You are on page 1of 126

UNIVERSITY

COLLAGE OF ENGINEERING &


TECHNOLOGY
DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL
AND COMPUTER ENGINEERING

6/12/17
ADU,CET,ECEg3153
Course name: Introduction to
control systems
Course code: ECEg3153
Course instructor: Getnet Z.
Contact information:
1
Email: abaye.get@gmail.com
Consultation hours:
Wednesday and Friday : from
OUTLINE
Introduction

6/12/17

Timedomainanalysisof

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
Firstordersystems
Secondordersystems

Steadystateerror
Stabilityanalysis's
Routhsstabilitycriteria

2
INTRODUCTION
TimeDomainAnalysisofControlSystems
In timedomain analysis the response of a dynamic

6/12/17
systemtoaninputisexpressedasafunctionoftime.
It is possible to compute the time response of a

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
system if the nature of input and the mathematical
modelofthesystemareknown.
After the engineer obtains a mathematical
representation of a system, the system is analyzed
for its transient and steadystate responses to see if
thesecharacteristicsyieldthedesiredbehavior

3
INTRODUCTION
Theconceptofpolesandzerosarefundamentalto
theanalysisanddesignofcontrolsystemswhich
simplifiestheevaluationofasystem'sresponse.

6/12/17
Pole,ZerosandSystemResponse

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
PoleofaTransferFunction:Thevaluesofthe
Laplacetransformvariable,s,thatcausethe
transferfunctiontobecomeinfinite
ZerosofaTransferFunction:Thevaluesofthe
Laplacetransformvariable,s,thatcausethe
transferfunctiontobecomezero

4
INTRODUCTION
Usually, the input signals to control systems arenot
knownfullyaheadoftime.

6/12/17
Forexample,inaradartrackingsystem,theposition
andthespeedofthetargettobetrackedmayvaryin

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
arandomfashion.
It is therefore difficult to express the actual input
signalsmathematicallybysimpleequations.
SoinordertogetSystemResponse:

Thecommonlyusedtestinputsignalsarestep
functions,rampfunctions,accelerationfunction,
impulsefunctionsandsinusoidalfunctions.

5
INTRODUCTION
StandardTestSignals
The characteristics of actual input signals are a

6/12/17
sudden shock, a sudden change, a constant velocity,
andconstantacceleration.

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
Thedynamicbehaviorofasystemisthereforejudged
and compared under application of standard test
signalsanimpulse,astep,aconstantvelocity,and
constantacceleration.
Another standard signal of great importance is a
sinusoidalsignal.

6
INTRODUCTION
StandardTestSignals
Impulsesignal

6/12/17
The impulse signal imitate the
sudden shock characteristic of

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
actualinputsignal.

IfA=1,theimpulsesignaliscalled
unitimpulsesignal.

7
INTRODUCTION
StandardTestSignals
Stepsignal

6/12/17
The step signal imitate the
suddenchangecharacteristic u(t)

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
ofactualinputsignal.
A

0 t
If A=1, the step signal is
calledunitstepsignal

8
INTRODUCTION
r(t)
StandardTestSignals
Rampsignal

6/12/17
The ramp signal imitate the
constant velocity

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
characteristic of actual input
signal. t
0

r(t)

rampsignalwithslopeA

IfA=1, the ramp signal is r(t)


calledunitrampsignal

unitrampsignal
9
INTRODUCTION
Standardtestsignal
Parabolicsignal

6/12/17
The parabolic signal imitate p(t)

the constant acceleration

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
characteristic of actual input
signal.

0 t

IfA=1,theparabolicsignalis
calledunitparabolicsignal.

10
INTRODUCTION
RelationbetweenstandardTestSignals
Impulse A t0
(t ) d

6/12/17
0 t0
dt

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
Step A t0
u(t )
0 t0 d
dt
Ramp At t0
r(t ) d
0 t0
dt
Parabolic

At 2
t0
p(t ) 2 11
0 t0

INTRODUCTION
LaplaceTransformofTestSignals
Impulse

6/12/17
A t0
(t )
0 t0

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
L{ (t )} (s ) A

Step
A t0
u(t )
0 t0

A
L{u(t )} U (s ) 12
S
INTRODUCTION
Laplacetransformoftestsignals
Ramp At t0
r (t )

6/12/17
0 t0

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
A
L{r (t )} R(s )
s2
Parabolic At 2
t0
p(t ) 2
0 t0

2A
L{p(t )} P(s ) 3
13
S
INTRODUCTION
TimeResponseofControlSystems
Timeresponseofadynamicsystemisresponseto

6/12/17
aninputexpressedasafunctionoftime.

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
Thetimeresponseofanysystemhastwo
components
Transientresponse
Steadystateresponse.
14
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF1ST
ORDERSYSTEMS
TransientResponseAnalysis
FirstOrderSystem:

Firstordersystemwithoutzero

6/12/17

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
ThefirstordersystemhasonlyonepoleconsideringwithgainK.
C (s ) K

R(s ) Ts 1

WhereKistheD.CgainandTor1/aisthetimeconstantofthe
system.
Time constant is a measure of how quickly a 1 st order system
respondstoaunitstepinput.
D.CGainofthesystemisratiobetweentheinputsignalandthe 15

steadystatevalueofoutput.
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF1ST
ORDERSYSTEMS
AsanexampleForthefirstordersystemgivenbelow
10
G(s )

6/12/17
3s 1
D.Cgainis10andtimeconstantis3seconds.Andfor

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
followingsystem 3 3/5
G( s )
s5 1 / 5s 1
D.CGainofthesystemis3/5andtimeconstantis
1/5seconds.
Ingeneralhaving

E.g:Ifunitstepinputisappliedtothisfirstorder
system Cn(t):(natural),transited
response
16
Cf(t):forced(ss)response
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF1ST
ORDERSYSTEMS
Testing1stordersystems
ImpulseResponseof1stOrderSystem

6/12/17
Considerthefollowing1stordersystem
(t)
K

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
1
R(s ) C (s )
Ts 1
K
0
t
R( s) ( s) 1 C ( s)
Ts 1
Rearrangeaboveequationas K /T
C (s )
s 1/T
Inordertorepresenttheresponseofthesystemintime
domainweneedtocomputeinverseLaplacetransform
oftheaboveequation. 1 A at K t / T
L Ae c(t ) e 17
sa T
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF1ST
ORDERSYSTEMS
Testing1stordersystems
StepResponseof1stOrderSystem

6/12/17
Considerthefollowing1stordersystem

K
C (s )

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
R(s )
Ts 1
K
C (s )
s Ts 1
1
R(s ) U (s )
s

InordertofindouttheinverseLaplaceoftheabove
rcedResponse
K KTNaturalResponse
equation,weneedtobreakitintopartialfractionexpansion
1 T
C (s ) C (s ) K
s Ts 1 s Ts 1

c(t ) K u (t ) e t / T

TakinginverseLaplace

18


c(t ) K 1 e t / T
63%offinalvalue)
c (t ) K 1 e 1
Havingu(t)=1andt=T(atwhichtheresponsereach's
0.632 K
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF1ST
ORDERSYSTEMS
StepResponseof1stOrderSystem
E.g:IfK=10andT=1.5sthen

6/12/17

K*(1-exp(-t/T))
11

c(t) K 1et /T 10
Step Response

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
9

8 steady state output 10


D.C Gain K
7 Input 1
6
c(t)

2
Unit Step Input
1

0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Time

Exercise:fined1storderresponseforparabolicand
rampsignalinput. 19
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF1ST
ORDERSYSTEMS
RelationBetweenStepandimpulseresponse
Thestepresponseofthefirstordersystemis

6/12/17
c(t ) K 1 e t / T K Ke t / T

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
Differentiatingc(t)withrespecttotyields

dc(t ) d
dt

dt

K Ke t / T
dc(t ) K t / T
e (impulseresponse)
dt T
20
Example: Impulse response of a 1st order system is
givenbelow.

6/12/17
c(t ) 3e 0.5t
solution
Findout

ADU,CET,ECEg3153

The Laplace Transform of Impulse


TimeconstantT response of a system is actually the transfer
D.CGainK functionofthesystem.
Therefore taking Laplace Transform of the
TransferFunction
impulse response given by following
StepResponse equation.

C ( s ) C (s ) 3
c(t ) 3e 0.5t
(s ) R(s ) S 0.5
3 3
C (s ) 1 (s ) C (s ) 6
S 0.5 S 0.5 21
R(s ) 2 S 1
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF1ST
ORDERSYSTEMS
TransientResponsePerformanceSpecification:
TimeConstant:Toraistheonlyparameterneeded

6/12/17
todescribethetransientresponseWecall1/aorTthe
timeconstantoftheresponse.

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
Thetimeconstantcanbedescribedasthetimeforexp(
at)todecayto37%ofitsinitialvalue.Alternately,the
timeconstantisthetimeittakesforthestepresponse
toriseto63%ofitsfinalvalue
Itisrelatedtothespeedatwhichthesystemresponds
toastepinput.
Sincethepoleofthetransferfunctionisata,wecan
saythepoleislocatedatthereciprocalofthetime
constant,and
Thefartherthepolefromtheimaginaryaxis,thefaster 22

thetransientresponse.
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF1ST
ORDERSYSTEMS
RiseTime,Tr:Risetimeisdefinedasthetimefor
thewaveformtogofrom0%or10%to90%or100%

6/12/17
ofitsfinalvalue.
Risetimecalculatedbysolvingforthedifferencein

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
timeatc(t)=0.9andc(t)=0.1.Hence,
OrTr=2.2T
SettlingTime,Ts:Settlingtimeisdefinedasthe
timefortheresponsetoreach,andstaywithin,2%of
itsfinalvalue.
Lettingc(t)=0.98andsolvingfortime,t,wefindthe

settlingtimetobe
OrTs=4T
23
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF1ST
ORDERSYSTEMS
Couldbesummarizedas:

6/12/17
OrSlope=1/T

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
Ts=4T

24
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF1ST
ORDERSYSTEMS
Example:asystemhasatransferfunction

6/12/17
Findthetimeconstant,Tc,settlingtime,Ts,andrise

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
time,Tr?
Solution:
a=50
Tc=1/a=0.02sec
Tr=2.2/a=0.044sec
Ts=4/a=0.08sec

Whatwillbethetotaltimestepresponseandshowthe
naturalandforcedresponses?
1exp(50t)Totalresponse
1forcedresponse 25

exp(50t)Naturalresponse
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF1ST
ORDERSYSTEMS
1stOrderSystemwithaZero
C ( s ) K (1 s )

6/12/17
R( s) Ts 1
Zeroofthesystemlieat1/andpoleat1/T.

ADU,CET,ECEg3153

Stepresponseofthesystemwouldbe:

K (1 s )
C (s )
s Ts 1
K K ( T ) PartialFractions
C (s )
s Ts 1
K InverseLaplace
c(t ) K ( T )e t / T 26
T
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF1ST
ORDERSYSTEMS
1stOrderSystemwith&W/OZero(Comparison)
C (s ) K C (s ) K (1 s )

6/12/17
R(s ) Ts 1 R(s ) Ts 1

c(t ) K 1 e t / T K
c(t ) K ( T )e t / T

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
T
IfT>theshapeofthestepresponseis
approximatelysame(withoffsetaddedbyzero)
Unit Step Response
K 10

c(t ) K (n )e t / T 9.5
T
n
9

c(t ) K 1 e t / T 8.5

T
c(t)

7.5 offset
C (s ) 10(1 2s )
7

R(s ) 3s 1 6.5 27
10 0 5 10 15

c(t ) 10 (2 3)e t / 3 Time

3
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF1ST
ORDERSYSTEMS
IfT<theresponseofthesystemwouldlooklike
Comparingthe2cases
C (s ) 10(1 2s )

6/12/17
Unit Step Response of 1st Order Systems with Zeros
14
R(s ) 1.5s 1
13

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
10
c(t ) 10 (2 1)e t /1.5 12
1.5 11
T

nitStepResponse
Unit Step Response of 1st Order Systems with Zeros
14 10

9 T
13

U
Unit Step Response

8
12
7

11 6
0 5 10 15
Time
10
28
9
0 5 10 15
Time
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF1ST
ORDERSYSTEMS
ExamplesofFirstOrderSystems
ArmatureControlledD.CMotor(La=0)

6/12/17
ElectricalSystem
MechanicalSystem

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
Ra La
B
ia
eb T J
u
Eo (s ) 1

Ei (s ) RCs 1
X o (s ) 1
(s)

K t Ra
X i (s ) b
U(s) Js B K t K b Ra s 1
k 29
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
2ndordersystems
Wehavealreadydiscussedtheaffectoflocationofpole

6/12/17
andzeroonthetransientresponseof1 stordersystems.
Compared to the simplicity of a firstorder system, a

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
secondordersystemexhibitsawiderangeofresponses
thatmustbeanalyzedanddescribed.
Varying a firstorder system's parameters (T, K)
simplychangesthespeedandoffsetoftheresponse
Whereas,changesintheparametersofasecondorder
systemcanchangetheformoftheresponse.
A secondorder system can display characteristics
much like a firstorder system or, depending on
componentvalues,displaydampedor pureoscillations
30
foritstransientresponse.
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
2ndordersystems
Ageneralsecondordersystem(withoutzeros)is

6/12/17
characterizedbythefollowingtransferfunction.

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
n2 OpenLoop
G(s)
s( s 2 n ) TransferFunction

C (s ) n2 ClosedLoop

R(s ) s 2 2 n s n2 TransferFunction
damping ratio of the second order system, which is a
measure of the degree of resistance to change in the
systemoutput.
undamped natural frequency of the second
n 31
order system, which is the frequency of
oscillationofthesystemwithoutdamping.
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
Letsstudytheeffectofpolelocationbeforefinding
responseofthesystem.

6/12/17
letshavethecharacteristicequationordenominator

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
Thefollowingconclusioncouldbedrawn:

32
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
SecondOrderSystems:
Letstakenumericalexamplesofthesecondorder

6/12/17
systemresponseswhichhastwofinitepolesandno
zeros.

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
33
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS

6/12/17
ADU,CET,ECEg3153
34
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
NB:Varyingafirstordersystem'sparametersimply
changesthespeedoftheresponse,changesinthe
parametersofasecondordersystemcanchangethe

6/12/17
formoftheresponse.

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
Therefore;dep.Ondampingratio()theresponse

Overdampedresponses() 1
Poles:Tworealat(i.e)

Naturalresponse:Twoexponentialswithtime
constantsequaltothereciprocalofthepolelocations,

35
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
0 1
Underdampedresponses()
Poles:Twocomplexat(i.e)

6/12/17
Naturalresponse:Dampedsinusoidwithan
exponentialenvelopewhosetimeconstantisequalto

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
thereciprocalofthepole'srealpart.Theradian
frequencyofthesinusoid,thedampedfrequencyof
oscillation,isequaltotheimaginarypartofthepoles,

0
Undampedresponses()
Poles:Twoimaginaryat(i.e)

Naturalresponse:Undampedsinusoidwithradian

frequencyequaltotheimaginarypartofthepoles,
36
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
Criticallydampedresponses() 1
Poles:Tworealat(i.e)

6/12/17
Naturalresponse:Onetermisanexponentialwhose
timeconstantisequaltothereciprocalofthepole

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
location.Anothertermistheproductoftime,tand
anexponentialwithtimeconstantequaltothe
reciprocalofthepolelocation,

37
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
GeneralSecondOrderSystem
Twophysicallymeaningfulspecificationsforsecond

6/12/17
ordersystemstransientresponselikethatoftime
constantforfirstorderresponse.

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
NaturalFrequency,n:Thenaturalfrequencyofa
secondordersystemisthefrequencyofoscillationof
thesystemwithoutdamping.
Forexample,thefrequencyofoscillationofaseries
RLCcircuitwiththeresistanceshortedwouldbethe
naturalfrequency
DampingRatio,Itistheratioofexponentialdecay
frequencyoftheenvelopetothenaturalfrequency.
Thisratioisconstantregardlessofthetimescaleof 38
theresponse.
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
Mathematically;

6/12/17
Expressingsecondordersystemintermsofnatural
frequencyanddampingratio

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
Let,

Withoutdamping,thepoleswouldbeonthejaxis,and
theresponsewouldbeanundampedsinusoid.Forthe
polestobepurelyimaginary,a=0.Hence,

Bydefinition,thenaturalfrequency,,isthefrequencyof
oscillationofthissystem.Sincethepolesofthissystem
areonthejaxisat, 39

Then,
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
Fortheabovegeneralsecondordersystemtransfer
function,assumingunderdampedsystem,the
complexpoleshavearealpart=a/2andthe

6/12/17
magnitudeofthisvalueistheexponentialdecay
frequency.

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
Havingthisgeneral2ndorderunitFBtransfer
function:thegeneral2ndordertimeresponseof
sinusoidalandexponentialparts. 40
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
Cont
c(t ) 1 e nt cos d t sin d t
1 2

6/12/17
ADU,CET,ECEg3153
n n 2 1
RealPart ImaginaryPart

41
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
Example1:Forasystemwithatransfer
functiongivenbelowcalculatethedampingratio
andthenaturalfrequencyofthesystem.

6/12/17
Solution:

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
FromtheTF,
substitutingthevalueofdampingratio

NB:Thedampingratioandthenatural
frequencyofasystemcanbe
relatedwiththepolelocationofthesystem:which
meansiftheinformationaboutthesetwoparameter
isknownwecancalculatethepolesofthesystem.
42
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
Example 2; The natural frequency of closed loop
poles of 2nd order system is 2 rad/sec and damping

6/12/17
ratio is 0.5. Determine the location of closed loop
poles so that the damping ratio remains same but

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
thenaturalundampedfrequencyisdoubled.Pole-Zero Map 3
3
Solution 0.5 0.38 0.28 0.17 0.08 2.5

n2
0.64
C(s) 4 2
2
2
1.5
R(s) s 2ns n2 s2 2s 4 0.8
1
1
0.94 0.5
Imaginary Axis

0.94 0.5
-1
1
0.8
1.5
-2
2
0.64 43
0.5 0.38 0.28 0.17 0.08 2.5
-3
-2 -1.5 -1 -0.5 30 0.5
Real Axis
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS

6/12/17
ADU,CET,ECEg3153
44
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
UnderdampedSecondOrderSystem
Theunderdampedsecondordersystemisa

6/12/17
commonmodelforphysicalproblemswhich
displaysuniquebehaviorthathavetobeitemized;

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
Hence,adetaileddescriptionoftheunderdamped
responseisnecessaryforbothanalysisanddesign.
Thestepresponseforthegeneralsecondorder
systemis:

45
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
StepResponseofunderdampedSystem
C (s ) n2 n2
StepResponse C ( s)
s s 2 2 n s n2

6/12/17
R(s ) s 2 2 n s n2

Thepartialfractionexpansionofaboveequationis

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
givenas 1 s 2 n
C (s )
s s 2 2 n s n2

n2 1 2

1 s 2 n
C (s ) 2
s 2 n 2 s s 2 n s 2 n2 n2 2 n2

1 s 2 n
C (s )

s s n 2 n2 1 2
Aboveequationcanbewrittenas
1 s 2 n
C (s ) 46
s s n 2 d2
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
Where,isthefrequencyoftransientoscillations
andiscalleddampednaturalfrequency.
TheinverseLaplacetransformofaboveequationcanbe

6/12/17

obtainedeasilyifC(s)iswritteninthefollowingform:
1 s n n

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
C (s )
s s n 2 d2 s n 2 d2


n 1 2
1 s n 1 2
C (s )
s s n 2 d2 s n 2 d2
1 s n d
C (s )
s s n d
2 2
1 2 s 2 2
n d

47

1 2
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
Cont

c(t ) 1 e nt cos d t sin d t

6/12/17
When
1 2
0
d n 1 2

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
c(t ) 1 cos n t
n

Example:ConsiderEffectofvaryingdampingratio
withconstantnaturalfrequencyforunderdamped
systems.
I, if 0.1 and n 3 rad / sec
II, if 0.5 and n 3 rad / sec
III, if 0.9 and n 3 rad / sec
48
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
Theresponselooks:
1.4
1.8

6/12/17
1.6 1.2

1.4
1

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
1.2

III
1
0.8

0.8 0.6

0.6 0.4

0.4
0.2
0.2

0
0 0 2 4 6 8 10
0 2 4 6 8 10

1.4

1.2

III 1

0.8

0.6

0.4 49

0.2

0
0 2 4 6 8 10
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
Homework:StepResponseofoverdampedand

6/12/17

criticallydampedSystems?

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
50
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
TimeDomainSpecificationsofUnderdampedsystem
For0<<1andn>0,the2ndordersystems

6/12/17
responseduetoaunitstep

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
51
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
Risetime,Tr:Thetimerequiredforthewaveformto
gofrom0%or10%ofthefinalvalueto90%or100%of
thefinalvalue.

6/12/17
Peaktime,Tp:Thetimerequiredtoreachthefirst

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
themaximum,peak.
Percentovershoot,%OS:Theamountthatthe
waveformovershootsthesteadystate,orfinalvalueat
thepeaktime,expressedasapercentageofthesteady
statevalue.
Settlingtime,Ts:Thetimerequiredforthe
transient'sdampedoscillationstoreachandstaywith
in2%(}5%)ofthesteadystatevalue.
Thedelay(td)time:isthetimerequiredforthe
responsetoreachhalfthefinalvaluetheveryfirst 52

time.
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
NB:Alldefinitionsarealsovalidforsystemsoforder
higherthan2,howeveranalyticalexpressionsfor

6/12/17
theseparameterscannotbefoundunlessthe
responseofthehigherordersystemcanbe

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
approximatedasasecondordersystem,
Risetime,peaktime,andsettlingtimeyield
informationaboutthespeedofthetransient
response.
Thisinformationcanhelpadesignertodetermine
whetherthespeedandthenatureoftheresponsedo
ordonotdegradetheperformanceofthesystem.

53
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
Evaluatingtheperformanceparameters
TimeDomainSpecifications(RiseTime)

6/12/17

n t
c(t ) 1 e cos d t sin d t

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
1 2

Put t t r in above equation

Where c(tr ) 1
n t r
cos d t r
c(t r ) 1 e sin d t r
1 2


n t r
0 e cos d t r sin d t r
1 2


e ntr 0 0 cos d t r sin d t r
1 2
54
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
TimeDomainSpecifications(RiseTime)

6/12/17
cos d t r sin d t r 0
1 2

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
above equation can be re - writen as 1 2
sin d t r cos d t r

1 2
1 n 1
2
1 2 1
d t r tan t
1
tan
tan d t r r d n



tr
d

a
tan 1
b
55
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
TimeDomainSpecifications(PeakTime)

c(t ) 1 e nt cos d t sin d t

6/12/17
1 2

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
In order to find peak time let us differentiate above
equationw.r.tt.
dc(t )
nt
n e cosd t sind t e n d sind t
t d
cosd t
dt 1 2 1 2

2n d
nt
0e n cosd t sind t d sind t cosd t
1 2
1 2

2n n 1 2
nt
0e n cosd t sind t d sind t cosd t
1 2
1 2 56

TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
TimeDomainSpecifications(PeakTime)
2 2
sin d t n
d 0 n
d 0 sin d t 0

6/12/17
1 2 1 2

0, , 2 ,

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
d t sin 1 0
t
d
Sinceforunderdamped stable systems firstpeak
ismaximumpeaktherefore,

tp
d

TimeDomainSpecifications(MaximumOvershoot)

57
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
TimeDomainSpecifications(MaximumOvershoot)
n t p

c(t p ) 1 e cos d t p sin d t p c() 1

6/12/17
1 2

ADU,CET,ECEg3153


M p 1 e n p cos d t p sin d t p 1 100
t
1 2


Put tp in above equation
d
n
cos 100
M p e d
d sin d
d 1 2 d

58
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
TimeDomainSpecifications(MaximumOvershoot)
Put d n 1- 2 in above equation

6/12/17
n

n 1 2 cos 100

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
Mp e sin
2
1



Mp e
1 2
1 0 100



1 2
Mp e 100
59
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
TimeDomainSpecifications(SettlingTime)
Settlingtime(2%)criterion

6/12/17
Timeconsumedinexponentialdecayupto98%
oftheinput.

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
1
T
4 n
t s 4T
n

Settlingtime(5%)criterion
Time consumed in exponential decay up to
95%oftheinput. 3 60
t s 3T
n
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
Example1:Considerthesystemshowninfollowing
figure,wheredampingratiois0.6andnatural

6/12/17
undampedfrequencyis5rad/sec.Obtaintherise
timetr,peaktimetp,maximumovershootMp,and

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
settlingtime2%and5%criteriontswhenthesystem
issubjectedtoaunitstepinput.

61
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
Solution
RiseTime
tr

6/12/17
d

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
2
1
tan1( n ) 0.93 rad
n
3.141 3.141 0.93
tr tr 0.55s
n 1 2
5 1 0.6 2

PeakTime

3.141
tp tp 0.785 s
d 4 62
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
Cont
SettlingTime(2%) SettlingTime(4%) MaximumOvershoot

6/12/17
4 3
ts ts
n n 1 2

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
Mp e 100
4 3
ts 1.33s t s 1s
0.6 5 0.6 5
3.1410.6
1 0.6 2
Mp e 100
Example:calculateTp,Ts,%OSandTrfora
systemwithatransferfunction;
63
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
Relationshipb/n%OS,TpandTstothelocation
ofthepolesofthesystem

6/12/17
Thepoleplotforageneral,underdampedsecond
ordersystem,FromthePythagoreantheoremthat

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
theradialdistancefromtheorigintothepoleisthe
naturalfrequency,n,andthecosineoftheangle
formedb/nthisline&therealaxisbethedamping
ratio.

64

Poleplotforsecondorderunderdampedsystem
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
Fromthepreviouspeaktimeandsettlingtime
equationforsecondorderstepresponse.Comparing
thevaluestothepolelocations;

6/12/17
ADU,CET,ECEg3153
Where;distheimaginarypartofthepoleandis
calledthedampedfrequencyofoscillation,disthe
magnitudeoftherealpartofthepoleandisthe
exponentialdampingfrequency.

65
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
Fromtheequations,Tpisinverselyproportionalto
theimaginarypartofthepole.Sincehorizontallines
onthesplanearelinesofconstantimaginaryvalue,

6/12/17
theyarealsolinesofconstantpeaktime.

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
Thesettlingtimeisinverselyproportionaltothereal
partofthepole.
Sinceverticallinesonthesplanearelinesof
constantrealvalue,theyarealsolinesofconstant
settlingtime.
Finally,since=cos,radiallinesarelinesof
constant
Sincepercentovershootisonlyafunctionof ,radial
linesarethuslinesofconstantpercentovershoot, 66
%OS.
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
Linesofconstantpeaktime,Tp,settlingtime,Ts,
andpercentovershoot,%OS.

6/12/17
ADU,CET,ECEg3153
67
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS

6/12/17
ADU,CET,ECEg3153
68
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
Example1:ForthesystemshowninFigure(a),
determinethevaluesofgainKandvelocityfeedback
constantKhsothatthemaximumovershootinthe

6/12/17
unitstepresponseis0.2andthepeaktimeis1sec.
WiththesevaluesofKandKh,obtaintherisetime

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
andsettlingtime.AssumethatJ=1kgm2andB=1
Nm/rad/sec.

69
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
Solution:reducetheblockinto

6/12/17
ADU,CET,ECEg3153
Since J 1 kgm 2 and B 1 Nm/rad/sec
C (s ) K
2
R(s ) s (1 KK h )s K
ComparingaboveT.Fwithgeneral2ndorderT.F
n K
C (s ) n2
2 (1 KK h ) 70
2
R(s ) s 2 n s n
2 K
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
Cont
Maximumovershootis0.2. Thepeaktimeis1sec

6/12/17

tp

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
d
3.141
1

n 1 2
) ln 0.2
1 2
ln(e
3.141
n
1 0.4562

n 3.53
71
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
Cont Thentheriseandsettling
timecanbecalculatedas:
n 3.96

6/12/17
(1 KK h )
tr
2 K n 1 2
n K

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
t r 0.65s
0.456 2 12.5 (1 12.5K h )
3.53 K 4
ts
2 K h 0.178 n
3.53 K
t s 2.48s

K 12.5 3
ts
n
t s 1.86s 72
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
Example2:Giventhesystemshowninfollowing
figure,findJandDtoyield20%overshootanda

6/12/17
settlingtimeof2secondsforastepinputoftorque
T(t).

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
Solution:modelT.F

73
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
Cont

6/12/17
ADU,CET,ECEg3153
74
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
Exersice1:Figure(a)showsamechanicalvibratory
system.When2lbofforce(stepinput)isappliedto

6/12/17
thesystem,themassoscillates,asshowninFigure
(b).Determinem,b,andkofthesystemfromthis

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
responsecurve.

75
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
Exersice2:WhenthesystemshowninFigure(a)is
subjectedtoaunitstepinput,thesystemoutput

6/12/17
respondsasshowninFigure(b).Determinethe
valuesofaandcfromtheresponsecurve.

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
a
s ( cs 1)

76
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
EffectofAddingPoleandZeroonthe
TransientResponseofSecondOrderSystem

6/12/17
Addingpoleforsecondordersystem:

Ifasystemhasmorethantwopolesorhaszeros,

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
wecannotusetheformulastocalculatethe
performancespecificationsthatwederived.
However,undercertainconditions,asystemwith
morethantwopolesorwithzeroscanbe
approximatedasasecondordersystemthathasjust
twocomplexdominantpoles.
Then,theformulasforpercentovershoot,settling
time,andpeaktimecanbeappliedtothesehigher
ordersystemsbyusingthelocationofthedominant 77
poles.
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
Consideringathreepolesystemwithcomplexpoles
andathirdpoleontherealaxis.

6/12/17
Assumingthatthecomplexpolesareat

andtherealpoleisatr,thestepresponseofthe

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
systemcanbedeterminedfromapartialfraction
expansion.
Andthesystemresponsebecome;

78
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS

6/12/17
ADU,CET,ECEg3153
79
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
If(CaseII),thepureexponentialwilldieout
muchmorerapidlythanthesecondorder

6/12/17
underdampedstepresponse.
Ifthepureexponentialtermdecaystoan

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
insignificantvalueatthetimeofthefirstovershoot,
suchparametersaspercentovershoot,settlingtime,
andpeaktimewillbegeneratedbythesecondorder
underdampedstepresponsecomponent.
Thus,thetotalresponsewillapproachthatofapure
secondordersystem(CaseIII).

80
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
NB:Ifrisnotmuchgreaterthan(CaseI),the
realpole'stransientresponsewillnotdecayto

6/12/17
insignificanceatthepeaktimeorsettlingtime
generatedbythesecondorderpair.

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
Inthiscase,theexponentialdecayissignificant,and
thesystemcannotberepresentedasasecondorder
system.
Howmuchshouldfurthertheadditionalrealpole
fromthedominantpoledependsontheaccuracyfor
whichwearelooking.Butmostofthetimefivetime
constants.
Hence,therealpoleshouldfivetimesfarthertothe
leftthanthedominantpoles,torepresentthesystem 81
byitsdominantsecondorderpairofpoles.
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
Wehavetoalsoconsideralsotheeffectoftheresidue
onthemagnitudeoftheexponentialmagnitude.

6/12/17
Example:Comparingtheeffectofaddingrealpole
onstepresponseforthefollowingthreesystem

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
82
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
AddingZerosonthesystem:
Thezerosofaresponseaffecttheresidue,or

6/12/17
amplitude,ofaresponsecomponentbutdonotaffect
thenatureoftheresponse,exponential,damped

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
sinusoid,andsoon.
Letsaddarealaxiszerotoatwopolesystem.We
canaddazeroeitherinthelefthalfplaneorinthe
righthalfplane.

83
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS

6/12/17
ADU,CET,ECEg3153
Thecloserthezeroistothedominantpoles,thegreater
itseffectonthetransientresponse.Asthezeromoves
84
awayfromthedominantpoles,theresponseapproaches
thatofthetwopolesystem.
TIMEDOMAINANALYSISOF2ND
ORDERSYSTEMS
Secondordersystems
Exercise:Describethenatureofthesecondorder

6/12/17
systemresponseviathevalueofthedampingratio
forthesystemswithtransferfunction

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
12
1. G ( s ) 2
s 8 s 12

16
2. G ( s ) 2 Dothemasyourown
s 8s 16 revision

20
3. G ( s ) 2
s 8 s 20 85
STEADYSTATEERROR
SteadyStateResponse:
Controlsystemsanalysisanddesignfocusonthree
specifications:

6/12/17
(1)Transientresponse
(2)Steadystateerrors

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
(3)Stability

SteadyStateError:Steadystateerroristhe
differencebetweentheinputandtheoutputfora
prescribedtestinputast.
E(s)=C(s)R(s)

86
STEADYSTATEERROR
Steadystateerrorforunityfeedbacksystem
Itcanbecalculatedfromasystem'sclosedloop

6/12/17
transferfunction,T(s),ortheopenlooptransfer
function,G(s),forunityfeedbacksystems.

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
SteadyStateErrorinTermsofT(s)

87
6/12/17 ADU,CET,ECEg3153
88
STEADYSTATEERROR
STEADYSTATEERROR
ConsideringG(s)

6/12/17
ADU,CET,ECEg3153
89
STEADYSTATEERROR
Any physical control system inherently suffers steady
stateerrorinresponsetocertaintypesofinputs.

6/12/17
Asystemmayhavenosteadystateerrortoastepinput,
but the same system may exhibit nonzero steadystate

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
errortoarampinput.
Whether a given system will exhibit steadystate error
for a given type of input depends on the type of open
looptransferfunctionofthesystem.
ClassificationofControlSystems
Control systems may be classified according to their
ability to follow step inputs, ramp inputs, parabolic
inputs,andsoon.
The magnitudes of the steadystate errors due to these
individual inputs are indicative of the goodness of the 90

system.
STEADYSTATEERROR
ClassificationofControlSystems
Considertheunityfeedbackcontrolsystemwiththe

6/12/17
followingopenlooptransferfunction

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
It involves the term sN in the denominator,
representingNpolesattheorigin.
A system is called type 0, type 1, type 2, ... , if N=0,
N=1,N=2,...,respectively.
Asthetypenumberisincreased,accuracyisimproved.
91
STEADYSTATEERROR
ClassificationofControlSystems
However,increasingthetypenumberaggravatesthe

6/12/17
stabilityproblem.
A compromise between steadystate accuracy and

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
relativestabilityisalwaysnecessary.
SteadyStateErrorofUnityFeedbackSystems
Considerthesystemshowninfollowingfigure.

Theclosedlooptransferfunctionis
92
STEADYSTATEERROR
SteadyStateErrorofUnityFeedbackSystems

The transfer function between the error signal E(s)

6/12/17
andtheinputsignalR(s)is

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
E (s ) 1

R(s ) 1 G(s )
Thefinalvaluetheoremprovidesaconvenientwayto
findthesteadystateperformanceofastablesystem.
SinceE(s)is

Thesteadystateerroris
93
STEADYSTATEERROR
StaticErrorConstants
The static error constants are figures of merit of

6/12/17
controlsystems.Thehighertheconstants,thesmaller
thesteadystateerror.

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
In a given system, the output may be the position,
velocity,pressure,temperature,orthelike.

Therefore, in what follows, we shall call the output


position,therateofchangeoftheoutputvelocity,
andsoon.

This means that in a temperature control system


position represents the output temperature,
velocity represents the rateof change of the output 94

temperature,andsoon.
STEADYSTATEERROR
StaticPositionErrorConstant(Kp)
Thesteadystateerrorofthesystemforaunitstep

6/12/17
inputis

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
ThestaticpositionerrorconstantKpisdefinedby

Thus,thesteadystateerrorintermsofthestatic
positionerrorconstantKpisgivenby
95
STEADYSTATEERROR
StaticPositionErrorConstant(Kp)
ForaType0system

6/12/17
ADU,CET,ECEg3153
ForType1orhighersystems

Foraunitstepinputthesteadystateerroressis

96
STEADYSTATEERROR
StaticVelocityErrorConstant(Kv)
Thesteadystateerrorofthesystemforaunitramp

6/12/17
inputis

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
ThestaticpositionerrorconstantKvisdefinedby

Thus,thesteadystateerrorintermsofthestatic
velocityerrorconstantKvisgivenby
97
STEADYSTATEERROR
StaticVelocityErrorConstant(Kv)
ForaType0system

6/12/17
ADU,CET,ECEg3153
ForType1systems

Fortype2orhighersystems

98
STEADYSTATEERROR
StaticVelocityErrorConstant(Kv)
Forarampinputthesteadystateerroressis

6/12/17
ADU,CET,ECEg3153
StaticAccelerationErrorConstant(Ka)
Thesteadystateerrorofthesystemforparabolic
inputis
99
STEADYSTATEERROR
ThestaticaccelerationerrorconstantKais

definedby

6/12/17
Thus, the steadystate error in terms of the static

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
accelerationerrorconstantKaisgivenby

ForaType0system

ForType1systems
100
STEADYSTATEERROR
Fortype2systems

6/12/17
Fortype3orhighersystems

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
Foraparabolicinputthesteadystateerroressis

101
STEADYSTATEERROR
Summery

6/12/17
ADU,CET,ECEg3153
E.g.1:Forthesystemshowninfigurebelow
evaluatethestaticerrorconstantsandfindthe
expectedsteadystateerrorsforthestandardstep,
rampandparabolicinputs.
100(s 2 )(s 5)
R(s) s 2 (s 8)(s 12 ) C(S)
102
STEADYSTATEERROR
Solution:(evaluationofStaticErrorConstants)
100(s 2)(s 5)
G( s ) 2
s (s 8)(s 12)

6/12/17
K p lim G(s )
s 0 K lim sG(s ) v
s 0

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
100(s 2 )(s 5) 100s(s 2 )(s 5)
K p lim 2 K v lim 2
s 0 s (s 8)(s 12 ) s 0 s (s 8)(s 12 )

Kp Kv

2 100s 2 (s 2)(s 5) 100(0 2)(0 5)


K a lim s G(s ) K a lim Ka
10.4
s 0 (0 8)(0 12)
s 0 2
s (s 8)(s 12)

0 0 0.09
103
STEADYSTATEERROR

6/12/17
ADU,CET,ECEg3153
Ex:Findthesteadystateerrorsforinputsof
5u(t),5tu(t),and5tu(t)tothesystemshownin
below

104
STABILITYANALYSIS
Stability:isthemostimportantsystem
specification.

6/12/17
Ifasystemisunstable,transientresponseand
steadystateresponse(i.e.steadystateerror)are

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
nothing.
Thereared/tdefinitionofstabilityforacertain
system
Ingeneral:
Stable:ifnaturalresponseapproacheszeroastime
approachesinfinity.
Unstable:ifthenaturalresponsegrowwithout
boundastimeapproachesinfinity.
MarginalStability:neithergrowsnordecaybut 105

remainconstantoroscillate.
STABILITYANALYSIS
AnOtherDefinition:
Asystemisstableifeveryboundedinputyieldsa

6/12/17
boundedoutput.
Asystemisunstableifanyboundedinputyieldsan

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
unboundedoutput.(wecallitBIBOstability
definition)
StabilityandRootsofCharacteristicsEquation

CharacteristicsEquation:isthedenominatorofour

systemtransferfunction.Forinstanceforasecond
ordersystem,
Then,therootswillbe:

106
STABILITYANALYSIS
Basedonthesystempolelocationdefinitionsof
stability:

6/12/17
Stablesystemshaveclosedlooptransferfunctions
withpolesonlyonthelefthalfplane.

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
Iftheclosedloopsystempolesareontherighthalf
ofthesplanei.e.havingapositiverealpart,the
systemisunstable.
Thustherootsofthecharacteristicsequation
determinethetransientresponseofthesystem.
asecondordersystemcouldbe:
Overdamped:
Criticallydamped:
Underdamped:
107
STABILITYANALYSIS
Ifthecoefficientofbintheaboveequationbe
negative,therootswillbe:

6/12/17
Ingeneralifanyoftherootsofthecharacteristics
equationhaspositiverealparts,thesystemwillbe

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
unstable.

108
STABILITYANALYSIS
Cont

6/12/17
ADU,CET,ECEg3153
109
STABILITYANALYSIS
Cont

6/12/17
ADU,CET,ECEg3153
110
STABILITYANALYSIS
RouthHurwitzStabilityCriterion
RouthandHurwitzgiveamethodofindicatingthe

6/12/17
presenceandnumberofunstableroots,butnottheir
value,usingRouthtable.

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
TheRouthHurwitzcriterionstatesthatthe
numberofrootsofthecharacteristicequationwith
positiverealpartsisequaltothenumberofchanges
insignofthefirstcolumnoftheRoutharray.
Thismethodyieldsstabilityinformationwithoutthe
needtosolvefortheclosedloopsystempoles.
Usingthismethod,wecantellhowmanyclosedloop
systempolesareinthelefthalfplane,intheright
halfplane,andonthejaxis.(Note:wearesaying 111
howmany,notwhere.)
STABILITYANALYSIS
The method requires two steps:
1. Generate a data table called a Routh table.

6/12/17
2. interpret the Routh table to tell how many closed-loop
system poles are in the LHP, the RHP, and on the jw-axis.

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
Thecharacteristicequationofthenorder
continuoussystemcanbewrittenas:

ThestabilitycriterionisappliedusingaRouthtable
whichisdefinedas:

112
STABILITYANALYSIS
Cont

6/12/17
ADU,CET,ECEg3153
HowtogenerateRouthTable:
Firstlabeltherowswithpowersofsfromhighest
powerofsdowntolowestpowerofsinavertical
column.
NextformthefirstrowoftheRouthtable,usingthe
coefficientsofthedenominatoroftheclosedloop
113
transferfunction(characteristicequation).
STABILITYANALYSIS
Startwiththecoefficientofthehighestpowerand
skipeveryotherpowerofs.

6/12/17
Nowformthesecondrowwiththecoefficientsofthe
denominatorskippedinthepreviousstep.

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
Thetableiscontinuedhorizontallyandvertically
untilzerosareobtained.
Forconvenience,anyrowcanbemultipliedor
dividebyapositiveconstantbeforethenextrowis
computedwithoutchangingthevaluesoftherows
belowanddisturbingthepropertiesoftheRouth
table.

114
STABILITYANALYSIS
RouthTableInterpretation
Iftheclosedlooptransferfunctionhasallpolesin

6/12/17
thelefthalfofthesplane,thesystemisstable.
Thus,asystemisstableiftherearenosignchanges

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
inthefirstcolumnoftheRouthtable.
TheRouthHurwitzcriteriondeclaresthatthe
numberofrootsofthepolynomialthatareliesinthe
righthalfplaneisequaltothenumberofsign
changesinthefirstcolumn.
Hencethesystemisunstableifthepolesliesonthe
righthandsideofthesplane.

115
STABILITYANALYSIS
Fortheretobenorootswithpositiverealpartsthen
thereisnecessary,butnotsufficient,conditionthat

6/12/17
allcoefficientsinthecharacteristicsequationhave
thesamesignandthatnonearezero.

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
Iftheaboveissatisfied,thenecessaryandsufficient
conditionforstabilityisallcoefficientsofthefirst
columnofRoutharrayhavethesamesign.The
numberofsignchangesindicatethenumberof
unstableroots.

116
STABILITYANALYSIS
Onlythefirst2rowsofthearrayareobtainedfrom
thecharacteristicequationtheremainingare
calculatedasfollows;

6/12/17
ADU,CET,ECEg3153
117
STABILITYANALYSIS
Example2:Findthestabilityofthesystemshown
belowusingRouthcriterion.
TheRouthtableofthesystemis:

6/12/17
ADU,CET,ECEg3153
Systemisunstablebecausetherearetwosignchanges
inthefirstcolumnoftheRouthstable.Hencethe 118

equationhastworootsontherighthalfofthesplane.
STABILITYANALYSIS
Exercise:Findthestabilityofthesystemusing
RouthHurwitzCriterion.

6/12/17
ADU,CET,ECEg3153
SpecialCases:
Case1:AZeroOnlyintheFirstColumn,substitute
withaverysmallnumber0andproceed
Example:determinethestabilityofthesystem

StabilityviaEpsilonMethodRouthtable 119
STABILITYANALYSIS
Cont

6/12/17
ADU,CET,ECEg3153
Ifischosenpositive,thetableshowsasignchange
fromthesrowtothesrow,andtherewillbe
anothersignchangefromthesrowtothesrow.
Hence,thesystemisunstableandhastwopolesin
therighthalfplane.
120
STABILITYANALYSIS
CaseII:EntireRowisZero
SometimeswhilemakingaRouthtable,wefindthat

6/12/17
anentirerowconsistsofzeros.
Thishappenbecausethereisanevenpolynomial

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
thatisafactoroftheoriginalpolynomial.
Thiscasemustbehandleddifferentlyfromthecase
ofazeroinonlythefirstcolumnofarow.

121
STABILITYANALYSIS
Cont

6/12/17
ADU,CET,ECEg3153
122
STABILITYANALYSIS
Applicationofrouthsstabilitycriteriatocontrol
systemanalysis

6/12/17
ThiscriteriahaslimiteduseinLTIsystemsbecause
itdoesnotsuggesthowtoimproverelativestability

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
orhowtostabilizeunstablesystems.
Howeverwecanconsiderthesysteminwhichthe
rangeofparametersvalueofwhichdetermines
stabilityofthesystem(likethegainorDCgainod
system)
Example:Determiningacceptablegainvalues
forasystemForthesystembeingstable:Considera
systemwhoseclosedlooptransferfunctionis
123
STABILITYANALYSIS
Cont

6/12/17
ADU,CET,ECEg3153
124
STABILITYANALYSIS
Cont

6/12/17
ADU,CET,ECEg3153
125
6/12/17
Thank you dear

ADU,CET,ECEg3153
students
Any questions?

126

You might also like