Professional Documents
Culture Documents
INTRODUCTION
Time-limited, interpersonally focused, psycho dynamically informed psychotherapy Goals :
Interpersonal Contextthe relational factors that predispose, precipitate and perpetuate the patients distress.
INTRODUCTION
Interpersonal relationships :- Focus of therapeutic attention as the means to bring about change. Aims :
Helping to improve pts interpersonal relationships Change their expectations about them Assist patients to improve their social support network
INTRODUCTION
Multiple types : Long-term, insight-oriented, theoretically based, interpretive, and open-ended IPTs More-modern, short-term, time-limited, no interpretive approaches - avoid theory & insight Common belief Interpersonal relationships of a patient, have a role in etiology of his/her psychopathology & its treatment.
INTRODUCTION
Spectrum of approaches + Open-ended : Emphasize participant role of therapist and interpersonal relationship of patient & therapistlonger, more interpretive. Time-limited : Emphasis is on patient and his /her current interpersonal relationships in real life. - 1 or 2 current relationships targeted.
HISTORY
Roots in Psychodynamic Theory Primary instincts of sex and aggression involve relating to others Relationships with others contribute to personality development Psychological Problems due to deficits in early relations
HISTORY
Object-Relations influence Object is human being Relations are internal, external, fantasized or real interactions with others Early parent-child relations are internalized as expectations for future relationships Identity/personality derived from pattern of early relationship experiences Expectations of others impacts quality of current interpersonal relationships and mood
HISTORY
Biopsychosocial
Patterns of attachment : develop early & tend to persist, but are not fixed persist within relationships persist across relationships
Less secure attachment - more prone to psychiatric symptoms Disruption of attachment increases vulnerability to psychiatric symptoms
IMPLICATIONS: Focus on attachment i.e. interpersonal relationships Resolution of here-and-now problems should result in symptom relief Fundamental personality change is unlikely in short-term treatment
HISTORY
American psychiatrist Harry Stack Sullivan (18921949) - Father of Interpersonal Psychotherapy. Alternative formulation to classic psychoanalytical theory 2 basic drives:
(Physical) satisfaction (i.e., food, warmth shelter, sex) (Interpersonal) security
HISTORY
HISTORY
We learn :
How to separate fantasy from reality develop a sense of self and self-esteem (or lack) develop strategies for coping with anxiety
Social stages of child development :Enduring patterns of thinking and behaving Dont develop much because of inner conflicts, as an attempt to deal with human environment of one's family, school & community. Ultimately maladaptive mental illness.
Therapist is not & cannot be a passive observer Identify patterns of behavior & thinking from the patient's history Support self-esteem of patient and reinforce it appropriately Address positive aspects of patient & his/her successes
The story of interpersonal therapy (IPT) began in 1969 at Yale University. Dr. Gerald Klerman was joined by Dr. Eugene Paykel(London) to design a study to test the relative efficacy of a tricyclic antidepressant(TCA) alone and that with psychotherapy as maintenance treatment of nonbipolar depression.
Evidence for efficacy of TCAs for reducing the acute symptoms of depression was strong, yet the main treatment for depression at the time was psychodynamic psychotherapy. It was clear that many patients with acute depression relapsed after termination of TCA treatment.
Unclear how long psychopharmacologic treatment should continue? Whether psychotherapy had a role in the prevention of relapse? Some psychotherapists thought medication would make patients less interested in psychotherapy. Some psychopharmacologists felt psychotherapy would undo the positive effects of medication by having patients talk about upsetting material.
Psychological Factors
Attachment Style Temperament Cognitive Style Coping Mechanisms
Unique Individual
Interpersonal Crises
Grief and Loss Interpersonal Disputes Role Transitions Interpersonal Sensitivity
Interpersonal Distress
Therapist :
Is a participant Cant be entirely objective Cant avoid being target of patient's stereotypical behaviour
Kiesler Dyadic:-Therapist is a participant observer Impact messages: Feelings, thoughts & behaviours of therapist in response to patient
Direct feelings Action tendencies Cognitive attributions Fantasies
Categories of reply:
Simply respond to the manifest content of the statement Ignore it and change the subject Interpret statement as an unconscious message of patient to himself /patient to therapist Share either his personal reflection on or his reaction to patient's statement.
TIME-LIMITED IPT
Our original intent was not to develop a new psychotherapy, but to describe what we believed was reasonable and current practice with depressed patients who might be considered for inclusion under the rubric of short term supportive psychotherapy. Weissman & Klerman, (1993)
TIME-LIMITED IPT
Noninterpretive, time-limited psychotherapy Gerald Klerman and colleagues Treatment of nonbipolar, non psychotically depressed outpatients. No assumptions about causes of psychiatric illness Onset, response to treatment, and outcomes are influenced by interpersonal relations between the patient and significant others.
TIME-LIMITED IPT
Set number of sessions Transference may be ignored/undermined Workbook may be used
Focus is specifically on the pt's interpersonal relationships. Advantage : IPT can be researched. Goal :- Reduce and/or eliminate psychiatric symptoms by improving quality of pt's current interpersonal relations & social functioning.
TIME-LIMITED IPT
Defined phases : Specific strategies and tasks for therapist and patient. Resolving problems within 4 social domains: Grief, interpersonal role disputes, role transitions, and interpersonal deficits. Efficacious for major depression Adapted to treat other types of mood and nonmood disorders.
TIME-LIMITED IPT
A persons behavior is viewed as influencing the reactions of people around them The persons typical interpersonal style may influence negative feedback from others, social isolation, relationship difficulties, etc. These situational factors may lead the individual to become depressed
Interpersonal
therapy helps patient to improve functioning, particularly in current relationships, in order to break the depressive cycle Sessions focus on interpersonal style and interpersonal relationships Interpersonal therapists focus on the functional role of depression rather than on its etiology or cause They look at the ways in which problematic interactions develop when a person becomes depressed
4 SOCIAL DOMAINS
1.
2.
Grief : Problem area when onset of the patients symptoms is associated with loss of a person or a relationship, either recent or past. Interpersonal role disputes: Conflicts with a significant other (e.g., a partner, other family member, coworker/ close friend) that emerge from differences in expectations about the relationship.
4 SOCIAL DOMAINS
3.
4.
Role transitions : difficulties associated with a change in life status (e.g., graduation, leaving a job, moving, marriage/divorce, retirement, change in health status) Interpersonal deficits : Apply to those patients who are socially isolated or are in chronically unfulfilling relationships.
TECHNIQUES
TECHNIQUES
Explorative techniques Non-directive exploration Begin sessions with: How have things been since we last met? Use open-ended questions Encourage clients sense of responsibility Direct questioning
TECHNIQUES
Encourage the Affect Learning in psychotherapy is emotional learning Eliciting affect informs client remeaningful goals Facilitate acceptance of painful affect
encourage clear expression of painful, suppressed or unacknowledged feelings inquire into sensitive areas
TECHNIQUES
Use emotions in relationships Assist client to negotiate painful affect in significant relationships Client may change relationship behavior (self or other) to eliminate painful affect Client may learn new ways to cope with anger or anxiety Client may eliminate irrational thinking and emotional sequelae
TECHNIQUES
Help clients with suppressed emotions For clients who may be emotionally constricted or unassertive Client may lack awareness or confidence to express Some clients distressed by strong emotions (e.g. trauma history) may need help suppressing overwhelming emotions
may be counter-productive to encourage emotional display
TECHNIQUES
Clarification Communication techniques to review content, clarify feelings, promote awareness
repeating, rephrasing statements calling attention to logical implications of statements raising contradictions or contrasts
TECHNIQUES
Communication analysis Identify communication failures to improve relationship satisfaction Frequently review important conversations or arguments Illuminate common communication difficulties
TECHNIQUES
Use of Therapeutic relationship Clients feelings toward therapist and therapy are helpful focus may reflect characteristic ways of feeling and behaving in other relationships Therapist instructs client to express complaints, fears, that arise about therapist model genuine negotiation with such feeling therapist can correct distortions and acknowledge genuine deficiencies
TECHNIQUES
Directive techniques Include educating, advising, modeling Initially open to practical help: depressed clients may need case management Provide suggestions if client unable to make successful decisions independently Modeling may involve informing client how therapist might handle similar situation Use directive techniques sparingly use early, w/o undermining clients autonomy
TECHNIQUES
Decision analysis :
Help patient integrate communication analysis, wishes & options & constraints of situation Decide specific course of action
Role playing :
Help rehearse course of action before implementing in real life
TIMELINE OF TREATMENT
Typical course lasts 12 to 20 sessions over a 4- to 5-month period. 3 phases : Initial phase : Dedicated to identifying the problem area that will be the target for treatment. Intermediate phase : Devoted to working on the target problem area(s) Termination phase : Focused on consolidating gains made during treatment & preparing the patients for future work on their own
Review significant relationships, past and present Identify interpersonal precipitants of episodes of psychiatric symptoms Select and reach consensus about the interpersonal problem area(s) and treatment plan with patient
INITIAL PHASE
Assessing the patient's current psychiatric symptoms and obtaining a history of these symptoms, the therapist gives the patient a formal diagnosis (DSM,ICD) Discuss diagnosis, as well as what might be expected from treatment. Assignment of the sick role Dual function
Conducts an interpersonal inventory with the patient and develops an interpersonal formulation determine precise focus of treatment
Thorough psychiatric interview Assigning the sick role : Purposes are both theoretical and practical. Reinforces the idea that patient has a known condition that can be treated Explicitly identifies the patient as being in need of help Temporarily exempt the individual from other responsibilitiesdevote full attention to recovery
Sick is undesirable and needs to be improved Person obliged to cooperate with treatment Shifts blame from client to illnessmitigate self blame Symptom relief starts with helping the patient to understand that his/her psychiatric symptoms are part of a known syndrome that responds to several treatments.
Structure for elucidating social & interpersonal context of the onset and maintenance of psychiatric symptoms & delineates the focus of treatment. Concerns changes in relationships proximal to the onset of symptoms Obtain chronological history of
significant life events fluctuations in mood and self-esteem interpersonal relationships psychiatric symptoms
Make connection between certain life experiences and psychiatric symptoms Thorough interpersonal inventory :
Problem area that seems most likely to be responsive to treatment is addressed first Patient's morale and overall sense of competence enhances when progress is made
Formulate a treatment plan with specified goals Guide the day-to-day work Identify specific steps the patient will take to improve relationships and socialization Summary should include reference to specific individuals, events, & interpersonal themes to help ensure that they are as personally meaningful to the patient as possible. Written summary Treatment contract
INTERMEDIATE PHASE
8-10 sessions work of the therapy Strengthen the connections patient makes between the changes he/she is making in his/her interpersonal life and the changes in his/her psychiatric symptoms Treatment strategies implemented specific to identified problem area
IMPORTANT TASKS : Help client discuss topics pertinent to problem area Attend to clients affective state Assist client in discussing therapeutic relationship Prevent client from sabotaging treatment
GRIEF - GOALS
Facilitate the mourning process Help client re-establish interests and relationships to substitute for what has been lost
GRIEF - STRATEGIES
Reconstruction of Relationship
Use photos and stories to discuss relationship Use belongings and memories to evoke painful feelings client has avoided What were the ups and downs in relationship? (normalize negative features)-- Facilitate Expression of Affect
GRIEF - STRATEGIES
Behavior change:
Plan and discuss development of new social relationships (e.g. organizations, church, work, dating) Support client as they learn to fill empty space
ROLE TRANSITIONS
Role transitions are varied in their nature. Examples according to Stuart and Robertson (2003) include: situational role transitions, e.g., job loss, promotion, graduation, migration. relationship role transitions, e.g., marriage, divorce, stepparenthood.
illness related role transition, e.g., diagnosis of chronic illness, adaptation to pain or physical limitations. post-event role transition, e.g., posttraumatic symptoms, refugee status.
ROLE TRANSITIONS
Diagnosis Assess: How did life change? What people in your life changed or left? Goals :
mourning & accepting the loss of old role recognizing the positive & negative aspects of both old and new roles restoring the patient's self-esteem
ISSUES
Differences in expectations/values between client and other? Clients wishes in relationship? Other wishes? What are the clients options? How have they resolved disagreements in past? Strengths and weaknesses in relationship? What changes are realistically possible?
IP ROLE DISPUTESSTRATEGIES
Assess stage of Role Dispute: Impasse- discussion stopped, low-level resentment exists treatment may initially increase disharmony Renegotiation- aware of differences, actively trying to change Treatment may require calming parties to facilitate resolution Dissolution- implies the relationship is irretrievably disrupted Treatment may resemble grief therapy
IP ROLE DISPUTESSTRATEGIES
Find Parallels in previous relationships What does client gain by the behavior? What are unspoken assumptions that lie behind behavior? Optimistic tone: lets figure out what went wrong here so we can decide how to help you make it better Often communication problems are revealed- Treatment involves improving skills
IP ROLE DISPUTESSTRATEGIES
Help identify mixed feelings e.g. anger, fear, sadness Devise strategies for managing feelings e.g. direct communications, reducing irrational suspicions Role Play Rehearse expressing feelings and wishes Anticipate communication problems Consider Conjoint sessions with significant other
INTERPERSONAL DEFICITS
DIAGNOSIS: History of social impoverishment, chronic inadequate or unsustained relationships Consider Dysthymia (or Double Depression)
Long standing or temporary deficits in social skills yields low self-esteem, withdrawal
IP DEFICITS - GOALS
Reduce Clients social isolation Enable:
close relationships with intimates or family members satisfying relationships with friends adequate relationships in work role
IP DEFICITS - STRATEGIES
Review past significant relationships including childhood relationships with family members depressed patients minimize or forget positive experiences explore repetitive or parallel problems in past relationships define interpersonal situations that lead to difficulties
IP DEFICITS - STRATEGIES
IP DEFICITS - STRATEGIES
IP DEFICITS - PROGNOSIS
Treatment of interpersonal deficits often difficult Client often lacks relationships to practice and develop skills Treatment goals limited to making early gains interpersonally, not resolving interpersonal deficits.
TERMINATION PHASE
For time-limited treatment, important to keep initial contract for 12-16 weeks Termination Treatment issues explicit discussion of termination during last 3-4 sessions acknowledge ending may involve loss and grief normalize fear, anger, sadness may need to distinguish sadness from depression
TERMINATION ISSUES
Foster clients self-confidence in coping independently Deflect clients attribution of success to therapist Call attention to clients accomplishments Anticipate future difficulties with client
help plan for future problems rehearse explicit scenarios if helpful discuss possibility of relapse of
TERMINATION DIFFICULTIES
Failure for depression to resolve refer for other treatment, encourage hope Client wants to continue schedule 8 week waiting period impart to client self-confidence in ability to cope Maintenance IPT may be appropriate for: chronic or recurring depression clients with personality problems or interpersonal deficits
Assignment of the sick role, Interpersonal inventory, Development of the problem area(s) Development of treatment goals
Important interpersonal skills are learned while participating in a group (e.g., interpersonal confrontation, honest communication, expression of feelings)
Maintaining IP focus :
Use of group summaries/self help manuals Group stage development theory interventions - intensifies group cohesiveness, prevents premature dropouts
INDICATIONS
Major depressive disorder Bulimia nervosa IPSRT(IP social rhythms therapy) Bipolar disorder Anxiety disorders less evidence Substance use,dysthymic disorders no advantages
International society for IPT May 2000,Chicago Manuals different age groups, subpopulations , different lengths, formats including telephone adaptations Basic principles followed:
No fault definition of illness Excusing pt from blame Continued focus on relation b/w pts mood and life situations
Never indicated as monotherapy for psychotic depression or bipolar disorder. Complications : Straightforward therapy
Treatment nonresponders should be evaluated for possible prescription of an alternative, evidence-based treatment
Ethical issues : Require training and supervision to develop proficiency Specific IPT training guidelines(Weissman et al) Specific group training guidelines(Wilfley et al)
Depressed adolescents (IPT-A) 3 RCTs IPT > CBT self esteem and social adaptaion
Maintainence treatment(Pittsburgh):
128 pts IPT +imipramine for 4 mths Remitted pts randomly assigned : IMI+CM ,IMI+mthlyIPT,mthlyIPT , mthlyIPT+placebo, pla+CM Both IPT & Imipramine superior to placebo
Dysthymic disorder : Reconceptualize lifelong character flaws ego-dystonic,chronic mood dependent symptoms 3 RCTs improvement in IPT + sertraline combination significant
Non mood disorders : Bulimia Fairburn modified IPT long term benefits,decreased binge eating Anxiety disorders Not yet tested Substance use no efficacy in 3 CTs
Predictors of response
Social Dysfunction(higher functionbetter) Cognitive dysfunction Expectation of improvement Therapeutic alliance Endogeneity of depression-better Double depression poorer outcome Personality traits poorer response Duration of current episode (longerworser) Prior social judgement good
Case study
22y Brendan Depressed mood,poor concentration,lethargy,reduced appetite,sleep disturbance,suicidal ideation since 3-4y,^since 3 mths Sertraline 100 mg mod. Improvement Carpenter by occupation ,had difficulties with the way supervisor talked to him .always quiet at work,enjoyed work
1 good friend since primary school Felt uncertain around girls Mother expired 2y back cancer Not much contact with dad and elder brother O/E cooperative,depressed mood ,restricted affect
Supervisor diff IP dispute Mothers death grief Impoverished social network IP sensitivity
IP inventory attachment insecure avoidant Formulation IPT focus created Roles explained
Sessions 1-7-wkly,8-10-fortnightly,11-12 mthly Middle sessions 3 problem areas addressed pt was quite introverted Dispute with supervisor priority Affect elicited and therapeutic relationship established Communication analysis supervisors behaviour not personal Brainstorming scenarios & role play sessions-assertiveness
Next to grief Seq of events related to moms death recreate relationship Process affect elicited anger ,guilt Next to utilise existing social supports to develop new interests Sought to develop stronger relationship with a maternal aunt & family friend Socializing more with quieter men at work Began to relax during events at tavern secure base-looked for support & guidance from therapist
Termination phase discuss feelings to prevent symptom intensification Advised maintainence sessions if he relapsed
FUTURE DIRECTIONS
1.
Little is known about mechanisms by which interpersonal psychotherapy exerts its effects
Greater understanding would assist in further refinements and yield insights about nature of the psychiatric syndrome under investigation.
2.
Increased efforts to improve the effectiveness of interpersonal psychotherapy -altering the structure , identifying specific therapist behaviors
FUTURE DIRECTIONS
3. 4.
Refining the definitions of the target populations is advised Need to translate interpersonal psychotherapy efficacy data to effectiveness studies and appropriate clinical practice.
CONCLUSION
IPT stands, in contrast to other therapies through an emphasis on the effects of a persons external interpersonal environment upon their mental health Sufficient clinical trials conclude that IPT is an efficacious time limited treatment for a range of conditions,esp. depression and bulimia Manualised format makes it relatively easy to learn and apply.