You are on page 1of 55

HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics

Summary

1. Earth-based observations
 Discuss Galileo’s use of the telescope to identify features of the Moon

Galilei Galileo did not invent the telescope, but he improved its design. He built refracting
(lens) telescopes, which formed upright images and also covered the edges of his telescope to
reduce spherical aberration and form clearer images.

Galileo identified and gather evidence on:


-the moons of Jupiter
-the phases of Venus
-sunspots on the sun,
-many ‘new’ stars
-the rings of Saturn
-features of the moon

In particular, he was able to make qualitative and quantitative observations of geographical


features of the moon. This included mountains, craters and lava flows which he called ‘seas’.
This provided evidence against the (then) popular view that all heavenly objects were perfect
and unchanging.

 Discuss why some wavebands can be more easily detected from space

Almost all information from space comes in the form of EMR. The EMR spectrum is divided
into ‘wavebands’. Each particular waveband covers a specific range of wavelengths in the
EM spectrum. The Earth’s atmosphere absorbs, diffracts and scatters some wavebands more
than others.

The high energy gamma and x-rays ionise molecules and are therefore strongly absorbed by
the upper atmosphere. Most UV radiation is absorbed by the ozone layer while some
penetrates to the ground. Water vapour and gases in the atmosphere reflect most of the
infrared radiation. Visible light and most radio waves are able to fully penetrate to the ground

This limits ground-based astronomy to the visible and radio wavebands. In order to study the
other EMR effectively, one must go above the atmosphere. Infrared radiation can be studied
by placing infrared telescopes on mountaintops above the densest regions of the atmosphere.

Robert Lee Chin Page | 1


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

Absorption of EMR wavebands by the Atmosphere:

Visibl
Gamma X-rays UV e Infra
Microwave Radio
red

100

Ionosphere
90

80

70

Altitude (km) Mesosphere

60

50

40

Ozone layer
30

20

10

Wavelength

 Define the terms ‘resolution’ and ‘sensitivity’ of telescopes

Resolution
Resolution aka ‘resolving power’ is a measure of a telescope’s ability to clearly distinguish
between two very close objects in space. When this occurs, the objects are said to be resolved.

Robert Lee Chin Page | 2


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

Telescope resolution is limited by:


-imperfections in the lens/mirror
-diffraction i.e. ‘bending’ of light around objects or through gaps

Resolution is quantitatively defined by the angle of separation between two light wavefronts
e.g. a binary star. It is measured in radians or arcs seconds. The resolving power of a
telescope is given by. The smaller the angle of resolution, the greater the resolving power.
Hence, a smaller wavelength and larger diameter size improve resolution.

Two light sources that have been Two light sources with overlapping
resolved have separate diffraction diffraction fringes cannot be resolved

Sensitivity
Sensitivity is a measure of the ‘light gathering’ power of a telescope i.e. its ability to clearly
detect photons from sources in space- the more light that can be detected, the fainter the
object that can be seen. The sensitivity of a telescope is the minimum intensity of light that
needs to be detected to form a suitable image. Quantitatively, sensitivity is proportional to the
surface area of the aperture. Telescopes with large apertures are nicknamed “light buckets”

 Discuss the problems associated with ground-based astronomy in terms of resolution


and absorption of radiation and atmospheric distortion

Atmospheric Distortion
Ground-based telescopes view space from beneath the dynamic mixture of gases, dust and
water vapour of the atmosphere. Variations in temperature and pressure with altitude cause
corresponding changes in the refractive index, causing stars to ‘twinkle’. Or more correctly,
the object shimmers in and out of focus, lowering the resolution of the telescope. The true
colour of images is altered due to variations in absorption with wavelength. Objects lower in
the sky are even more susceptible because the light has to travel through more atmosphere to
reach the ground. The atmosphere also scatters unwanted light from nearby cities and vehicles
into the telescope.

Absorption of radiation
Gamma rays, x-rays, UV, some infrared and the longer wavelength radio waves are absorbed
and scattered by the atmosphere. This means the intensity of these EMR reaching the ground
is very low, so ground-based astronomy is very difficult. Furthermore, much light from the
violet end of the visible waveband is scattered (making the sky blue) so optical astronomy is
impossible during daytime.

 Outline methods by which the resolution and/or sensitivity of ground-based systems


can be improved, including:

Robert Lee Chin Page | 3


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary
-adaptive optics
-interferometry
-Active optics

The easiest approach to reduce atmospheric distortion is to place the telescope as high in the
atmosphere as possible. This means placing telescopes on very high mountaintops, above the
densest regions of the atmosphere. Another advantage is the remoteness means there are no
unwanted light sources from human activity.

Active Optics
Active optics aims to increase sensitivity by compensating for imperfections in the telescope
mirror. Sensitivity is proportional to the surface area of the mirror; however, larger mirrors
are more susceptible to distortion and the thicker it needs to be. Active optics uses many
small composite mirrors, each controlled by its own actuator which pushes or pulls on the
back of the mirror to ‘actively’ adjusting its shape accordingly. The mirrors are adjusted about
once a minute.

One of the best examples is the Keck observatory, at the top of an extinct Hawaiian Volcano,
‘Mauna Kea’. It comprises of 36 hexagonal mirrors to give the same sensitivity as a 10m
diameter mirror.

The Keck
Observatory
telescope mirror

Adaptive Optics
Adaptive optics aims to increase resolution
by measuring and compensating for atmospheric
distortion. Similar to active optics, adaptive optics
uses actuator-controlled composite mirrors but has much faster
response speed. It involves sampling part of the incident light using a wavefront
sensor to measure the amount of atmospheric distortion. The system relies on a bright
reference star or artificial laser pulse to detect this distortion. The mirrors are adjusted using
actuators, up to 1000 times per second, effectively ‘neutralising’ atmospheric changes.

Robert Lee Chin Page | 4


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

Interferometry
Resolution depends on the diameter of the
aperture. Interferometry uses the principle of
several small telescopes linked in an array to
give a higher
resolution
. The device
The shape of the mirror constantly changes to used is called
keep the rays of light at one focal point an Diameter ‘x’
interfero
meter and is most
commonl
y used in radio telescopes because they can be linked over
great distances.

Resolution of two mirrors in interferometer


mode separated by ‘x’ is equal to a single
mirror with diameter ‘x’

Radio interferometry works by combining the same radio sources (which are slightly ‘out of
phase’ due to time differences) electronically, so that they interfere by superposition.

Radio telescopes in different continents (and even satellites) can be linked to from a very long
baseline (up to 3 times the Earths diameter). This technique is called very large baseline
interferometry (VLBI) and it used to produce extremely high resolutions.

Optical interferometry aims to produce a brighter image by using constructive interference of


the incoming wavefronts. It is mainly used for determining stellar distances and diameters.

 Gather, process and present information on the next generation optical telescopes

The next generation telescopes are designed to have lighter, larger mirrors than before. This
allows astronomers to view fainter objects with higher resolution and ensures stability in the
mirrors.

Spin casting and rotating mercury

Robert Lee Chin Page | 5


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary
Lighter mirrors can be made by spinning the glass into a hyperbolic shape as it cools.

A new generation of parabolic mirrors uses rotating liquid mercury and gallium alloys. The
layer is only 2mm thick and they are low cost compared to conventional mirrors. They are
restricted to facing only directly upwards and objects cannot be tracked.

Thin and replica mirrors


A recent development in mirrors is the production of 1mm thick mirrors made from curved
sheet-glass attached to a honeycomb backing structure. A prototype has already been
fabricated for the HST’s successor, the James Webb Space telescope, expected to be launched
in 2014.

Another technique involves replicating pre-existing mirrors by applying a graphite reinforced


honeycomb composite (GRHC). When the GRHC cures, it is used as a ‘template’ for new
mirrors.

Extremely large telescopes: The ‘Giant Magellan telescope’ (GMT), Thirty Meter
Telescope (TMT) and European-Extremely large telescope (E-ELT)
The largest, the E-ELT has a diameter of 42 metres and is predicted to be 15 times more
sensitive than the current largest 10 metre Keck telescopes. The TMT has a 30 metre diameter
and the GMT has a 24.5 metre mirror. They are expected to be completed by 2020.

All rely on adaptive optics to make their resolution as powerful as any space based
observatories.

 Identify data sources, plan, choose equipment or resources for, and perform an
investigation to demonstrate why it is desirable for telescopes to have a larger
diameter objective lens or mirror in terms of both sensitivity and resolution

Investigation: Aperture size and its effect on sensitivity and resolution

Aim: To demonstrate why it is desirable for telescopes to have large diameter aperture in
terms of sensitivity and resolution

Resolution
The following table summarises data on a range of telescopes
Telescope Primary mirror SA primary Theoretical Theoretical
diameter (m) mirror (m ) 2 resolution gain in
(arcseconds) magnitudes
Human eye 0.007 0.001 17 0
6 inch refractor 0.15 0.02 0.8 7
Faulkes 2.0 3 0.06 12
Telescope
Anglo-Australi 3.9 12 0.03 14
an telescope
Keck telescope 10 79 0.01 16

Robert Lee Chin Page | 6


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

Note: The gain in magnitudes is related to the sensitivity. A more sensitive telescope can
detect objects many magnitudes fainter than the human eye.

Describe the relationship between sensitivity and mirror diameter.


As mirror diameter increases, the sensitivity increases.

Plot the theoretical gain in magnitude against SA primary mirror and describe the
relationship
As the SA increases, the gain in magnitude (i.e. the sensitivity) increases.

Plot the theoretical resolution vs. Aperture diameter and describe the relationship

Robert Lee Chin Page | 7


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

It is observed that as the mirror diameter increases, the angle of theoretical resolution
decreases i.e. as diameter increases, resolution increases.

2. Parallax

 Define the terms parallax, parsec, light-year

Parallax is the change in apparent position of a nearby object viewed along two different lines
of sight. Quantitatively, it is measured as the angle between the two lines. Trigonometric
parallax is half the annual parallax.

Viewpoint A

Viewpoint A Viewpoint B

Viewpoint B

A parsec is an astronomical unit of distance. It is defined as the distance away a star would
need to be in order for its annual parallax to be 1 degree. In terms of annual parallax, a parsec
is the distance at which the radius of Earth’s orbit subtends and angle of 1 degree.

Definition of a parsec:

Robert Lee Chin Page | 8


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

1 arc second
1 AU

1 parsec

A light year is an astronomical unit of distance. It is defined as the straight line distance light
travels in a vacuum in 1 year. .

Converting AU to parsecs

 Explain how trigonometric parallax can be used to determine the distance to stars

Trigonometric parallax is half the angular shift of a star (in arc seconds) as observed from
Earth over a period of 6 months i.e. half the annual parallax. Because even our closest stars
are so distant, a considerable change in the observer’s position is required to notice any
change in the star’s relative position. By observing parallax in 6 month intervals (from
opposite points of the Earth), the change in the observer’s position becomes twice
Earth-to-Sun distance or 2 Astronomical Units (AU). Observing 6 months apart maximises
the parallax angle by maximising the baseline and neutralises the slight eccentricity of Earth’s
orbit

Robert Lee Chin Page | 9


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

p
2 AU
 = Sun
 = Earth
d
= nearby star

= distant star

Using trigonometry,, d is the unknown distance from the Sun to the Star and p is the
trigonometric parallax angle. Therefore d can be calculated by .

 Solve problems and analyse information to calculate the distance to a star given its
trigonometric parallax using:
Using the above example, when the parallax of the star (p) is 1 arc second, then the distance d
in parsecs is given by . Remember:

Examples:
1) The star 40-Eridini is 5 pc away. Calculate its parallax in:
a) Arc seconds.

b) Degrees

c) A star has a parallax of 0.3 arc seconds. Calculate its distance from the Earth
in:

a) parsecs

Robert Lee Chin Page | 10


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

b) light years

 Discuss the limitations of trigonometric parallax measurements

The ‘seeing’ or ‘shimmering’ effect of Earth’s atmosphere limits the precision of parallax
measurements. The smallest parallax that can be observed from Earth is ≈0.01 arc seconds.
This means only about 700 of the closest stars (within 100 pc) can be measured by
Earth-based telescopes. The limitations can be lessened by using space-based telescopes
above the atmosphere or by using a larger baseline for the annual parallax e.g. placing a
satellite in orbit around the sun at a distance from Earth’s orbit.

Using a satellite to give a


larger baseline
 Gather and process information to
determine the relative limits to trigonometric parallax distance determinations using
recent ground-based and space-based technologies

Resolution of ground-based telescopes is currently limited to 0.01 arcseconds (100 pcs), due
to atmospheric distortion. Only about 1000 stars within 20 parsecs can be accurately
measured.

Space based telescopes do not suffer atmospheric distortion, so parallax measurements are
determined by the quality and size of the aperture. In 1989, the European Space Agency
(ESA) launched the Hipparcos satellite, which has catalogued accurate parallax
measurements down to 1 milli-arcsecond (mas) for distance measurements of ≈120 000 stars
out to about 1000 pcs.

Future space telescopes include Gaia and the Space Interferometry Mission (SIM). GAIA has
an accuracy of 10 micro arcseconds (10-5 arcsec) and will catalogue over 1 billion stars
within distances of 100 000 pcs while SIM will use optical interferometry to give parallax of
4 micro arcseconds within 10% accuracy of distances up to 25 000 pcs. The data collected
will allow for a dynamic 3D map of the Milky Way.

Robert Lee Chin Page | 11


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

3. Spectroscopy
 Account for the production of emission and absorption spectra and compare these
with a continuous blackbody spectrum

Emission Spectra
Emission spectra of a chemical element/compound consist only of radiation of a discrete
number of wavelengths. It appears as bright lines against a dark background. This radiation is
produced by hot diffuse gases, such as in a gas discharge tube.

Electrical/heat energy supplied to the atoms/molecules raises the energy level of the electrons.
As the electrons fall back down to their ground state, they emit a quantum of energy which
corresponds to one of the observed wavelengths. The bright lines of emission spectra
correspond to all of the possible energy transitions. The relative intensity of each line depends
on the composition of the gas.

Hot gas
Spectrograph

Emission Spectra for Hydrogen:

Wavelength (nm)
Absorption Spectra
Absorption Spectra
consist of a
Each element has its own unique emission spectra continuous range of
wavelengths, with
discrete gaps at particular wavelengths. It appears as dark lines on a continuous background
of colours. It is produced when a continuous spectrum of light passes through cool gas e.g. in
the Sun, the dark lines result from specific wavelengths being absorbed by cooler gases in the
outer layers.

Atoms/molecules in the gas absorb quantum of energy which corresponds to specific


wavelengths of light. This causes the energy level of the electrons to ‘jump’ before falling
back to ground state, remitting absorbed wavelengths in all directions. Thus, the intensity of
light transmitted at these wavelengths is reduced. The relative intensity of the lines depends
on the size and density of the gas cloud.

Robert Lee Chin Page | 12


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

Cool
gas
Spectrograph

Absorption spectra for hydrogen:

Wavelength (nm)

Continuous Blackbody Spectrum


Blackbody spectrum consists of a continuous range of wavelengths with no lines. It appears
as a continuous ‘rainbow’ of colours. It is produced by thermal emission of hot substances
e.g. the surface of the Sun acts as a blackbody at high temperatures.

The higher the temperature, the shorter wavelength of peak intensity emission i.e. the
maximum intensity is inversely proportional to the temperature of the hot surface. This is

shown by: where, λ is the wavelength (nm) and T is the temperature (K). This

is also why hotter stars appear blue and cooler stars red.

Wavelength (nm)

Robert Lee Chin Page | 13


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary
5000 K

Continuous Blackbody
Spectrum

4000 K
Intensity of
radiation
emitted

3000 K

UV 1000 IR 2000 3000


Visible
Wavelength (nm)
Emission Spectra Absorption Spectra

Consists of radiation of only Consists of a continuous Consists of a continuous


a discrete wavelengths range of wavelengths, with range of wavelengths, with
gaps corresponding to no gaps
discrete wavelengths
Appears as white lines Appears as dark lines against Appears as a continuous
against a dark background a continuous background of range of colours
colours
Produced by hot diffuse Produced when light from a Produced by thermal
gases hot source passes through emission from. solids, liquids
cool gas & high-pressure gases
Wavelengths emitted depend Wavelengths absorbed All wavelengths produced at
on electron energy depend on electron energy varying intensities
transitions of gas atoms transitions of gas atoms
Intensity varies with Intensity varies with Intensity varies smoothly
wavelength, depending on wavelength, depending on with wavelength. The peak
gas composition gas composition and density emission is inversely
proportional to the
temperature

 Describe the technology needed to measure astronomical spectra

A spectroscope is a device used to visually observe spectra. A spectrograph is a device


mounted onto a telescope used to record and measure spectra and the recorded photograph is
called a spectrogram.

A spectrograph or spectroscope consists of three parts:

Robert Lee Chin Page | 14


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

The collimator uses a narrow slit and mirrors or lenses to form a parallel beam of light from a
light source.

The second part disperses the light into its component wavelengths to produce the spectra. It
consists of wither a triangular prism or a diffraction grating which can be further subdivided
into transmission or reflection gratings. Diffraction gratings consist of thousands of parallel
slits per cm which cause the light to spread out into a spectrum. Most modern spectroscopes
use diffraction gratings because they scatter less light and give better resolving power than
prisms.

The third part allows the spectra to be viewed or recorded. It consists of either a telescope, a
focusing mirror with a photographic plate or an electronic image device such as a charged
couple device (CCD). Fibre optics may be used to simultaneously obtain multiple spectra.

Prism spectroscope:
Focussing
slit

Collimator
Transmissi
Viewing on grating:

Reflection grating:

 Identify the general types of spectra produced by stars, emission nebulas, galaxies
and quasars

Stars
Stars act as blackbodies and therefore produce spectra that depend on their surface
temperature according to Plank’s Blackbody radiation. Absorption spectra are produced as the
result of the radiation passing through the star’s cooler atmosphere.

Emission nebulas
Emission nebulae are regions of hot gas (mainly hydrogen) and dust that become heated by
radiation from nearby hot stars. As the electrons in the nebulae drop back to their lower
energy level, they produce emission spectra in the UV, visible, infrared and radio bands
(depending on the nebula composition).

Galaxies
Galaxies consist of up to billions of stars, nebula and planets all circling a common centre.
Therefore, the spectra for galaxies combine the spectra of all these celestial objects. They

Robert Lee Chin Page | 15


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary
emit light from the entire EM spectrum, particularly infrared and radio. Absorption lines of B
and K type stars are common, along with emission lines for hydrogen, nitrogen, carbon and
silicon. Almost all galaxies are moving radially away from the Milky Way, so the spectra are
red-shifted.

Quasars
Quasars are distant ‘point sources’ producing vast amount of radiation across the entire EM
spectrum, but mostly in the radio band. The spectra consist of broad, high-intensity emission
lines that are extremely red-shifted. There are only 1-2 LY across and are believed to be
formed by gas being swallowed up by black holes,

 Describe the key features of stellar spectra and describe how this is used to classify
stars

A stellar spectrum is the spectrum of radiation emitted by a star. Stellar spectra consist of a
black body spectra superimposed with absorption lines characteristic of the elements in the
star’s atmosphere.

The shape of the curve, particularly the position of the peak emission wavelength and the
absorption lines for specific elements indicates the surface temperature.

To produce lines for hydrogen, the temperature must be in the range of 4000-12000K while
helium must be in the 15000-30000K range. Too low temperatures and the electrons will
produce faint absorption lines, too high and the atoms will be completely ionised, again
resulting in no absorption lines.

When different stars are compared, there is a change in colour as luminosity increases. The
coolest stars are red, then orange, yellow, white and blue for the hottest stars.

Stars can thus be classified into spectral class: O, B, A, F, G, K, M (mnemonic: Oh Be A Fine


Girl Kiss Me) from hottest to coolest. There are 10 further subdivisions from hottest to
coolest: A0-A9.

Spectral Class Colour Surface Absorption line Spectral Features


Temperature

O Blue <30 000 K Strong Ionised He


Doubly ionised O, N & C
Weakly ionised H

B Blue-white 30 000-15 000 K Strong He


Weakly H

A White 15 000-10 000 K Strong H


Singly Ionised Mg, Si, Fe, Ca, Ti

Robert Lee Chin Page | 16


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary
F White-yellow 10 000-7000 K Weakly neutral H
Stronger neutral Mg, Si, Fe, Ca, Ti

G Yellow 7000-5000 K Strong metals esp. Ca


Weak H
Many single lines ionised and neutral
metals
K Orange 5000-4000 K Strong metals
Molecules e.g. CH, CN
Almost nonexistent H
M Red 4000-3000 K Strong molecules esp. TiO

Spectral Class Example Star


O5 Naos
B3 Achermar
A7 Altair
F0 Canopus
G5 Capella
K2 Arcturas
M1 Autares

 Describe how spectra can provide information on surface temperature, rotational


and translational velocity, density and chemical composition of stars

Surface Temperature
The surface temperature can be determined by observing the position of the peak wavelength
emission. According to Wien’s Displacement law, where

peak wavelength is inversely proportional to the surface temperature. Therefore stars that are
blue are hotter than stars that are red.

Translational Velocity (relative motion)


The proper velocity of a star relative to the sun is made of two components: the radial
velocity and the translational velocity. The radial velocity is a measure of whether the star is
moving towards us or away and how fast it is moving. Translational velocity is a measure of
the motion of a star across our line of sight.

The radial velocity obtained by observing the Doppler shift of a star, compared to
laboratory-measured spectra. If a star is moving towards us, the wavelengths will contract and
there will be a blue-shift. Conversely, if a star is moving away the wavelengths will ‘stretch
out’ and there will be red-shift. A red-shift indicates the star is moving away while a
blue-shift indicates a star is moving towards us. The faster the radial velocity, the greater the
Doppler shift.

Robert Lee Chin Page | 17


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary
The translational velocity is measured by determining the change in position of the star over
long time periods. The distance of a star obtained from parallax measurements is used to
determine the translational velocity.

Velocity components of a star:


Radial Velocity

Increasing
Distant wavelength (nm)
Proper Velocity
Star

Laboratory measured
Translational
Proper
‘Red shift’ spectra Velocity
motion

‘Blue shift’ spectra


Rotational velocity
Sun If a star is rotating,
then one edge is moving
towards us while the other
is receding. One edge will
therefore be red-shifted and
the other side will be
blue-shifted by the same amount. The centre will not exhibit Doppler shift. Individual
spectral lines are broadened by an amount dependant on the rotational velocity of the star- the
faster it rotates, the more the lines broaden.
Increasing wavelength (nm)

Blue-shift
Non-rotating spectra

No Doppler Earth
Star

Red-shift
In the case of binary
Combined blue and red shift broaden the spectral lines stars, the rotational
velocity around their
centre of mass can be determined using the Doppler Effect. The two stars periodically
approach and recede; hence the spectral lines will be alternately blue-sifted and red-shifted.
From this, the speed of approach and recession can be calculated, which is then used to
determine orbital periods and rotational velocities.

Density
The surface density and therefore surface pressure of a star broadens the spectra lines.
Increased gas pressure produces more rapid collisions between atoms during emission or
absorption of radiation. These collisions result in electrons shifting energy levels, hence

Robert Lee Chin Page | 18


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary
producing broader spectral lines. Dwarf stars with high density produce the broadest spectral
lines whilst super giants produce narrow spectral lines.

Chemical Composition
Each element, ion or molecule has its own characteristic emission lines which represent the
various electron energy levels. These lines are in the same position in a star’s absorption
spectrum. Comparing a star’s absorption lines with the emission lines for known elements
allows the star’s composition to be determined.

 Perform a first-hand investigation to examine a variety of spectra produced by


discharge tubes, reflected sunlight or incandescent filaments

Investigation: Using a CD as a Spectroscope

Aim: To observe and examine a variety of spectra produced by discharge tubes, reflected
sunlight or incandescent filaments.

Equipment:
For the spectroscope: Light sources:
-a silvered CD -tungsten filament light bulb
-cardboard box -Neon light sign
-cardboard tube -Yellow-orange street light (sodium vapour lamp)
-craft knife -Mercury vapour lamp
-aluminium foil -Halogen car light
-sticky tape

-digital camera
-computer, for analysing spectra images

Method:
1/ At night stand 20m from the light source and holding the CD 40cm in front of your
chest look at the reflection of the light on the silvered side of the CD. The bright and
dark lines or regions are emission and absorption lines respectively.

2/ Take a picture of the reflection for later analysis and comparison

Results:

Light source Spectra Features


Tungsten filament light argon
bulb (argon gas)

Robert Lee Chin Page | 19


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary
Neon light sign

Sodium vapour lamp Strong peaks in yellow,

Mercury vapour lamp Strong peaks in yellow,


orange, yellow-green

Halogen car light (xenon xenon


gas)

Conclusion:

 Analyse information to predict the surface temperature of a star from its


intensity/wavelength graph

Examples:

1) The graph shows blackbody radiation curves for three temperatures:

Energy radiated (K) vs. λ (nm)

Robert Lee Chin Page | 20


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

a) Define a black body

A black body is an object that is emits or absorbs radiation perfectly i.e. it emits or absorbs
radiation across the entire EM spectrum, at varying intensities.

b) Explain the relevance to astrophysics of black body radiation

The black body radiation curve can be used to determine the surface temperature of stars.

c) Explain how Wien’s law is used to determine the temperature and composition
of a star
Wien’s law states that the peak wavelength emission of a blackbody is inversely proportional
to its surface temperature i.e. Rearranging, It can be used to predict the surface temperature
of a star:
. From the surface temperature and the colour of the star, the star’s

chemical composition and spectral class can be predicted.

4. Determining distance using photometric measurements


Luminosity is the measure of the power emitted by a star and depends upon the size (radius)
and surface temperature of the star. Given the same temperature, large stars are more
luminous than small stars and given the same radius, hotter stars are more luminous than
cooler stars.

Robert Lee Chin Page | 21


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary
Brightness (I) of a star is a measure of the intensity of radiation reaching Earth from a star.. It
depends on the intrinsic luminosity (L) of the star and its distance (d) away.

Mathematically:

 Define absolute and apparent magnitude

Apparent magnitude (m) is the brightness of a star as observed from Earth. Brighter stars have
lower magnitude and an increase in 1 represents a decrease in apparent brightness of 2.512.

Absolute magnitude (M) is the brightness a star would have when observed from a distance
of 10 parsecs. Absolute and apparent magnitude use the same scale, therefore, more negative
number correspond to higher luminosity. It is estimated by comparison with reference stars of
the same spectral class and known distance (from parallax).

 Explain how the concept of magnitude can be used to determine the distance to a
celestial object

If a star is closer than 10 pc, “m” is larger than M and if it is further than 10 pc., the reverse is
true. The amount by which the absolute magnitude (M) and apparent magnitude (m) differ
depends on the star. If both m and M are known, the difference modulus can be used to
calculate the distance to a star:

For stars closer than 10 pc, the distance modulus is negative, while for stars further than 10
pc, it is positive.

Solve problems and analyse information using and


to calculate the absolute or apparent magnitude of stars using data and a reference
star

Examples:

1) Our Sun has an apparent visual magnitude of -26.5 and an absolute visual
magnitude of +4.83. Explain why these magnitudes are different

Apparent magnitude is a measure of the intensity as viewed from Earth whereas absolute
magnitude is a measure of the intensity when viewed at a distance of 10 parsecs. The more
negative the value for absolute or apparent magnitude the more negative the value. Therefore,
because we are closer to the Sun than 10 pc, the apparent visual magnitude of the Sun is
negative while its absolute magnitude is positive i.e.

2) A star of the sixth magnitude is located 40pc from the Sun. Calculate its absolute
magnitude

Robert Lee Chin Page | 22


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

A star has an apparent magnitude of +8 and an absolute magnitude of 0. Calculate the


parallax of them star.

3) Use the table to answer the following questions

Star Apparent magnitude (m) Absolute magnitude (M)


Arcturus 0.00 -0.3
Betelgeuse +0.41 -5.6
Hadar +0.63 -5.2
Sirius -1.51 +1.4
Vega +0.04 +0.5

a) Identify which star is the brightest to an observer on the Earth. Explain your
answer.

For an observer on Earth, we use the apparent magnitude. The more negative the value, the
brighter the star appears. Therefore, the brightest star to an Earth observer is Sirius, with
m=-1.51

Robert Lee Chin Page | 23


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

b) Calculate the distance to Vega

c) Calculate how much brighter Betelgeuse appears than Hadar

d) Calculate how much brighter Betelgeuse actually is compared to Hadar.

 Outline spectroscopic parallax

Stereoscopic parallax is a technique used to determine the distance to a star by comparing the
absolute and apparent magnitude. The term “parallax” is simply an analogy for distance.

A star’s spectrum indicates its spectral class or temperature, which are located on the
horizontal axis of a Hertzprung-Russel diagram and its luminosity, located on the vertical
axis. By finding the position where the lines intercept, the absolute magnitude (on vertical
axis) can be determined. The apparent magnitude can be directly-measured using photometry.

Robert Lee Chin Page | 24


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary
The distance modulus equation can then be used to determine the distance in pc. This method
is not precise, but is useful as an estimation of distances to stars.

 Explain how two-colour values (i.e. colour index, B-V) are obtained and why they
are useful

Colour index values are useful because they allow the surface temperature of starts to be
determined without spectra.

Stars may have 3 different magnitudes depending on the instruments used to view them: the
human eye, a photographic emulsion (light-sensitive colloid) or a photocell. The eye is most
sensitive to yellow-green light; photographic emulsions are most sensitive to blue-violet light;
photocells perform well at all wavelengths. Hence, a blue star would appear brighter on a
photograph than to the eye.

Blue or photographic magnitude (B) is the magnitude of a star measured through a blue filter
so it only allows wavelengths of ~440 nm to pass through. The visual magnitude (V) is
measured through a yellow-green filter which allows wavelengths of ≈550 nm to pass
through.

The colour index is the difference between the photographic and visual magnitude i.e. . It
follows that if is positive (, then the star will be redder and therefore, cooler. If is negative (,
then the star will be bluer and therefore, hotter.

Colour Index: Relative size of Relative Colour Relative Relative


magnitudes temperature Spectral Class
More positive redder Cooler Towards O
More negative bluer Hotter Towards M

Robert Lee Chin Page | 25


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

B intensity
(440 nm) V intensity
(550 nm)

In the above graph, the star emits more energy in the B waveband than the V waveband.

The colour index is calibrated so that a (white) main sequence star (spectral class A,
luminosity class V) has a CI of 0.00. The CI for hotter stars will be negative CI while for
cooler stars it will be positive.

 Describe the advantages of photoelectric technologies over photographic methods


for photometry

Photographic photometry
Photographic photometry uses visual comparison of star images on photographic plates.
Brighter stars appear larger and denser on the plate and it is possible to obtain photometry for
thousands of stars using a single image, using a laser to scan and produce a digitised image. It

Robert Lee Chin Page | 26


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary
does not calibrate stars accurately; however, it provides higher resolution than photoelectric
devices.

Photoelectric photometry
Photoelectric devices include: photomultiplier and charged-coupled device (CCD).

A photomultiplier (vacuum tube technology) converts weak light into stronger electrical
current. It consists of an evacuated tube, with a thin glass window that allows photons to enter
and hit a photo-cathode. Electrons are emitted in proportion to the light intensity (termed
‘secondary emission’) and a series of 9-14 electrodes (dynodes), of increasing voltage are
used to accelerate the electrons. Secondary emission creates an increasing the number of
photoelectrons and hence, a larger measurable current.
Incoming
photon Photomultiplier:
Thin
window Photo-cathode

+100
+200 V
+300 V
+400 V
+500 V
+600 V
+700 V
Anode to
measuring
device

A CCD (solid-state technology) uses an array of millions of light-sensitive ‘pixels’ on a


silicon chip to measure current. The pixels act as capacitors, storing charge proportional to
the light intensity. The accumulated charge in each capacitor can be rapidly scanned and
analysed via computer.

Advantages of photoelectric over photographic technologies


-Objects can be scanned extremely quickly with quick response time (due to electronic
detectors
-More uniform response across the entire visible spectrum
-Sensitive to a wider range of wavelengths esp. infrared and can be altered to increase
sensitivity for different wavelengths
-Give more accurate measurements of magnitude
-Data can be collected remotely and transmitted digitally
-Data is processed more easily

Robert Lee Chin Page | 27


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

 Solve problems and analyse information using: to calculate the absolute or apparent
magnitude of stars using data and a reference star

Examples:

1) Refer to the table below


Star Apparent Absolute brightness Colour Index (B-V)
Brightness
Sirius -1.45 +1.41 0
Canopus -0.73 -4.70 +0.16
Betelgeuse +0.41 -5.50 +1.15

a) Predict which star appears brightest to us. Explain.


Sirius appears brightest to us. Observing the star from Earth means we need to look at the
apparent brightness. Magnitude is inversely proportional to brightness, hence, the lower the
magnitude, the brighter the star.

b) Predict which star has the highest temperature. Explain.


Stars with more positive colour (indices are hotter. This is because as the value of B
increases, the intensity of light emitted at the blue end of the visible spectrum increases. Blue
stars are hotter than red stars, hence, Canopus has the highest temperature.

c) Calculate the distance to Canopus

d) Calculate the parallax of Canopus

Robert Lee Chin Page | 28


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

e) Predict the likely spectral class for Betelgeuse. Explain.


The colour index for Betelgeuse is positive, meaning that it emits more energy towards the
red end of the visible spectrum than the blue end. Red stars are cooler than blue stars; hence
it is a cool red star. Betelgeuse is most likely to be M-type, A1 spectral class.

2) A star is observed to have an apparent magnitude of 6.0 and is 20 parsecs from


Earth. Calculate its absolute magnitude.

3) Use the table below to answer the following questions


Star Apparent visual Absolute visual Spectral Class
magnitude magnitude
Acturus 0.00 -0.3 K2
Betelgeuse +0.41 -5.6 M2
Hadar +0.63 -5.2 B1
Sirius -1.51 +1.4 A1
Vega +0.04 +0.5 A0

a) Predict which star is hottest. Explain.


Stars with a spectral towards O are hotter. The spectral classes, in order of temperature are O,
B, A, G, K, M. Therefore, Hadar is the hottest star.

b) Predict the colour of Arturus. Explain.


Artucus is spectral class K2, which corresponds to a relatively cool star which emits the
orange waveband of the visible spectrum most intensely.

c) Predict which star is the faintest when viewed from Earth. Explain.

Robert Lee Chin Page | 29


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary
Viewed from Earth refers to the apparent visual magnitude. More positive values for
magnitude correspond to fainter stars. Thus, Hadar is the faintest star when viewed from
Earth.

d) Calculate the distance to Hadar.

 Perform an investigation to demonstrate the use of filters for photometric


measurements.

Aim: To observe the effect of various coloured filters on the brightness of a light source

Equipment:
-Red, Blue and yellow-coloured filters
-data logger with light intensity probe attachment

Method:
1/ Place light meter on flat table in a well-lit room (fluorescent lighting)
2/ To simulate a red star,

Results:

 Identify data sources, gather, process and present information to assess the impact
of improvements in measurement technologies in our understanding of celestial
objects.

Space technology has allowed telescopes to overcome atmospheric distortion. However, these
telescopes are expensive to launch and usually only last several years before falling back to
earth due to orbital decay.

Hubble Space Telescope (HST)


The HST purpose was to photograph nearby stars and distant galaxies to improve our
understanding of the universe. It carried 5 scientific instruments:

Robert Lee Chin Page | 30


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

Instrument Name Purpose/description Observed


wavebands
Wide Field and Planetary 2 optical cameras, each with 4 CCDs Visible
Camera (WF/PC)
WF: wider viewing angle
PC: greater magnification
Goddard High resolution Record spectra in high resolution UV
spectrograph (GHRS)
High speed photometer (HSP) Measure brightness of fast-moving UV, visible
objects
Faint object camera (FOC) High-resolution imaging devices. Used Visible
faint object spectrograph photon-counting digicon rather than
(FOS) CCDs

The impact of these technologies has been:

-to constrain the value of the Hubble constant – the rate of expansion of the universe.
--However, by observing distant supernovae, it found that the rate of expansion of the
universe may be accelerating
-It demonstrated the connection between galaxies and their central black holes
-High-resolution images of the collision of comet shoemaker-Levy 9 in 1994 were
crucial in developing an understanding of the dynamics of comet collisions with
Jupiter
-Discovery of proplyds (dense gas ‘discs’ surrounding newborn stars) and the optical
sources of gamma-ray bursts
- the Hubble-deep and ultra-deep space field images, which utilised the sensitivity of
the HST to obtain optical images of galaxies billion of years away, which has
generated a wealth of scientific papers.

Cosmic Background Explorer (COBE)


COBE’s purpose was to measure the cosmic microwave background radiation (CMB) and
provide measurements to shape our understanding of the cosmos. It carried 3 instruments:

Instrument Name Purpose/description Observed


wavebands
Differential Microwave Microwave instrument designed to map microwave
Radiometer (DMR) variations in the CMB.

Far-Infrared Absolute Spectrophotometer designed to measure the Infrared


Spectrophotometer spectrum of the CMB
(FIRAS)
Diffuse Infrared Multi-wavelength infrared detector designed to Infrared
Background Experiment map dust emission

Robert Lee Chin Page | 31


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary
(DIRBE)

The DMR provided data on the structure formation of the Universe, indicating cluster so
galaxies and vast empty regions. DIRBE detected 10 new IR-emitting galaxies, which were
able to provide data on very cold dust (VCD). It was also able to collect data on interplanetary
dust (IPD) and concluded it originates from asteroids. DIRBE was also able to model the
Galactic disc of the Milky Way, indicating it is not a thick disc. COBE provided important
constraints on the star formation rate, although it was unable to resolve the exact star
formation history, so future observations are necessary.

Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP)


WMAP purpose was to measure temperature variations in the CBM to study the geometry,
content and evolution of the Universe; to test the Big Bang model and cosmic inflation
theory. To achieve this, it had to create an accurate map of the CMB.

Instrument Purpose/description Observed


wavebands
Primary mirror: Opposite facing; focus signal into secondary Radio, microwave
Pair of Gregorian mirrors.
1.4 x 1.6 m
reflecting mirrors
Secondary Transmit signal to receivers
Mirror:
Pair of 0.9 x 1.0
m reflecting
mirrors
Polarisation-sensi A set of 20, divided into groups, using 5 discrete Microwave,
tive differential frequencies; Measure differences between two radio
Radiometers telescope beams
Low-noise Amplify weak incoming signal n/A
amplifiers

WMAP’s measurements have been key to establishing our current model of the cosmos.
Among its achievements include:

-mapping the CMB and producing the first microwave high-resolution map of the sky
-determining the age of the universe to be 13.73 ±0.12 Billion years
-determining that ‘normal atoms called baryons only compose 4.6% of the universe,
23.3±1.3% is ‘dark matter’ and 72±1.5% is ‘dark energy’
-narrowing down the possibilities of what occurred during the first trillionth of a
trillionth (10-24) s, ruling out well-known textbook models

Chandra x-ray telescope

Robert Lee Chin Page | 32


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary
Chandra’s purpose was to observe x-rays from high-energy regions of the universe, such as
supernova remnants

Instrument Purpose/description Observed


wavebands
Wolter telescope Consists of nested hyperbolic and x-ray
parabolic surfaces coated with
iridium/gold, to absorb x-ray photons.
Advanced CCD Imaging 10 CCDs
Spectrometer (CIS
High resolution camera Has two micro channel plates used to
(HRC) detect particles and radiation
High- and low-energy Provides high-resolution spectroscopy
Transmission grating over a wide range in the x-ray
Spectrometer

Data gathered the Chandra has greatly advances the field of x-ray astronomy:

-Images of supernova remnants revealed neuron stars and black holes


-showed for them first time a smaller galaxy being ‘cannibalised’ by a larger galaxy
-x-ray emissions from main sequence stars
-strong evidence for existence of dark matter
-Observations of neutron stars, pulsars, gamma ray bursts, black holes and possible quark
stars

5. Binary and variable stars

 Describe binary stars in terms of the means of their detection: visual, eclipsing,
spectroscopic and astrometric
 Perform an investigation to model the light curves of eclipsing binaries using
computer simulation

Binary stars consist of a pair of stars revolving around a common centre of gravity. They are
grouped according to their method of detection.

Visual Binaries
Visual binaries can be resolved directly via telescope as ellipses traced out relative to
background stars. The mutual separation of the stars is from 100-10 000 AU with an angle of
separation arc seconds. Observations must be made with telescopes of at least 15cm diameter
and a micrometer is used to measure the angle of separation.

Robert Lee Chin Page | 33


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

More massive star


follows a smaller Barycentre
elliptical orbit Eclipsing Binaries
Eclipsing binaries cannot be
resolved via telescope and are
detected by fluctuations in brightness when one star moves in front of the other, and vice
versa.

When the brighter star (blue) moves completely in front of the duller star (red), there is a
slight dip in brightness called a secondary eclipse. When the duller star moves completely in
front of the brighter star, there is a larger dip in brightness, called a primary eclipse.

Light curve for total and partial eclipses:

Intensity Secondary eclipse


Primary
eclipse

Time

Intensity Secondary eclipse Primary


eclipse

Time

A similar situation occurs for a partial eclipse, with the dips being a V-shape, rather than
flat-bottomed.

Spectroscopic binaries

Robert Lee Chin Page | 34


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary
Spectroscopic binaries cannot be resolved via telescope and are detected by the Doppler shift
of their spectra. When one star is approaching, it will produce blue-shift while the other is
receding from the observer and will produce red-shift. The combination of both broadens the
spectral lines. This technique only works when the motion of the stars is transverse to the
observer’s line of sight (will not work if motion is perpendicular). This method is preferred
to visual binaries as there are more distant stars than near stars and because their speeds are
easily measured using Doppler shift.

Red-shift

Blue-shift

Astrometric binaries
Astrometric binaries cannot be resolved properly because only one star is bright enough to
see. The presence of a companion star is inferred by the oscillation or ‘wobbling’ of the
visible star from the mean path of motion due to the gravity of its companion.

Robert Lee Chin Page | 35


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

Path of mean
proper motion
 Explain the importance of binary stars in
determining stellar masses

Binary stars provide virtually the only means of directly


measuring the masses of stars other than the Sun. The
mass of a star is key to determining the processes it
undergoes during its lifecycle and endpoint and is
therefore vital in refining our model of stars.

Applying Kepler’s Laws for a binary system where the


masses of the two stars are similar:

-the stars orbit each other in ellipses with a common centre of motion called the barycentre
-the line joining the two stars (radius vector) covers equal area in equal periods.
-The square of the period is directly proportional to the cube of its radius:

Barycentre
m1
m2 r1
r2

Radius of individual star (if M and R are known)


By definition, at the barycentre:

Robert Lee Chin Page | 36


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

Deriving the formula for total mass of system:

Total mass of system


If T and R are known, use

If T is given in years and R is in AU, use

Individual masses (given M, R and radius of mass)

Robert Lee Chin Page | 37


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

Other useful identities

 Solve problems and analyse information by applying:

Examples:
1) Two stars in a visual binary system have an orbital period of and are
determined to be apart. Calculate the combined mass of the system.

2) [from Question 30, 2004]


An astronomer made regular measurements of the intensity of a star over the course of several
days and obtained the light curve shown below.

(i) Describe the features of this light curve that suggest the astronomer is
observing an eclipsing binary system.
The light intensity of the system varies periodically with time. The ‘dip’ in luminosity
represents when one star moves completely in front of the other, resulting in a decrease in the
intensity or amount of light coming from the system.

Robert Lee Chin Page | 38


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

(ii) If both starts have equal masses of determine the separation of the two stars.

3) From 2006, Question 30


(a)
(i) Describe the spectroscopic observations that would determine whether a
particular star is really a binary system
The spectra of the system would be observed to show both red-shift and blue-shift as one star
recedes while the other approaches, leading to a broadening of the spectral lines. This would
only occur, however, if the system was viewed transverse to the observer’s LOS.

(ii) The graph represents the variation in brightness of a binary star system
Given that the mass of the system is determined to be kg, calculate the average distance
between the stars within the system.

Robert Lee Chin Page | 39


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

 Classify variable stars as either intrinsic or extrinsic and periodic or non-periodic

Variable stars are stars whose brightness, colour or other property varies with time. They are
classified according to the cause of the variation and the periodic nature of the variation.

The brightness of non-periodic variables varies irregularly with time. These include novae
and supernovae

Intrinsic variables are stars whose variation in luminosity is due to physical changes within
the properties of the star itself. Intrinsic stars may be divided into two main subclasses:

*periodic variables
*non-periodic variables (novae and supernovae)

Periodic variables are variables that expand and contract fairly regularly with a defined
period. They can be further subdivided into two main groups:
*cepheids: those that have short, regular periods of days to months (generally blue
stars towards spectral class O)
*long period (Mira Ceti) variables: those with longer, more irregular periods
(generally red giants of spectral class M) and large variations in luminosity

Other examples include RR Lyrae and RV Tauri variables

Irregular period or non-periodic variables can be subdivided into three main groups:
*semi-regular variables: mainly red stars, giants or supergiants which display small
variations in luminosity and constant brightness
*Irregular variables: include most red giants. They have short periods and display
rapid, although small variations in luminosity (include red giants, white dwarfs)
*Eruptive variables: include the novae and supernovae, which display sudden bursts
in luminosity (typically include giants and supergiants, which emit vast quantities of
energy due to their large mass)

Other examples include flare stars, T-Tauri stars and R Coronawe Borealis variables

Extrinsic variables are stars whose variation is due to external properties. They can be divided
into two main subgroups:

Robert Lee Chin Page | 40


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

*Eclipsing variables: periodic changes in luminosity are due to an eclipsing


phenomena
*Rotating variables: whose variability may be caused by a misalignment of the
rotational axis with the magnetic axis, leading to thermal ‘hotspots’ on the surface. It
may also be caused by irregularities in the star’s chromosphere or an ellipsoidal shape.

 Explain the importance of the period-luminosity relationship for determining the


distance of cepheids.

Cepheids are periodic intrinsic variables whose periods of pulsation are proportional to their
luminosity. As they expand, surface temperature increases while luminosity decreases and as
they contract, their surface temperature increases while luminosity decreases.

Typical light curve for a Cepheid:

Light

Time
It has been
found that the maximum intensity occurs just after the minimum radius. Thus, the steep rise
in luminosity is due to the increase in temperature after the star contracts. In 1912, Henrietta
Leavitt discovered the period- luminosity relation, by plotting the luminosity values of
cepheids on a log-log graph.

The period-luminosity relation is given by the equation: , where

Robert Lee Chin Page | 41


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

L is the luminosity, in magnitudes


A is the gradient of the graph
T is the period, in days
B is the y-intercept

Period-Luminosity graph of cepheids:

-6
Type I (classical
cepheids) For cepheids, a definite
relationship exists
Absolute between its period of
magnitude pulsation and luminosity.
Type II
There are two types of
-2
cepheids: Type I
(classical cepheids) and
0 Type II (younger stars
with lower metal content)
10 100
Period, T (days) Hence, if we know the
period of pulsation we
can graphically determine
the absolute magnitude. Combining with the apparent magnitude, we can use the distance
modulus to determine the distance.

Cepheid variables are also observed in other galaxies well beyond the scope of parallax
measurements. Thus, if other galaxies contain cepheids, the distances to those galaxies can be
accurately measured. Cepheid variables have been vital in determining the cosmic expansion
of the Universe.

6. Stellar Evolution

 Describe the processes involved in stellar formation

Protostar

Robert Lee Chin Page | 42


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary
Gravity causes interstellar nebula of gas and molecules to collapse. These nebulas have
diameters of LY and masses of solar masses. If the mass exceeds the “Jeans mass” gravity
overcomes any outward thermal pressure and the clouds begin to collapse.

Protostar:
GPE → heat

During contraction gravitational potential energy converts into heat- a protostar. The star
begins to faintly emit visible red and infrared radiation. The temperature is too low for
nuclear fusion to begin yet but its vast size means it is luminous, placing at the top RH corner
of the H-R diagram.

 Outline the key stages in a star’s life in terms of the physical processes involved

Pre-Main Sequence: dust


and gas are removed by
the stellar wind

Pre-main sequence
Increased temperature increases thermal pressure, opposing gravity and slowing down
contraction. Eventually the protostar reaches a temperature where hydrogen molecules
decompose into atomic hydrogen, allowing further compression and heating to occur. As the
protostar collapses, it rotates and several stars may form by fragmentation to form a cluster.
Surrounding gas and dust are blown away. When maximum luminosity is reached, it is called
a pre-main sequence star.

The mass and composition of interstellar medium determines when and where the star enters
the main sequence (called the “Zero-age main sequence”). The lower the mass, the longer it
takes the star to enter the zero-age main sequence- stars of less than 0.08 solar masses never
reach the temperatures to begin nuclear fusion.
Main Sequence:
Gravity and
outward thermal
pressure are

Robert Lee Chin Page | 43


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

Main Sequence
Once temperature and pressure are high enough for nuclear fusion, the star enters the main
sequence. Outward pressure and gravity are balanced, so the star is stable. Dust and gas not
accreted to the core are removed by the stellar wind. The star begins the process of hydrogen
fusion in its core for energy. It becomes slightly hotter and more luminous as radiation and
particles radiate into space in a stable manner.

 Describe the types of nuclear reactions involved in Main-Sequence and


post-Main Sequence stars

Main-Sequence
Main sequence stars produce energy from the conversion of hydrogen to helium in its core.
There are two nuclear fusion reactions involving hydrogen:

-the proton-proton chain


-the carbon-nitrogen cycle

In both cases, the net effect is the same: 6 protons are involved, two of which are regenerated
while the other four are converted into two helium nuclei, two neutrinos, two positrons and
gamma radiation. The net reaction is:

Proton-Proton (PP) Chain


The PP chain occurs in lower mass, cooler MS stars (less than 20 million Kelvin) and takes
~7 billion years. There are three steps involved:

Robert Lee Chin Page | 44


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

1. Fusion of two protons (hydrogen nuclei) into a deuterium (rare isotope of hydrogen)
nucleus. One proton decays into a neutron, releasing a positron and a neutrino.
Positrons (positive charge) readily ionise, emitting gamma radiation. Neutrinos have
no mass or charge and pass out of the core.

2. Fusion of a deuterium nucleus and a proton to form a helium-3 nucleus, with energy
in the form of gamma rays also emitted.

3. Fusion of two helium-3 nuclei to form a stable helium-4 nucleus and two protons.
These protons may strike other protons and begin the chain reaction again.

The Carbon-Nitrogen (CNO) cycle


The CNO cycle occurs in higher mass, hotter MS stars (more than 30 million K) and takes 7
million years to complete. There are six steps involved:

1. Fusion of a proton and a carbon nucleus to form a nitrogen-13 nucleus and 2 MeV of
energy I the form of gamma radiation.

2. Nitrogen-13 is unstable and decays into Carbon-13, releasing a neutrino and a


position. The positron annihilates itself when it meets an electron, releasing 1 MeV of
energy

3. Fusion of a proton and Carbon-13 to form nitrogen-14, releasing 8 MeV of gamma


radiation.

Robert Lee Chin Page | 45


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary
4.
Fusion of a proton and Nitrogen-14 to form Oxygen-15 and & MeV of gamma
radiation.

5.
Oxygen-15 is unstable and decays into Nitrogen-15, releasing a neutrino, a positron
and 1.7 MeV of energy

6.
Fusion of a proton and Nitrogen-15 to regenerate the carbon nucleus, a helium nucleus
and 0.5 MeV of gamma radiation.

Post-Main sequence
Over time, hydrogen-fusion in main sequence stars produces a helium core and an outer
hydrogen-burning shell. When the hydrogen in the core is depleted, hydrogen fusion cannot
occur and gravity causes the core to collapse. GPE is converted into heat, causing the outer
layers to expand. The brightness of the star gradually decreases as the surface area expands
faster than energy is produced so the star becomes a red giant.

As the core continues to collapse and temperature increases, helium fusion begins explosively
in the ‘helium flash’. This causes the star to contract.

End of MS: inner helium Core collapses due to


core and outer gravity: GPE → heat
energy-producing hydrogen
shell Heat causes outer layers
to expand- the star
begins the Red Giant
stage

Triple Alpha process

Robert Lee Chin Page | 46


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary
In Red Giants, three helium nuclei fuse to form a carbon nucleus in the triple alpha process:

When the core is mainly carbon, helium fuses with carbon to produce an oxygen core. Further
exothermic reactions in the outer hydrogen shell form heavier elements up to iron.

 Discuss the synthesis of elements in stars by fusion

The heat of the Big Bang synthesised only hydrogen and helium. All other elements have
been created by stellar nucleosynthesis.
Further helium is produced in MS stars via hydrogen fusion (PP chain in cooler stars, CNO
cycle in hotter stars).
Helium fusion produces carbon, oxygen, neon and magnesium in post-MS stars via the Triple
Alpha Process i.e. fusion of the product nuclei with alpha particles.
Beyond iron, the reactions are endothermic and occur in the stages beyond Red Giants,
although elements up to lead may be formed by the slow capture neutron process (S-process)
in red giants. All the elements heavier than gold are produced by the rapid capture neutron
process (R-process) in supernova explosions.

 explain how the age of a globular cluster can be determined from its zero-age
main sequence plot for a H-R diagram

Robert Lee Chin Page | 47


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary
Stars in a globular cluster are approximately the same age as they were formed by the same
nebula. This means the stars in the cluster have similar chemical compositions and cover the
entire range of stellar masses. The zero-age main sequence plot shows the stars when they
have just begun the main sequence stage.

Globular clusters are observed to be missing high-mass stars (spectral class O and B). This is
because high-mass stars use their hydrogen more quickly than smaller stars and move off the
main sequence. As a cluster ages, it appears to form a ‘knee’, bending upwards from the right
of the MS. The absolute magnitude at this ‘turn-off’ position is a function of the age of the
cluster.

Thus, the age of a globular cluster can be determined by the position of the massive stars. If
the cluster is:
-old, there will be less of the high-mass stars on the MS
-young, there will be more high-mass stars on the MS

 Explain the concept of star death in relation to:


-planetary nebula
-supernovae
-white dwarfs
-neutron stars/pulsars
-black holes

Star death occurs when nuclear fusion in the core of stars ceases and the outward thermal
pressure due to radiation is overcome by the inward force of gravity. The processes that occur
next depend on the mass of the star.

Low mass stars (2-5 solar masses)


After low-mass stars have begun the helium-burning stage, oxygen and carbon accumulate in
the core. In order to remain stable, the outer hydrogen burning shell moves outwards, ejecting
shells or rings of ionised gas around the core, forming what is known as planetary nebulae.

The core temperature is too low for fusion of oxygen and carbon into other elements, so the
core simply contracts, supported only by the quantum effect called “electron degeneracy
pressure” which prevents further core collapse. It is now called a white dwarf. Its high mass
and low surface area means it is hot (~105 K), but low luminosity (therefore very faint). It is
now called a white dwarf.

White dwarfs have no energy source as such, simply relying on residual heat from the core.
Eventually, all this heat is radiated into space and the white dwarf is thought to become a cold
brown or black dwarf. However, no black dwarfs are believed to exist as they would take
longer than the age of the Universe to reach this stage.

Robert Lee Chin Page | 48


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

Gravity

Core mass of 1.4 - 3.0 solar masses:


Electrons stop further collapse

High mass stars (5-8 solar masses)


In more massive stars, nuclear fusion in the core forms elements up to iron. The electron
degeneracy pressure, which prevents electrons from being forced into the nucleus, is
overcome by the inward gravitational force. This causes electrons to be forced into protons,
forming neutrons. The core resists further collapse due to the quantum “neutron degeneracy
pressure”.

Any further collapsing matter simply ‘bounces’ off the core with an ejection of subatomic
particles called neutrinos, resulting in a “supernova” explosion. Supernova explosions are
only relatively brief and cannot be seen on an H-R diagram as they are too hot and luminous.
Elements heavier than iron are synthesised during supernova. What occurs next depends on
the core mass of the original star

Neutron stars
If the supernova core mass is 1.4 – 3.0 solar masses, the neutron degeneracy pressure prevents
further core collapse, forming a neutron star. Neutron stars are extremely dense, small (10-20
km in diameter), with powerful gravitational and magnetic fields. They emit radiation in the
gamma and x-ray wavebands. Most known neutron stars are called pulsars, which emit beams
of radio waves from their magnetic poles as they rotate (light a lighthouse). When the beams
sweep past the Earth, we detect them as regular radio pulses, hence the term “pulsar.

Neutron stars obtain their energy from either from angular momentum from the supernova
explosion which created them, from their intense magnetic fields or from the accretion of
matter from ‘companion stars’

Core mass 1.4 - 3.0 solar masses:


Gravity
Electrons forced into protons,
forming neutrons i.e. “electron
capture”. Neutrons prevent
Black Holes (>8 solar masses)
For stars that begin greater than 8 solar
masses, the supernova remnant core will be greater than 3 solar masses. At this stage, gravity
completely overcomes even the neutron degeneracy pressure and the core continues to
collapse into a singularity. The gravity is so powerful that not even light can escape its
surface- a “black hole” is formed!

Robert Lee Chin Page | 49


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

Core mass > 3 solar masses:


Gravity overcomes neutron

 Present information by plotting Hertzprung-Russell diagrams for: nearby or


brightest stars, stars in a young open cluster, stars in a globular cluster

Robert Lee Chin Page | 50


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

Robert Lee Chin Page | 51


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

Robert Lee Chin Page | 52


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

Open Cluster Globular cluster


H-R diagrams vary greatly for different H-R diagrams are all similar
clusters i.e. some are sparse, others are
densely populated
Giants and supergiants present No supergiants
Giant branch at zero absolute magnitude Giant branch at -3.5 absolute magnitude
Giant branch separate from MS Narrow band connects giant branch with MS
Stars have varying ages Low ‘turn-off’ point, indicating they are old
clusters

Robert Lee Chin Page | 53


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

Globular Clusters
Globular clusters are generally composed of hundreds of thousands of old, low-metal stars.
As a result, there are no supergiants and few dust and gas clouds, as all the stars have
surpassed this stage. All the stars are about the same distance away from us, so the apparent
magnitude and the absolute magnitude for all stars differs about the same amount. By
matching up H-R diagrams for absolute and apparent magnitude and using the distance
modulus gives an estimate of the age of the cluster.

All the stars in a globular cluster fall upon a well-defined curve. As each star on an H-R
diagram varies with age, this can be used to estimate the age of the star. The highest mass
stars are the most luminous and the first to become red giants. As the cluster ages, lower mass
stars also begin entering the red giant stage- this forms a “turn-off” point on the diagram. The
absolute magnitude at this “turn-off” point is a function of the age of the cluster, so an age
scale can be plotted parallel to the magnitude.

If the main sequence contains O-type stars, the cluster is less than 10 million years old
because this is the amount of time it takes for an O-type star to deplete its core hydrogen. If it
contains A- or B-type stars, the cluster is older than 10 million years old.

Open Clusters
Stars in an open cluster are approximately the same age, mass, chemical composition and the
masses of the stars vary greatly.

 Present information by plotting on a H-R diagram the pathways of stars of 1, 5


and 10 solar masses during their life cycle

A star of 1 solar mass e.g. the Sun, enters low on the MS (spectral class M). It remains here
for most of its life, slowing moving up the MS to spectral class F. Once it has depleted
hydrogen in the core, it becomes brighter and moves horizontally right to the Red giants
(spectral class K). Once all its nuclear fuel is depleted, its outer layers are radiated off, leaving
a small, hot core. This makes it spectral class F, towards the bottom LH corner of the
diagram.

A 5 solar mass star enters higher on the MS (spectral class F). It spends less time here before
becoming a red supergiant (spectral class G). Eventually, it moves off the H-R diagram as it
forms a supernova explosion, which is too hot and luminous to graph. The neutron star that
forms next is also too hot and luminous to be graphed.

A 10 solar mass star enters even higher on the MS, for an even shorter time period. There are
two possible stages which occur next:
-the star can become a blue supergiant (spectral class B-A) which forms a supernova
directly before forming a black hole
-the star many become a red supergiant (spectral class G), before becoming a
supernova, and the a black hole

In both cases, the star simply moves upwards off the H-R diagram

Robert Lee Chin Page | 54


HSC Physics Option Module: Astrophysics
Summary

Massive stars (e.g. 10 solar masses) will enter high on the MS and will spend a relatively
short period of time there. Next, it will move to the supergiants (spectral class G) before
moving up off the H-R diagram

 Analyse information from a H-R diagram and use available evidence to


determine the characteristics of a star and its evolutionary stage

Robert Lee Chin Page | 55

You might also like