Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Thinking
Created by
Y. Adam Prasetyo
Referrence
Bowell, Tracy., Kemp, Gary. (2002) Critical Thinking 3rd Edition, New
York: Routledge.
Persuadin
g
Argument
React to
Act Act
from
Reason
Interpret
and
Evaluate
Recognizin
g
Argument
s
Rhetorical force
This is the rhetorical aspect of a sentences
meaning. It is not part of the propositional
content that it expresses; rather, it is the
emotive or otherwise suggestive windowdressing surrounding the proposition, which
may be used to persuade us. The sentence in
question can reasonably be taken to express this
rhetorical message given the linguistic
conventions according to which the words
involved are normally used.
Aspect of
Meaning
Implicature
Implicature is meaning, which is not stated, but
which one can reasonably take to be
intended, given the context in which the
sentence is written or uttered (it is known
more generally in linguistics as
conversational implicature). Unlike rhetorical
force, implicature cannot typically be interpreted
according to conventions covering our ordinary
use of the words in the sentence used.
Definitions
Definitions tell us what it takes for something
to qualify as a particular type of thing. The
kind of definition with which you are most familiar
is probably a dictionary definition.
one premise:
Bart has two sisters.
Therefore, Bart is not an only child.
This has two:
Helping someone to commit suicide is the same as
murder.
Murder is wrong.
Therefore, helping someone to commit suicide is
wrong.
Standard
Form
Reconstru
cting
Argument
s
Identifying
identification of conclusions an
easier task
Conclussio
n
indentifica
tion
1.
2.
3.
4.
phrase of
conclusion
indicators
Identifying
premises
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Premises
Arguments
and
Explanatio
ns
Referrence