Professional Documents
Culture Documents
“IE A RED On December 1, people wear red ribbons to show they have joined the fight against HIV and AIDS.
RIBBON Go to www.worldaidsday.org to order free ribbons and find out more about the deadly virus.
Armenicum or nothing?
Ten Years On, the So-Called “Miracle Cure” Still Unproven
By Sara Khojoyan be treated with Armenicum, while the stan- Barseghyan said. “But as the HIV problem monitoring the 250 patients who have been
and Leah Kohlenberg dard ARV regimen costs $1,700 per patient gets worse, it will be more difficult to bring treated with the drug in the past four years,
Amnewsservice.org per year. The Armenian taxpayer paid enough drugs into the country.” though they contend “many” have lived for
$300,000 to treat 50 Armenicum patients When Armenicum was first introduced ten years using the drug.
For ten years, Armenians have been this year, while the Global Fund paid in Armenia ten years ago, founders called it “Armenicum is still experimental and we
told about the wonders of Armenicum, the $160,000 to treat 93 patients with ARV a “revolutionary cure for AIDS,” and it are in the middle of the testing phase,” said
locally produced formula whose makers drugs. In other words, it costs twice as immediately captured high-ranking govern- Ashot Melkonyan, head of the Armenicum
claim it has curative powers over the dead- much to treat half as many Armenicum ment officials’ interest. Early on, initial pay- Clinical Center in Yerevan. “But when we
ly HIV virus. patients. ments for Armenicum treatments came are ready, we will show the world what we
And while doctors who use the drug say So far, the U.S.-funded Global Fund, from the Defense Ministry in an effort to have.”
it does seem to relieve some of the symp- through the local World Vision Armenia promote the drug’s research and develop- Despite the lack of evidence supporting
toms of HIV, after a decade the company office, has been paying for and procuring ment. Armenicum’s possibilities caused a Armenicum’s claims, the National Center
has yet to produce any viable clinical trials ARV treatments. But technically, that buzz of excitement in the tiny country. for AIDS Prevention clinicians say they
proving more substantive treatment claims. money ran out in June, and though the Businessmen, it was reported in some consider Melkonyan and the Armenicum
What most Armenians probably don’t grant has been extended until February newspapers in 1999, were buying property doctors colleagues in the fight against HIV,
know is that their tax dollars are paying for and the National Center for AIDS so that they could rent it to all the people and have supported anecdotal claims that
Armenicum, which is more than triple the Prevention is currently applying for another who would fly to Armenia to take the cure. some of their patients have responded well
cost of the world’s only proven treatment grant, this one for six years, there is no Yet a decade on, only about 800 people to the treatment.
for HIV, Anti Retroviral (ARV) drugs. They guarantee that the Global Fund will contin- have actually taken Armenicum. “We are cooperating all the time, and
probably also aren’t aware that in a few ue to fund future ARV treatments for newly Worldwide, the most effective treatment we always discuss every case to find a bet-
months Armenicum may be the only choice revealed cases. for HIV are Anti Retroviral drugs, which in ter solution,” said Dr. Arshak Papoyan,
available in Armenia for future HIV-infected “If the Global Fund does not finance internationally accepted clinical trials have head of the National Centre for AIDS
people. Armenia again, the national HIV program been the only proven way to keep patients Prevention Epidemiology Unit.
In Armenia, treating HIV positive will be in great jeopardy,” said Mark Kelly, alive, often for years. The drugs work by But it’s hard to find a doctor treating HIV
patients shouldn’t be a major problem – World Vision Armenia’s National Director. directly attacking and reducing the amount patients who will be quoted publicly saying
and on the surface, the system seems to be “Currently the Global Fund pays for the of HIV virus in the body, keeping the patient the drug doesn’t work, some say, because
working. The HIV positive population is majority of testing and prevention pro- from developing Acquired Immunodeficiency the pressure for the Armenian-made drug
small, with only 649 reported cases. Even grams, and all ARV treatments.” Syndrome (AIDS), a complete immune sys- to succeed is so high that criticism is con-
including the estimated 3,000 unreported Compounding the problem, according tem failure which leads to death. The drugs, sidered unpatriotic.
cases out there, they still make up a mere to World Vision Procurement Officer Mher offered in cocktails of three or four at a time, “I know many clinicians who don’t
.01 percent of the total population. Armenia Barseghyan, is that ARVs are currently not are often changed as the virus becomes believe in Armenicum, but they are not
does offer an efficient, government funded a registered drug in Armenia and the gov- resistant. allowed to say anything,” said one doctor
National Center for AIDS Prevention, which ernment has so far been unable to pay the Alternatively, the makers of Armenicum, involved in the HIV treatment field, who
not only records but offers testing and treat- approximate $15,000 it will cost to register whose primary ingredient is iodide, claim it refused to be identified.
ment to anyone who needs it, based on these internationally accepted drugs as boosts the immune system, allowing the The Health Ministry refused to answer
World Health Organization standards of “safe to import.” Because the drugs aren’t body to fight the virus. Armenicum clinic repeated questions about Armenicum.
care. registered, each shipment takes about six doctors also contend the drug has been Even if the jury is still out on
But instead of paying for HIV patients to months to arrive in the country, from the shown to reduce a patient’s viral load – the Armenicum, World Vision and Global Fund
to receive all accepted treatments, the gov- hundreds of phone calls Barseghyan must amount of HIV virus in the body – and that representatives say the most important
ernment is throwing all its money and make to individual drug companies in an the HIV virus never becomes resistant to it. thing is to make sure HIV patients have an
resources towards supporting Armenicum, effort to convince them to send such small The problem is that company scientists informed choice between all the treatment
and is requiring AIDS Center doctors to batches, to the months those boxes of have never even tried to prove any of these options.
offer the drug, though still unproven, as a ARVs spend sitting in customs aging to the claims – at least, not according to the World “We just want to make sure ARVs are
choice. point of expiration. Health Organization international stan- available,” said Kelly. “The most important
This is a costly priority. Currently, it “Right now, we are managing to get dards of clinical trials that ARVs have thing is that every person living with HIV
costs about $6,000 per patient per year to treatment to everyone who needs it,” passed. They admit to not even formally can be treated with ARVs if they choose.”
DECEMBER SEXUAL HEALTH IN ARMENIA 3
Everything became clear only just about the disease. She has found, perhaps
before the death of the two-year-old girl, surprisingly, that priests have been the most
owing to a blood test, which showed the supportive, besides family and close
child had HIV. Next, the parents were test- friends.
ed, showing that they, too, carried the virus. “The major reason is the lack of aware-
“I’m a decent woman, who thought of ness and the Armenian set of mind,” she
HIV/AIDS as a deadly disease threatening said. “When people do not avoid a person
only prostitutes and people of bad behavior, suffering diabetes but do avoid us.”
who became its victim,” said Rouzanna. “I have not robbed anyone, I have not
Though her husband had contracted done anything wrong, have I?! This is a dis-
HIV first and had it for longer, he had a ease that knows neither guilty nor innocent”
lower viral load – the amount of virus in the In fact, she now uses her work to steer
body -- than his wife. But Rouzanna’s health people clear of the idea that there are
deteriorated rapidly after her child’s death. “I “guilty” or “innocent” victims of the disease,
was exhausted, thin, unhealthy, without an “I’m a decent woman, who thought of HIV/AIDS as a deadly disease threatening though she admits to once using those con-
appetite, I was taken to the hospital with only prostitutes and people of bad behavior, who became its victim.” cepts to distinguish her from others inflicted
pneumonia,” she said. Pneumonia is one with HIV.
the primary diseases that kills HIV patients, She thinks it will take years for
as it attacks a defenseless immune system. wife. Her brother brought Rouzanna back to keep the family secret within their home. Armenians to accept people with HIV/AIDS
Though she said at first, doctors had no her parents’ home, blaming her husband And there has been a rift between as full members of society and understand
hopes of healing her, they managed to save and refusing to speak to him or his family. At Rouzanna and her husband’s families, who the real ways the disease is transmitted.
her, prescribing Anti Retroviral (ARV) med- first, she agreed with him. no longer communicate as her brother can’t Meanwhile, life goes on for the 28-year-
ications. Taken daily for a lifetime, ARVs are “I would ask myself: why? What I felt first forgive her husband old woman and her husband, who plan to
the most successful treatment worldwide for was disgust, anxiety and disappointment The disease has brought Rouzanna a get a home, and a car, and dream of possi-
HIV, which can stop the virus from repro- with my husband,” she recalled. new calling. An economist by training, she bly even having another baby, if they can
ducing and spreading, though it can’t cure She spent months not speaking to her now works at Real World, Real People ensure that the child is not HIV-infected.
it. Her illness was in the process of devel- husband and her family. But over time, after (See more about this group on page 8), an She is happy that people still treat her well
oping into Acquired Immune Deficiency her health improved and the pneumonia organization that supports HIV positive after learning of her illness, by not avoiding
Syndrome (AIDS), the oft-fatal version of retreated, and her grief for her child sub- people. her or using the same kitchenware, embrac-
the disease, when the ARVs were pre- sided a bit, these feelings were gradually “This seems to have become my second ing her and kissing.
scribed. replaced with pity and love for her husband: profession,” said Rouzanne, who works in And always, always, she works with
“It was AIDS at the beginning, but then “Maybe it was my conscience, and I real- the monitoring and evaluation department many groups of people to increase the num-
within the course of two years it downgrad- ized he was not guilty, that we shared a and as a trainer. She likes her job, she ber of those informed.
ed to HIV under the influence of medica- common pain and we had to go through it explained, because she can help people at “The more one knows, the better for us,
tion,” she said. together.” the early stage of their illness, and give peo- those who are sick,” she said.
4 SEXUAL HEALTH IN ARMENIA DECEMBER
a
inhibited society, most rate information about o
information about sex is sex. But experts say, m
gained from more per- such access is limited, fo
S
sonal sources such as particularly in villages. th
immediate family and ”Parents prefer to H
community, not doctors. simply give their chil- b
Chastity is condemned dren materials about the p
li
in men, but demanded problems. Today, they
in women. still aren’t ready to open-
But when highly ly speak about sex. It is 6. Gonorrhea S
trained medical doctors preferable to let them a
to
and sex educators find read materials,” said a
that even they have Melyan. n
trouble discussing the It’s time to break the silence The discussion can o
facts of life with their chil- be difficult, which is why M
d
dren, it raises some diffi- most health education fr
cult questions. What is the best way to make appropriate place for people to ask educated organizations are spreading their messages s
sure that factual information gets passed on? questions about sex. In school, students are through public workshops in rural areas. c
How can the common practice of passing infor- often given texts to read at home with no dis- “I met a grandmother who wanted to edu- c
mation from person to person help people learn cussion or perspective. Parents are often cate her 14-year-old grandson about sex,” she
to protect themselves? embarrassed and themselves ill-informed, and said. “But she couldn’t bring herself to speak to
7. Human Immunodeficiency
In short, how can we get expert information most still consider it shameful for women to talk him directly. So she took him to our local office Virus (HIV) H
about how to prevent sexually transmitted dis- about sex openly. and we organized a workshop with the commu- b
th
eases to travel – or “go viral” -- as quickly as the Dr. Karine Abelyan, an educator with the nity. Both she and her grandson participated.” p
viruses spread themselves? USAID funded Innovations in Support of If only one neighbor actively and vocally ly
With HIV and other sexually transmitted dis- Reproductive Health (NOVA), often meets with takes care of her health, others will follow. n
eases on the rise, most dramatically in Russia, village women to discuss prenatal health In Shirak, Melyan recalled, there are a s
r
and with tens of thousands of Armenians going issues. group of women who are very active in forcing S
to work abroad and away from their families for “Once when I started to explain how to pre- their husbands to get a medical checkup when in
months at a time, there has never been a more vent an undesired pregnancy by using con- they returned from their temporary jobs in s
important time to talk honestly about sex. Yet doms, one of the women got up and stormed Russia. No tests, no sex, became their informal h
ly
those difficult conversations are not happening out of the room. She was angry, and told me we slogan. to
often enough: between parents and children, shouldn’t be speaking about such things,” said “That practice was started by two vocal w
teachers and students, boyfriends and girl- Dr. Abelyan. women,” she said. “When all their friends
friends, even husbands and wives. Ruzanna Melyan, a public education team joined, it became a movement.”
DECEMBER SEXUAL HEALTH IN ARMENIA 5
Numbers show that women get STI tested more often than men
Learning Prevention
or Preventing Learning?
Few Schools Teach HIV, Sexual Health to Teens
By Gayane Abrahamyan and Alla sumed the subject needs to be taught by
Avazyan the same teacher. But we are not sure that
Amnewsservice.org the physical education teachers are ade-
quately prepared to properly present the
Within the last seven years, the number subject,” said Alexanyan.
of people living with Human Ella Avagyan, deputy head of studies at
Immunodeficiency Virus – commonly known the prestigious Checkov School in Yerevan,
as HIV - in Armenia has tripled to 649, and has assigned the course to their science
experts estimate there are thousands of department.
additional unreported cases. But as the “Introduction of the subject is of the
threat grows, teenagers, the most vulnera- utmost necessity. These new times make us
ble, seem to be ignored. face the problem of educating children, but
According to an Association for Family it is more important how the teacher will
Health survey, nearly 25 percent of unmar- introduce the subject. We will have a biolo-
ried girls in Armenia have their first sexual gy teacher instruct the course. This person
intercourse between the ages of 14 to 19, will be able to familiarize children with the
while 40 percent of boys start their sexual issues of, say, reproductive health and relat-
life between 13 and 17. Compared to a ed information more accurately,” she said.
decade ago, today’s youth have their first Pediatrician and psychologist Svetlana
between you and a host of health problems, or even an STI can’t happen to them.”
death. A tradition of shame around sex also stops people
While almost everyone understands this, from buying condoms. To overcome this inhibition,
Armenians still aren’t using condoms: although dur- the Association of Armenian Medical Students is
ing the recent years the percentage of condom users planning to introduce condom vending machines to
has increased, it’s still low. Armenia next year, which, according to the President
Dr. Karine Abelyan, a family planning coordinator Alexandar Ter Hovakimyan, will ensure anonymity
of Project NOVA and also the medical consultant for and will help to overcome the shyness and humilia-
this publication has observed there are several rea- tion people might feel during the purchase.
sons for people not wanting to use condoms. For more information on where these machines Pocket (of )Change:The trusty condom is the only reliable method
“Many people think that using condoms suggests will be located, call Ter Hovakimyan at 091-400-469 for preventing STIs, including the HIV virus.
8 SEXUAL HEALTH IN ARMENIA DECEMBER
Project NOVA
Phone: 010274125, 010277065, 010277069
Website: www.nova.am
Primary Health Care Reform Project
Phone: 010261312
Website: www.phcr.am
AIDS Education, Help and Care
Phone: 010633913,
Real World, Real People
Phone: 010556114
Website: www.realwrp.net
Red Cross Armenia
Phone: 010536412
Website:www.redcross.am
UNAIDS
Phone: 010547099
Website: www.unaids.am
World Health Organization
Phone: 010512004
Website: www.who.org
National Center for AIDS Prevention
Phone: 010610730
Website: www.armaids.am