Professional Documents
Culture Documents
C. A L B R E C H T W I E B A L C K
HUGO VAN AKEN
frequently used around the world. It is almost insoluble and for that reason
can not be used parenterally. In certain circumstances, for example after an
acute trauma or operation, intravenous administration is preferable because
of potential dysfunction of the gastro-intestinal tract and reduced time of
onset. Propacetamol is a water-soluble precursor of paracetamol with the
same properties. Plasma esterases act on propacetamol and release para-
cetamol rapidly and completely (Depr6 et al, 1992). One gram of propa-
cetamol is the equivalent of 500mg paracetamol. Depr6 et al (1992)
compared the pharmacokinetics of 500 mg paracetamol given orally with
1 g propacetamol given intravenously in a double-blind, placebo-
controlled, randomized, two-period cross-over study, Between 1 and 2
hours after administration, mean plasma concentrations of paracetamol
became practically identical. These authors also demonstrated that no sig-
nificant accumulation of paracetamol occurred even after five dosages of
2 g propacetamol/24 hours. Half-life was 3.6 hours and distribution volume
was 93 + 26 litres.
NSAIDs are widely used for their analgesic, anti-inflammatory and for
some agents antipyretic effects. As some of these drugs are non-prescrip-
tion or over-the-counter drugs, it is estimated that up to 2% of the North
American population use NSAIDs on a daily basis (Knodel et al, 1992).
NSAIDs consist of several chemical classes, which are shown in Table 1.
The NSAIDs differ from each other both based on their pharmacokinetics
and, at least to some extent, their pharmacodynamic profile. The mean
plasma elimination half-life ranges from 1 to 60 hours, but it may be that
other factors like differences in stereo selectivity, protein binding and kinet-
ics in connective tissue are equally important for the clinical efficacy
(Lapicque et al, 1993; Simkin et al, 1993). Nevertheless, NSAIDs have
much in common: good oral resorption, high protein binding (> 90%) and
a relatively small distribution volume, 0.1-0.2 l/kg.
MECHANISMS OF ACTION
Table 1. NSAIDs and paracetamol: chemacal classes, dosages and avmlable preparations
Approximate
Single adult durationof action Preparataon
Chemical class Available agent dose (mg) (hours) available
Acetic acids Indomethacin 50-100 12 oral rectal
50 12 1.m, 1.v.
Carboxylic acids Aspmn (ASA) 500-1000 6-8 oral
Lysm acetylsallcylate 500-1000 6-8 av
Sallcylamide 500-1000 6-8 im
Enolic acids Oxyphenbutazone 100-200 8-12 oral, rectal
Phenylbutazone 200 12-24 oral, rectal
PlrOxlcam 10-20 24 oral, rectal
20--40 24 im
Tenoxlcam 20 24 oral, rectal
20 12 im,iv
Fenamle acids Flafenme 200 6 oral, rectal
Mefenamlc acid 250-500 6-8 oral
Niflumlc acid 250 8-12 oral
700 12 rectal
Para-amlnophenol Paracetamol 300-1000 4-6 oral, rectal
Propacetamol 1000-2000 4-6 Iv
Phenylacetic acids Aclofenac 500-600 8-12 oral, rectal
650 24 im
D~clofenac 100-150 8-12 oral, rectal
75 12 lm,lv
Fenclofenac 600 12 oral
Ketorolac 30 4-6 1.m, ~ v
Propionlc acids Flurbiprofen 50-100 6-8 oral, rectal
Ibuprofen 400-600 6-8 oral, rectal
Ketoprofen 100-200 8-12 oral, rectal
100 8-12 i m , i.v
Naproxen 250-500 12 oral, rectal
ANALGESIC EFFICACY
DRUG ADMINISTRATION
There are very few drugs that have such a low intensity and frequency of
side effects and complications as paracetamol. Some case studies have
reported allergic reactions [cross allergy to acetylsalicylic acid (Ispano et
al, 1993)], also, during rapid injection, propacetamol may lead to a tempo-
rary decrease of blood pressure and a slight irritation at the site of injection.
Several drug interactions are theoretically possible, but they are clinically
irrelevant (Lechat and Kisch, 1989). Dosages should be reduced in patients
with severe renal insufficiency (creatinine clearance < 10 ml/min) and with
severe deficiency of liver cell glutathione which may occur in patients with
profound hepatocellular insufficiency, administration of antiepileptica and
premature babies. In summary, paracetamol may be administered in almost
all patients irrespective of age, underlying disease or pregnancy.
The goal of post-operative pain relief is to allow the patient the quickest
and most convenient restoration of his normal functions, e.g. breathing,
coughing and mobility. This can be supported by the inhibition of trauma-
induced nociceptive impulses in order to blunt autonomic and somatic
reflex responses to pain (Kehlet, 1994).
Post-operative pain therapy should be structured. It should be based on
the general principles of pre-emptive analgesia and the multimodal
approach (Kehlet and Dalai, 1993). The value of pre-emptive analgesia is
limited at present (Dahl and Kehlet, 1993), but this principle may have
some implications in the future. The multimodal approach includes the
principle of balanced analgesia. The basic idea is to combine different anal-
gesic drugs and techniques to achieve an additive or synergistic analgesic
effect. So, the doses of the single drugs can be reduced and side effects are
limited. Another element is the assessment of pain and the choice of the
appropriate treatment.
The first step of the 'analgesic treatment ladder' is represented by para-
cetamol and NSAIDs which are the first line drugs for control of mild to
moderate pain. This has been recommended by many authors and the
World Health Organization (Rummans, 1994) as these analgesics have less
side effects than opioids. Patients treated with NSAIDs are less drowsy
than opioid-treated patients, although the incidence of nausea and vomit-
ing is similar with both treatments. No respiratory effects have been
observed after paracetamol/NSAIDs, in contrast, a decrease in respiratory
rate and an increase in arterial partial pressure of carbon dioxide may
478 C. A. W I E B A L C K A N D H . V A N A K E N
Paracetamol and NSAIDs, both and even together are indicated for the
treatment of mild to moderate pain and for more severe pain, in combina-
tion with opioids, local anaesthetics and other adjuvant medications. The
most problematic side effects of NSAIDs are related to the inhibition of the
peripheral cyclooxygenase-system: bleeding, gastro-duodenal and renal
adverse events. The analgesic potential of paracetamol may be less pro-
nounced and of shorter duration, but there are almost no side effects.
As one of the highest commandments 'Nihil nocere.t' requires, NSAIDs
should be avoided if certain risk factors for NSAIDs-induced side effects
are present such as advanced age, gastroduodenopathy, bleeding diathesis,
renal insufficiency and other factors listed in Table 3. Today, it is recom-
mended that paracetamol alone represents the non-opioid background anal-
gesia.
In the future, a more rational choice of the optimal drug may be possible
as there are some differences among non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs
(Furst, 1994). Research on efficacy, tolerance, incidence of adverse effects,
optimal route of administration and dosage schedules will provide more
information. Then, the choice of a specifically indicated NSAID can be
based on (patient-related) efficacy, patients' concomitant medications and
diseases, and consideration of cost.
SUMMARY
REFERENCES
Abba&e C & Besson J-M (1994) Chronic treatment with aspirin and acetammophen reduce both the
development of polyarthntis and post Fos-hke immunoreactivity in rat lumbar spinal cord Pam
59:45-54
Ballantyne JC, Cart DB, Chalrners TC et al (1993) PostoperaUve patient-controlled analgesia Meta-
analyses of mmal randomized control trials Journal of Climcal Anesthesia 5: 182-193.
Baude C, Long D, Chabrol B e t al (1991) Postoperative analgesia for nephrectomy Cahters
d'Anesthgsiologw 39: 533-536.
Beanheu P (1994) Intravenous admimstratlon of paracetamol (Propacetamol) for postoperative anal-
gesia Anaesthesta 49:739-740
Benoxst JM (1988) Mamement des analgtslques antlpyrttiques In Boreau Fr (ed.) Prattque du
Traltement de la Douleur, pp 125-143. Paris- Dora Editeurs.
Bjorkman R (1995) Central antinoclceptive effects of non-steroidal anla-inflammatory drugs and
paracetamol. Acta Anaesthestologwa Scandmavtca 39 (supplement 103): 1M-4
Bjtrkman R, Hallman K, Hedner J e t al (1994) Acetammophen blocks spinal hyperalgesla induced
by NMDA and substance P Pare 57: 259-264.
Brooks PM & Day RO (1991) Nonsteroldal anU-mflammatory drugs~&fferences and slrrulantles
New England Journal of Medicine 324:1716--1725
480 C.A. WIEBALCK AND H. VAN AKEN
Brouwers JRBJ & De Smet AGM (1994) Pharmacokinetlc-pharmacodynamic drug interactions with
nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs Chntcal Pharmacoktnetws 27: 462-485.
Buchan IE & Bird HA (1991) Drug interactions in arthritic patients. Annals of the Rheumatic Diseases
50:680-681
Buckley MM-T & Brogden RN (1990) Ketorolac A review of its pharmacodynamic and pharmaco-
kinetic properties, and therapeutic potential. Drugs 39: 86--109.
Cahadell-Carafi J, Moreno-Londono A & Conzales-Caudevllla B (1991) Ketorolac, a new non-oplmd
analgesic: a single blind trial versus buprenorphine in pain after orthopaedic surgery Current
Medtcal Research and Opmton 12:343-349
Campbell WI & Kendrick R (1991) Intravenous &clofenac sodium. Does its administration before
operation suppress postoperative pain? Anaesthesia 4: 763-766.
Carlsson KH, Mouzel W & Jurna I (1988) Depression by morphine and the non-oploid analgesic
agents, metamizol (&pyrone), lyslne acetylsahcylate, and paracetamol of activity in rat thalamus
neurons evoked by electrical stimulation of nociceptive afferents Pam 32: 313-326.
Coderre TJ & Melzack R (1992) The contribution of excitatory ammoacids to central sensitization
and perslstant nociceptIon after formalin induced tissue injury Journal of Neurosctence 12:
3665-3670.
Cohen FL (1980) Postsurgical pain relief Patients' status and nurses' medication choices. Pain 9:
265-274.
Connelly CS & Panush RS (1991) Should non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs be stopped before
elective surgery? Archives of Internal Medtcine 151: 1963-1966.
Cousins MJ (1989) Acute pain and the injury response: immediate and prolonged effects Regwnal
Anesthesta 14:162-179
Dahl J & Kehlet H (1991) Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, rationale for use in severe postop-
erative pain. British Journal of Anaesthesia 66: 703-712.
Dahl J & Kehlet H (1993) The value of preemptive analgesia in the treatment of postoperative pain.
Brlttsh Journal of Anaesthesta 70: 434-439.
Dauber A, Ure BM, Neugebauer E et al (1993) Zur Inzidenz postoperativer Schmerzen auf chlrurgis-
chen Normalstatlonen. Anaestheszst 42:448-454
Davies SN & Lodge D (1987) Evidence for involvement of N-methyl-D-aspartate receptors in 'wind
up' of class 2 neurones in the dorsal horn of the ~at Bram Research 424: 402--406.
Dekens J, Lepomte F, Besserve P et al (1988) Analg6sie postop6ratotre en chn-urgle ost6oarticulaire
par le k6toprof'ene en perfuslon Cahters d'Anesth3slologze 36:25-27
Depr6 M, Van Hecken A, Verbesselt R et al (1992) Tolerance and phannacokinetics of propacetamol,
a paracetamol formulation for intravenous use. Fundamentals of Clinical Pharmacology 6:
259-262.
Dolcl G, Ripari M, Pacificl L e t al (1993) Analgesic efficacy and the tolerance for plroxlcam-beta-
cyclodextrin compared to plroxlcam, paracetamol and placebo m the treatment of postextractlon
dental pare Mmerva-Stomatologlca 42: 235-241.
Donovan M, Dillon P & McGmre L (1987) Incidence and characteristics of pain in a sample of med-
xcal-surglcal mpatlents. Pain 30: 69-78.
Dupms R, Lemay H, Bushnelle MC et al (1988) Preoperatwe flarbiprofen in oral surgery a method
of choice m controlhng postoperative pain. Pharmacotherapeutwa 8:193-200
Ffltzer HS (1980) Double-bhnd randomized comparison of naproxen sodium, acetaminophen and
pentazocine m postoperative pare. Current Therapeutic Research, Clinical and Experimental 27:
293-302
Furst DE (1994) Are there differences among non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs? Arthrttls and
Rheumattsm 37:1-9
Garret F, Chupm AM & Souron R (1991) Analgesle postop6ratoire par le propacetamol. Cahters
d'Anesthgsiologte 39:333-335
Grass JA, Sakima NT, Valley Met al (1993) Assessment of ketorolac as an adjuvant to fentanyl patient-
controlled epldurai analgesia after radical retropubic prostatectomy. Anesthestology 78:642-648
Hans P, Brichant JF, B onhomme V e t al (1993) Analgesic efficiency of propacetamol hydrochlonde
after lumbar &sc surgery Acta Anaestheslologica Belgica 44: 129-133.
Hawkey CJ (1990) Non-steroidal anta-inflammatory drugs and peptic ulcers. British Medical Journal
300:278-284
Hogan DB, Campbell NR, Crutcher R et al (1994) Prescription of nonsteroldal anti-inflammatory
drugs for elderly people in Alberta. Canadzan Medical Assoctatton Journal 151: 315-322.
Ispano M, Fontana A, Scibiha Jet al (1993) Oral challenge with alternative nonsteroldal anti-inflam-
PARACETAMOL AND PROPACETAMOL 481
matory drugs and paracetamol m patients intolerant to these agents. Drugs 46 (supplement 1P):
253-256.
Juma I (1991) Central analgesic effects of non-steroidal anti-rheumatic agents, Zettschrift fur
Rheumatologte 50 (supplement 1): 7-13
Jurna I & Brune K (1990) Central effect of the nonsteroldal ants-inflammatory agents lndomethacln,
ibuprofen and diclofenac, determined in C fiber-evoked activity m single neurons of the rat thal-
amus Pare 41:71-80
Keats AS (1956) Postoperative pain research and treatment Journal ofChromc Dtseases 4:72-83
Kehlet H (1994) Postoperative pare relief--what is the issuer Brttish Journal of Anaesthesta 72:
375-378.
Kehlet H & Dahl JB (1993) The value of 'multimodal' or 'balanced analgesia' in postoperative pain
treatment Anesthesta and Analgesta 77:1048-1056
Knodel LC, Rousch MK & Barton TL (1992) Nonsteroldai anti-inflammatory drugs Chnical
Pedtatric Medtcal Surery 9:301-325
Laitinen & Nuutlnen L (1992) Intravenous &clofenac coupled with PCA fentanyl for pain relief after
total hip replacement Anesthestology76:194-198
Lmtmen J, Nuutmen LS, Kliskil~t EL et al (1992) Comparison of intravenous diclofenac,
lUdomethacin and oxycodon as postoperative analgesics in pataents undergoing knee-surgery
European Journal of Anaesthestology 9:29-34
Lanza FL, Karlln DA & Yee JP (1987) A double bhnd, placebo-controlled endoscopic study corn-
panng the mucosal injury seen with an orally and parenteralty administered new nonsteroldal
analgesic' ketorolac thromethamine at therapeutic and supratherapeutlc doses AmericanJournal
of Gastroenterology 82:939
Lapicque F, Muller N, Payan E et al (1993) Protein-binding and stereoselectivity of nonsteroldal anti-
inflammatory drugs. Chnwal Pharmacokmetws 25:115-125
Lechat P & Kisch R (1989) Le parac6tamol. Actualisatlon des connalssances en 1989. Thdrapte 44:
337-354
Lckken P, Skoglund LA & Skjelbred P (1977) Anti-Inflammatory efficacy of treatments with aspirin
and acetammophen Pare 60: 231-232.
Malmberg AB & Yaksh TL (1992) Antmociceptor actions of spinal non-steroidal anti-inflammatory
agents on the formalin test m the rat. Journal of Pharmacology and Experimental Therapeutics
263: 136-146.
Maimberg AB & Yaksh TL (1993) Pharmacology of the spinal action ot ketorolac, morphine,
US0488H, and L-PIA on the formalin test and an lsobolographlc analysis of the NSAID interac-
tion Anesthestology79:270-281
Marks RM & Sachar EJ (1973) Undertreatment of medical inpatients with narcotic analgesics Annals
of Internal Medwme 78:173-181
Maces TJ, Pechman PS, Meller ST et al (1994) Ketorolac potentiates morphine antinociception dur-
ing visceral nocicepaon m the rat. Anesthestology 80:1094-1101
McCormack K (1994) Nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs and spinal nocicepave processing Pare
59:9-43
McCormack K & Brune K (1991) Dissociation between the antlnoclceptlve and antllnflammatory
effects of the non-steroidal antiinflammatory drugs. Drugs 41:533-547
McGaw T, Raboru W & Grace M (1987) Analgesics in pediatric dental surgery relative efficacy of
aluminium ibuprofen suspension and acetammophen ehxlr. Journal of Denttstryfor Children 54:
106-109.
Moffat AC, Kenny GNC & Prentice JW (1990) Postoperative nefopam and dlclofenac evaluation of
their morphine-sparing effect after upper abdominal surgery. Anaesthesia 45: 302-305.
Moore DC (1990) The role of the anesthesiologist in managing postoperative pain Regtonal
Anesthesia 15: 223-231.
Moote C (1992) Efficacy of non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs in the management of postopera-
tive pain Drugs 44 (supplement 5): 14-30
Moreau X, Cottmeau C, Cocaud J et al (1990) Analg6sie pedoperatolre en chirurgle vemeuse
p6nph6dque Cahtersd'Anesth~siologie 38: 403-407.
Morrison NA & Repka NX (1994) Ketorolac versus acetammophen or lbuprofen in controlling post-
operaUve pain in patients with strabismus. Ophthalmology 101:915-918
Muller P, Dammann HG, Leucht U & Simon B (1989) Comparison of the gastrodnodenal tolerance
of tenoxicam and diclofenac Na a double-blind, endoscopically controlled study in healthy
volunteers. European Journal of Chmcal Pharmacology36:419-421.
482 C.A. WIEBALCK AND H. VAN AKEN
Murphy PJ, Ba&a P, Myers BL et al (1994) Nonstermdal anti-inflammatory drugs affect normal sleep
patterns in humans Phystology and Behavtor 55:1063-1066
Nuutinen LS, Lmtmen JO & Salomaki TE (1993) A risk-benefit appraisal of inJectable NSAIDs m the
management of postoperaUve pain. Drug Safety, 9:380-393
O'Brian W (1986) Adverse reactions to nonsteroldal antHnflammatory drugs Dlclofenac compared
with other nonsteroldal anta-mflammatory drugs. American Journal of Medtcme 80 (supplement
4B): 70-80
Ogunbode O (1987) A comparative trial of plroxlcam and paracetmnol after eplslotomy wound repair
Current Therapeutic Research, Climcal and Expertmenta141: 89-94
Ostensen M (1994) Optimlsatlon of antirheumatlc drug treatment in pregnancy. Chmcal
Pharmacokmetws 27:486-503
Papper EM, Bro&e BB & Rovenstme EA (1952) Postoperative pain' Its use in comparatwe evalua-
tion of analgesics Surgery 32:107-109
Parker RK, Holtman B, Smith I & White PF (1994) Use of ketorolac after lower abdominal surgery
Anesthestology 80: 6-12.
Ready KB, Brown CR, Stahlgren LH et al (1994) Evaluation of intravenous ketorolac administered
by bolus or infusion for treatment of postoperative pmn Anesthestology 80:1277-1286
Rod B, Monrlgal JP, Lepoittevin Let al (1989) Traitement de la douleur postoperatoare chez l'enfant
en salle de reveille Utillsatlon de la morphine et du propacetamol par voie intraveneuse Cahters
d'Anesth~szologte 37:525-530
Rosenblum M, Weller RS, Conrad P e t al (1990) Ibuprofen provides better analgesm than fentanyl
following laparascopic surgery Anesthestology 73:A778
Rummans TA (1994) Nonopmld agents for treatment of acute and subacute pmn Mayo Chmc
Proceedings 69:481-490
Sager DS & Benett RM (1992) Indivlduallsmg the risk/benefit ratao of NSAIDs m older patients
Gerlatrtcs 47:24-31
Slmkin PA, Mary PW & Foster DM (1993) Articular pharmacokmeUcs of protein bound
antlrheumatlc agents. Chmcal Pharmacokmetics 25:342-350
Skjelbred P, Album P & LOkken P (1977) Acetylsabcylic acid vs paracetamol: effects on postopera-
tlve course European Journal of Clmtcal Pharmacology 12:257-264
Skovlund E, Fylhngen G, Landre H et al (1991) Comparison of postpartem pare treatments using a
sequential trial design" naproxen versus paracetamol European Journal of Chntcal
Pharmacology 40: 539-542.
Sorkin LS (1993) IT ketorolac blocks NMDA-evoked spinal release of prostaglandm E2 (PGE2) and
thromboxane B2 (TXB2) Anesthesiology 79: A909.
Umbrmn V, Moerman I & Camu F (1994) Postoperative analgestafor dental surgery: a double bhnd
compartson Abstract for Congress 6-11 November 1994 in Bangkok, Thailand
Vargas Busquets MA, Keoshlan LA, Kellemer R et al (1988) Naproxen sodium versus aceta-
mmophen-codeine for pmn following plastic surgery Current Therapeuttc Research, Clmtcal
and Expertmenta143: 311-316
Von Meynng J (1893) Beltrage zur Kenntnis der AntipyreUka Therapeuttsche Monatsschrtft 7:577
Watcha MF, Jones MB, Lagueruela RG et al (1992) Comparison of ketorolac and morphine as adju-
vants during paediatnc surgery Anesthestology 76: 368-372.
Wong HI, Carpenter RL, Popazc DJ et ai (1993) A randomized double-blind evaluation of ketorolac
trlmethamine for postoperative analgesia in ambulatory surgery patients Anesthestology 78"
6-14.
Woolf CJ (1989) Recent advances m the pathophysiology of acute pain. Brmsh Journal of
Anaesthesta 63:139-146.