Juanita Jackson

February 23, 2010

Reaction to Harry Emerson Fosdick’s Sermon, “Shall the Fundamentalists Win?”

It is evident that Fosdick’s sermon or thoughts have had a great impact on the Christian church and
society in America. Today more people, even professing Christians, have their own way of looking
at the Word of God; they manipulate it to suit their fleshly sensibilities and natural understanding.
Liberal thought has inundated practically every aspect of our society and the church. The church
has lapped up so much of the world’s culture that many professing Christianity question or disagree
with the very foundation of the faith. In fact, it is getting harder and harder to tell the believers
from the unbelievers.

Another point of influence is Fosdick’s continued use of the “watch words” intolerance and
tolerance. This is a word that has been used to bring guilt for not supporting unbiblical beliefs and
what God calls sin. If you do not go along with what the world decides is right (it’s your thing do
what you want to do) then you are branded as intolerant. This intolerance idea has permeated the
Christian church and shackled many to the point they refuse to stand up and tell the truth
regarding not only sin but also who a true Christian is. They see and hear the unscriptural and
refuse to speak out against it under the excuse of false love. Just as our society rejects anyone who
speaks the truth, so goes the backbone of the church to stand up for what is right (this is as a
majority; i know there are still some who are not afraid to stand for what is right).

Jesus is the Word of God and nothing was made without Him (John 1:1-5). If we do not believe the
infallible Word of God then we are not Christians. We may use the “name” but we are not true
Disciples of Christ. Those who would cast off the virgin birth as fact are not Christians. To reject
the second coming of Christ as portrayed in the Holy Scriptures is to call the Lord a liar; therefore,
they are not Christians. The Bible says all scripture is infallible and given by inspiration of God (2
Timothy 3:16, 2 Peter 1:20-21 etc… ). The Bible says that Jesus was born of a virgin (Isaiah 7:14,
Matt 1:18-25, Luke 1:26-35, Gal 4:4 etc…). The Bible says that Christ will return again; there are
numerous passages regarding this including Acts 1:11, Titus 2:13, Luke 21:25-28, and Matt 24:27,
36-44. To reject the Bible is to reject Christ; therefore, if we do so, we are not Christians.

Knowledge/Science has its place. For true believers knowledge such as this strengthens the belief
in God and His Word. We are not to walk in the “vanity of our minds” (Eph 4:17...), using the
knowledge we obtain to inflate our heads with arrogant pride and reject our creator (Romans 1). If
anyone comes into the church with “facts” that do not coincide with the facts given us in scripture
then we are not to "tolerate" it. If they will not accept the flawlessness of God’s Word then we
should not continue to listen to them; we are actually instructed to avoid those who believe
contrary to the sound doctrine we have been given (Romans 16:17-18). A little bit of truth mixed
with a lie is detrimental to those who hear it; it is deception and we are to guard against that.

Liberal thought as been around in some form since the Bible days; John stood against the Gnostic
thought trying to permeate the church in his day. We are also given numerous warning concerning
those who would be in our midst spreading drivel in attempt to lead Disciples of Christ away (Acts
20:28-31, 2 Peter 2:1-3,). The Fundamentalists of the 20s and beyond were/are not wrong to
combat Liberal thought of their (our) day. The scripture instructs us to bring open rebuke on those
who sin (including those who commit the sin of teaching erroneous doctrine) even putting them out
of the congregation if necessary (Prov 27:5, 1 Tim 1:20, 1 Tim 5:20).

I would that someone had reminded Fosdick of 2 Corinthians 11:13-15 and explained to him that
the root of his sheep coated sermon is a lack of faith. It all boils down to faith for those who would
Juanita Jackson
February 23, 2010
Reaction to Harry Emerson Fosdick’s Sermon, “Shall the Fundamentalists Win?”

truly follow Christ. We cannot be Christians without faith in God and His Word. Faith is the
substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen (Heb 11:1). Faith allows us to stand
with God when the world and its philosophies, opinions, feelings, and scientific reports would try
and coerce us otherwise. It takes faith to be a true disciple of Jesus Christ. Those who would try
and redefine scripture to sooth their own itching ears do not have faith; therefore, they do not
have God. They may have a form of godliness, but they deny the power. Followers of Christ must
turn away from them (2Timothy 3: 1-17).

Copyright 2010