Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Õ Soil erosion
Õ Drying lakes
Õ Disappearing species
Õ Global warming
m Ecosystem
m The idea maintains that environment deserved to be preserved for its own sake, regardless whether it
benefits human being.
m Ecological ethics claims that welfare of at least
some nonhumans is intrinsically value and
deserve to be respected and protected.
m Two traditional views such as utilitarianism and
concern for human rights can help us to
develop an environmental ethics.
m Utilitarianism views claims that moral worth of
an action by any human being ! !
!
!! !
!!!
m The fact that we are only part of large
ecological system, has led many writers insist
that we should recognize our moral duty to
protect the welfare of human and non human
parts of the system.
m Several supporters of this approach have
formulated their views/statements:
m The well being and flourishing of human and
nonhuman life have value in themselves.
m Richness and diversity of life forms
contribute to the realization of these values.
m Humans has no right to reduce this richness
and diversity except to satisfy vital needs.
m Flourishing of human life and culture is
compatible with a substantial decrease of
human population. The flourishing of
nonhuman life requires such decrease.
m Present human interference with nonhuman
world is excessive and situation is rapidly
worsening.
m Policies must be changed which will affect
basic economic, technological and ideological
structure.
m The ideological change is mainly that of
appreciating life rather than to increase high
leaving standard.
m Those who wants to make changes have
obligations directly/indirectly to participate in the
attempt to implement necessary changes.
m Varieties of ecological ethics
mThe most popular version claims that animals
have intrinsic value and deserve our respect and
protection.
mThe first utilitarians Jeremy Bentham says that
pain is evil whether it inflicted human or animals.
mVccording to Peter Singer most recent utilitarian
the pain of animal must be considered equal
comparable to human pain to do other wise is
speciesism comparable to racism & sexism.
mSo we have the direct duty to animals to avoid
causing pain to them.
mÔertain nonutilitarians conclude that life of every
animal itself has value apart from the interest of
human being.
m Human has duty to respect the right of animal to
be treated with respect.
m More extreme arguments extend rights and an
interest in living & flourishing beyond animals to
plants.
m Natural things such as wild rivers, mountains
have right to have their integrity, stability and
beauty preserved.
m Rights extend beyond individual living things to
whole systems.
m Utilitarianism approach on environmental
problems.
mSees environmental problems as market defects.
society as a whole.
mFor example, an electric firm consumes
certain amount of fuel, labor and equipment to
produce one kilowatt of electricity.
mThe cost of these resources is its private cost.
mTherefore, private cost is the price it must pay
from its own pocket to manufacture the
product.
mPrivate cost are the actual cost firms incur too
produce a commodity.
m Vccording to utilitarians the remedy for external
costs is to internalize the that is to ensure
producer pays all the real cost of production
and use this costs to determine price of
commodity.
m Internalizing external costs is consistent with
the retributive of justice compensatory justice ²
those responsible for pollution bear the burden
to rectify and compensate those harmed.
m Duties of the firm
mThe polluting agent has the duty to pay all
those being harmed an amount equal to the
cost the pollution imposes on them, voluntarily
or by law.
m But the problem is when several polluters
involved it is not clear who is damaging
whom.
m Polluter should stop pollution by installing
pollution control devices. This way external
costs of pollution are translated into internal
costs where firms itself pay the installation of
pollution control device.
m Ôonclusions
mThe costs of pollution control should be borne
by those who cause them and benefiting from
pollutions activities.
mThose who had to bear the external cost of
pollution should benefit from pollution control.
mInternalizing cost meets the requirement