because the physical bands had lacerated some superficial tissues,
processes of intra-operative tourniquet use they may have relieved some local edema
and tourniquet injury are similar, these stud- allowing preservation of deeper neurovascu-
ies are relevant and reveal details about the lar structures. Upon presentation, a com-
process that may aid in treatment and prog- plete neurologic exam was difficult to
nosis; however, there are shortcomings to interpret given the bilateral distal forelimb
this comparison. Although the physical lameness and edema. The lameness was
processes of intra-operative tourniquet presumed to be due to pain and not neuro-
application and tourniquet injury are similar, logic compromise because the patient had
they are not identical. Studies discussed in demonstrated intact nervous sensation.
this report used a variety of tourniquets Reperfusion injury was not a concern in this
often used intra-operatively, including case due to the relatively small proportion
Esmarch and pneumatic tourniquets. of tissue involved compared to body mass.
However, an animal suffering tourniquet Tourniquets have been used in human
injury may have a variety of foreign objects surgery for centuries and have been used to
causing the injury, including ropes, wire, a lesser extent in veterinary surgery.
chain link, bandages, or rubber bands. How However, there are risks associated with the
these items may alter the local tissues and use of tourniquets in medicine as demon-
microenvironment is unknown. Moreover, strated by Volkmann's contracture, nerve
in most studies discussed here, tourniquets palsies, ischemic skin necrosis, injuries sec-
were applied for a relatively short period of ondary to bandage application, and myocyte
time (minutes to hours), whereas an animal damage. Furthermore, as this report illus-
may have been suffering from tourniquet trates, severe injuries can occur secondary
injury for days to weeks prior to presenta- to foreign bodies acting as tourniquets.
tion. Additionally, the studies discussed in These injuries can arguably be much more
this report used a wide variety of species, severe than bandage injuries or intra-opera-
including dogs, humans, rabbits, and pri- tive tourniquet use because the two vari-
mates. One can presume the physiology ables affecting the degree of injury, pressure
across species is similar. However, as dis- and duration of application, are not con-
cussed, Volkmann's contracture, which is trolled, and their degree and extent may be
very common in humans following tourni- unknown.
quet application, is seldom recognized in
veterinary patients. There may be important REFERENCES
differences in physiology that remain to be 1. Sadler V, Wisner E: What is your diagnosis?
elucidated. The studies presented here also JAVMA 2000;216(11):1723-1724.
used a variety of tourniquets (Esmarch or 2. Harris E: Acute digital ischemia in infants: the
hair-thread tourniquet syndrome a report of 2
pneumatic), a variety of occlusion times cases. J Foot Ankle Surg 2002;41(2):112-116.
(minutes to hours), a variety of breathing 3. Corazza M, Carla E, Altieri E, et al: What syn-
periods, and a variety of inflation pressures. drome is this? Pediatr Dermatol 2002;19(6):555-
These variables make direct comparisons 556.
between results difficult.
72 Intern J Appl Res Vet Med • Vol. 4, No. 1. 2006
4. Smith A, Peckett W, Davies M: Acquired con- 10. Blood DC, Studdert VP: Saunders Comprehensive
striction ring syndrome. Foot Ankle Int Veterinary Dictionary. 2nd edition. W.B.
2003;24(8):640-641. Saunders: New York; 1999:838.
5. Love B: The tourniquet. Aust NZ J Surg 11. Storm S, Weiss M. Self-inflicted tourniquet paral-
1978;48(1):66-70. ysis mimicking acute demyelinating polyneuropa-
6. Blass C, Moore R: The tourniquet in surgery, a thy. Muscle Nerve 2003;27:631-635.
review. Vet Surg 1984;13(2):111-114. 12. Ogata K, Whiteside L: Effects of external com-
7. Anderson D, White R: Ischemic bandage injuries: pression of blood flow to muscle and skin. Clin
a case series and review of the literature. Vet Surg Orthop Relat Res 1982;168:105-107.
2000;29:488-498. 13. Mathru M, Dries DJ, Barnes L, et al: Tourniquet-
8. Derner R, Buckholz J: Surgical hemostasis by induced exsanguinations in patients requiring
pneumatic ankle tourniquet during 3027 podiatric lower limb surgery. An ischemia-reperfusion
operations. J Foot Ankle Surg 1995;34(3):236- model of oxidant and antioxidant metabolism.
246. Anesthesiology 1996;84(1):14-22.
9. Kornbluth I, Freedman M, Sher L, et al: Femoral, 14. McMichael M: Ishcemia-reperfusion injury:
saphenous nerve palsy after tourniquet use: a case assessment and treatment, part II. J Vet Emerg
report. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 2003;84:909-911. Crit Care 2004;14(4):242-252.

Intern J Appl Res Vet Med • Vol. 4, No. 1. 2006 73

You might also like