Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Libba Willcox
To cite this article: Libba Willcox (2017) Vulnerability in the Art Room: Explorations of Visual
Journals and Risks in the Creation of a Psychologically Safe Environment, Art Education, 70:5,
11-19
Article views: 84
Download by: [Ohio State University Libraries] Date: 27 December 2017, At: 08:59
Vulnerability
in the Art Room:
Explorations of Visual Journals and Risks
in the Creation of a Psychologically Safe Environment
Libba Willcox
T
Downloaded by [Ohio State University Libraries] at 08:59 27 December 2017
hinking back to my first years of teaching high school, there are many things I would change.
During those years, I saw my students try new techniques that led to successful art pieces, but I
also remember vulnerable moments when my students’ attempts did not yield results they desired.
Some students embraced these so-called failures and started again, while others were paralyzed
by them; they feared what other students thought about their abilities. Many students in the art
classroom view making art, and creativity, as innate abilities rather than something to be learned.
When students take risks, and fail, many believe they are flawed and do not belong in an art class.
These vulnerable moments can become courageous risks or confirmation that they do not belong
in the art room. These moments of vulnerability need pedagogical and curricular attention from art
educators to create a psychologically safe environment where students can be creative.
Utilizing the word safe in an art room can reduce art to a subject art teachers should scaffold the act of embracing personal
without substance, without innovation, and without creativity; this vulnerability when taking creative risks. Karinna Riddett-Moore
interpretation would render art education as frivolous. Instead, (2009) asserted “Students are more likely to be receptive of new
I advocate that psychological safety encourages courageous ideas when they feel it is safe to explore, question, and express
vulnerability, enables creative risks, and minimizes shame. Brené those ideas” (p. 9). While in my teaching statement I claimed
Brown (2006) defined shame as “An intensely painful feeling or that I wanted my students to experiment and push boundaries,
experience of believing we are flawed and therefore unworthy of in my classroom I did not know how to do it. How could I enable
acceptance and belonging” (p. 45). While shame is universal, it students to embrace their vulnerability and feel safe in my art
is often unspoken and can be detrimental to education. Different room? Teachers can encourage vulnerability, support student risk-
from guilt (which emerges from behavior) and humiliation (which taking, and create a safe environment of creative exploration by
is undeserved), shame is a feeling of rejection associated with the designing a curriculum to scaffold learning, noticing details in the
social, emotional, and cultural self. Those who experience shame classroom and in student work, developing trusting relationships,
often feel trapped, powerless, and isolated (Brown, 2006). Brown’s and engaging in authentic dialogue.
(2006) research suggested embracing one’s personal vulnerability is Attention to the learning environment and the learning process
one way to develop resilience to shame. Students and teachers must is now emphasized in the 2014 National Visual Art Standards and
embrace their personal vulnerability in the art room to engage in has become the teacher’s responsibility, but little information exists
creative risk-taking that minimizes shame. on how to create a safe environment. Previous literature on creating
Vulnerability is being susceptible, accessible, sensitive, liable, a safe milieu can be divided into two differing perspectives.
and tender; according to Brown’s (2012) TED Talk on listening On one hand, the literature suggests that the environment is
to shame, vulnerability is “emotional risk, exposure, [and] established with the setting of policies, such as creating routines,
uncertainty.” Making and sharing artwork can be a vulnerable establishing rules, and enforcing rules (Evertson & Emmer,
experience. Because vulnerability is a part of art and of education, 1982; Horsch, Jie-Qu Chen, & Nelson, 1999; Susi, 1996, 2002).
September 2017 11
Downloaded by [Ohio State University Libraries] at 08:59 27 December 2017
Figure 1. This visual journal entry by Kaitlynn Mockett illustrates experimentation with bleeding tissue paper,
newspaper, and ink.
The physical environment of the classroom is also important; safe environment where students could create, discuss, explore,
teachers must think about spatial arrangement (Susi, 1986, 1996, experiment, “fail,” and succeed (Figure 1). I observed how Rose’s
2002), movement pathways (Susi, 1986), student art storage (Susi, curriculum and pedagogy fostered a safe environment. Searching
1986), and material location and organization (Broome, 2013; for goodness across the data, as promoted in Sara Lawrence-
Susi, 1986). On the other hand, some literature associates the Lightfoot’s portraiture methodology (Lawrence-Lightfoot &
climate of a classroom with care (Noddings, 1992) and aesthetics Hoffmann Davis, 1997), I used the repeated themes, patterns,
(Greene, 1995), or both (Heid, 2008; Riddett-Moore, 2009; and refrains found from coding the observation and interview
Siegesmund, 2010, 2012). Few articles articulated how to create transcriptions to create a framework for my narrative. In this
an environment where vulnerability would not hinder creativity, article, I weave my perceptions with literature in education to
and as Brown (2012) said in her TED Talk, “Vulnerability is the highlight Rose’s curricular decisions and pedagogical choices
birthplace of innovation, creativity, and change.” Classrooms that that encouraged her students to take risks and embrace their
engage students in the creative process of artmaking and promote vulnerability.
creativity require students to be vulnerable. How do we enable
students to embrace the vulnerability of artmaking to enhance Visual Journals as a Safe Curricular Choice
their creativity? During my time in Rose’s classroom I observed students
flourish socially with acceptance and belonging, emotionally
In the pursuit of understanding how to create a psychologically
without anxiety of rejection, and intellectually with nuanced
safe art classroom for students, I conducted a descriptive case
understandings of artistic processes in conception, creation, and
study of a high school visual arts teacher. Emily Rose,1 lovingly
perception. By utilizing visual journals as a key feature in her
referred to as Rose by her students, is known for creating a “safe
curriculum, Rose provided a safe space for creative risk-taking in
haven” in her classroom. Through three months of observations,2
her classroom (Figure 2 and Figure 3).
and six interviews, I explored how Rose created a psychologically
12 Art Education
Downloaded by [Ohio State University Libraries] at 08:59 27 December 2017
Figure 3. Jamie Lane’s visual journal entry depicts an artistic investigation of her lived experiences.
September 2017 13
The visual journal is a reflective altered-book (or sketchbook)
that students used to document and express their lived experiences
(Figure 4 and Figure 5). Student visual journals were used not
only to make critical and aesthetic judgments about the world, but
also to focus on the process of artmaking rather than just the final
product. Visual journals gave freedom to explore ideas, experiment
with materials, and discover techniques; they also allowed multiple
opportunities for fresh starts. While visual journals are shared
with other students and teachers, in Rose’s classroom students
controlled which pages to share. Consequently, visual journals were
a low stakes assignment (Elbow, 1997a) that allowed students to
work out ideas visually and verbally, without the associated sense
of failure if a larger assignment did not meet their expectations
(Figure 6). Elbow (1997a) encouraged low stakes assignments,
informal and frequent assignments that have little impact on a
Downloaded by [Ohio State University Libraries] at 08:59 27 December 2017
Figure 5. Kaitlynn Mockett’s visual journal entry illustrates creative risk taking by exploring the marriage
of images and words.
14 Art Education
Figure 6. Rebecca Bower’s exploration of wasted materials
illustrates the potential of creative risks.
September 2017 15
Table 1. Guiding questions for designing a curriculum to Rose created a learning opportunity by noticing the details in
create a psychologically safe classroom her student’s journal and her student’s life. Rose demonstrated the
Minimal grading ● Do you provide multiple need to perceive work in her students’ journals. For John Dewey
opportunities for graded and non- (1934), recognition was the beginning of perception. Recognition
graded feedback for in-progress occurs when we see something and then stop thinking about it
assignments? because it fits into a previously formed schema (Dewey, 1934).
● Do you allow students to select which Perception, going further, requires heightened consciousness and
entries they will be graded on? continued looking (Figure 8). Developing heightened awareness
and consciousness helps students experience, learn, and grow, and
● Do you give non-graded feedback on
assignments to encourage students according to Maxine Greene (1995) it is the teacher’s responsibility
to take creative risks? to develop this skill. Rose used her ability to notice or perceive
details to build students’ confidence and develop relationships,
Writing to learn ● Do you create opportunities for
which helped to create a psychologically safe classroom
artistic exploration of ideas, materials,
environment (Table 2).
and techniques in your classroom?
Developing Relationships
Downloaded by [Ohio State University Libraries] at 08:59 27 December 2017
Noticing Details
In this interaction, Rose modeled how important perceiving
details is for artists and for students. Rose believed that to develop
a positive class climate, attention to individuals, attention to parts
of their art, and attention to social interactions between students
were necessary (E. Rose, personal communication, December
10, 2010). When Rose viewed the visual journal, she celebrated
not only the product of art that her student provided, but also
celebrated the process of making and perceiving the new journal
entries.
Modeling the process of perception was important in Rose’s
development of a psychologically safe environment. Learning to
reason through perception is an essential outcome of art education
(Siegesmund, 1998, p. 209). Richard Siegesmund (1998) advocated
that students’ ability to perceive the surrounding world, and to
act with reason on those perceptions, is vital to success. He stated,
“The role of the artist and poet is to help us to see, to take note, to
notice” (Siegesmund, 1998, p. 209). Because reasoned perception is Figure 8. Visual journal entry about perception by Rebecca
needed in the arts, scaffolding this process is important. Bowers.
16 Art Education
Table 2. Guiding questions for noticing details to create a
psychologically safe classroom
Attend to students as ● Do you ask students what kind of
individuals feedback they desire when working
on a piece? Can you evaluate this
topic in formative and summative
assessments?
● Do you use open-ended assignments
to learn about your students?
● How do your students receive
feedback? Do they prefer written
feedback or verbal conversations?
Figure 9. Visual journal entry about relationships by Emily Rose.
● How do you document your student’s
transformation in skills, ideas, and
engagement? which are important in establishing a safe environment (Carter,
Downloaded by [Ohio State University Libraries] at 08:59 27 December 2017
September 2017 17
These standards indicate that creative risk-taking is a life skill
that should be developed in visual arts classes.
The Vulnerable Risk of Creativity [E]ducation always involves a risk…. The risk is not that
students might fail because they are not working hard
I observed how Rose created a safe space for her students
enough or are lacking motivation…. The risk is there because
emotionally, socially, and intellectually using visual journals
education is not an interaction between robots, but an
(Figure 10). Seeing the importance of a teacher’s reaction, I
encounter between human beings…. [I]f we take the risk out
understood the vulnerability of a student differently than I did of education, there is a real chance that we take out education
in my own classroom. If perception is essential to art education, altogether. (p. 1)
as Siegesmund (1998) expressed, then the act of viewing and
Because the art classroom promotes risk-taking as a part of
responding to artwork with students becomes an essential part
education, art teachers have an opportunity to teach students how
of teaching. Teachers have multiple opportunities to model
to try new things and learn from these trials, no matter the result.
the process of qualitative reasoning with students beyond just
Creating a space in which learning is possible also enables our
Downloaded by [Ohio State University Libraries] at 08:59 27 December 2017
critiquing work of famous artists. The art teacher can create a safe
students to benefit from the beautiful risk of education in the art
space for students to engage in creative acts by modeling their own
room and in life. n
process of noticing details, viewing relationships, and articulating
the connections between viewing art and making art. Engaging in Author Note
dialogue about their work and the artistic process helps make the I thank Emily Rose for allowing me to observe months of teaching, Lara Lackey
social, emotional, and intellectual nature of the arts transparent for her encouragement and feedback, and my Critical Friends for suggestions to
for students. While much of Rose’s pedagogy created a safe space strengthen this article.
for students, her choice to view the journal with her students
demonstrated how vulnerability can be an act of courage and how Libba Willcox is Assistant Professor in Art Education, Valdosta State
risk-taking is necessary for both teachers and students. University, Valdosta, Georgia. E-mail: libba.willcox@gmail.com
In 2014, the National Coalition for Core Art Standards
released standards for the visual arts promoting a relational
understanding of the processes involved in art education. These References
process-oriented standards acknowledge the overlapping spaces Biesta, G. J. (2004). Mind the gap and Dewey, J. (1934). Art as experience.
of creating, responding, and presenting and emphasize the essential the educational relation. In C. W. New York, NY: The Berkley
Bingham & A. M. Sidorkin (Eds.), Publishing Group.
role these processes play in making connections. These standards No education without relation (pp. Elbow, P. (1997a). High stakes and low
emphasize the need to support creativity and creative risks. For 11-22). New York, NY: Peter Lang. stakes in assigning and responding
example, standard #VA:Cr1.1 poses essential questions such as Biesta, G. J. (2013). The beautiful risk to writing. New Directions for
“What conditions, attitudes, and behaviors support creativity and of education. Boulder, CO: Paradigm Teaching and Learning, 69, 5-13.
Publishers. Elbow, P. (1997b). Grading student
innovative thinking?” and “What factors prevent or encourage
Blatt-Gross, C. (2010). Casting writing: Making it simpler, fairer,
people to take creative risks?” These standards indicate that the conceptual net: Cognitive clearer. New Directions for Teaching
creative risk-taking is a life skill that should be developed in visual possibilities for embracing the and Learning, 69, 127-140.
social and emotional richness of art Evertson, C., & Emmer, E.
arts classes. Further, these standards establish teaching creative
education. Studies in Art Education, (1982). Preventative classroom
risk-taking as the art teacher’s responsibility. 51(4), 353-367. management. In D. L. Duke
Encouraging creative risk-taking increases vulnerability for the Broome, J. L. (2013). A case study in (Ed.), Helping teachers manage
classroom management and school classrooms (pp. 2-31). Arlington,
student and the teacher. While vulnerability could be viewed as a involvement: Designing an art room VA: Association for Supervision and
destructive feeling in the art room, one that can initiate shame, I for effective learning. Art Education, Curriculum Development.
argue vulnerability and risk-taking are linked to creativity and are 66(3), 39-46. Gottschalk, K., & Hjortshoj, K.
essential to art education. Brown, B. (2006). Shame resilience (2004). The elements of teaching
theory: A grounded theory study writing: A resource for instructors in
The 2014 standards created an opportunity for art teachers on women and shame. Families in all disciplines. Boston, MA: Bedford/
Society: The Journal of Contemporary St. Martins.
to scaffold creative risk-taking, enabling students to learn
Social Services, 87(1), 43-52. Greene, M. (1995). Releasing the
how to embrace their vulnerabilities in the art room. As Rose Brown, B. (2012). Listening to shame. imagination: Essays on education,
demonstrated using visual journals in her curriculum, creating a TED talk: Ideas worth spreading the arts, and social change. San
safe environment does not eliminate risks. Rather, it establishes a [video podcast]. Retrieved from Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
www.brenebrown.com/welcome Heid, K. (2008). Care, sociocultural
space for students to take risks, and embrace “failures” as learning
Carter, M. (2007). Making your practice, and aesthetic experience
opportunities. Illustrating the educational importance of risks, environment “The third teacher.” in the art classroom. Visual Arts
Biesta (2013) stated: Exchange, 176, 22-26. Research, 34(1), 87-98.
18 Art Education
Downloaded by [Ohio State University Libraries] at 08:59 27 December 2017
Horsch, P., Chen, J., & Nelson, D. Noddings, N. (1992). The challenge Siegesmund, R. (2010). Aesthetics as
(1999). Rules and rituals: Tools for to care in schools: An alternative a curriculum of care and responsible Endnotes
creating a respectful, caring learning approach to education. New York, choice. In T. Costantino & B. White
Emily Rose is a pseudonym for the
1
community. Phi Delta Kappan, NY: Teachers College Press. (Eds.), Essays on aesthetic education
teacher whom I researched.
81(3), 223-227. Pinkston, J. W. (1989). Thoreau and for the 21st century (pp. 81-92).
Boston, MA: Sense Publishers. I observed Rose’s high school visual
2
Lawrence-Lightfoot, S., & Hoffmann current trends in the teaching of
design, advanced art, and Advanced
Davis, J. (1997). The art and science writing. The English Journal, 78(7), Siegesmund, R. (2012). Emergent
Placement (AP) art classes between
of portraiture. San Francisco, CA: 50-52. outcomes: Inquiry, qualitative
November 2010 and January 2011.
Jossey-Bass. Riddett-Moore, K. (2009). reasoning and the aesthetics of care.
McMahon, S. D., & Wernsman, J. Encouraging empathy through In G. Graville (Ed.), Art education
(2009). The relation of classroom aesthetic engagement: An art lesson and contemporary culture: Irish,
environment and school belonging in living compositions. International experiences, and international
to academic self-efficacy among Journal of Education & The Arts, 10 perspectives (pp. 263-282). Bristol,
urban fourth- and fifth-grade (Portrayal 2), 1-22. England: Intellect.
students. The Elementary School Siegesmund, R. (1998). Why do we Susi, F. (1986). Physical space and
Journal, 109(3), 267-281. teach art today? Conceptions of art the teaching of art. Art Education,
National Core Art Standards: A education and their justification. 39(2), 6-9.
Conceptual Framework for Arts Studies in Art Education, 39(3), Susi, F. (1996). Becoming a behavior-
Learning. (2014). Retrieved from 197-214. minded art teacher. Art Education,
www.nationalartsstandards.org/ Siegesmund, R. (2004). Somatic 49(5), 62-68.
content/resources knowledge and qualitative Susi, F. (2002). Behavior management:
reasoning: From theory to practice. Principles and guidelines for art
The Journal of Aesthetic Education, educators. Art Education, 55(1),
38(4), 80-96. 40-45.
September 2017 19