Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Version 1.1
31 March 2006
Department of Defense - Human Resources Management
Table of Contents
Version History ............................................................................................................................................................ii
1. Executive Summary..............................................................................................................................................1
2. Purpose ..................................................................................................................................................................2
2.1 Document Scope ............................................................................................................................................... 2
2.2 Document Organization .................................................................................................................................... 2
3. Change Management and Communications ......................................................................................................2
3.1 Approach to Change Management and Communications ................................................................................. 2
3.1.1 Certification ...............................................................................................................................3
3.1.2 Portfolio Management ...............................................................................................................3
3.1.3 Enterprise Architecture..............................................................................................................4
3.2 Change Management Model ............................................................................................................................. 4
3.3 Strategic Communications Model ..................................................................................................................... 5
3.4 Change Enablers................................................................................................................................................ 6
3.5 HRM Change Management and Communications Goals.................................................................................. 7
3.6 HRM Change Management and Communications Objectives .......................................................................... 7
4. HRM Stakeholders ...............................................................................................................................................8
5. HRM Themes and Key Messages......................................................................................................................11
6. Tools and Tactics ................................................................................................................................................13
7. Execution Approach...........................................................................................................................................17
8. Evaluation ...........................................................................................................................................................17
8.1 Quantitative Methods ...................................................................................................................................... 18
8.2 Qualitative Methods ........................................................................................................................................ 18
8.3 Strategic Use of Evaluation Methods .............................................................................................................. 19
9. Conclusion...........................................................................................................................................................19
List of Figures
Figure 3-1 Change Management Model............................................................................................................................ 4
Figure 3-2 Strategic Communications Model ................................................................................................................... 5
Figure 4-1 HRM Stakeholders by Level of Involvement ................................................................................................ 11
List of Tables
Table 3-1. HRM Change Implications ............................................................................................................................. 4
Table 3-2 Change Management Outreach Examples ........................................................................................................ 7
Table 4-1 HRM Stakeholder Analysis .............................................................................................................................. 8
Table 6-1 Communications Tools and Tactics ................................................................................................................ 13
Table 8-1 Methods for Measuring Success ..................................................................................................................... 18
VERSION HISTORY
1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The Under Secretary of Defense for Personnel and Readiness (USD (P&R)) vision is for the
Department of Defense (DoD) to be recognized as an employer of first choice, attracting and
retaining the nation’s finest people to provide world-class support to the Warfighter and other
DoD customers. The HRM mission is to ensure that human resources staff is trained, capable,
motivated, and ready to support DoD. To work toward its mission and vision, HRM requires a
robust change management and communications strategy that facilitates two-way
communications. The communications will need to address far-reaching changes within DoD
and HRM, ensuring that stakeholders are fully aware of, engaged in, and supportive of HRM
policies and procedures.
Facets of change include people, process, and technology. The Department is currently
experiencing change in the following areas:
• Certification;
• Portfolio Management (PfM);
• Enterprise Architecture (EA); and
• Specific HRM business line initiatives.
Accordingly, the overarching goal of the HRM Change Management and Communications
Strategy is to:
Increase awareness, understanding, and acceptance of HRM’s Portfolio
Management, Enterprise Architecture, Certification, and other efforts through
targeted change management and communications activities.
To meet this goal, the HRM Change Management and Communications Strategy employs a
blended approach that combines both change management and strategic communications models.
Change management seeks to build stakeholder buy-in, while strategic communications seek to
proactively engage stakeholders in a two-way information exchange. HRM change management
activities will facilitate an interactive dialogue between HRM and its stakeholders using various
communications channels.
More specifically, this document outlines a strategic approach to change management and
communications and provides specific themes, messages, tools, and tactics to facilitate
communication between HRM and its stakeholders. It also provides a framework for HRM to
execute effective change communications.
Additionally, the HRM Change Management and Communications Strategy describes evaluation
methods to measure effectiveness. These methods are both quantitative, providing numerical
values, and qualitative, providing anecdotal information. Using a strategic combination of
quantitative and qualitative methods is essential to a successful communications program
because it helps assess how effectively the program is meeting stakeholder needs throughout the
life cycle of a program.
A tactical execution plan, outlining specific timelines and related messaging, will follow in a
separate document.
2. PURPOSE
2.1 Document Scope
To work toward the P&R vision and mission, HRM requires a robust change management and
communications strategy that facilitates communication of far-reaching changes within DoD and
HRM, and ensures that stakeholders are fully aware of, engaged in, and supportive of HRM
policies and procedures.
This document outlines a strategic approach to change management and communications and
provides specific messages, tools, and tactics to facilitate communication between HRM and its
stakeholders. This strategy provides a framework for HRM to execute effective change
communications. The tactical execution plan that outlines specific timelines and messaging will
follow in a separate document.
3.1.1 Certification
The DoD Certification process has been mandated for all business systems for which the
development or modernization cost is in excess of $1 million.
HRM goals for Certification are to:
• Educate those responsible for development, modernization, or upgrades on the
Certification process for system expenditures greater than $1 million and the
requirements and responsibilities mandated for Certification.
• Provide guides, tools, and templates to support program managers or their designees
during the Certification process.
• Answer related questions and act as a resource for any aspect of the Certification process.
1 Deputy Secretary of Defense memo on Information Technology (IT) Portfolio Management, March 22, 2004.
• Perform PfM Scorecard analysis for managing selected HRM systems; and
• Ensure that HRM systems comply with Control phase results.
Building Circle,” as it fully engages stakeholders in the change process, builds acceptance, and
results in stakeholders owning the change. This process is accomplished primarily through a
deep understanding of and interactive communication with stakeholders to resolve issues causing
resistance.
• The “Awareness” stage lays the groundwork for all other change management activities.
Stakeholders become familiar with impending changes in their organization, which opens
the first effective channel for ongoing communications.
• “Understanding” establishes the framework upon which to build stakeholder support and
sustained success. During this stage, stakeholders understand what changes are expected
of them and how the change process works as a whole.
• Successful change management efforts understand the complexities of each stakeholder
group’s resistance, recognize its unique communication and information needs, and tailor
appropriate responses. Therefore, in the “Ability” stage, stakeholders are taught the skills
and given the tools and other information necessary to embrace any change.
among other tools. Feedback results are incorporated into communications tools and tactics to
ensure that efforts are effective and meeting stakeholder needs. As the model indicates,
stakeholder feedback, when available, is incorporated into each phase.
mission areas, Services, and others to actively participate in HRM focus areas, including
Certification, PfM, and EA. These activities foster timely, two-way communications
between HRM and its stakeholders. In turn, stakeholders contribute to the development
of HRM strategy and/or products, while gaining a sense of ownership within the sub-
mission area and becoming knowledgeable advocates and spokespeople within their
organizations.
4. HRM STAKEHOLDERS
The term “stakeholder” refers to any organization or individual impacted by or holding an
interest in HRM activities, policies, and programs. The HRM Stakeholder Analysis indicated in
the table below segments key stakeholders into categories and groups by level of involvement.
The analysis also notes insights into reaching these stakeholder groups. Reviewing the HRM
Stakeholder Analysis will allow HRM leadership and staff to target messaging, tools, and tactics
to the right audience at the right time.
Table 4-1 HRM Stakeholder Analysis
STAKEHOLDER
STAKEHOLDER GROUP(S) INSIGHTS/ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
CATEGORY
STAKEHOLDER
STAKEHOLDER GROUP(S) INSIGHTS/ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
CATEGORY
• Service members and dependents • In the warfighter area, personnel and
• Inspector General organizations are managed in Combat Service
Support systems, which execute “focused
• Defense Information Systems Agency logistics” (DLA).
(DISA)
• HRM pay interface to DFAS disbursements is
• Defense Intelligence Agency (DIA) a key area of work.
• Defense Logistics Agency (DLA) • HRM encompasses the organizations
• Defense Finance and Accounting conducting security background investigations
Service (DFAS) (DSS).
• Defense Security Service (DSS) • Uniformed Services University of Health
• Uniformed Services University of Sciences is part of the Military Health System
Health Sciences Sub-Mission Area and under Training
Capability – also involved in inputs to
• Homeland Defense credentialing.
• National Security Agency (NSA) • HRM under quality of life (QOL)/morale,
• Defense Commissary Agency (DeCA) welfare, and recreation (MWR) manages
• DoD Education Activity (DODEA) commissaries and other non-appropriated fund
operations (DeCA).
OSD Leadership • Office of the Secretary of Defense • OSD(PAE) conducts independent analysis for
• Office of the Under Secretary of and provides independent advice to the
Defense (Comptroller) Secretary and Deputy Secretary of Defense.
• Office of the Under Secretary of
Defense (Acquisition, Technology,
and Logistics)
• Office of the Assistant Secretary of
Defense for Networks and Information
Integration (OASD (NII))
• Office of the Director for Program
Analysis and Evaluation OSD(PAE)
Transformation • Financial Management
Partners • Material Supply and Service
Management
• Real Property and Installation
Lifecycle Management
• Weapon System Lifecycle
Management
Non-DoD Partners • Department of Veterans Affairs (VA)
• Department of Homeland Security
• National Archives and Records
Administration (NARA)
• Department of Labor
• National Oceanic & Atmospheric
Administration (NOAA)
• Public Health Service (PHS)
Non-Government • United Service Organizations (USO) • OUSD (P&R) assumes responsibility for
Support health, welfare, and safety of USO and Red
STAKEHOLDER
STAKEHOLDER GROUP(S) INSIGHTS/ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
CATEGORY
Organizations • American Red Cross Cross employees, etc. when they are sent into
theatres.
Level of Involvement: Tier 2
Foreign • Foreign governments • Foreign governments and military
Organizations • Foreign military organizations organizations are international user groups for
the Defense Integrated Military Human
Resources System (DIMHRS):
Canada—Military Officer Exchange programs
Great Britain, Australia—DIMHRS,
Peoplesoft
Legislative/ • Congress
Oversight Bodies • Congressional Budget Office
• Government Accountability Office
• Office of Personnel Management
• Office of Management and Budget
Other Non-DoD • Department of State
Partners • Social Security Administration
• Federal Bureau of Investigation
• All 50 state governments
• Territorial governments
• District of Columbia
• Department of Justice
Level of Involvement: Tier 3
Media • Local media
• National media
• Trade media
below,
graphically depicts the relationship between the different stakeholder groups.
Tri-fold brochure A six-panel printed piece used to generate Use as needed. • All stakeholders
awareness and persuade or inform. Normally Update quarterly.
full color with numerous visuals. Can be
various sizes (e.g., 11 by 17 inches, 8.5 by 11
inches). Possible topics: each sub-mission
area .
Website (core business A group of web pages that serves as an up- Check weekly. • All stakeholders
mission area, sub- to-date resource and repository for Update as needed.
mission area, etc.) information, including soft copies of relevant
communications products.
Certification web page A web page that provides up-to-date
Certification information and materials. May
include Certification briefings, background
information, files for submission, a
Certification schedule, Certification-related
diagrams, etc.
PfM web page
A web page that provides up-to-date PfM
information. May include PfM briefings,
background information, updates, PfM-
EA web page related diagrams, etc.
A web page that provides up-to-date EA
information. May include briefings,
background information, architectural
Media Center diagrams, and/or products.
A repository for electronic versions of
communications products. Located on the
web site.
• Medium Level of Engagement
Briefing A tailorable presentation that addresses key Use as needed. • All stakeholders
topics or issues. May be followed by a Q&A
session.
Talking points
The voice track that accompanies a brief.
Online feedback A Web-based tool that allows stakeholders to Use as needed. • All stakeholders
mechanism provide input. Can submit input via online
form or e-mail address.
State of the Core A face-to-face meeting that gives Quarterly or semi- • Services, Components, and
Business Mission Area stakeholders updates regarding recent HRM
Focus group A session where participants are pre-screened Use as needed. • Services, Components, and
and then questioned by a trained facilitator Agencies
about a specific subject. Participants may
receive read-ahead materials, briefings, and
other communications products. Findings
and other information are submitted in a final
report to the client after the event.
Road show A face-to-face meeting between an Use as appropriate. • Services, Components, and
organization and its stakeholders held at a Agencies
series of locations, where communicators
7. EXECUTION APPROACH
As of this plan’s publication date, most HRM stakeholders are in the “Awareness” stage, which
means they are becoming familiar with impending changes in the organization. Before outlining
a full execution plan, HRM should undertake the following steps:
• Solidify the HRM communications infrastructure—ensure standardization in language,
terminology, and basic products (Website, work templates, etc.) so that stakeholders have
a common language in speaking about and understanding HRM
• Solidify HRM focus areas—determine which areas within HRM will have the most
impact on stakeholders
• Solidify HRM key messaging—ensure that all messaging is timely, highlights HRM
focus areas, and meets stakeholder needs
• Determine HRM timelines and milestones—identify specific HRM timelines and
milestones so that developed tools and tactics communicate critical key messaging about
changes within HRM
8. EVALUATION
In any given program, communicators typically use several different methods to measure
effectiveness. Some methods are quantitative, providing numerical values, while other methods
provide anecdotal, or qualitative information. These methods are essential to a successful
communications program, because they help assess how effectively the program is meeting
stakeholder needs. Evaluation methods can also be used to improve change management and
communications activities throughout the life cycle of the program.
QUANTITATIVE: PROGRESS
QUALITATIVE: FEEDBACK MECHANISMS
INDICATORS
• To determine the number of stakeholders • To gauge stakeholders’ level of understanding and/or acceptance, analyze:
reached, track the frequency and/or use of: Print or electronic surveys
Website hits Focus groups
Feedback e-mail Face-to-face interviews
Events an organization has hosted and/or Other face-to-face interactions
presented at • Meetings
Attendees at each event • Collaborative sessions
QUANTITATIVE: PROGRESS
QUALITATIVE: FEEDBACK MECHANISMS
INDICATORS
Communications materials distributed • Road shows
Media coverage and circulation figures • Conferences
• Training sessions
• Working groups
• Brown bags
Feedback e-mail via HRM Website
Unsolicited feedback via telephone, e-mail, etc.
9. CONCLUSION
This strategy outlines an HRM change management and communications approach, while providing a
goal and objectives, themes and key messages, tools and tactics, and other relevant information. The
framework outlined in this strategy will allow HRM to execute effective change communications and
support its stakeholders in moving through the phases of change to result in an increased commitment to
HRM initiatives. Using this iterative process will also ensure that HRM’s change management and
communications program remains flexible and adjusts to the changing needs of all stakeholders.
Appendix A: Acronyms
Table A-1 Acronyms